IT Cosmetics Bye Bye Undereye will cover anything. I find it a little too thick and tacky for me personally but you wouldn’t be able to see even the darkest circles through it.

I am cursed with the same dark circle affliction so I feel your pain. I've tried all of the expensive brands + some of the ones you mentioned (Jeffree *, Tarte, and Wet n Wild), but none of them completely concealed my circles. Like, you could always see them even if it was annoyingly barely visible. On a whim I bought this one on Amazon and it works better than any of the expensive name brands for me. I hope you find what you're looking for because it was such a confidence booster for me to finally completely get rid of my dark eye circles (even though the only one who probably cared or noticed was me lol)

Dark circles can be tricky to cover up, but I've found a product that has worked wonders for me. jane iredale's Under-Eye Concealer is what I consider my 'Holy Grail'. It manages to provide high coverage without feeling heavy or cakey and is great for those annoying dark circles. Plus, it's hydrating so it doesn't settle into fine lines. But remember, skincare is just as important when dealing with dark circles so ensure you're well hydrated and getting enough sleep!

Drak circles are hard to hide, i see that you tried many concealers just to hide those dark spots, personally I like the Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Concealer. It's a game-changer, even for hereditary dark circles. Give it a shot and embrace your natural beauty....

Omg you have to try Mac Pro longwear concealer in the pump. It smells like paint but it’s my freaking holy grail. You can come personally sue me if you don’t love it. I’m telling you. I have tried so many things. This concealer is the absolute best.

Agree with above commenter about it cosmetics bye bye under eye but two things- it creases like a bitch and it stays sticky. It also feels so, so heavy. It also tends to break me out. It’s almost too brightening too. But I mean I can see the appeal. Especially during colder weather.

For lighter makeup days I like using Bobbi brown brightening concealer.

Edited to add a pic of me with the pro longwear concealer. I have super dark circles naturally also and am very fair! I never set the concealer either.

https://preview.redd.it/2zpx99q88gbb1.jpeg?width=1125&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=97a88ee057f9d2d8b3597b03d24d151216f9176e

Milani Conceal & Perfect has excellent coverage with or without a color corrector -- I use Light Natural best as a Medium to Light Medium Neutral Olive. Not heavy at all and a frequent repurchase for me.

Kosas's concealer is very nice and can be layered in coverage -- moisturizing formula.

Contrary to what most mua recommend, i find using peach tone concealers somehow accentuate my dark circles instead. Not sure if its due the peachy tone clashing with my olive skintone, making the discoloration appear even more obvious.

I was using the catrice camouflage cream concealer previously. The slight yellow tone looks way more natural against my skintone. Its highly affordable too so might be worth a try.

I use too faced btw multi-use concealer. It has great coverage and is not drying under eyes.

You should try bobbi brown corrector in an appropriate shade (maybe peach) and get a concealer that matches or is 1-2 shades lighter than ur face.

I have very bad genetic dark circles and lately I’ve been covering them with a coral colored lipstick, then I blend it in with my BB and then on top I do maybelline age rewind concealer and bake it with banana powder and it covers my circles really nicely.

Shake hands! I also have major dark circles under my eyes that defies every concealer I’ve tried EXCEPT for innisfree concealer stick. It has very very good coverage and sticks to my skin all day long. Other concealers I’ve tried include Nars radiant creamy concealer, MAC concealer stick, seam liquid concealer, Maybelline fit me. These all failed to hide my dark circles completely. Only innisfree. Literally my savior

The Clio Kill Cover Liquid Concealer is the most full coverage concealer I've ever tried!

The Saem Cover Perfection Ideal Concealer Duo :) My undereyes are quite dry but the stick end of the concealer works really well to cover up and it's not dehydrating. I go in with the cream concealer side for extra coverage too

Onomie is the only undereye concealer in the world worth a damn imo

I really like the Skinfood Salmon concealer, it lasts a long time. It is in a little pot to be applied with your finger and I keep it in my purse for touch ups. I have the same dark circles as you.

Sephora Collection Bright Future Gel Serum Under Eye Concealer. The coverage is light to medium, looks like skin, and is actually hydrating under the eyes. It's a very thin formula and would be great for layering on top of a color correcter.

It only creases if you don't set with powder, but so does every non-matte concealer

I like the glossier stretch concealer

Honestly MAC prolong wear. Just use the tiniest amount. It will last you forever! I never set it with a powder and it does not crease. Go to the MAC store and have them color match you. It’s great natural coverage.

A vote for Dior backstage concealer. It’s medium coverage and luminous. When I pair it with the Bobbi Brown corrector, it looks marvelous.

try the caliray color corrector!! been hearing great things about

It's not sephora but my HG concealer is Maybelline Instant Age Rewind Eraser Multi Use Concealer.

Too faced born this way concealer

NARS creamy radiant or elf hydrating camo with a little bit of pinkish powder (I use eyeshadow!) on top

Dior forever skin correct. Light weight, full coverage and hydrating

I have these too, unfortunately they're hard to cover because it's also the shape as well as the colour, but I find using a good colour corrector, a more 'dewey' concealer, and setting spray keeps the area looking bright when wearing makeup 😊 anything too heavy doesnt look right there for me personally.

I recently tried the soap and glory kick ass concealer and colour corrector which I'm loving at the moment!

I also find dark eye makeup make it look worse, so I tent to stick to lighter colours, and bangs also make it look worse because of the shadow it can cast under your eyes.

You need to colour correct first (I have the same problem) for my skin tone I use orange - papaya from Huda Beauty - but I think you would need pink. Set it with translucent powder and then put your concealer on top.

It's also worth checking you don't have any vitamin/mineral deficiency contributing to them before just covering them up. Can sometimes happen with a big Wright loss

A concealer alone might not do the trick if you’re not colour-correcting first to cancel out the darkness.

Since dark circles often stem from genetics, you could also look into skincare specifically formulated to brighten the under-eye area.

From Ulta- Bobbi brown color corrector stick. Natasha Denona concealer. Possibly the new Double wear concealer depending on your dryness.

I love the Kulfi concealers. I have so many shades. They are amazing and SO underrated imho. One thing I have found is that if I pat it into my skin with my fingers, I avoid creasing (like if I used a beauty blender). Then I set it with powder right away. (Oh, I also use two shades of the Huda Beauty correctors beforehand!) 🫶

Natasha denona

I have a Natasha denona sample and that is going to be my next purchase concealer. I did also get the Live Tinted concealer and love that as well. Very light and hydrating but covers my bags well.

Nars soft matte concealer

First you need an orange or peach color corrector. You apply that to the whole area and then you can apply medium or full coverage concealer depending on the look you’re going for. Any concealers will Work once you have a good color corrector base! Once you blend it out set it with a setting powder and brush it off immediately so it doesn’t look cakey. You should be good after that! Some really good color correctors I’ve found are Huda beauty faux filter, fenty and LA girl is a classic cheap but amazing quality one!

It cosmetics bye bye undereye is my go to

MAC pro longwear concealer is what we were trained to cover bruises with when I worked there. + a color corrector for underneath.

hello, if you have very big dark circles, start with an orange corrector and then, try the Huda beauty concealer, for my it’s the best and it’s not cakey :)

For dark circles, a color corrector is probably better. It would take so much product to cover mine that it would be cakey if I was relying on concealer alone. I use a peach color corrector and then only need a minimal amount of concealer to hide everything. I’ve been using Ulta’s corrector fluid, but tons of brands offer options.

I prefer the Laura mercier flawless fusion. The nars is great for brightening lightweight under eye coverage, but I don’t find it super great at concealing dark spots. The Tarte is too heavy imo for everyday use unless you wear a full coverage face everyday. Haven’t tried the elf.

I personally really like the Tarte shape tape! The trick is really to not use a lot of product. I like to dab a bit on the back of my hand, and then use my fingers to pick up just a tiny spot and then tap it over my dark spots/dark under eyes.

Elf camo and shape tape are very similar, the downside to elf camo is that the shades are weird to figure out.

I use LOreal Infallible, also extremely similar to shape tape. I actually only use this for my base, don't use foundation at all.

I haven't tried Nars Radiant Creamy but I want to because my skin is getting a bit drier as I get older. I'll probably try it out this winter once my skin needs it.

Personally, tarte shape tape is my favorite! I have normal to dry skin but it’s the only concealer that covers my dark spots/dark circles and STAYS. I have a lot of acne scars and cystic acne pit scarring. A lot of concealers can look really heavy and or don’t stay put but shape tape works so well for me. I have tried so many concealers that are great initially but don’t have the staying power like shape tape. For hard to cover spots, I’ll dab a little concealer on the spot, leave it for 30 seconds before blending and I achieve more coverage that way. I actually find it lasts me a lot longer than other concealers because a little goes a long way! You could pair it with an under eye corrector. Something peachy under the eye to color correct then a little concealer! The elf camo concealers are good, but they break me out. I have sensitive acne prone skin though!