TL;DR
Quality vs. Cost in Art Supplies
When it comes to paint, especially oil, acrylic, and watercolor, investing in higher-quality options is recommended for vibrant and lasting pigments [1:1]. However, brushes don't need to be top-tier as long as they serve their purpose without shedding
[1:3]. Watercolor paper is another area where spending more is advisable, as cheap paper can negatively impact your work
[1:8].
Alternative Sources for Budget Art Supplies
For those on a tight budget, exploring dollar stores can yield surprisingly extensive craft sections with various paints, brushes, and canvases [5:1]. Thrift stores and estate sales are also worth checking out for hidden gems
[5:3]. Online platforms like Facebook Marketplace can offer affordable second-hand options
[5:5].
Affordable Brands and Recommendations
Pentel oil pastels are praised for their quality despite being budget-friendly [4:1]
[4:3]. Crayola offers limited colors but is noted for its creamy texture
[4:1]. For acrylic paint markers, Shuttle Arts provides good cheap options
[2:4]. Himi jelly gouache is another popular choice for inexpensive experimentation
[3:1].
Digital Art as a Cost-Effective Alternative
Digital painting can be a budget-friendly option, especially using free software like Krita [5:5]. While starting with a mouse is possible, affordable drawing tablets can be found on second-hand marketplaces, offering a long-lasting solution for digital art creation.
Online Retailers for Art Supplies
Several online retailers offer competitive prices for art supplies. Dick Blick, Jerry's Artarama, and Cheap Joe's (though closing) are frequently recommended [2:1]
[2:5]. St. Louis Art Supply also provides good deals
[2:2]. These stores often have sales or clearance items that can further reduce costs.
Do I really need to buy the most expensive supplies for the best quality?
Edit: I'd like to clarify what I mean by quality; I want beautiful and long lasting pigments, supplies that aren't unnecessarily difficult to work with, and surfaces that aren't going to worsen the application and preservation of my work. Just a few examples of what I mean.
Former art supply salesman here, I’ll give you my 2¢:
If you’re starting out on a new medium, it IS detrimental to cheap out IF you’ve never used it before. I saw this so much, where a parent or student would get cold feet, buy the cheapies, and come back later complaining that it “wasn’t working,” and ask how to fix it.
The thing is, that if you’re expecting a certain result of how the materials should work, the cheap stuff won’t do that, because the inexpensive options contain more binder than pigment, or use low quality elements to offset the costs.
So you’ll find a runny paint, or bristles falling out or not holding more water, or paper curling more or yellowing faster, colors looking duller, or if you’re using colored pencils, gaining a waxy bloom or breaking inside the pencil itself when you try to sharpen them.
If you DO have experience with the medium, and know the risks going in or don’t care, then yeah, go for the cheap stuff!
I don’t work in that industry anymore, so I genuinely don’t have any skin in the game for whatever you choose, but do consider all that, especially if you’ve not used ____ before!
This right here is why the debate between student/studio quality lines and artist lines of paint for beginners still exist.
Some people swear by artist quality because it is easier to learn and work with; others swear by student quality because it gives you less excuse not to practice with cheaper materials.
Anecdotally, cheaper paints did get me trying things I otherwise would not, but I thought I was messing up a lot since I could not predict the results. So I usually ended up trying a better version anyway, though I ultimately fall on the side of whatever gets you practicing.
Over many years, here's my experience:
Oil paints - Get the best paints you can afford, but the quality of brushes does not matter, as long as the bristles don't fall out, or you're trying to get type of brushstoke (soft brushes for smooth, hard brushes for crisp or textured strokes). Ok to go cheap on brushes.
Watercolor/gouache - Brushes do matter here, since nicer brushes will give you a lot more control over the paint. For watercolor paint, I actually really like grumbacher academy, and a little paint actually lasts a long time. For gouache, unfortunately I haven't found any really cheap brands I like. Paper is also worth spending a bit more, try to get 100% cotton, or cotton blends if you want to go cheaper.
Drawing/sketching - The cheapest pencils and paper will do. I go through boxes of cheap mechanical pencils and sale sketchbooks. I like kneaded erasers, so I also go through boxes of the cheapest I can find.
Ink - Not one of my main mediums, so I'm not as familiar, but there's lots of cheap options out there. Just be warned that cheaper ink pens work fine, but run out of ink faster and dry up when you're not looking.
Sometimes, a bic pen is enough.
It's not the tool, it's how you use it.
Agreed. I am good to start most projects with a plastic mechanical pencil. The mechanical version of a no.2 pencil from high school. I still use them to sketch out first drafts.
Even just normal pencils. You don't need super expensive pencils to start with. £10-£15 would get you a decent set of different hardnesses.
I actually prefer a bic pen over a more expensive ballpoint. I love how the bic pens don’t let out too much ink
I prefer the cheap stuff
never craft paint in bottles, but the cheap tubes with the pigments listed
There is but cheap paint can be corrected by adding flow extender and body gel. I use craft paint often. I add liqutex and golden mediums to it.
It's not going to match a premium brand by any means, but it does make it workable if all you have on hand is craft paint.
So I've painted with acrylics, gouache, oils and Watercolours and the biggest difference in any art supplies I've found is watercolour paper. As people have said, you can add mediums to cheaper acrylic paints and they will work nicely. Cheap watercolour paper will fuck you up. I was used to not having to really worry about art supplies always being the best quality - yes more expensive paints are better of course. But man using the proper cotton watercolour paper is like the difference between children's cheap poster paints and the best quality acrylic.
At least 3 or 4 years ago, I spent NZ$5 on a 2-pack of kneaded erasers. I only opened the second one recently to keep one on my desk and one with my travel supplies. I love those things, I think they’d survive the apocalypse.
I soooo disagree with this when it comes to paint, for the most part. There have been some good developments with low-cost high quality gouache, but you cannot cheap out on oil paint, acrylic, or watercolor if you want vibrant and rich color.
Same thing with paper.
i dont use amazon, i really need acrylic paint markers that come in skin tones but i dont want to spend $3 on one marker, (posca) but other brands aren’t really reviewed where i look, and i honestly dont even really know where to look. im looking for affordable and reliable art supplies. any recommendations? (sorry if this is worded weird. im tired)
I live in a small town, but there's a small art supply store here that also does paint-your-own ceramics (which I suspect is what pays the bills). They can order most things and their prices are reasonable, so you might want to do some digging and see if there's anything nearby.
For mail order, Jerry's Artorama, Cheap Joes (RIP - they're in the process of closing their doors), Dick Blick, etc.
I've found some things at St. Louis Art Supply for a good price, as well. https://shop.stlartsupply.com/
Block art materials is a reliable website to order from in the us. I don’t have any specific brand recs though
Blick's art supplies is good but the paint markers I like from them are Acrea and they're $20 for a 6 pen set, also Shuttle Arts has some good cheap acrylic painter markers.
I love dickblick!!! They're great
I really like the Himi jelly gouache.
Tempera paint- cheap by the jug. Black, white, and burnt sienna is all you need for contrast and warm/cool action. Get a big roll of paper and you’re in business.
Charcoal! Dirt cheap and easy to enjoy. You can draw on cardboard or newsprint. You can wander the streets and make street art along the avenues. You can just doodle for fun.
ohuhu alcohol markers are actually great to work with, on canson mixed media paper!
Thx for letting me know. I have both the sketchbook and the markers I just didn't know if they worked well together
I like using ballpoint pens and highlighters for random doodles. Adding some pops of color can make the doodles a lot more interesting.
The dollar store my beloved
Honestly I love getting old supplies from friends/family and I love going to discount stores and finding whatever unbranded pack of 75 colored pencils they have. The thrift store craft section always has some treasures, and one cannot ignore the humble pen found in a parking lot
I started experimenting with oil pastels through some pastels I had in an art kit from a craft shop, and they interested me enough to continue, but they were dry as hell, they didn't blend, and if you tried to blend them clumps of waxy pastel would lift off the page. So I decided to get some dedicated pastels, and as I'm on a real budget, I decided to get some pentels.
Now, I know they're probably not as good as Mungyo or Paul Rubens and they're certainly not as good as Sennelier, but jesus christ I LOVE them. They're buttery smooth, nicely pigmented, they blend, they're a millionty billion times better than the ones I was using. I may graduate from them one day, but if you're a beginner and you're kinda thinking about trying oil pastels, go ahead and grab a set. At the very least, it'll give you an idea of if you like them or not. I got a set of 50 for under a tenner, you can't say fairer than that.
That's priceless advice for someone just starting out - thanks for sharing. I had a similar experience with Royal Talens Van Goghs - a tiny bit more expensive than your Pentels but, a year on, I wouldn't part with them for the world. I've added a few NeoPastels and was kindly gifted a lovely set of Senneliers, but the Van Goghs still make up 90% of all the pics I do. You really don't need to break the bank to have some fun being creative!
I have oil pastels from several brands and I also was pleasantly surprised about how good the Pentels are. They really do blend quite well and look nice. The price can't be beaten either and back here they're available quite widely in the shops. So it's thumps up from me too.
Pentels are better than they're given credit for imo, I've seen some gorgeous work made with Pentels alone on this sub and I've found use for them in my collection of pastels. I have various sorts but Pentels were the first decent ones I bought (craft store brand ones are so much worse in comparison), I use them for a base layer, simple background or just by themselves if I just want to make a quick piece
Another that's surprisingly good is Crayola, the downside is the available colours are very limited but they're a lot creamier and more pigmented than you'd expect
Edit a day later: For those put off by the funky smell Pentels have I found leaving the box open somewhere for a few hours helped, haven't had a problem with the smell since
My family is in a financial crisis, I love oil painting but art supplies cost a lot, I haven't been so mindful about not squeezing too much paints before. Is there a way to get art supplies online/in person for cheaper? I live near NYC area
It's rare but some stores sell tested used oil paints for super cheap! I've Been Framed in Portland Oregon does and it's an amazing way to get great pigments from good brands for $2-5 a tube. Last time I was down there I walked out with an unopened Viridian for $4 and a barely used Cobalt Blue for $4.50. It's a grab bag of brands.
Estate sales can have hidden gems. Lots of families won’t have another artist interested in the supplies.
google how to make it yourself using a base and pigments for example. or whatever recipes there are. look for off brand oil paints using google and shop online.
you could even paint larger parts in budget oil paint, and use the more expensive ones for the accents,
You could try out digital painting, it's free if you use software like Krita for example and many have learnt to draw with a mouse first. Personally after trying it out with a mouse I got a drawing tablet on facebook marketplace for around 30 bucks but I've seen some for a lot cheaper too. And they last for years. If you want physical paints etc though you could still try out looking for them at facebook marketplace.
I've been to a few dollar stores with surprisingly extensive craft sections, with multiple kinds of paints, brushes, canvases, palettes, etc. Not every location has all that stuff in stock, but the ones that do have a lot to choose from. Considering it's a dollar store. It's not all going to be the highest quality materials, but it's better than nothing when all you want to do is paint.
Wo kann man in Darmstadt gut Künstlerbedarf kaufen? Pinsel, farbtuben, Leinwände, spezielles Papier, professionelle Bleistifte. Ich war im Müller und bei Karstadt, aber hatte den Eindruck da gab's eher nur so Schulkram. Gibt es einen richtigen Künstlerbedarfsladen in Darmstadt? (Und btw, keine Ahnung was die richtige Bezeichnung für so ein Geschäft ist xD)
Format - aber der Laden ist absolut megateuer.
Ich empfehle einen Besuch bei Bösner in Frankfurt - Riesenladen, haben alles und sind günstiger.
Format Heidelberger Landstraße ist zu empfehlen
Würde auch behaupten, das Format trifft das, was OP sucht.
Format sollte alles haben - bzw. besorgen können.
Der Farbenkraut hat auch einiges.
Falls du an der LiWi studierst, gibt es noch den Papierladen in der ULB, der einiges für Studienzwecke verkauft (technisches Zeichnen, Modellbau etc.)
Definitiv Format in der Heidelberger Straße, direkt an der Haltestelle „Prinz-Emil-Garten“
Weiss nicht ob die alles haben was du suchst, aber Karl-Gieselberg Schreibwaren ( http://gieselberg-schreibwaren.de/ ) beim Luisenplatz haben meine ich im zweiten Stock einiges an Kunstbedarf. Zumindest Leinwände habe ich da schon mal gekauft.
Und zumindest für Stifte/Papier könnte das Format in der Heidelberger Straße 63 die gew ünschte Auswahl bieten.
My favorite pencil at the moment!!
For example
-Staedtler Design journey, Noris, Ergosoft...
-Caran d'Ache Swisscolor
-Faber Castell Goldfaber
-Winsor & Newton Studio collection
-Derwent Academy
Which one of these do you like the best? Or something else?
I for a budget option, I would recommend the Faber Castell Black Edition - sets come in up to 100 colours, and they are good value for money in a lot of countries.
I feel like I’m beating a dead horse with all my posts of love. But black widow pencils. They come in sets. I believe to get all the sets will put the price about the same as a full set of prismacolor in the US (I know overseas they are a lot more).
I have fancy pencils: polychromos, prisma, albrechet durer etc. I grab my black widows so often. The colors are unique and amazing.
Does any particular paper influence your opinion of Faber Castel, black edition, pencils? In other words, do your favor them even on most light or white papers as you do other pencils?
Does any particular paper influence your opinion of Faber Castel, black edition, pencils? In other words, do your favor them even on most light or white papers as you do other pencils?
Snacky was referring to Black "Widows" which are a cheap Chinese pencil made with inks and not pigments. They actually suck and are overpriced for what they are. You can get get a 150 set of artist grade Prismas for what the cheaply made Black Widows cost.
As for FC's Black Editions I bought mine to use on Black paper and love how pigmented they are. They do look okay on white, but for white/lighter papers I still reach for my Prismas, Pablos or Polys.
I posted a chart of part of the 100set Black Editions in another post on this thread, but here is the "skintone" set they had that I tried first. I did some quick swatches on both white and black cardstock. I like this little set so much that I quickly decided to get the 100set of Black Editions:
I have, or have had, all of the pencils you've listed.
My absolute favourites are the Winsor & Newtons. 🥰🥰
I think Faber-Castell makes good budget pencils-- and I vastly prefer them to Polychromos --, but so do other respected/legacy art supply companies (like, from outside of your list, Cretacolor, Lyra, Bruynzeel).
While I love the W&Ns, their range is sadly very basic and limited. Out of cheap pencils, Koh-I-Noor Polycolors are amazing. Their price varies a lot, though. I paid less than 50 cents per pencil for my set, but I know in some places they can go as high as 4 times that.
I got interested in Koh-i-Noor Polycolors now. How different are these compared to Polychromos? Are they as pigmented?
They are softer and more opaque than Polychromos. Pigmentation about on par. They are artist quality pencils so absolutely nothing to complain about. So much better value for money. 😉
I don't have any of those you mentioned. I really like FC's student grade Black Edition. They look GREAT on black paper. Nicely pigmented and soft.
i have some stadtlers, and they are good enough. you can get a small set for cheap, and a bigger one for not that much. they have a few lines, a soft line. i just have the standard set.
What’s up Artist Lounge! Check out some of my pen & ink on paper artwork in my avatar and profile. I’ve been drawing since age 5.
I’ve been trying to level up my drawing setup, and lately, I’ve been wondering—where do most artists actually get their sketching supplies? Do you have a go-to spot for pencil drawing supplies, or do you just grab whatever is on sale?
I’ve tested out different graphite vs. charcoal drawing tools, tried various fine liner pens for detailed drawings, and even experimented with different best paper for pencil drawings—but I feel like I’m still figuring out what works best. Some brands feel overpriced, while others seem like hidden gems.
For those who swear by mechanical pencils for sketching, do you think they’re better than traditional pencils? And when it comes to top-rated colored pencils, do you notice a big difference between budget brands and pro ones like Prismacolor or Faber-Castell?
Also, what’s the one drawing supply you refuse to compromise on? For me, it’s blending tools for shading—I used to just smudge with my fingers, but after switching to tortillons and chamois cloths, my shading looks way smoother.
Curious to hear what works for you all! Any underrated best brands for drawing supplies that deserve more love?
Online: Jerry’s Artarama, Blicks, occasionally Cheap Joe’s. I actually have a brick & mortar, Jerry’s Artarama within driving distance. For those in the NYC area who are old enough to remember it, I really miss going to Pearl Paints. Way more than everything you could want in one place.
also lucky enough to live near a Jerry's. my favourite, Asel Art Supply, closed down, and another, Miller Blueprint, shifted toward architecture/imaging etc. so Dick and Jerry for me then.
I dont really draw these days, but my secret weapon was always one of those thin retractable erasers, like this one
Tombow mono retractable erasers + eraser shields are seriously amazing
I’m an NYC resident since ‘83. I haven’t been to Cheap Joe’s yet. Yes I remember the big ass Pearl Paints on Canal St in Manhattan. It’s a shame that one had to go. My first art store as a child: Janoff’s near Columbia University in Manhattan.
Yeah I go to the Jerry’s in Princeton
The Jerry’s on route 1 south, in Lawrenceville? Maybe I’ll see you there sometime!
St. Louis Art Supplies. I like them because I don’t have to pay sales tax, they stock lots of inks and pens, some unus supplies and priced are reasonable.
Michael's
Walmart. Its all we got in kc. Anything we buy online gets stolen as soon as its delivered
Thank you for posting in r/ArtistLounge! Please check out our FAQ and FAQ Links pages for lots of helpful advice. To access our megathread collections, please check out the drop down lists in the top menu on PC or the side-bar on mobile. If you have any questions, concerns, or feature requests please feel free to message the mods and they will help you as soon as they can. I am a bot, beep boop, if I did something wrong please report this comment.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
What hell is that did she become Yandere or something?
I think art is not about how much you spend. Is about the artist not the tools so i think any tools work. I personaly use pencils for everythink and some times color pencil.
Best affordable art materials
Key Considerations for Affordable Art Materials
Quality vs. Price: Look for brands that offer a good balance between quality and affordability. Sometimes, mid-range products can perform better than cheaper options.
Versatility: Choose materials that can be used for multiple techniques or styles, such as mixed media supplies, to maximize your investment.
Essential Supplies: Focus on acquiring the basics first, such as sketchbooks, pencils, acrylic or watercolor paints, brushes, and canvases.
Bulk Buying: Consider purchasing materials in bulk or sets, which often provide better value than buying individual items.
Local vs. Online: Check local art supply stores for sales or discounts, and compare prices with online retailers. Sometimes, local shops have unique deals.
Recommended Affordable Art Materials:
Sketchbooks: Strathmore or Canson sketchbooks are affordable and come in various sizes.
Pencils: Prismacolor Scholar Colored Pencils offer good quality at a reasonable price.
Paints: Liquitex Basics Acrylic Paints are budget-friendly and provide decent pigmentation.
Brushes: Royal & Langnickel or Artify offer good quality brushes at lower prices.
Canvases: Look for pre-stretched canvases from brands like Fredrix or Art Alternatives, which are often available in packs.
Recommendation: Start with a basic set of acrylic paints, a few good brushes, and a sketchbook. This combination allows you to explore various techniques and styles without breaking the bank. As you progress, you can invest in higher-quality materials based on your preferences.
Get more comprehensive results summarized by our most cutting edge AI model. Plus deep Youtube search.