I’m looking for a new toaster oven to replace my old one that broke down. I want something that can toast, bake, broil, and roast with ease and efficiency. I also want something that is easy to clean, has a large capacity, and has a sleek design. What are some of the best toaster ovens in 2023 that meet these criteria? Please share your recommendations and experiences. Thanks!

Recently, I had the opportunity to explore and review over 25 different high-end toaster ovens, each offering unique features and capabilities. After thoroughly testing them, I realized that choosing the right one can be overwhelming. So, I decided to share my insights and recommendations to help anyone looking for a high-quality toaster oven that fits their needs.

If you want a toaster oven that does more than just toast, this list is for you! These ovens can air fry, roast, bake, dehydrate, and even grill-perfect for those who want a powerful and versatile kitchen appliance.

What to consider before buying?

• Size & Capacity - Make sure it fits your counter space and meets your cooking needs.
• Cooking Functions - More functions mean more versatility.
• Ease of Use - Simple controls and presets make cooking easier.
• Cleaning & Maintenance – Look for nonstick interiors and removable trays.
• Budget - High-end models vary in price, so pick one that fits your budget.

Top High-End Toaster Ovens

(Best Overall) Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro (BOV900) - A powerful toaster oven with 13 cooking functions, including air frying and dehydrating. Uses Element iQ technology for even cooking.

(Best Small-Sized) Cuisinart Air Fryer Oven with Grill (TOA-70) - Compact yet versatile, featuring air frying, baking, grilling, and toasting functions. Perfect for smaller kitchens.

(Best French Doors) Emeril Everyday 26 Qt Air Fryer Toaster Oven - Large capacity with 24 cooking presets and French doors for easy access. Includes a rotisserie function for slow roasting.

I recommend quickly checking this page to see more options, including my detailed reviews. There’s a nice filter to help you find the best product for your budget and needs.

I've been searching for quite some time for a good toaster oven and I've found 3 models come up pretty consistently but coverage and comparisons online seem very lacking.

Breville BOV800XL Oster XL Digital Convection Oven w/ French Doors Ninja® Foodi™ 10-in-1 XL Pro Air Fry Oven, Large Countertop Convection Oven

Some have an air fryer, some don't. It'd be nice but I don't care about it all that much. Bigger is better but not at the expense of quality. Breville does make a model with an air sryer but it's crazy expensive and I'm at the end of my rope with this toaster oven thing so I'd appreciate genuine knowledge on the subject.

Smart toaster ovens with app controls have made cooking easier and more efficient. Iwant to share my insights to help you find the right one.

What to Consider:

• Cooking Functions - Check if it supports air frying, baking, roasting, and other cooking modes.
• App Control Features - Look for remote control, preset recipes, and integration with Alexa or Google Assistant.
• Heating Technology - Convection fans and smart heating elements can make a big difference in cooking speed and consistency.
• Size & Capacity - Ensure it fits your countertop space and can handle the portions you need.
• Build Quality & Design - Stainless steel models are usually more durable and look sleek in any kitchen.
• Ease of Cleaning - Removable crumb trays and non-stick interiors make maintenance easier.

Best Smart Toaster Ovens with App Controls:

Best Overall - Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro (BOV900)

A large-capacity toaster oven with 13 cooking functions, including air frying and dehydrating. It uses Element iQ tech for precise cooking and a super convection fan for even heat distribution.

Most Advanced - Breville Joule Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro (BOV950)

Comes with Joule Autopilot, which automatically adjusts cooking settings. Features 13 preset modes and six quartz heating elements for precise temperature control.

Best for Versatility - Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer (BOV860)

Offers 11 cooking functions, including air frying and roasting. Its super convection system speeds up cooking while ensuring crispy and even results.

There are many great options out there, so take your time to compare features and find the best one for your needs. Have you used any of these? Let’s discuss your experience and recommendations!

Testing out the Cuisinart TOB-260N1 has been quite an experience for me, as someone who spends a lot of time cooking and baking at home. I’ve had my fair share of toaster ovens in the past, and this one piqued my interest with its array of features. Its design, capacity, and performance made me eager to put it through the paces. While this product has been a great addition to my kitchen, there are certainly some things you should be aware of before committing to it.

Sturdy Design with Thoughtful Features

Right off the bat, the brushed stainless steel construction gives this toaster oven a sleek and professional appearance. It fits surprisingly well into my somewhat cramped kitchen, though it’s definitely a larger appliance. I found the layout of the controls intuitive, and the large blue backlit digital display is easy to read, even when I’m half-asleep making breakfast. The auto-slide rack is a neat touch, sparing me from the occasional hand burns I’m prone to while removing hot trays. The attention to detail continues with the non-stick interior, which makes cleaning a breeze.

Versatile Functions That Cover Everything

What really sold me on this convection toaster oven is the insane versatility it offers. With 1800 watts of power, I’ve been able to use it for an endless list of tasks—baking cookies, broiling salmon, toasting bread, reheating leftover lasagna, and even cooking a decent pizza on its included pizza stone. The dual-cook feature has seriously changed the way I approach making layered dishes. The Exact Heat sensor does an admirable job of maintaining consistent temperatures, and the "Always Even" toast shade control has been reliable for getting the perfect level of browning. I didn’t expect to enjoy the "keep-warm" option as much as I have, but it’s a lifesaver during busy evenings when my dinner companions are perpetually late.

Check Cuisinart TOB-260N1 price on Amazon.

Surprising Capacity for Its Size

Another highlight is its capacity. I’ve managed to fit a 13-inch pizza and a full 9x13-inch baking pan inside without any awkward rearranging, which is impressive for a toaster oven. Being able to toast up to nine slices of bread at once seems excessive for my small household but has been a game-changer for family brunches and lazy Sunday mornings. For those who like entertaining or have a bigger family, the spacious interior will undoubtedly prove useful.

Cooking Accessories and Bonus Features

Alongside the pizza stone, the package includes an enamel baking pan, broiling pan, and two cooking racks. While I haven’t used every accessory yet, the pizza stone won my heart instantly by delivering crisp yet chewy pizza bases. There’s even an interior light that helps in monitoring food—something I didn’t appreciate until I realized how much I used it. The timer and clock are straightforward to adjust, and the front pull-out crumb tray has saved me a ton of cleanup after toast-heavy breakfasts.

Upsides

• Sleek, durable stainless-steel design fits most modern kitchens
• Wide variety of cooking modes, including dual cook and convection
• Spacious interior accommodating pizzas, large pans, and more
• Added convenience with auto-slide rack and interior light
• Non-stick interior significantly eases cleanup
• Includes several high-quality accessories such as pizza stone and pans

Areas of Improvement

• The size of the oven might not suit everyone, especially those with small counter spaces.
• Preheat time is a bit longer compared to simpler toaster ovens.
• Although the oven feels sturdy, the buttons have a slightly less premium feel than I expected for its price range.
• It does tend to heat up the surrounding area, which could be a drawback in warmer climates.

Product Alternatives

While this product has exceeded my expectations in many ways, it’s not the only quality toaster oven on the market. Brands like Breville and Ninja offer competitive models. For instance, Breville’s Smart Oven Air is a strong contender, with its excellent air-frying capabilities and faster preheat times, though it comes at a higher cost. On the other hand, Ninja’s Foodi Digital Air Fry Oven provides similar cooking versatility with the bonus of being more compact, which might be better for smaller kitchens. However, neither quite matches the Cuisinart model’s spacious interior and solid all-around performance for various cooking tasks.

Worth Every Penny

In terms of value for its features, this toaster oven strikes a decent balance. Admittedly, it sits on the pricier side for toaster ovens, but the wide functionality, thoughtful design, and build quality make it a worthy investment for avid home cooks. Instead of having several small appliances cluttering your kitchen, this product combines various capabilities into one flexible machine. If you’re on a tight budget, there are less expensive options, but they likely won’t offer the same level of cooking precision or spacious capacity. This is one of those cases where you truly get what you pay for.

Want Cuisinart TOB-260N1? Discover the price on Amazon.

I need help to decide on what toaster oven I should get, please help with suggestions. My main things are: -should preheat in the “bake” setting in a couple of minutes -should make a sound or notify when preheat is done -will mainly use it to make salmon, chicken or brownies/cookies

• preferably a medium sized one, not too big not too small. -good quality and easy to clean, I really want this to last and not blow out in a few months to a year.

Additions: I hear the Ninja SP351 also has a thermostat option where it turns off once the chicken reaches desired temp, that would be really nice. So if I could find something like that as well, would be amazing.

I posted this on another smaller sub and didnt get any responses. This is why I should just stick to asking questions here...

I have a few of my top choices in mind here... what is typically regarded as the best BIFL toaster oven? It looks like the Cosari air fryer/oven combo is good, if not the best. Wondering what people use, how long they have owned it for, and how they like it? Im also looking at the black and decker brand, but to me black and decker symbolizes middle tier equipment, so probably going to go with the cosari

Main things Id use for:

-Chicken :D

-Chicken wings

-more f'in chicken

-toast

Do any good ones exist that last more than 6 months to a year? Willing to pay more for good quality. Thanks!!

Can anyone recommend a high quality toaster that will last? I don't need any fancy controls, in fact, the fewer the better. Just a toasty level dial and nothing more ideally.

I don't need Bluetooth & wifi, I don't need a special setting for gluten free bread. I just want a simple box that I put bread into and get toast out of. And I want it to outlive me. Is this too much to ask?

Edit: now y'all have sent me down a rabbit hole. I've definitely gone through a few of the super cheap Walmart ones, they do last a surprisingly long time. I'd like to upgrade in overall quality to be honest.

It seems like Dualit might be worth it in the long run. Or just saving and grabbing a proper toaster oven. Oooor a vintage Sunbeam... I thought this would make things easier, hahaha! Thank you for the recommendations.