Recommended Carry on Luggage in 2023

ORIGINAL POST

Over the past year, my professional journey has led me to spend almost 200 nights in hotels, flying on a weekly basis. My work assignments typically span four days, during which I rely solely on a messenger bag – the command center of my workspace – and a domestically sized carry-on for all my travel needs.

Interestingly, I've noticed a gap in discussions here regarding the nuances of packing and curating a wardrobe for frequent travel. Hence, I decided to share my insights on the matter, hoping it proves valuable to someone navigating similar demands.

First, let me share a picture of my dependable travel companion, the TravelPro 21" spinner carry-on. I'll try my best not to check a bag unless I really have to. TravelPro stands as a preferred choice among flight crews. My rationale was simple – if it meets the demanding needs of those navigating the skies daily, it's likely to meet ours as well. The four spinner wheels, a marvel in crowded airports, efficiently optimize space, while the ability to tilt the luggage forward facilitates smooth navigation over rough surfaces.

Recommended Carry on Luggage in 2023

I went through a bunch of Reddit posts, comments, and suggestions from other travelers to put together this list of the top carry-on luggage picks.

No place online is totally safe from fake reviews and spam. But, you know, on Reddit, it kind of happens less. Why? Well, let me break it down in simpler terms:

People on Reddit, they're into sharing what they know and kinda showing off a bit. They correct each other, too. It's like a big brain-sharing party. On the flip side, big company websites are more about making money, so sometimes they might share not-so-honest stuff.

Now, the cool thing about Reddit? If someone smells something fishy, they'll downvote it right away. It's like an instant "this doesn't seem right" button. And there's this karma thing – it's like a trust score. The higher, the better.

To formulate this list, I took into account factors such as durability, storage capacity, ease of maneuverability, and overall value for money. Combining my own experiences with the wisdom of the Reddit community, I've managed to curate a variety of carry-ons that cater to different needs and preferences.

Product	Main Features
Travelpro Platinum Elite Expandable Spinner	High-end carry-on with expandable capacity and spinner wheels for easy maneuverability.
Samsonite Freeform Hardside Expandable with Double Spinner	Durable hardside luggage with expandable capacity and double spinner wheels for smooth rolling.
Briggs & Riley ZDX Luggage Carry-On 22 Inch	22-inch carry-on with ZDX technology for better organization and superior durability.
LEVEL8 Hard Shell Carry on Luggage	Hard shell carry-on with sleek design and TSA-approved locks for added security.
Coolife Luggage Expandable 28″	Spacious expandable carry-on with 28-inch size and multiple interior compartments for organized packing.

1. Travelpro Platinum Elite Expandable Spinner

The Travelpro Platinum Elite Expandable Spinner is a top-notch carry-on that offers both style and functionality. With its abundance of space and well-designed organization features, packing for any trip becomes a breeze. The smooth and quiet wheels, as well as the adjustable handle, make maneuvering through airports a seamless experience. Plus, the built-in USB port is a convenient addition for charging devices on the go. Overall, this suitcase is a traveler's dream.

2. Samsonite Freeform Hardside Expandable with Double Spinner

The Samsonite Freeform Hardside Expandable with Double Spinner is the perfect combination of sleek design and practicality. With its 360-degree spinning wheels, navigating crowded airports becomes effortless. The aluminum telescoping handle adds convenience, and the suitcase performs well on various surfaces. What sets this carry-on apart is its stylish appearance, with 12 color options to choose from. This suitcase is an excellent choice for travelers who want both functionality and a touch of fashion.

3. Briggs & Riley ZDX Luggage Carry-On 22 Inch

The Briggs & Riley ZDX Luggage Carry-On 22 Inch is a reliable and well-made suitcase that offers plenty of space and organization options. The expandable zippered compartment is a handy feature, providing extra room when needed. The built-in USB port is a thoughtful addition for charging devices on the go. This bag is durable, lightweight, and easy to maneuver, making it a great choice for frequent travelers. With its soft-sided design and RFID shielding technology, this suitcase offers both flexibility and protection.

4. LEVEL8 Hard Shell Carry on Luggage

The LEVEL8 Hard Shell Carry on Luggage is a sleek and functional bag that ticks all the boxes for frequent travelers. The multi-directional spinner wheels make maneuvering through busy airports effortless, while the spacious interior provides ample room for all your essentials. With no exterior pockets, you can maximize packing capacity without sacrificing style. Made by a reputable New York-based company, this bag offers both durability and sophistication.

5. Coolife Luggage Expandable 28″

The Coolife Luggage Expandable 28″ is an affordable option that doesn't compromise on quality. With its budget-friendly price tag and positive reviews, this luggage offers excellent value for your money. The fabric divider panel allows for easy organization, and the zipper pockets are a practical touch. This versatile bag can be used as a spinner or an overhead luggage, fitting perfectly in airplane compartments. With its expandable capacity, this luggage is a great choice for travelers seeking functionality on a budget.

12 replies

Responsible_Mud8126 · 1 year ago

I'm looking for opinions on the best spinner carry-on luggage for domestic flights. I mostly travel within the country (90% domestic, 10% international) and usually have gold or platinum status each year. I've used a Briggs and Riley Baseline two-wheeler for over 15 years, and while it's been great, it's starting to feel heavy on my arms and shoulders, especially with my backpack on top. I think a spinner would be easier to handle. Any recommendations?

1 upvotes on reddit

ExactAd360 · 1 year ago

Rimowa might not be listed here due to its cost, but it’s genuinely amazing—and not just because it looks trendy.

Lifetime Warranty: Rimowa offers a lifetime warranty, which is fantastic. For instance, when an airline crushed the top left corner of my aluminum trunk, causing it to misalign and not close properly, I took it to the service center. They repaired it without asking for any proof of purchase. I just brought it in, they snapped a couple of photos, and fixed it. The whole process took about five minutes, and they shipped the luggage back to me in just a few days.

Smooth Wheels: Rimowa's wheels are some of the best out there. You’ll really notice this if you’re pushing two pieces of luggage together. Even though my trunk is pretty heavy, it’s so much easier to roll compared to other brands.

Cons: Of course, there are some downsides. It’s quite expensive, but I think it’s worth it in the long run (definitely has "Buy It For Life" status). Also, it’s very recognizable. If you don’t like standing out or prefer to be low-key, you might feel a bit uncomfortable with it.

Overall, I believe the pros of Rimowa luggage outweigh the cons.

1 upvotes on reddit

Due_Interest_4451 · 1 year ago

I've been searching for a new spinner carry-on suitcase, but one thing that's bothering me is the wobbliness of the telescoping handle on many options I've looked at. I've checked out different brands like Samsonite, Delsey Paris, and even higher-end ones like Tumi, but I wasn't too impressed with how much the handles move around. For comparison, the telescoping handle on my REI rolling duffel is really strong and steady—it doesn't move at all. So, I'm looking for something similar to that. I think Briggs and Riley might be a good choice because they're known for their durability, but I haven't been able to find any videos or reviews specifically talking about how sturdy their carry-on handles are. Plus, I don't have any Briggs and Riley retailers nearby, so I'm limited to what I can learn about them online.

1 upvotes on reddit

Mobile-Raise-6343 · 1 year ago

I'm a big fan of Ogio— their products have proven to be incredibly durable and reliable. I own their Layover carry-on bag, and it's by far the sturdiest one I've ever used. Additionally, I also rely on their Terminal bag for my travels. Moreover, I've put their 9800 sled rigs to the ultimate test during my contracting work, enduring 11 combat deployments in less than ideal conditions. Surprisingly, despite the harsh environments, none of them have required any repairs so far. However, I did notice a slight click in one of the wheels of the 9800 rig after encountering a rough rock, but it's still rolling smoothly after ten years of service. Overall, Ogio's exceptional durability and performance have made them my go-to choice for travel and demanding work environments alike.

1 upvotes on reddit

MolassesConfident645 · 1 year ago

Considering Briggs and Riley's lifetime warranty, I'm leaning towards them because even if their handle isn't as sturdy as I hope, I can always get it replaced if it ever fails. It's a reassurance knowing that I won't have to worry about unexpected handle issues in the long run. Additionally, I've heard good things about Away luggage—they also offer a lifetime warranty, but at a more affordable price point. It might be worth checking them out as well to compare options and see which one suits my needs and budget best.

1 upvotes on reddit

Forsaken_Detail2 · 1 year ago

I've been using a Briggs & Riley full-size suitcase for the past 15 years, and it has endured a significant amount of wear and tear without showing signs of giving up. The telescoping handle still operates smoothly, maintaining its functionality just like when it was new. While it has held up admirably well overall, the only issue I've encountered is with the main compartment zipper pull tabs. On two occasions, the tabs broke off due to exposure, but I was pleasantly surprised that Briggs & Riley replaced them for free under warranty, without any hassle or questions asked. This experience speaks volumes about their commitment to customer satisfaction and the quality of their products, reaffirming my trust in the brand for future luggage purchases.

1 upvotes on reddit

Quiet_Orange_6594 · 1 year ago

I'm a big fan of Bermas luggage, but it's a bit tricky to find them in the US unless you purchase through platforms like Buyee or Rakuten. Despite the challenge, I've managed to get my hands on two Bermas suitcases—one I've had for 11 years, and the other for 9—and both have served me incredibly well without any issues. In fact, I once witnessed a carousel attendant accidentally drop my 11-year-old Bermas suitcase, but it emerged from the mishap unscathed. Recently, I decided to try out a Lojel suitcase, and while it's decent overall, I still prefer the Bermas. However, I didn't encounter any problems with the telescoping handle on the Lojel, so that's a plus.

1 upvotes on reddit

Huge_Clue2949 · 1 year ago

From what I've observed, airlines often provide flight crew with Travelpro luggage. Despite enduring considerable wear and tear—often more than what a typical traveler would subject their luggage to—the handles tend to hold up for about 5 to 6 years. However, many pilots opt to upgrade to LuggageWorks. While I haven't personally used their rollers, I've seen flight crew members with LuggageWorks shoulder bags that still look brand new after four years of rigorous use. This speaks volumes about their durability and reliability, making them a promising option for frequent travelers or those in demanding professions like aviation.

1 upvotes on reddit

No-Comment-8441 · 1 year ago

Carry-on bags on US flights are getting out of hand. Comparing it to places like Australia, the amount of carry-on luggage people bring onto American domestic flights is just too much. It looks like everyone is trying to take as much as they can, and some bags are clearly too big for the overhead bins. Dealing with this slows down boarding a lot, maybe by 30%, because the bins fill up fast and people struggle to fit everything in. It's a big waste of time. How do people tolerate this?

1 upvotes on reddit

Fickle_Height7331 · 1 year ago

You think it's chaotic here? Try traveling in China sometime—it's a whole different level of crazy.

The big issue is that nobody wants to check their bags if they can help it, and who can blame them? The luggage staff at airports are so scarce that it can take ages for your bags to show up. I've witnessed it firsthand—waiting an entire hour just for your luggage to appear on the carousel is no joke.

If the airports would just do their job properly, I'm sure more people would opt to check their bags. Honestly, by the time I've gotten off the plane, gone through immigration and customs, and trekked what feels like miles to the baggage claim, my bags should already be waiting for me. It's a simple expectation, really.

1 upvotes on reddit

Upstairs_Fig5772 · 1 year ago

Back when checked bags were included in the ticket price, this wasn't a problem. But once airlines started charging extra for them, it's no surprise that people started bringing more carry-on bags instead. In my view, airlines should either include everything in one price, like some budget airlines such as Spirit and Frontier, or charge separately for each service. This in-between approach just encourages people to bring more carry-ons, even though planes weren't built to handle all that extra stuff. So, when airlines make carry-ons seem "free" and charge $70 for checked bags, it's no wonder this became a common issue.

1 upvotes on reddit

Ok_Baby9716 · 1 year ago

We should make it normal and even encourage calling out people who stash their bags in the front and then stroll to the back of the plane. It's such a hassle to have to store your carry-on several rows away and then awkwardly retrieve it once the plane lands. It's like they're playing a game of "find your bag" while everyone else waits impatiently. Let's shine a light on this behavior and make it clear that it's not okay. It's time for some etiquette in the air!

1 upvotes on reddit

See 12 replies

r/TravelHacks • [2]

Summarize

What's the Best Carry On Luggage?

Posted by -AliRaza- · in r/TravelHacks · 1 year ago

Hi guys, I'm in need of luggage for travel purposes and I need a carry on luggage for myself. I need a carry on luggage that lasts longer and has durability.

Here are some carry on luggage brands I like

Samsonite
Travelpro
Briggs and Riley

Help me in choosing the best luggage for travel and let me know what other brands I should consider:)

6 upvotes on reddit

8 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

8 replies

El_Gronkerino · 1 year ago

I've used Samsonite exclusively and forever. They're very light but sturdy enough. They get abused by the airport handlers as I can see paint/scrape marks, but they've always lasted me a long time while traveling all over the world. They're also relatively cheap for what you get.

4 upvotes on reddit

Baaastet · 1 year ago

I’ll second Samsonite but because they have a range that weigh the least. I compared a lot of them against each other. Some bags weigh 2-3kgs more. I want that weight to use myself, not for the bag.

Also the wheels are the best with long or lifetime replacement.

3 upvotes on reddit

pbandbob · 1 year ago

I love my travel pro. The wheels are FAB. Although sometimes it does try and escape from me

9 upvotes on reddit

thisissamuelclemens · 1 year ago

Tumi or rimowa

5 upvotes on reddit

IYIik_GoSu · 1 year ago

This.

1 upvotes on reddit

[deleted] · 1 year ago

For lightweight carry on I love Delsey Paris, it’s really good.

3 upvotes on reddit

more_nutmeg_please · 1 year ago

I love my Delsey Paris. It's so sturdy and it's pretty unique looking.

1 upvotes on reddit

Mediocre_Park_2042 · 1 year ago

I spent some bucks a while back on Briggs and Riley roller and have been using it for close to 13 years at this point. I've flown a ton and have had very little damage. The wheels are still working fine.

10 upvotes on reddit

See 8 replies

r/ManyBaggers • [3]

Summarize

What’s the best carry on luggage in 2025? Looking for a reliable suitcase for travel

Posted by MoraymaDoroshewitz · in r/ManyBaggers · 3 months ago

Alright, I’m ready to get roasted, but hear me out.

I’ve been researching the best carry on luggage in 2025, and honestly? A lot of the "top" bags people rave about just don’t seem that impressive once you dig in. Overhyped marketing, mediocre durability, and inflated prices are everywhere. I’m starting to think we’ve all just accepted certain brands as “the best” without really questioning them.

Here’s the shortlist I’ve been narrowing down:

Samsonite Freeform Hardside– looks decent but feels kinda flimsy?
Antler Clifton 22 Inch – gorgeous design, but is it really built to last?
Travelpro Platinum Elite – flight crew favorite, but is it actually that much better than the cheaper Maxlite?
Travelpro Maxlite 5 – lightweight for sure, but feels like it could collapse if I look at it wrong
Samsonite Omni PC″ – tons of hype, but I’ve read reviews saying it scratches if you breathe on it

What I actually want:

A true carry on suitcase that won’t die after 3 trips
Fits overhead bins for both US and international airlines
Good wheels and a handle that doesn’t rattle like a shopping cart
Decent internal layout (nothing fancy, just functional)
Under $500, and I don’t want to pay extra just for brand clout

I keep hearing that these are the “best carry on luggage” options out there, but I’m not fully convinced. Am I missing something? Are there better options that aren’t hyped into oblivion?

Or tell me if I’m wrong, is one of these actually the one?

Update: After All the Research and Feedback, Here’s What I Bought and What I Think Is Best for Carry-On Luggage in 2025

Thanks to everyone who chimed in with their experiences and recommendations, this community really helped me cut through the noise!

What I Learned:

Briggs & Riley Baseline remains the gold standard for durability and repairability, but it’s heavy and pricey. Great if you want a lifetime investment and don’t mind the weight.
TravelPro (especially the FlightCrew and Versapack+ lines) offers excellent value, durability, and smart features at a reasonable price. Flight crews love it, partly because of discounts, but their consumer lines hold up well too.
Samsonite Freeform and Outline are solid mid-range choices, with Freeform offering reliability for a very fair price.
Maxlite 5 is surprisingly durable for the price and weight, great for travelers on a budget.
Monos, Away, Beis, and Heys bring style and good customer service, but watch prices and return policies.
ThinkTank and Solgaard are solid niche options with outstanding build quality and lifetime warranties.
Other notable mentions: Patagonia rolling duffels for a flexible, rugged alternative; Ridge for a durable option; and keeping an eye out for sales on Samsonite’s Silhouette and Armage II series.

What I Bought:

After weighing the options, I went with the TravelPro Versapack+ carry-on. It hits the sweet spot for me with its balance of weight, durability, internal organization, and price (usually under $400). The new YKK zippers and proven water resistance were big selling points. Plus, I like that it’s favored by frequent travelers but still offers great value compared to pricier brands.

57 upvotes on reddit

12 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

1) TravelPro Platinum Elite
2) Briggs & Riley Baseline Spinner

12 replies

1800treflowers · 3 months ago

I travel internationally (mostly Asia) several times a year, domestically much more and have loved the Briggs ZDX domestic carry on. It's a beast and still looks brand new, rolls nicely and sturdy. I just looked and they actually have it $100 off so it meets your budget too.

16 upvotes on reddit

mrsmithzoo · 3 months ago

I’m also a fan of the ZDX. I got a couple of the carry-on duffles for a trip to Japan. The 2 wheels vs spinner were great for varying terrain and stairs. It was amazing what can be fit in them.

Of you’re a Costco member, they’re part of the Costco NEXT program.

4 upvotes on reddit

MoraymaDoroshewitz · OP · 3 months ago

Nice, that ZDX looks like it means business. Have you ever had issues fitting it in stricter international overhead bins, especially in Asia? Some of those flights can be pretty unforgiving with size limits.

2 upvotes on reddit

007meow · 3 months ago

Worth the splurge: Briggs and Riley Baseline - durable, fantastically designed, and the compression system has saved me in a pinch. It is THE highest standard. But also with the highest price, outside of Rimowa.

Not worth it: Tumi Alpha - Great bag and well made... but heavy and not worth the premium. You're paying a lot for the brand.

Best value: TravelPro Crew Classic/Versapack. Gets you 80-90% of what the higher end bags give you for half the price.

5 upvotes on reddit

MoraymaDoroshewitz · OP · 3 months ago

Appreciate this breakdown, super helpful.

I’ve been eyeing Briggs & Riley, especially with that lifetime warranty. Just tough to swallow the price when I’m still not sure if I’m someone who travels enough to justify it (yet). That compression system does look slick though, has it actually held up well after a bunch of trips?

Totally agree with you on Tumi. Every time I try one in-store, I’m surprised by how heavy they are even empty. Cool design, but yeah, I don’t need to flex my suitcase.

And good to know about the Crew Classic/Versapack, I’ve mostly seen hype around the Platinum Elite and Maxlite, but if the Crew line gives me 80-90% of B&R for under $300, that’s kinda exactly what I’m looking for.

Have you traveled internationally with the Versapack? Curious how it fits in overhead bins on tighter carriers.

2 upvotes on reddit

BooMeRx_1 · 3 months ago

You’re not wrong to be skeptical. So much of the “best carry-on” chatter is driven by affiliate marketing and brand loyalty rather than real-world durability and design. That said, your shortlist isn’t far off, each of those bags has its place, but none of them are flawless.

10 upvotes on reddit

RoverAdam · 3 months ago

Not the good or flagship models… I just checked. I ended up getting the TravelPro Platinum Elite for the cost of shipping since I had an old Platinum 7 with the lifetime replacement warranty. Handle broke years ago and finally got the replacement. Took it on a 2 week trip across Asia and like it. Handle is secure, which works well with me 30-40L Black Ember Forge 40 that weighs 30-50 lbs depending on load out. I really wanted a Brigs and Riley but I read that the handle is wobbly and flimsy which would not last long with my briefcase/bag strapped to it. I really only like 2 wheelers cause I like a suitor and more room. 4 wheelers take up too much room.

1 upvotes on reddit

Sampyi · 3 months ago

I actually have the Travelpro Platinum Elite and it’s been a beast. Got it after seeing a bunch of airline crew swearing by it, and honestly? It lives up to the hype. Handle’s sturdy, zippers are smooth, and it rolls like a dream even on carpeted airport floors. Used it for both domestic and international, no issues fitting overhead.

Only one I’d personally avoid is the Samsonite Omni. A friend had it and that thing looked like it got in a fight after one trip. Scratches everywhere, and it just felt kinda cheap up close.

Can’t speak for the others, but if you're leaning toward the Platinum Elite and can find it on sale, it’s a solid long-hauler.

7 upvotes on reddit

zyklon_snuggles · 3 months ago

> Travelpro Platinum Elite

Have you ever had to check it? Just wondering how it stands up to that potential abuse.

1 upvotes on reddit

MoraymaDoroshewitz · OP · 3 months ago

Appreciate the firsthand feedback, this is exactly the kind of info I was hoping to get. Sounds like your Platinum Elite is holding up like a champ, which is encouraging.

Funny you mentioned the Omni… I had a feeling that one might be all show and no grit. Looks sleek online but just doesn’t feel confidence-inspiring in person.

Have you had to gate-check the Platinum Elite on any international flights or smaller planes? Just wondering how tight the fit is in those overhead bins when space is at a premium. Also, any issues with the weight when it’s fully packed? It looks a bit chunkier than some of the ultralights like the Maxlite.

Thanks again for the insight, it’s helping me lean in a bit more on the Platinum if I can catch it on sale.

3 upvotes on reddit

emeybee · 3 months ago

If your bag is breaking down after 3 trips then you’re doing something wrong. I have a cheap Dakine roller that I’ve checked on dozens (if not hundreds) of flights over the past 20 years, and it’s still going great with no issues.

23 upvotes on reddit

MoraymaDoroshewitz · OP · 3 months ago

Fair enough, sounds like you’ve got a bag that’s built to last! Maybe I’m just a bit rougher on mine or unlucky with certain airlines. What model is that Dakine? Might be worth checking out if it’s held up that well over so many trips.

0 upvotes on reddit

See 12 replies

r/ManyBaggers • [4]

Summarize

What’s the best carry-on luggage in 2025? Need the best one!!

Posted by nosocoolt · in r/ManyBaggers · 6 months ago

Yo, I’m on the hunt for a durable, lightweight, and easy-to-maneuver carry-on that won’t get wrecked after a few trips. Gotta be TSA-friendly, have smooth wheels, and actually fit in overhead bins without a fight. Not trying to deal with cheap zippers, weak handles, or bags that scuff up after one flight.

UPDATE: I finalized the list below and chose the first one.

I’ve had some mid carry-ons before, but either the wheels got stuck, the handle felt flimsy, or it just didn’t hold enough. Looking for something that actually holds up for frequent travel. What’s the best one in this year??

16 upvotes on reddit

12 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

12 replies

its-creator1036 · 23 days ago

I read reviews and threads, and other's personal experiences. I'd actually recommend the Samsonite Freeform Carry-on. It's way more affordable than the travelpro or briggs, but still super tough and built to last through dozens of flights. The double spinner wheels are buttery smooth, handle feels solid and it fits overhead bins without drama. Honestly, for long term and durability this beats the pricier options and won't leave you waiting months like peak.

1 upvotes on reddit

valentinelocke · 6 months ago

This. I just upgraded my B&R because I passed my original (7 year old) one to my son. It’s still in like new condition, but their warranty is so good it’ll be like new for as long as we own it.

I have the cabin spinner and the 21” global carry on now. Smoothest carry on experience ever.

Definitely get the spinner, not the 2 when version. That’s my only regret about my first one; I immediately wished I had the movement of the spinner.

1 upvotes on reddit

SmugBeardo · 6 months ago

I got the 2 wheel version and love it, but to each their own. I liked the 2 wheel version’s orange hi-vis interior and sturdier wheels for cityscapes that aren’t well paved. It’s held up super well and best part (of both models) is the top zip pocket! Makes emptying pockets at security check such a breeze. Lowkey favorite feature.

2 upvotes on reddit

21WatchingWatches · 6 months ago

Travelpro Platinum Elite spinner. I have used mine for 3 years now. Still looks and rolls like new. It’s excellent and generally rated as the best overall carryon

14 upvotes on reddit

slow-loser · 6 months ago

I had an almost ten year old Travel Pro die because of severe abuse from an airline (Allegiant) and as soon as the check came in from them, I bought a Platinum Elite spinner.

5 upvotes on reddit

21WatchingWatches · 6 months ago

Aren’t they great?! Best money I’ve spent on luggage

3 upvotes on reddit

krsb09 · 6 months ago

This. My only complaint is that they roll just a bit TOO well. If something taps it and you're not holding on, you better start running after it.

2 upvotes on reddit

Wajid-H-Wajid · 19 days ago

Yeah Peak Design looks awesome 😅. Back then the wait was rough, but glad it’s in stock now. SwissGear Sion and Samsonite Freeform keep showing up in travel gear discussions and people rate them pretty well.

-50 upvotes on reddit

Wajid-H-Wajid · 15 days ago

-10 upvotes on reddit

PeteyNice · 6 months ago

There is no one right answer. It depends on your budget, what you value, and what airlines you fly.

The usual suspects are the usual suspects for a reason.

Spinner, two wheels, or no wheels at all?

Softside or hardside?

Maximize packing space or maximize airline acceptance?

People like the TravelPro Platinum Elite spinner, but it is a big bag for a carry on and while unlikely to be an issue on legacy US airlines, you are rolling the dice every time you fly an international airline.

The Briggs and Riley baseline is bombproof and has an unmatched warranty but it weighs 10 lbs empty. If you fly airlines with strict weight limits that can be a problem.

You can buy lighter weight bags like say a TravelPro MaxLite but you give up durability for the weight savings.

It's all trade offs. Which ones you are willing to make is a personal decision.

5 upvotes on reddit

nosocoolt · OP · 6 months ago

yeah, you're totally right, it’s all about the trade-offs. depends on what matters most to you, like weight or durability. i’ve heard good things about travelpro, but the whole weight thing with the briggs and riley is a solid point too. it’s a tough call, but definitely gotta think about how strict airlines are on weight limits, especially on intl flights. guess it all comes down to what you prioritize!

1 upvotes on reddit

derouville · 6 months ago

Travelpro max lite. Cheap, light, and durable.

17 upvotes on reddit

See 12 replies

r/ManyBaggers • [5]

Summarize

What’s the Best Carry-On Luggage That Actually Lasts?

Posted by ParticularSubject411 · in r/ManyBaggers · 1 month ago

I’ve been researching carry-on luggage for a while now, and honestly, it feels like a rabbit hole. Between hardshell vs. softshell, spinner vs. roller, lightweight vs. durable… it’s hard to know what’s actually worth the money.

I travel often enough that I want something that checks these boxes:

Fits international and domestic carry-on size limits
Durable enough to survive overhead bins & rough handling
Smooth wheels (airport floors can be a nightmare)
Smart compartments for laptop / essentials
Ideally under $300

Some options I’ve found so far:

Away Bigger Carry-On - stylish, good warranty... but some people say it scuffs easily.
Samsonite Winfield 3 DLX - seems like a safe, classic choice.
Travelpro Platinum Elite - flight crews swear by it.
Monos Carry-On Plus - looks premium.. but wondering if it’s worth the price.
Briggs & Riley - $$$ but everyone says their warranty is unbeatable.

For those of you who travel frequently:
> Which carry-on bag do you swear by?
> Is hardshell really better than softshell in the long run?
> Do “premium” brands actually hold up better than mid-range?

I’m hoping to hear real experiences!!!! Thanks

5 upvotes on reddit

12 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

12 replies

JB_Redo · 1 month ago

Briggs and Riley. Buy once, cry once, and never have to think about your carry-on bag again.

It will not be under $300.

I've had mine for 12 years, carried it on, checked it, over packed it...It has some scuffs on the outside but still works perfectly well. It is not a hard shell but as noted, I have no concerns about durability. Everyone I know who has a B&R says the same things about durability.

I would suggest going to a store that sells their bags and looking at them in person. The options can be a little overwhelming online.

25 upvotes on reddit

ParticularSubject411 · OP · 21 days ago

Just bought this one from Briggs and Riley.... thanks everyone for the suggestions!

1 upvotes on reddit

JB_Redo · 17 days ago

I hope you get decades of reliable service. Safe travels!

1 upvotes on reddit

NKB246 · 1 month ago

I’ve had a B&R Baseline carry-on sitting in my closet for a few years and am just using it right now for the first time. It is great. The compression system works well and the wheels are smooth. Pretty boring to look at, but I am very happy I have it.

0 upvotes on reddit

thatgirlinny · 1 month ago

Briggs & Riley Baseline forever! Mine’s taken abuse worldwide, still looks great years later. And what’s inside (including items on hangers) gets to each destination soundly.

Buy well, and you buy once!

3 upvotes on reddit

Boots-bags-jackets · 1 month ago

You can find pretty good deals for Briggs and Riley on EBay/ Poshmark.

1 upvotes on reddit

despitethetimes · 1 month ago

Flight crew here. Briggs & Riley, Luggageworks, and Strongbags are the three brands I see most often. I prefer Strongbags. No smart compartments but the inner shell is super durable.

12 upvotes on reddit

Indelible_Eraser · 1 month ago

Strongbags look great -- but even for the 20" international size, the weight of the bag itself is 5.8 kg -- nearly TWICE the weight of a carryon roller from Briggs & Riley, Travel Pro, or any other bag intended for passengers rather than crew.

Internationally, most airlines have a weight limit of 7 kg to 8 kg for carryon bags, though for some airlines the limit is 10 kg. If a passenger is flying with a Strongbags roller and any of those airlines weigh it, they undoubtedly will require the passenger to check it.

6 upvotes on reddit

Sellum · 1 month ago

Love my Briggs & Riley, I bought mine with airline miles so in a way my company bought it for me.

7 upvotes on reddit

steponmedaddies · 1 month ago

Ideally under $300

Everyone: How about this $700 bag instead?

11 upvotes on reddit

CommercialGur3015 · 1 month ago

It's luggage.

5 upvotes on reddit

UnionCrafty3748 · 1 month ago

I’ve had the Briggs & Riley global carry on spinner for years and it’s been rock solid. The only issue is that it is expensive and heavier than most carry ons. Another quality carry on bag I’ve been using for the last couple of months is the Bellroy Transit. Great bag.

7 upvotes on reddit

See 12 replies

r/ManyBaggers • [6]

Summarize

Best carry on luggage recommendations?

Posted by Sanskarikela · in r/ManyBaggers · 18 days ago

I’m planning to invest in a solid carry-on suitcase and would love some recommendations. Ideally, I’m looking for something that’s durable, lightweight, and easy to maneuver through airports. Bonus points if it fits most airlines’ size requirements and has good storage organization.

For those of you who travel often, what’s your go-to carry-on luggage brand or model, and why do you recommend it?

EDIT: Forgot to mention these: Budget ($300–$400) / A normal 13–15" laptop / Location: USA

19 upvotes on reddit

12 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

https://wearenthusiast.com/best-carry-on-luggage-2025/

12 replies

Spare_Shirt260 · 17 days ago

I’ve heard away is no longer the best. Heard monos is better. Belroys first carry on seems like a hit as well. It’s engineered for self repair which I thought was super clever and I believe it comes with removable packing cubes. I personally went with aers first carry on and I love love love it! I’m a sucker for a good looking product honestly. Made with excellent materials, AirTag pocket, brake locks for the wheels, hinomoto wheels and easy gliding telescopic handle, My only issue is that reviews said it scratches easily because of the flat surface so I bought a cover to prevent that. It is also a bit heavier than other similarly priced competitors but for me this isn’t an issue. I would weigh the pros and cons between these three and see what works best for you! Personally these were my top options.

2 upvotes on reddit

Gloomy-Wave1418 · 13 days ago

Good call on Monos, that's a solid choice. But if you are looking at that price point, you've also got some other heavy hitters like Away and Travelpro that are just as popular for a reason.

There are a lot of great luggage out there right now and the details can make all the difference. I found a good breakdown of the top brands and what makes each one stand out which might help you decide:

1 upvotes on reddit

NKB246 · 16 days ago

I bought a B&R Baseline and it is awesome. Purchased brand new on eBay from a seller I used in the past. In the price range. Not the most exciting bag, but really nice.

2 upvotes on reddit

Sanskarikela · OP · 15 days ago

I’ve heard a lot of good things about Briggs & Riley, especially their durability. How’s the weight and maneuverability on the Baseline?

1 upvotes on reddit

LoveOfSpreadsheets · 14 days ago

I have one and I don't like it (but do love my backpack and checked bag from them). It weighs nearly 10lb empty. Non USA airlines ( like Singapore Air or Lufthansa as two examples) wanna see bags weighing as low as 17lb so what's the point? And if you're flying domestic USA then then weight doesn't matter, so I end up with less carrying capacity than my 7lb Samsonite that's 23x15x9 and fits in the overhead bin.

If I was buying today with the benefit of hindsight, I'd keep my B&R medium checked Spinner but buy a Travelpro carry on, either crew classic or platinum elite. If you check them out notice the "carry on vs compact carry on" sizes. Briggs Baseline is the latter volume and twice the price. I went for Briggs for BIFL but I don't want it for life.

1 upvotes on reddit

NKB246 · 15 days ago

It’s not flimsy and the compression system adds weight, but I don’t find it noticeably heavy. The wheels are great. I had a Rimowa before this one and that was maybe a little smoother, but fractionally. I got the International carry-on size and had more than enough space for an eight day trip.

1 upvotes on reddit

ajaak7 · 17 days ago

I really like my Monos Carry-on Hybrid. Just got back from a 4 day work trip and it worked great paired with a backpack.

2 upvotes on reddit

effinexpletive · 17 days ago

This is my favorite luggage. Great heft, smooth wheeling, sturdy trolley handle, and and no external zips to worry about. Of note: the hybrid is a bit tighter than a standard carry-on. I've found this to be a good thing as it fits overhead on even the smallest regional jet.

1 upvotes on reddit

zackumar25 · 17 days ago

Do take a look at Bellroy transit carry-on.

2 upvotes on reddit

Sanskarikela · OP · 15 days ago

Thanks! I will check them out.

1 upvotes on reddit

Soft-Football8303 · 10 days ago

Travel pro are awesome

1 upvotes on reddit

SnooHamsters7373 · 15 days ago

Monos are good. I have one and I really love it.

1 upvotes on reddit

See 12 replies

r/ManyBaggers • [7]

Summarize

What is the Best Carry-On Luggage to Buy Right Now?

Posted by Financial-Magazine72 · in r/ManyBaggers · 1 month ago

I’ve got a hectic travel schedule coming up, both domestic and international, with a mix of short and long trips. Please advise on a highly durable carry-on that can handle heavy use. Something expandable would be ideal for those times when I need to pack just a little extra. Smooth and sturdy rollers would be great to have. What’s the best option in terms of cost and value? Is Briggs & Riley really the “buy once cry once” investment everyone talks about? Or does Travelpro offer great quality for its price? Could a more affordable option (under $200) still last 2 to 3 years of heavy use?

22 upvotes on reddit

11 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

11 replies

Emotional-Ad3521 · 1 month ago

Had great luck with travel pro. 10 yrs on an elite spinner and over 15 trips a year, and still looks new.

19 upvotes on reddit

Potterco24 · 1 month ago

The top load zipper is the key for me. I’ve come to despise clamshell design after decades with those models and trying to use them in tiny European and Asian hotel rooms

4 upvotes on reddit

Swamp_Hawk420 · 1 month ago

Not the new Peak Design roller, that's for sure lol. My cousin is an international pilot, he carries a Travelpro Maxlite 5, that's certainly within your budget. To be fair tho, I've never used one and my cousin is a bit of a cheap asshole.

8 upvotes on reddit

Nutchos · 1 month ago

Whats wrong with the PD one?

2 upvotes on reddit

Swamp_Hawk420 · 1 month ago

The hinge sounds like someone hooked an amplifier up to my knees getting out of a chair

2 upvotes on reddit

Baaastet · 1 month ago

Weight is most important (fitting the measurements too for course) for me as I travel with hand-luggage only. When I bought the last bag for work, that was a Samsonite.

8 upvotes on reddit

Minimum-Dot1057 · 1 month ago

This. I have TP3, PD 45, CabinZero military, American Tourist, couple of Wenger but Samsonite is my way to go on budget flights. 30l, slightly longer then allowed, great organization, comfortable and just 850g. Perfect.

5 upvotes on reddit

rubberchain · 1 month ago

although i've moved on, I can't say anything bad about the samsonites i've had. Most are designed very good pocketing and layout, super durable skate wheels (i'm a 2 wheels only person), and nice zippers. In all that time, i've only had a minor problems.

1 upvotes on reddit

007meow · 1 month ago

There have been so many threads about exactly this in just even the past month alone.

Have you searched? What makes your use case different than those?

36 upvotes on reddit

Blugrl21 · 1 month ago

Typing the post title into Reddits new answers AI mode gives a great summary of these threads. But the AI answers depend on people periodically asking the same questions to keep the answers fresh

-6 upvotes on reddit

Cedosg · 1 month ago

for durability, the briggs and riley is top of the line imo but it is heavy so you have to judge for yourself if you prefer a lighter less durable luggage.

for example it's a good 5 pounds heavier than a travelpro maxlite.

9 upvotes on reddit

See 11 replies

r/ManyBaggers • [8]

Summarize

NYT: The Best Carry-On Luggage. Do you agree?

Posted by sinclave · in r/ManyBaggers · 1 year ago

nytimes.com

26 upvotes on reddit

12 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

https://www.reddit.com/r/HerOneBag/comments/1bpa6at/best_carryon_luggage_recommendations/

12 replies

driftingphotog · 1 year ago

There are few brands I will constantly shill for, and Briggs and Riley is one of them. The warranty and service is still one of “those” companies, where it’s actually forever, actually no questions, and actually easy to deal with (assuming you’re near an authorized service center). None of that “lifetime warranty but actually this is just normal wear and tear so we won’t cover that” bullshit.

They’re actual But It For Life items, with the company longevity to back that up.

It’s the little things. Sure, the handle feels flimsy, but it’s actually quite strong and more importantly outside of the storage volume. Makes it so much easier to use cubes. And the compression system is great.

Mine has hundreds of thousands of flight miles on it. Checked and carryon. The only con is that it’s heavy.

My bag setup is either my B&R Baseline 2-Wheel, an Eagle Creek rolling duffel, or a Patagonia Black Hole.

26 upvotes on reddit

reikableu · 18 days ago

yeah honestly it shakes out like this for me:

travelpro platinum elite is the most practical - built for people who actually fly a lot, not pretty but never breaks. kind of ugly though if you care about that stuff.

briggs riley has that lifetime warranty thing but costs way too much unless youre flying every week for work. like why spend 500 on a suitcase.

away looks good in photos but see way too many posts about wheels breaking and shells cracking after like a year. overrated imo.

nomatic classic feels better cuz the hardshell actually holds up at tsa and the compression system inside makes packing way easier than the others.

4 upvotes on reddit

sinclave · OP · 1 year ago

Too true, my checked suitcase for months long trips is a Briggs and Riley extendable suitcase. Wow am I obsessed with it! My hesitancy was indeed that the handle feels flimsy. However, I always chalked it up to the nearly 50lbs of stuff packed within the bag.

Considering how much l love my B&R, I may need to look into shelling out some more to the B&R 4 wheel carry on....

Love the Patagonia Black Hole as well!

2 upvotes on reddit

YourCaptainSpeaking_ · 1 year ago

I don’t disagree with most of it. People searching “best carryon suitcase 2024” would all be well-served by most of those options. The only one that really stands out to me is the Yeti. I think there are a lot of better options for that style of rolling duffel (Patagonia, Northface, and Osprey just to name a few).

TravelPros are solid bang-for-buck, and Briggs and Riley is considered a gold-standard bag. My gf uses a Beis (Away/Monos style&price) that has help up great for the <5 flights she may take in a year and is honestly super feature rich.

“The best” is on such a case by case basis that it’s hard to compile a list. The best makers of spinners may not make the best roller. The best duffel bag manufacturers won’t make the best spinner, etc.

I’ve been using a combination of Briggs&Riley spinner, Patagonia Black Hole, and Mystery Ranch backpack for years now and am very happy, but I’m not buying a Briggs duffel or a Patagonia spinner, ya know?

16 upvotes on reddit

seche314 · 1 year ago

I do have a Briggs carry on duffel and like it a lot. But it is sized to work as a personal item akin to a backpack. The specific model is discontinued though - I don’t think I would purchase the newer one as I don’t like the organization quite as much

1 upvotes on reddit

Apprehensive_Shallot · 1 year ago

Yes--this is great rolling luggage for their typical readers.

The Travelpro stuff is well made for a not-so-dear price. The Away and Monos look sleek and roll nicely. They do not last as long as the nice soft=sides, in my experience. (Currently rolling a Monos.

It's just a suitcase.

31 upvotes on reddit

Ok_Courage_7781 · 1 year ago

Yes, also this thread is a really good read:

1 upvotes on reddit

fiverrpeao · 1 year ago

I have Antler Soft Stripe Cabin and it's been a wonderful experience. it's durable and has smooth-rolling wheels. Highly recommended. This post has some great recommendations

1 upvotes on reddit

fiverrpeao · 1 year ago

I have Antler Soft Stripe Cabin and it's been a wonderful experience. it's durable and has smooth-rolling wheels. Highly recommended.

1 upvotes on reddit

optix_clear · 1 year ago

Me too. I liked smaller carry-ons but thinking of. Carry on trunk. My husband has Solgaard. The child has 3 pcs level 8 cases, Samonite Tru- Frame spinner and rolling duffel when they went to camp.

4 upvotes on reddit

Apprehensive_Shallot · 1 year ago

I played with one once. If you like the built in packing bags, they are great. I tend to change the size and type of organizers in my luggage, so it wasn't for me.

3 upvotes on reddit

YourCaptainSpeaking_ · 1 year ago

Depends on what I’m doing. I swap between a 3Day Assault Pack and the Mission Rover 30.

The Rover is great bc it’s essentially the largest a “personal item” can be as long as it’s not completely full depth-wise. Had a should strap and stowable backpack straps. 1 large compartment, some zippered pockets, a shoe compartment, and a front laptop compartment.

The 3DAP is great, but I think I’d do the Scree series if I had to do it over again. The 3DAP is heavier and more “tactical”, but I use it for training classes and stuff so the durability is a plus. For strictly travel bags, there are better options from MR or other brands.

2 upvotes on reddit

See 12 replies

r/ManyBaggers • [9]

Summarize

What is the Best Carry-On Luggage to Buy Right Now?

Posted by bad_genitals · in r/ManyBaggers · 8 months ago

4 upvotes on reddit

12 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

https://aviation.travelpro.com/collections/flightcrew™-5/products/flightcrew™-5-slim-expandable-rollaboard®

12 replies

SvelteSyntax · 8 months ago

Travelpro really excels at price:performance.

Briggs & Riley has a few neat features (ratcheting expander, garment folder) and is more durable.

If you are a million miler or on track to be, B&R. For everyone else, there’s Travelpro.

6 upvotes on reddit

JeowJeow · 6 months ago

I got this one and it's pretty good. It’s lightweight, durable, and fits most airline size restrictions. The smooth spinner wheels make it easy to navigate, and the TSA-approved lock adds security.

2 upvotes on reddit

undergroundgirl7 · 8 months ago

I agree, really happy with my travelpro Maxlite 5 compact carry on. Well designed and extremely light

2 upvotes on reddit

Beerswain · 8 months ago

Just one more vote for Travelpro.

2 upvotes on reddit

Silver-Tooth-6955 · 20 days ago

Does maxlite travelpro 5 have a strap/slot to attach to larger suitcase?

1 upvotes on reddit

Accurate_Shine5695 · 8 months ago

I've had the Travelpro Platinum Elite Expandable for about two years, and it's been a solid and reliable choice. The wheels roll smoothly, even on uneven floors, and the expandable feature has been really useful for longer trips. The USB port is a nice touch, especially during layovers. If you're someone who travels a lot and needs a dependable carry-on, this one ticks all the boxes.

2 upvotes on reddit

OrangePilled2Day · 8 months ago

I've got the carry on and a medium checked bag from that series and they're by far the best bags I've ever owned. My mid-tier Samsonite I had before feels like dollar store luggage in comparison.

1 upvotes on reddit

jmmaxus · 8 months ago

Travelpro but the collection for airline employees which can be hard to find in their website. Flightcrew 5 series. I’d get the Travelpro FlightCrew™ 5 Slim Expandable Rollaboard.

4 upvotes on reddit

peynet · 8 months ago

I’ve had my Travel Pro Platinum Elite Rollaboard two wheel expandable suitcase for about 15 years and it’s still in pristine condition. It’s been on international trips, both as carry on and checked luggage, and I take it on weekend car trips maybe once a month.

I bought the Platinum Elite spinner this year for a trip to southeast Asia (my spouse needed his own suitcase) and was pleasantly surprised that the burgundy colorway still matches my old luggage. I’ve learned the hard way that this isn’t necessarily a given.

2 upvotes on reddit

DgenarationX · 8 months ago

I have used it extensively and it still looks brand new. Got nice features like good expansion size for extra packing, a zip-out toiletry bag, a garment bag, and compression straps that secure the entire opening. And it rolls quite smoothly if you aren't careful, it can run away from you lol.

1 upvotes on reddit

diatho · 8 months ago

I went with the max air but travel pro soft sides is the best

2 upvotes on reddit

DAZ_50 · 8 months ago

Elite Hardside 21 inch and no issues so far but I haven't gone international yet.

1 upvotes on reddit

See 12 replies

r/ManyBaggers • [10]

Summarize

Carry-On Luggage: Which one has the most carrying capacity?

Posted by nomnomcaek · in r/ManyBaggers · 3 years ago

I've been shopping around for a new bag since my travelpro maxlite 4 softside of 5+ years has been getting a little beat up. I prefer to travel with just a backpack and a carry-on so I'm looking for a 4 wheel carry-on as replacement. I dont mind if its soft or hardshell, but just would not want a black suitcase. I can usually fit about 2 weeks in my backpack + carry-on during trips (for both work and leisure, domestic and international). I have checked in the luggage (only for international return leg) if that's a factor.

I've complied a list of names I've seen floating around and their carrying capacity. Whats not online of course is their quality/what it feels like to use one of these luggages for a long time. If anyone who has used one or multiple of these carry-ons who can chime in with their thoughts, that would be great!

Away "the bigger carry-on flex": one of those 'new well marketed internet brands', it boasts a 47.9 L + capacity to expand
Monos "carry on plus": I've seen it getting compared to away, it boasts a 48 L carrying capacity with no expansion
Beis "carry on roller": also one of those 'new well marketed internet brands', it boasts a 45 L + capacity to expand
Briggs & Riley "Baseline 22''": has good lifetime warrenty? marked as having between 39-51 L capacity but also the most bland looking of the bunch
Travel pro "Elite 21'' Expandable carry-on": the OG brand - boasts 46 L capacity with room to expand. I believe ther's a 22'' option one as well but that seems to be sold out...
I've left tumi out on purpose because for the price, i've been advised to get tbe briggs and riley bag instead as its better quality (but please dispute me on that if I'm wrong)

Am I missing any brands? Does anyone have other favorites or recommendations? And more importantly which one should i buy?

3 upvotes on reddit

12 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/best-carry-on-luggage/

12 replies

ThisIsDarkestTime · 3 years ago

Briggs & Riley Baseline is hands down the best suitcase of the bunch. It's so smartly designed and backed by their lifetime warranty. I absolutely love compression feature and how the garment holder folds out.

I also like Samsonite. Had a basic soft side for almost 20 years and checked it for many long international hauls. It survived much more beating than the TravelPro. The TravelPro didn't last that many trips for me, but at a more accessible price point (especially on sale), it's adequate if you're an occasional traveler.

My SO swears by Tumi. (He also had a TravelPro break on him on a trip and he will never buy one again).

Out of the DTC/internet brands: Monos > Away >> Beis. Beis has a lot of negative reviews around quality issues.

Also check out Rimowa for hard side. Pricey but everyone I know that has one, owns it forever.

6 upvotes on reddit

nomnomcaek · OP · 3 years ago

Thank you for that information! I did a lot of work travel but that stopped during pandemic so it's mostly been leisure trips - so i wasnt sure how much use I'd get out of the garment hanger. But quality is definitely good to note.

I also had a samsonite soft side years ago (before travel pro) but that one had wheel troubles so I havent gone back - was there a specific model that worked for you?

I'm quite weary of the DTC/internet brands but so many of the online reviewers rave about those (instead of the old school ones) so i had to include it in here as comparison

I have seen flight attendents carrying rimowas in the airport now that I've looked them up - but yes the price is staggering - thats basically rent money!

1 upvotes on reddit

ThisIsDarkestTime · 3 years ago

I am pretty sure they stopped making the Samsonite model or rebranded it many times over- I got it back in the 90s. It survived a lot of rough terrains - rolled it up and down stairs, gravel and cobble stone, etc. Now it's retired and I use it to store my travel bags 😅

The DTC brands spend a lot of money to generate all the hype. It's hard to talk about durability and longevity when the product been out for such a short time. It really does come down to what's your budget, how often do you travel, and what type of travel do you do.

The DTC bags are much more accessible and will probably last a decent number of trips. Most people rank Samsonite and TravelPro similarly so you can't go wrong with either brands. I personally had a better experience with Samsonite than TravelPro and it seems like you had the opposite. However, if you can splurge, definitely go with a B&R or Tumi. In my opinion is definitely worth the price jump.

1 upvotes on reddit

Elegant-Step · 3 years ago

I tried both the Away and Monos bags you listed and ended up going with the Travelpro Platinum Elite. Here were my thoughts:

Hardside luggage looks pretty when you get it, but it scuffs so easily especially if you ever have to gate check it.
Hardside luggage also has no flexibility (obviously) so you can't squeeze in an extra shirt or souvenier. Additionally you'll have more trouble fitting it into some overhead bins because it won't squeeze in.
Travelpro's warranty is insanely good. Lifetime warranty, full stop, but wait there's more. On the Platinum Elite softside pieces, you also get free shipping for any repairs AND they will cover damage caused by an airline. They also have a full parts catalogue so if you need to replace any broken parts it's very straightforward.
Briggs and Riley also has a lifetime warranty which covers damage caused by the airline, and admittedly their bags look fantastic, but I think Travelpro's are quite handsome too (I have the coastal blue) and half the price or less.
Briggs and Riley seems to have a better compression system, but I think you can get some packing cubes and do your own compression.
The Travelpro bag has a lot of clever features. It comes with a garment folder which works quite well, the 4 wheels magnetically align so it naturally rolls straight, and it does have a bit of expansion.

If I had unlimited money I'd of course get a full B&R set. As it stands I don't, and $700 for the Baseline was over triple the $225 I paid for my Travelpro. B&R rarely does sales, while Travelpro does all the time. To me the B&R is not 3x as good, but if you have the funds there's no question it's the best. I think the Travelpro is quite excellent in its own regard, and should last me many years and trips I think.

2 upvotes on reddit

nomnomcaek · OP · 3 years ago

Thanks for the excellent breakdown - I've personally never had a hardside luggage so its good to hear its critiques. Good to see another point for B&R on quality, and Travelpro as well.

What made you go back to travelpro after using the Away and Monos bags (besides how easily scuffed it gets?)

1 upvotes on reddit

Elegant-Step · 3 years ago

They make a pretty convincing argument for softside luggage generally, and you'll note their top two are the Travelpro and B&R bags. I also found the clamshell style opening on hardside bags to be more annoying to work with than the panel style you can do on softside bags.

The scuff thing is no joke by the way. Even spending an hour tumbling around in an overhead bin will leave ugly streaks on the sides.

1 upvotes on reddit

bnmike · 2 years ago

also OP, interestingly travelpro has a platinum elite hardside and a platinum elite softide, and the hardside warranty is 5 years while the softside is lifetime. this makes me think that in general hardside luggage doesnt hold up in the long run as well as quality (nylon?) soft luggage.

1 upvotes on reddit

rahulio25 · 5 months ago

I went down a 2 week rabbit hole on this and clearly have nothing better to do, but I'm finally confident I have found the most spacious carry on.

Travelpro Maxlite 5 2-Wheel Carry-On - 46L unexpanded to 52L expanded.

I bought the Briggs and Riley 22" 2 wheeler as well, but its small. Unexpanded its a joke and if you expand it then its no longer a carry on....

1 upvotes on reddit

Asparagus_Ecstatic · 1 month ago

I was planning to get this one but noticed the height is 23" and many airlines such as united have 21/22 in restrictions so haven't pulled the trigger yet. Any issues?

1 upvotes on reddit

rahulio25 · 1 month ago

Ok so I actually decided on the Briggs and love it. I think it might actually have the most space

1 upvotes on reddit

William6635Oq · 8 months ago

I've been using a 4 wheel carry-on and it's spacious, durable, and comfortable to travel with.

1 upvotes on reddit

VisualStoryTelly · 6 months ago

Porsche suitcase

1 upvotes on reddit

See 12 replies

Top People to Talk to

These are some of the top contributors related to

CoffeeChronicles

TravelHacks

ManyBaggers

Huge_Clue2949

No bio available

Karma

Posts

Comments

Responsible_Mud8126

No bio available

Karma

Posts

Comments

ExactAd360

No bio available

127

Karma

Posts

Comments

Mobile-Raise-6343

No bio available

Karma

Posts

Comments

MolassesConfident645

No bio available

Karma

Posts

Comments

Forsaken_Detail2

No bio available

Karma

Posts

Comments

Due_Interest_4451

No bio available

Karma

Posts

Comments

Quiet_Orange_6594

No bio available

Karma

Posts

Comments