most of that list is fine for casual coffee drinkers but if we’re being honest, the only two worth talking about are the moccamaster and the fellow aiden. the moccamaster has been the gold standard for decades, built like a tank and dead simple, but it’s old school as in no scheduling, no fancy bloom programming, just hot water at the right temp and consistency.

the fellow is the one that actually pushed drip brewers forward. precise control over temp, adjustable bloom, batch vs single-cup modes, proper thermal carafe that doesn’t ruin flavor after an hour. it’s the first smart machine that isn’t gimmicky.

one thing that matters more than most people realize is the grinder. you can drop a few hundred on a brewer but if your grind is inconsistent, the cup will always taste flat or muddy. a good gevi grinder paired with something like the fellow is where you actually notice the difference, even cheap beans taste cleaner when the grind is uniform.

everything else on that list has compromises, oo plasticky, temp swings, or designed for versatility at the cost of straight drip quality. if the question is best drip coffee maker right now, it’s between those two, and i’d lean fellow just because it nails modern features without screwing up the fundamentals.

i know everyone likes to say "just get the aiden" or throw xBloom around, and those are fantastic if budget isn't an issue. moccamaster is the safe classic, wilfa performance is solid too depending on your region.
for anyone who wants something a little more accessible but still serious, the gevi grind and brew is actually underrated. you're getting a proper burr grinder built in plus bloom control and programmable settings, which gets you closer to that specialty vibe without having to buy two separate machines. it's not in the same league as a fellow aiden for precision, but for a daily driver drip setup at home it hits way above its price.
i'd also check out the sca certified brewer list on their site. all of those machines have been tested for proper temp and extraction. i ran a bonavita for over a decade before swapping it for a used ge café, and it's been great. looked at the oxo too but my family preferred the ge's design. honestly, anything on that list is going to brew well, it just comes down to which features and price point matter most to you.

I love my moccamaster KBTS. Not sure how you would determine the "best" drip coffee maker, but I love it dearly and it makes an amazing cup of coffee. I chose it over the Aiden / Xbloom for it's simplicity and easily replaceable parts.

For drip, I'm really enjoying the Breville (Sage) Precision Brewer Thermal.

I'll usually brew about 1.2L at a time. So I go with 1.2L Water / 75 g of freshly ground beans usually roasted about 5-7 days prior. Grind is medium/coarse (setting 7 on a Fellow Ode Brew Grinder Gen 2).

As far as the settings on the brewer, I'll usually go with the Gold settings -- making sure I'm using the cone filter instead of the basket filter. I've played around with brew temp, bloom times and such, but found that the Gold settings worked fine for us.

For drip, it does a good job. It's convenient when we are in a rush in the morning and need to have some coffee ready to go.

It isn't better than an Aeropress, V60 or French Press. I'll typically go with one of those when I have more time in the morning. But, in a pinch -- the Breville has worked out well for us.

https://www.reddit.com/r/BuyItForLife/comments/1jir5jj/what_is_the_best_coffee_makers_on_the_market/

I am in market for drip coffee machine. When I google Aiden it says companion app and I immediately get skeptical, is it one of those over engineered machines? Definitely looking for something simple

I concur - and I own a Technivorm too that no longer gets used.

I am a hardcore, 4-5 cups a day drinker, with a husband who drinks as many, for many, many years. So we do a LOT of coffee making. Cuisinart used to be the best, now their products do not last as long. Mr. Coffee is the best IMO. Boring, but indeed, they know how to make a coffee pot.

How fancy do you need it to be? I got a basic Mr. Coffee for like $15 when I went to college 10+ years ago and I’d probably still have it if I hadn’t switched to pour overs and passed it on. It was a gift from my grandma, who’s had the same style for as long as I can remember. No fancy settings, but the fewer buttons the less likely a thing is to fail.

If you are just requiring a basic drip then a Mister Coffee will be fine, they even have programmable settings that can autobrew for you in the morning as long as you load it with preground coffee, a filter and water. They can be found used for really cheap and are quite compact if you are just brewing for yourself you can get the smallest one.

Personally I dont bother with the machines because I find it easier personally to just do a pourover for myself with a electric water kettle but to each their own.

Moccamaster

I have a Zojirushi drip coffee maker made in Japan. Stainless steel insulated carafe. I’ve had it about 10 years and it definitely seems like a BIFL product.

agree with the people who commented here though. I’ve been using the Black+Decker 12-Cup Programmable one, it's super affordable and does the job well! If you want something fancier, the Bonavita just like the other said here

Fan of Bonavita Connoisseur too, super simple, heats water to the right temp. Definitely makes great coffee every time.

I’ve got the Bonavita Connoisseur and honestly love it! super easy to use and always makes a great cup. I’ve also heard really good things about the Moccamaster if you want something a bit fancier. 🙂

Been using the Bonavita Connoisseur for a while now. Simple, fast, and the coffee tastes legit every time. No fuss, just good brews<⁠(⁠￣⁠︶⁠￣⁠)⁠>

i can reco capresso coffee maker, for me a a solid choice for affordable yet high quality drip coffee.

Technivorm Moccamaster + a programmable plug so you can have a timer. The prices vary, but a few years ago they could be had relatively cheap for a great cup and solid build.

I have a Breville Precision Brewer and it’s pretty sweet too, 2 years of once or twice daily use and no issues.

My bunn from 2008 is still kicking doing a pot or two per day. But when I breaks down for good I’m going with the technivorm

Any stainless steel french press. Best coffee ever.

Bunn is good and pretty fairly priced. My fiance's family goes through more coffee than an AA meeting and I got one based on their recommendation, hasn't let me down in a decade.

Really like how quick it is too, make a pot of coffee in a minute or two.

I second the Technivorm (I own a coffee roastery and also use it at home). Can’t go wrong. The reason that it doesn’t have a timer is that’s it’s not good for fresh coffee. It’ll sit in the basket the whole night. I’d recommend buying a grinder and grind your beans first thing in the morning. Brewing only takes about 6 minutes. Believe me, you’ll get used to it :)

Moccamaster or Fellow Aiden.

There are a lot of factors that go into a recommendation for a coffee maker... is he making one cup at a time or are you looking for a batch brewer to make a pot at a time? What's his preferred format (espresso, American style, etc)? Does he have a grinder already?

If you're looking for a batch brewer, a Technivorm Moccamaster is great if you want to treat him. If you're on a budget, look for a brewer with a thermal carafe -- Oxo, Cuisinart and Breville/Sage all make decent ones. Avoid all-in-ones that have a built-in grinder... they tend to not be the best quality.

If you're looking for a single cup, I'd recommend going fully manual with a V60 or an Aeropress and a decent hand grinder (like a Timemore, for example).

Espresso on a budget is trickier, you have to spend $400 or more to get a good home machine, and you still need a good grinder on top of that, and good automatic espresso grinders start at the $400 range.

I am personally using OXO Brew 9 Coffee Maker because of its SCA certification, sleek design and consistent brew quality. It uses a rainmaker showerhead for even coffee ground saturation and it has a programmable start timer which makes it super convenient. The thermal carafe also keeps coffee hot for hours without burning it. If you are looking for still looking for the best coffee maker with good performance and ease of use then, it’s definitely one of the best options out there!

Does your dad appreciate good coffee or does he appreciate conveniently made coffee?

I just went through this process as our machine broke and we needed a new one.

It’s good to know what some of the non-negotiables are - like must it be able to be scheduled to brew at a specific time in the morning or does he want a thermal carafe or is he really into tweaking his coffee or does he want to be able to make one cup or batch or both?

I’d recommend popping down to Williams Sonoma or Crate and Barrel or other brick and mortar shop where you live and touch them if possible.

We wanted thermal, to schedule and I wanted to play around with different brew styles so the Fellow Aiden is what we decided on. The Aiden you can go complicated or super simple.

Good luck!

Cuisinart has very great drip coffee maker which isn't expensive aswell.

This one- Gevi drip coffee maker. I've owned several coffee grinders and relative to past products this is such a great value and works perfectly! Simply poor the beans in, put cap on, and press button. In a moment beans are ground and ready for use. Most important is how easy it is to clean. Left over residue comes out with ease and ready for the next use.

I've been using the MIROX Barista Espresso Coffee Maker Machine for a few weeks now, and I'm really impressed with it. It's easy to use and makes great espresso drinks. The built-in grinder produces a consistent grind every time, and the milk frother makes the perfect foam for my lattes and cappuccinos. I would definitely recommend this machine to anyone who loves espresso drinks.

Absolutely love my OXO Brew 8 Cup Coffee Maker after a friend referred me to it. I thought that the quality would maybe correlate to the low price but it was actually way better than I thought it would be

I've been using the cheapest version of Moccamaster for about 15 years. It just works so well.

If you’re in the US, go find a local TJ Maxx or Marshall’s. They typically have Breville Precision Brewers for on sale for $179. I actually got one for $89 recently.

Any of those on your list will be perfectly fine though. I like the OXO stuff for the money, but if you can wait on a moccamaster sale you’d be in good shape. It’s not my favorite brewer at MSRP (I much prefer the Breville precision, the Ratio 6, and the Fellow Aiden—all of which I’ve owned), but if you can get it around $200 it’s great.

The Moccamaster is a great machine. Highly recommend it.

If you don't mind aesthetics too much and they're available in your market Bonavita drippers are built like tanks.

Idk how this sub feels about the Simply Good Coffee brewer (and I don’t give a fuck this is my opinion lol) but I bought it on Black Friday last year and I loved the results. I did return it because I was able to buy a Mocca Master on Amazon for only $50 more than the Simply Good and I couldn’t pass it up. The Mocca Master is a much higher quality machine and will last a lifetime but the results from the Simply Good machine actually, in my opinion, were better. So if you don’t have the funds for a Mocca Master, don’t let these fools peer pressure you into thinking your only choice is a Mocca Master. I think you should consider the Simply Good machine. It’s comparable in a lot of ways and will give you actually great results. I can not advise as to how long it will last you though.

Do you have a good grinder? That's going to be a major factor in making a really good cup of coffee, so you definitely should factor that into your budget. The Baratza Encore (~$140) is often recommended as a solid entry-level grinder. You probably can find it for sale at a local coffee shop. Otherwise, you can find a place (either in store or online) on their website: https://www.baratza.com/where-to-buy/

That said, some drip machines that have been recommended here (in no particular order) are the Technivorm Moccamaster, the Bonavita BVT1900TS, and the Oxo On 9-Cup.

Another vote for a Technivorm Moccamaster. It's basically an automatic pourover, especially if you get the ArtisanSmith head that distributes the water better than the stock water spout. You'll need a proper grinder to get the most out of it, though.

I would recommend the Moccamaster too. Great machine, solid build, simple operation.

Get the one with a thermos rather than the hot plate.

Moccamaster is the best!!!!

You thought purple is not possible? Think again.

https://www.amazon.com/Technivorm-Moccamaster-59606-Coffee-Brewer/dp/B00QKKYLFY

The common answers here are the breville precision brewer or the technivorm moccamaster. Anything "nicer" is gonna be a comerical batch brewer.

+1 for the moccamaster.

Moccamaster with a Titus Nautilus doing the grinding.

I saw this compelling video regarding the Ratio Six but the other gold standard is the Mocamaster.

https://youtu.be/z-8UGE34Leo

https://youtu.be/xmd4iMZ39Qk