Love the mention of the Four Seasons at The Surf Club for its historical allure. But have you considered staying at the Biltmore Hotel in Coral Gables? It's not on the beach, but it's dripping with history from the 1920s, and the architecture is just stunning. Plus the golf course is legendary and it's a nice break from the usual South Beach scene.

We recently stayed at the Edition in South Beach which was fantastic! Restaurant in lobby and overall vibes were great. Honestly - I feel like you can’t go wrong with any of the 5 star spots in south beach.

The con you listed for the four seasons is expensive in room dining. The real con is that it is the most expensive hotel in Miami. And not worth the cost.

Lots of construction and hotel demolition going on in oceanfront Miami Beach right now. It’s a Shame for the Setai as a number of nearby and adjacent hotels…..The Delano, Raleigh, Shelbourne, etc . are loud dusty demolition sites. Cannot imagine how irritating that is if staying next door. It seems when the condo building collapsed in Sunny Isles a bunch of MB oceanfront property did not pass the 40 year inspections so they are getting torn down and rebuilt. The messy suspended construction site next to the Faena has been like that for years.

We honeymooned at the Boca Raton Waldorf Astoria - it’s no longer a Hilton property but it’s amazing.

Baker's Cay Resort Key Largo, Curio Collection by Hilton

Conrad Ft Lauderdale

Just checked out of the Conrad Fort Lauderdale yesterday. It was my second time there. Staff is great and the IRD food is phenomenal compared to a lot of hotels I’ve stayed (and worked) at. No complaints whatsoever.

The Bakers Cay Resort in Key Largo (Curio Collection) is amazing.

Aruba for sure! The quieter parts of the island - Baby Beach - not even another soul there! Accessed from rented motor scooter!

Ritz has the best spa — great restaurants too. The one on the beach is casual, almost like finger food, with a sushi restaurant and grill, etc. I’m not a big fan of the pool area — too much concrete.

LaPlaya only has one restaurant on the beach, Baleen. It’s not a big resort. The spa is good too, but very casual in comparison to the Ritz. Still pricey, but the service and offerings almost don’t match. The appeal is that you’re right on the beach. If you stay at the Ritz, you can walk to LaPlaya.

JW Marriott is very secluded. If you go there, you probably won’t visit Naples. It’s family-oriented. The beach is nice, but the walk from the hotel to the actual water is so long — in this heat, you get beat. I’d rate it third on the list after the other two.

If you want something less expensive, consider Naples Grande. It has a nice spa, but I’m not a fan of their food.

Edgewater Hotel is right on the Gulf, but in my opinion, it doesn’t get much sunshine.

You can stay at any of them and book her a spa day at Woodhouse Spa — the best in our area. It would probably be cheaper than any of the resort spas.

Edit: I wrote it all in one big sentence added ., lol

Vanderbilt beach resort or edgewater

Naples grande is awesome

JW does have a adults only section

Locals dont go to those properties too often. I've been a few times to each for dinners or events, but never stayed the night. Ritz Carlton and JW are both some of the most prestigious resorts in Marriott's collection. And I'd suggest searching the marriott subreddit, lots of people there have written about both properties. What I can say: Ritz Carlton has some amazing restaurants, including some new ones from post-Ian repairs. JW is a more family oriented resort. The beach is MASSIVE on Marco, much bigger than in Naples. La Playa has a restaurant called Baleen, which is consistently a highly rated restaurant.

If you're looking for a "quiet" resort, Im not sure you're going to find it with any of those options. The Ritz Carlton has almost 500 rooms (maybe more after renovation), and the JW has 700 or so. La Playa, Im less sure about it, maybe 200ish? In any case, they all are large, busy resorts that feature a TON of luxury accommodations. If thats what you're after, they're some of the best in the world. If you're after quiet, I'd recommend somewhere else. Escalante, for example, is downtown and much smaller, though not directly on the beach, it is pretty close.

Naples isn't really the quiet sleepy town it once was. I still love my town, but if you want "quiet" I'd look in to some other towns on the Gulf Coast.

The Grande Lakes complex is nice but doesn’t feel very luxury to me given the sheer number of people around you at any given time.

The JW Bonnet Creek is smaller, newer, and IMO a bit more pleasant/less of a zoo scene, but if you’re after large scale amenities, pools, etc. then Grande Lakes has more of that.

I stayed at Bonnet Creek in November, and it was really nice. The only thing that was a small let down was the fireworks visible on the rooftop nightly, it's much farther away than I expected from the description, so wasn't worth watching. Getting to universal took a long time. Going to the airport was expensive via Uber. Getting to Disney springs was super easy.

Im.here at Grande Lakes now and its cool very spacious lots to do good food.....

My Zeddy used to say “New is new”. And JW Bonnet Creek is new.

Just stayed at the JW Grande Lakes. One of my favorite Florida hotels w use of the Ritz amenities

Throwing in my .02 on the JW Marco Island. It was a great property but very heavily traveled by business folk and conferences, etc. While it was very, very nice and I loved the property, I didn’t walk away with baby moon vibes. Sounds like another poster on here loved it so maybe I didn’t get to see that side of things since I was there for work.

Just spent a few nights at the JW Marco Island for a conference. Couple of things to note:

-it's a huge hotel. Lots of conference space...not something real romantic or intimate.

-Feels like a Marriot, nothing real special IMO.

-Rooms are pretty worn, and housekeeping wasn't great.

St. Regis Kanai resort (Mexico) - super new & fancy.

St. Regis Punta Mita (Mexico) - a bit older, but renovated and one of my favorite resorts worldwide.

​

Cayman ritz is a bit dated, don't know about the other ones).

We did our babymoon at Zadun in San Jose del Cabo, which is a Ritz Carlton Reserve property. They go above and beyond to treat you to the best vacation experience possible. Plus it was only recently that you could book a Reserve property using points. Congratulations and best of luck on your search for your special getaway!

The Bacara (Santa Barbara Ritz) is great, we’ve really enjoyed stays there. Nice pool and great beach for beach walks. There is a natural tar that will get on your feet but they’ve got stuff for it. It’s not technically in SB so just know it’s an Uber to get to town.

Definitely worth looking up historical weather to be sure it’s warm enough there in February. It may be fine as that area can be pretty temperate but just worth checking

Last December they had 1 pool not finished. I'm sure you can call the property and ask. We did last year and they told us the exact situation. We didn't mind the 1 pool unavailable.

Marriot Grande Vista Orlando. Beautiful resort. Huge, and for kids.

Marriott Curacao is a great way to use those certificates

The property is amazing and amazing location to everything

Amelia Island is the tits. The Salt restaurant is cool, pool is awesome. The Ritz isn’t optimal for kids, especially at their ages. I wouldn’t take my kids there (4 & 6). 

Why not do a Gaylord? The one in Nashville is super cool. 

little palm island?

E: with kids, thanks to u/Soft_Knee_2707

Hawks key Cheeca Lodge

Casa Marina

Little Palm Island

Hawks Cay Cheeca Lodge

Surprised no one has suggested Isla Bella in Marathon.

There are no great luxury resorts in the Keys in my opinion. You’ll pay 5* prices and get 4* amenities and 3* service. You’re paying for location more than anything else. That is to say any of these recommendations are probably as good as any other. Look for the best deal you can find.

Carrillon, Aqualina, Faena, Surf Club, Edition are all great. Fontainebleau is a mess, as is the W and 1 Hotel. Setai is also very nice albeit a tad overpriced. One block from the ocean, the PaliHouse is the best. Signed, a Miami Beach Local.

Four seasons surf club if you’re ok being further north. There is no other choice.

Have sent tons of babymooners there. Great spa. Lmk if you need to be VIPed.

The St regis in Bal Harbour checks all of these boxes for you and is very luxurious.

I would have recommend fointainebleu but it’s gotten bad lately

1 vote for FS surf club! Never been but heard good things from friends