Add to Chrome

Log In

Sign Up

Try Gigabrain PRO

Supercharge your access to the collective wisdom of reddit, youtube, and more.
Learn More
Refine result by
Most Relevant
Most Recent
Most Upvotes
Filter by subreddit
r/Survival
r/specializedtools
r/preppers
r/CampingGear
r/Homebrewing
r/hikinggear

Best Portable Water Filters

GigaBrain scanned 485 comments to find you 107 relevant comments from 10 relevant discussions.
Sort
Filter

Sources

Best at home water filter?
r/Survival • 1
Any recommendations on portable water filters? I’ve looked at lifestraw and sawyer but I see a lot of bad reviews.
r/Survival • 2
Personal Water Filter
r/specializedtools • 3
View All
7 more

TLDR

Summary

New

Chat with GigaBrain

What Redditors are Saying

Best Portable Water Filters

TL;DR

  • Sawyer Mini and Sawyer Squeeze are highly recommended for their compact size and effectiveness.
  • Grayl water bottle is favored for convenience but has a higher cost per gallon.
  • Pre-filtering with cloth or coffee filters can enhance the performance of portable filters.

Sawyer Filters

The Sawyer Mini and Sawyer Squeeze are frequently mentioned as top choices for portable water filtration. Users appreciate their compact design, reliability, and ability to filter large quantities of water [2:1], [2:3]. The Sawyer Mini is particularly popular due to its versatility and ease of use, making it suitable for various environments like lakes, streams, and rivers [2:5]. However, users suggest using a Platypus bag instead of the Sawyer bag due to durability issues [2:3].

Grayl Water Bottle

The Grayl water bottle is another favored option for portable water filtration. It offers convenience by allowing users to filter water directly into a bottle, which is ideal for quick stops during hikes [2:9]. However, replacement filters can be costly, leading to a higher cost per gallon compared to other options [2:11].

Pre-Filtering Techniques

Pre-filtering water before using portable filters can significantly improve their efficiency. Using washable coffee filters or cloth can help remove sediment and prevent clogging of the main filter [5:2]. This step is especially important when dealing with turbid water or water containing visible particles [5:8].

Chemical Contaminants and Viruses

While portable filters like Sawyer and Grayl are effective at removing bacteria and sediment, they may not filter out chemical contaminants or viruses. For chemical contaminants, activated charcoal filters are recommended [1:7]. Tablets such as Aquatabs can kill viruses and bacteria, but they do not filter out particulates and may alter the taste of the water [5:2], [5:5].

Additional Options

Other brands like Katadyn and MSR offer reliable water filters that are worth considering, although they come with a higher upfront cost [5:5]. Steripens, which use UV light to purify water, are also an option but require clear water for effective use [5:7], [5:10].

See less

Helpful

Not helpful

You have reached the maximum number of searches allowed today.

Cut through the noise directly on Google.

The GigaBrain browser extension dives deep into billions of discussions, bringing you the most relevant and informative answers on the spot.

Add to Chrome

Products

Sawyer Products Micro Squeeze Water Filtration System

Sawyer Products
$28.01
4.6(1825)

See more

Katadyn 8018270 Hiker Microfilter Water Purification Unit

Katadyn
$89.95$99.95
4.7(1316)

See more

Source Threads

POST SUMMARY • [1]

Summarize

Best at home water filter?

Posted by mdsurf · in r/Survival · 3 years ago
183 upvotes on reddit
12 replies
Helpful
Not helpful
View Source
ORIGINAL POST

After seeing the situation in Jackson, Flint etc I'm wondering what is the best apartment / condo water filtering setup you could get if you were in a situation where water was still running but it was dirty, contaminated etc like it has been in these cities?

​

Are there people in these situations that are good to go because they have a good set up and can clean the water?

12 replies
K
KREDDOG79 · 3 years ago

We have a Berkey water filter with the cleanable black filters. We have not had any dirty water run through them yet but they are supposed to filter dirty water too. In an emergency like this i would prefilter dirty water through cloth/screen to get the larger sediment out to make the filters last longer.

You can buy the filters and make a diy filter system with 2 5 gal buckets and 2 lids.

76 upvotes on reddit
Trades_Raves_GymBoi · 3 years ago

I second the Berkey and have been using mine for a few years now!

6 upvotes on reddit
willowgardener · 3 years ago

Berkeys are great. They're standard issue for Peace Corps volunteers in West Africa. Thanks for protecting me from giardia, Berkey.

30 upvotes on reddit
R
Ralh3 · 3 years ago

Just to be clear- even on silty well water these filters keep going for YEARS, you take them out and clean them once in a great while. If they do stop flowing (not very likely or often) you can take em out wipe em down with a stiff scrubby sponge and soak em in vinegar and you are good too go.

14 upvotes on reddit
Ryakai8291 · 3 years ago

I’m in a mom FB group and a member asked for water filter recommendations and I had mentioned Berkey. She told me she had one but was changing the filters on it every year so it was getting expensive🤦🏻‍♀️

2 upvotes on reddit
K
KREDDOG79 · 3 years ago

We have the Royal Berkey (I think) 2.5 gal capacity and we have 4 filters in it. We run our well water through it. I use a Gallon jug that once held Arizona Iced Tea's Arnold Palmer to fill it.

3 upvotes on reddit
[deleted] · 3 years ago

Portable reverse osmosis system, nothing is better for filtration. Something small enough to fit under a sink and preferably with a ac/dc pump to assist in pushing water through the RO membrane and a shortage container for the filtered water. RO totally strips water of absolutely everything and needs to be remineralised for consumption but most systems have remineralisation cartridges that add calcium and magnesium back into the water to balance the ph back to neutral so its not acidic after stripping but you can make your own reminerizer with calcite rock.

One big drawback is RO systems have water waste because the membrane continually needs to be flushed during filtration. You'll lose 1/3 of water through the system to waste but that can be used as clean 'gray' water. I live where tap water is clean but I still strip it with RO to remove additives like chlorine, fluoride and whatever else the water corp is putting in it.

31 upvotes on reddit
P
P-K-One · 3 years ago

Careful with the recommended lifestraws. The general lifestraw doesn't do shit about heavy metals.

Water filters work with micropores that most things can't pass through. All the big manufacturers use pretty much the same filter types with pores from 0.1 to 0.2 microns. Those will filter out bacteria, other microorganisms and some viruses. They won't do shit about chemical contaminants or heavy metals. Those are too small and pass through.

For chemical contaminants (pesticides, herbicides,...) you need activated charcoal in the filters to combat those. The standard lifestraw, for example, doesn't have that. Katadyn has them in everything. But they have a much shorter life expectancy than the standard pore filters.

For heavy metals it gets even more complicated. They don't react with the charcoal like chemical contaminants. Lifestraw has exectly 1 mobile filter system in their sortiment that claims to be able to remove lead and that has a life expectancy of less than 1000 liters before it loses that ability.

https://eu.lifestraw.com/pages/compare

12 upvotes on reddit
S
sweerek1 · 3 years ago

Water. Diversity is key:

  • Case of water in yer car trunk
  • 30 gallons for 2 person-weeks at home, say in 1-7 gallon jugs
  • Sawyer filter w/ Micropur tablets backup (or similar combo, see links below)
  • Blue, used, 55 gallon barrels (~$15) sanitized w/ pool shock
  • Rotate above yearly
  • Bathtub, trash bins, sinks, or other large, hasty-tap-filled containers
  • Local, bulk source (stream, lake, swimming pool, well, rain collectors)
  • https://www.outdoorgearlab.com/topics/camping-and-hiking/best-backpacking-water-filter
  • https://www.wideners.com/blog/water-filter-tests-for-survival/
8 upvotes on reddit
[deleted] · 3 years ago

I use an an aquarium RO system that I modified with the addition of remineralisation cannisters. I got this systems many years ago when it was a LOT cheaper.

https://www.filtersystemsaustralia.com.au/5-stage-semi-commercial-reverse-osmosis-water-filter-35l-per-hour.html

There are other portable systems that don't cost so much but I wanted higher capacity with portability

3 upvotes on reddit
[deleted] · 3 years ago

Not necessarily they just need water pressure to push water through the membrane. There are hand pump units that are more 'prepper' style no electrical components

3 upvotes on reddit
C
Chemical_Inflation97 · 3 years ago

I use a Berkey with the added fluoride filters. Also have Sawyer for portable use and Zero Water pitchers too.

By far the best tasting is the Berkey. Zero leaves a slight metallic tasted that I can pick out in a blind test. I have Sawyer minis in multiple bags.

All of them should prove acceptable.

6 upvotes on reddit
See 12 replies
r/Survival • [2]

Summarize

Any recommendations on portable water filters? I’ve looked at lifestraw and sawyer but I see a lot of bad reviews.

Posted by [deleted] · in r/Survival · 3 years ago

Thank you everyone for the input! Apologies, can’t respond to everyone because I am juggling work too. I will check out all of these. Y’all are awesome!

134 upvotes on reddit
12 replies
Helpful
Not helpful
View Source
12 replies
P
popClingwrap · 3 years ago

I've used Sawyer mini for a few years now and never got sick. I've filtered from lakes, streams and rivers in Europe.

Get a bag to attach so you can squeeze fill your bottle or hang up as a gravity filter. Don't use the Sawyer bag though, they are shite and split really easily. Get a platypus one instead

32 upvotes on reddit
N
nbrooks77 · 3 years ago

I love my sawyer mini! Works great and pretty compact

7 upvotes on reddit
W
Wrobot_rock · 3 years ago

The mini squeeze fits right on to the msr dromedary and that thing is bulletproof

2 upvotes on reddit
P
popClingwrap · 3 years ago

I only recommend platypus as that is what I have and it's lasted well. I would like one with a roll top or ziplock style closure though as filling up from shallow or slow moving water is hard using the standard design.

2 upvotes on reddit
MycoMadness20 · 3 years ago

Versatile, low weight/high capacity, extremely reliable, and nothing better than having all your water filtered while you eat lunch with no effort

10 upvotes on reddit
B
Braindead_cranberry · 3 years ago

Sawyer is great. The filters are compact and filter lots of water

63 upvotes on reddit
L
Lizzietizzy101 · 3 years ago

Yup! Sawyer mini for the win! I own both and I prefer the Sawyer

5 upvotes on reddit
Jolcski · 3 years ago

Sawyer FTW. I love mine

16 upvotes on reddit
drunkbackpacker · 3 years ago

Sawyer Squeeze ftw

50 upvotes on reddit
F
foundationartschool · 3 years ago

Yeah!! It works great. I've had some tasty water from that filter.

5 upvotes on reddit
StaffSergeantBarnes · 3 years ago

Grayl water bottle is my new favorite, also bring a sawyer squeeze as a back up.

40 upvotes on reddit
fox-kalin · 3 years ago

Only problem is that a Grayl replacement filter costs $79 where I live, and is good for 65 gallons. $1.20 per gallon!

11 upvotes on reddit
See 12 replies
r/specializedtools • [3]

Summarize

Personal Water Filter

Posted by odel555q · in r/specializedtools · 7 years ago
post image
gfycat.com
104 upvotes on reddit
9 replies
Helpful
Not helpful
View Source
9 replies
I
idk_lets_try_this · 7 years ago

Just want to point out that the smaller ones do not filter viruses or chemical contaminants.

They are basically just a gimic to fund the large ones they hand out/sell in 3rd world countries.

They are ok if you use them from water that is pretty much safe but filled with sediment but not for water that has human waste in them like the water you would have after a natural disaster.

46 upvotes on reddit
B
beanmosheen · 7 years ago

You need a 1 micron spectrum filter and nobody's drinking from that by mouth!

2 upvotes on reddit
Breakingindigo · 7 years ago

The one they have on amazon doesn't seem to say it doesn't, but it also didn't say anything about viruses. Need to order bleach tablets now to go with my emergency kit.

1 upvotes on reddit
T
th3d3k0y · 7 years ago

I came here to say this after the video says "safe". It is safe-ish depending on where you are in the world.

19 upvotes on reddit
I
idk_lets_try_this · 7 years ago

Well it doesn't really depend on the area of the world. It is more where the water comes from.

Sewer water or flood water is never safe to drink trough this small one, no matter where in the world it occurs.

8 upvotes on reddit
C
Cranky_Windlass · 7 years ago

Had one in my go bag for years, nice to have as an option

7 upvotes on reddit
n0nn · 7 years ago

There is a filter for pretty much anything. Carbon may help with some chemicals. Etc... I don't think there is a filter for radiated water. That would be interesting to see.

1 upvotes on reddit
N
NotJimIrsay · 7 years ago

They apparently work if you drink from a urinal.

3 upvotes on reddit
dougb · 7 years ago

Hope that’s not shat water

1 upvotes on reddit
See 9 replies
r/preppers • [4]

Summarize

Guide to top portable water filters

Posted by the_prepared · in r/preppers · 7 years ago

An often-repeated question in prepper forums is which water filter to buy. So I just spent 48 hours checking out over 70 products:

Best survival water filters for bug out bags

The Sawyer Mini and Sawyer Squeeze are usually the most popular. We polled preppers on FB and the two Sawyer products were 1,000% more common than 2nd place (LifeStraw).

But we think there's a new top choice for most people's first buy: the HydroBlu Versa. It's very comparable to the Mini but has a better flow rate, which is a common frustration with the Mini once you start using it and could be a big problem in an emergency.

Other models we like:

  • Pumps: Katadyn Hiker Pro and MSR Guardian
  • Bottles: LifeStraw Go, Aquamira Frontier Flow, Sagan Journey, and LifeSaver Liberty
  • Gravity: HydroBlu Go Flow
  • Straws: Survivor Filter, HydroBlu Sidekick (EDC)

Which filter makes sense for you depends on factors like where you live, bug out bag space/weight, and so on. The right answer is usually a mix of different types (bottle, inline, pump, gravity kit, etc.)

For example, in one bug out bag I run a LifeStraw Go bottle with spare filter, HydroBlu Versa kit (with bags), and Katadyn Pocket. In another bag I plan on running a HydroBlu Go Flow gravity kit (with their inline filter), LifeSaver Legacy bottle, and Survivor Filter straw.

Happy to answer any questions about filters, alternatives, water threats, or whatever!

79 upvotes on reddit
4 replies
Helpful
Not helpful
View Source
4 replies
G
greggorievich · 7 years ago

Thank you for this! Your article is excellent, a very concise and accurate guide that should save most people dozens of hours of research (as I had done previously).

It's a little bit timely that I read this - I made a custom filter for backpacking and while I wasn't unhappy with the flow rate from the Sawyer mini that serves as the core of the system, there is significant room for improvement there.

A couple of thoughts from my own testing:

  • Most hydration bladders and similar use a fairly standard quick-connect fitting. Both these fittings and extra hose are available online (from, say, Fresh Water Systems), allowing you to further enhance your system and add versatility. for example, the system I made has a 3L "dirty" bladder that I can put in my pack to drink directly from, attach to another bladder to fill it directly, or let it flow into a hard bottle or pretty much any other container. Adding Sawyer inline adapters adds even more flexibility.
  • While out hiking (I know it's not the same as prepping/emergencies, but it's firsthand experience and that has value to me), we found that a useful combo was a gravity filter (at the time I had a Platypus GravityWorks) for use in camp or when you need lots of water and can just sit around and let it flow, and a pump (a hiking partner's MSR HyperFlow) to stop quickly at a source and fill or top off water bottles.
    My custom system resolves that - i can drop my pack, scoop water, put the bladder back into my pack, reattach the hose, and keep going, but if you don't want to mess about with that, a gravity filter/pump filter combo is pretty useful.
  • Your article (unless I missed it) didn't put much verbage into pre-filters, which can make filters flow faster and last longer. I notice you mention it in the comments, but it seems to not be in the article much. Neither are there mentioned any alternative methods to make the filter's job easier - like letting water settle for some time in a bucket or container if possible, and decanting the water to filter off of the top, thus preventing some particulate from entering the filter.
  • It's probably beyond scope for the article, but a cursory "be sure to read and take into account the instructions of the filter" and run quickly through how to do some maintenance tasks like back flushing, bleach flushing, or boiling, and also some common precautions (like how filters should not be allowed to freeze once wet). Obviously you can't cover all the bases, but giving a little attention to filter use might be wise.

Have you actually tested any of the filters effectiveness? I am willing to trust lab ratings and so on, but it would be neat to take, say, river water with a small amount of.... what, settled sewage maybe? blended in and then run through the filters and sent for testing thereafter. I know it's a lot to ask but it would sure be cool to know.

2 upvotes on reddit
T
the_prepared · OP · 7 years ago

Great comment brother!

Did you like your buddy's MSR HyperFlow?

>Your article (unless I missed it) didn't put much verbage into pre-filters
>
>It's probably beyond scope for the article, but a cursory "be sure to read and take into account the instructions of the filter"

I was originally thinking I'd put usage tips in the same article, because we like to aggregate content into singular pages, but it ended up at 10k words, so I'm going to do a separate article in the future about how to collect and filter water in the wild, including pre-filter tips like bandanas and coffee filters, intake an inch below the surface, DIY distill, etc.

>Have you actually tested any of the filters effectiveness?

So badly want to! But have not — I relied on reading the lab reports provided by manufacturers. Still a one man band and need to get more of the basic guides up first (medical, flashlights, knives, etc). I also wanted to do a big head-to-head armor test this summer, but alas it'll take too much time away from other content.

2 upvotes on reddit
G
greggorievich · 7 years ago

The hyperflow came in really handy. I will note that my experience with it is from one trip, and helping my buddy prepare it for the off season, so it's not comprehensive.

Using it is surprisingly fast. We filled a 1L Nalgene in something like 20 or 30 seconds (though I wasn't counting as such. It just seemed really fast). Super handy if you just want to stop and top off your water bottles. We used it on water that was not turbid at all so I can't speak as to clogging.

I wouldn't really want to try back flushing it in the field - it involves taking the filter apart and switching some valves around so the pump works in reverse. The instructions were clear and it was easy to do, but I would fear losing parts or getting some 'clean' part of the filter contaminated. I very much prefer the method for my gravityworks (switch the orientation of the bags so water flows backwards from the clean one through the filter and back into the dirty or just into the ground) or my sawyer (use the cleaning syringe to force water backwards through the filter) because they're much easier to do in the field.

It was relatively small and compact (more so by far than MSR's larger pumps). MSR apparently has an adapter kit to turn it into an inline gravity filter, which would add to it's versatility.

I think I prefer the Sawyer or similar style where the filter is a single piece with no moving parts and if it is no good or gets damaged you just replace the whole thing. I don't particularly fear the failure of things like the HyperFlow, but why mess around with maintenance kits and o-rings if you don't have to?

Oh! Also and unrelated: I noticed that Aquamira has some inline "virus filters". Did these make it into your review at all?

2 upvotes on reddit
hndcleaning · 7 years ago

Do you have a clean water pipe at home?

-No

HND - Expert in water pipe cleaning machine

Improve water quality & Extending the lifetime of your filter

0 upvotes on reddit
See 4 replies
r/Survival • [5]

Summarize

Looking for water filter/purification tablets

Posted by raconma · in r/Survival · 4 years ago

Hi guys! I want to buy a water filter/purification tablets but I have almost 0 idea. I've read to be careful with tablets that only kill bacteria. Any recommendations on which ones to buy? Are water filters better than the tablets?

Edit: Thanks to everyone, I wasn't expecting that much comments. Have a nice day!

44 upvotes on reddit
12 replies
Helpful
Not helpful
View Source
12 replies
C
carlbernsen · 4 years ago

For quick, simple, short term use tablets are great. For long term use the cost adds up so a filter like a Sawyer or similar may be better. Aquatabs kill viruses and bacteria and a filter of 0.01 micron will remove them. Sawyer, MSR and others make filters that fine. It’s recommended to pre filter with something like a washable coffee filter to remove sediment before using tablets or ultra fine filters, partly to remove the viruses and bacteria living in sediment and also to prevent clogging of the main filter. It’s a good idea to check which viruses etc are most likely in the area you’re going to and make sure you use a method suited specifically to those.

22 upvotes on reddit
raconma · OP · 4 years ago

Thanks for all the info! I will for sure pre filter if I use tablets :)

2 upvotes on reddit
Lucifarai · 4 years ago

Yea the sawyer mini filters around 300,000 gallons of water. In 2017 I went to Puerto Rico immediately after hurricane Maria. We didn't have running water so we were having to use water out of catchman tanks and stuff. So the sawyer was great at getting clean water, except that they don't filter out stuff like leptospirosis. Fortunately I have a UV filter as well that was rechargeable and filtered about 10,000 times in its bulb lifetime. We were staying in the middle of town with no electricity and couldn't build a fire. So we would do it in two parts. First through the sawyer and then through the UV. Unfortunately we only had enough supplies to keep water for our team and give water to the people most in need like children and diabetics or elderly folks. By time we got larger supplies in to make additional clean water, the municipality had gotten the water back on and all you had to do was boil it. Finding bottled water wasn't guaranteed till about the second month after the storm.

Edit : just looked, it's 100,000 gallons not 300,000

3 upvotes on reddit
S
Seawolfe665 · 4 years ago

I just bought a 2 pack of the sawyer filters, easy to use and each filter will filter to up to 100,000 gallons. Plus I'm pretty sure that the filter threads match my 6 gallon solar shower so that would work well for ease of use.

5 upvotes on reddit
Goblinkok · 4 years ago

Sawyer with adapter for a hydration pack and and also a catch pouch. Can't go wrong.

7 upvotes on reddit
raconma · OP · 4 years ago

A lot of people saying that too, thanks!

3 upvotes on reddit
blkfoam · 4 years ago

Tablets are gross. Not only do they add a flavor, they don't filter any particulate so you'll be drinking briny stink water.

If you're serious about being outdoors a good water filter is a must have. Katadyn and MSR are the brands I recommend. They have a relatively large upfront cost, but you can't be messing around with water.

6 upvotes on reddit
raconma · OP · 4 years ago

Yeah, after seeing all responses i'm really into buying a filter

2 upvotes on reddit
S
Seawolfe665 · 4 years ago

I like it not only for an easy camping / bug in shower, warm water solution, but it's also a container that can hold 5+ gallons of water, and it takes little space to store.

3 upvotes on reddit
drshneebly · 4 years ago

Any thoughts on getting a steripen? Expensive but works fast. You will still need a way to get sediment out. I just got one, haven't used it though.

3 upvotes on reddit
raconma · OP · 4 years ago

That's the UV one, isn't it? Is it better than a common filter?

2 upvotes on reddit
drshneebly · 4 years ago

Yes it is UV. There are pros and cons to both. Steripens only purify the water and cannot filter it. So you can't really use them with cloudy water. I would use it in running water, but not turbid

3 upvotes on reddit
See 12 replies
r/CampingGear • [6]

Summarize

Best water filters for long distance backpacking?

Posted by rcollins303 · in r/CampingGear · 3 years ago

Hello I have never used a water filter before and am not sure which one to get for my first trip. The pumping one seems like the best option

25 upvotes on reddit
12 replies
Helpful
Not helpful
View Source
12 replies
M
MilesBeforeSmiles · 3 years ago

The pumping ones are not the best option if you value your forearms not feeling like they are on fire. They are also the heaviest and bulkiest option.

Most people would recommend a Sawyer squeeze. A gravity filter like the Platypus Gravityworks is also a fgood option.

34 upvotes on reddit
FatbagCat · 3 years ago

This is the best solution for me! Only thing I would add is that the sawyer squeeze mini is terribly slow. I’d add the couple ounces for a bigger one any day.

9 upvotes on reddit
VesuvianButtToucher · 3 years ago

I'd go for either the regular or micro, agreed on avoiding the mini. Mini has the worst flow rate. The micro is in between but still not quite as good as the regular.

I actually carry the micro as a backup to my regular squeeze if I'm going solo (or no one else I'm with has filters)

1 upvotes on reddit
B
bandofgypsies · 3 years ago

Sawyer squeeze, 100%, but the Sawyer bags are unreliable and hard to fill without extreme patience or a decent water current. I use the Sawyer with this awesome 3L Cnoc reservoir that i cannot recommend enough.

You can also easily attach the Sawyer to standard bottles (like a plastic bottle/smartwater/etc).

Of course, you can use the attachment from the Sawyer to pump water directly into the balder in your pack, too, if you're carrying one. Which is super handy.

11 upvotes on reddit
S
salsanacho · 3 years ago

Sawyer Squeeze is a no brainer. Depending on how long you'll be out and your distance to civilization, I recommend bringing some iodine tablets as backup.

37 upvotes on reddit
rcollins303 · OP · 3 years ago

https://www.sawyer.com/products/squeeze-water-filtration-system

So this is all I need? And I can fill it up with stream or creek water?

1 upvotes on reddit
T
trailquail · 3 years ago

My only complaint with the Sawyer squeeze is that if the water source is shallow it’s hard to get the squeeze pouch filled without it wanting to close/flatten on itself. I sometimes have to scoop with a container (my mug usually) and fill it that way.

1 upvotes on reddit
T
trimbandit · 3 years ago

sawyer squeeze and a 2l cnoc for the dirty water

2 upvotes on reddit
D
destroy_the_defiant · 3 years ago

Pumps were the standard for many years. I still have the old version of what is now the Katadyn Hiker. It's an excellent pump, and it has never let me down. It is also pretty darn heavy, and time consuming to use. I would recommend it to anyone who was interested in it.

However, I recently switched to a gravity system. I personally have a Sawyer Squeeze filter with two CNOC bags. I do not regret switching one bit.

Edit/addition: Many people still use pumps, and they are still a good option. I didn't mean to make them sound antiquated.

20 upvotes on reddit
[deleted] · 3 years ago

Just spent a week in the boundary waters using the platypus gravity works. It worked great, would definitely recommend

22 upvotes on reddit
fishslushy · 3 years ago

Second this, the last thing I want to do after a long day on the trail is pump water. This thing works.

2 upvotes on reddit
JBone226 · 3 years ago

Also a Katadyn BeFree guy. Good flow rate, cleans water well, and packs up very small

12 upvotes on reddit
See 12 replies
r/preppers • [7]

Summarize

What are the best portable water filter options?

Posted by StrawberryChampagne_ · in r/preppers · 2 years ago

Sooo, I watched a documentary about the quality of US drinking water and now I’m paranoid about drinking tap filtered by my Brita. Could you guys give me some suggestions for portable filtered water options that remove PFAS and other harmful chemicals from water? I’m having such a hard time choosing a trustworthy brand.

I’m constantly traveling for work and I live in an apartment so I can’t get any fancy installations. I know reverse osmosis is one of the best ways to remove toxins but i don’t think I could successfully travel with a reverse osmosis filter without damaging it somehow. I’ve been researching pitcher filters and water bottles with filters built in from Berkey, Zero Water, and Clearly Filtered. I’m having a hard time choosing a brand to trust though, because everywhere I look I see debates on the legitimacy of the claims these water filter brands make. I’ve read some pretty bad things about Berkey in particular. Anyway, I could really use some guidance. Thanks in advance!

23 upvotes on reddit
12 replies
Helpful
Not helpful
View Source
12 replies
thisisnorthe · 2 years ago

Have owned both a Brita and a ZeroWater pitcher filter system that go right in the fridge

ZeroWater is a great filter. Even comes with a device to test water purity so you know when the filter needs changing

Better than Brita by far

7 upvotes on reddit
StrawberryChampagne_ · OP · 2 years ago

Thank you! I’m really interested in ZeroWater because they have filters that are actually certified by NSF. My only concern with them is that I’ve read that some people have had issues with the filter lifespan being really short. Have you experienced any issues with that?

5 upvotes on reddit
E
Eeyor-90 · 2 years ago

The lifespan of the Zero Water filter depends on the quality of the water you’re filtering. I bought one shortly after they were released to use in my home. The water tester read 988 ppm (parts per million) straight from the tap. That water was really poor quality; there was a warning on the back of the water bill advising pregnant people and those with compromised immune systems not to drink it. The Zero Water filter brought it to 0 ppm as advertised, but the filter only lasted for about 6 gallons before i had to replace it. At $35 per filter, it wasn’t cost effective so I store it as a backup now.

3 upvotes on reddit
mainely_eddie · 2 years ago

Project farm on YouTube does a comparison of all major pitcher filters and zero came way above all the others

3 upvotes on reddit
P
Philosopherski · 2 years ago

I for the lack of a better word owe my life to a sawyer mini. I hiked up a mountain that was supposed to have water in 2 different locations and as I made my way up there by sundown it turned out that both springs were dry.
I filtered about 5 liters of standing swamp water with a thick algae build up live to tell the tale.

26 upvotes on reddit
P
Philosopherski · 2 years ago

Ok if you do here's a HUGE tip. The filter has a threaded end meant to connect to the (dirty)water pouch so you can squeeze it to push it through the filter. Well the thread also happens to be the same size(28mm) as the standard soda top. What I personally do is use a Smart water bottle and fill it up at any running water source and cap it. If i ever need water I can simply pop the top of, screw the filter on and drink.

8 upvotes on reddit
T
TheSensiblePrepper · 2 years ago

For daily tap water drinking, Zero Water is my go to.

For Emergency use, Survivor Filter Pro has beat everything else I have tested. Getting down to 0.01 microns and removes even viruses.

5 upvotes on reddit
[deleted] · 2 years ago

Zerowater is underrated, for sure. They're NSF certified to remove PFAs as well. The only catch is that Zerowater effectively produces distilled water. That's not necessarily a show stopper, but if you plan on drinking it exclusively for more than a few days, you'll want to read up on managing your electrolytes.

I think Zerowater really shot themselves in the foot with their marketing. Their "0% TDS" comes across as a little gimmicky, and I think a lot of people assumed they were all marketing-speak. The reality is that it's actually a very good filter.

EDIT: Woah, their filter prices have crept up and their coupons have gone down. I'm guessing the news coverage about PFAs is driving their sales.

2 upvotes on reddit
T
TheSensiblePrepper · 2 years ago

The prices did go up but Amazon seems to have the best prices. The ones direct from Amazon are bought by Amazon direct from Zero Water.

2 upvotes on reddit
feelinuneasy1234 · 1 year ago

The filters seems to work pretty fine, however the bag is kind of awkward to get filled. In general is a great product

1 upvotes on reddit
UND_mtnman · 2 years ago

Sawyers are pretty extensively used by long distance thru-hikers. If you want something portable, seems wise to look to the people that live a portable life.

12 upvotes on reddit
D
doecliff · 2 years ago

Katadyn is an industry leader. Expensive but worth it.

3 upvotes on reddit
See 12 replies
r/Homebrewing • [8]

Summarize

The best portable RO filter

Posted by Beer-dude · in r/Homebrewing · 4 years ago

I'm open to suggestions. I need a portable for reasons I won't go into now but I like simplicity. 4-5 stage I'm thinking?

21 upvotes on reddit
12 replies
Helpful
Not helpful
View Source
12 replies
G
GrimBeaver · 4 years ago

All you need for brewing is a sediment filter, carbon filter and ro membrane. Takes my 560ppm tap water down to 6ppm. A few hours before I'm going to brew I turn it on and let it fill my kettle. I run a system rated for 75gpd because a membrane with a higher rating requires more water pressure than I have.

For reference this is the system I have: https://www.buckeyehydro.com/premium-ro-systems/

You could easily make it portable.

1 upvotes on reddit
UnBrewsual · 4 years ago

Not answering your question.. But I have been buying RO water from those fill stations at the grocery store, $4 gets me 10 gallons. I did the math and it just didn't make financial sense for me to get a RO system.

1 upvotes on reddit
Beer-dude · OP · 4 years ago

I've been doing the same for over 18 months but for some reason, maybe due to lack of service due to Covid, but many in my area are broken or shut off. The stores will just say it's going to be serviced soon but soon has been a long while. I've had to go further out to get my fill.

1 upvotes on reddit
E
Evil_Bonsai · 4 years ago

Reason I installed an under sink 6 stage RO system. It is pretty slow once past 2 gallon mark. Not really an issue, to me, though.

1 upvotes on reddit
Ok-Priority-2453 · 1 year ago

What grocery stores have RO fill stations? I’m in Texas

1 upvotes on reddit
O
Ovalman · 4 years ago

I'll weigh in with my knowledge of RO/DI.

I asked a pure water expert was DI safe to drink. They never responded but as we're boiling the water I don't think it matters.

There are 2 types of water purification RO and DI. Reverse Osmosis pushes the water through a membrane while Di pushes it through a resin. Both can purify water.

DI purifies on demand but can get expensive if used long term. 2 purifying units should produce enough water for your needs (one as a rinse). As a brewer this is the simplest and probably cheapest method.

RO gives a drip, drip, drip but can prove more cost effective long term. NOTE* The gallon per day is a theoretical limit and is never achieveable. It depends on your tap water TDS and your water pressure. For me I can equate GPD to Litre's per day. For a 50 GPD RO I can produce 50LPD which isn't much but enough to brew with.

Stages are just pre filters that will prolong your RO membrane. They aren't necessary but will massively prolong the life of your RO. The final rinse will be DI which sort of backs up my reasoning that DI is safe to drink.

First thing to buy is a cheap TDS meter. This will tell you your Total Dissolved Solids in your tap water. $10 should buy one delivered. If your tap water is really high + 100 then forget about DI and buy RO but even if your tap wtar is below 100 then RO is probably the best option for the least amount of hassle.

Source, I'm a window cleaner (washer to you US folk) who purifies water for cleaning windows. I'm also a home brewer.

5 upvotes on reddit
K
Ksp-or-GTFO · 4 years ago

The only reason DI might be dangerous is that it could lower your levels of ions and minnerals since it itself has none. There is some talk about it's low pH too but people drink soda with phosphoric acid in it so I can't imagine it is worse than that on your teeth. But this is like if you chugged it daily. On top of that you should be adding salts back to reach a profile so it stops being DI water.

8 upvotes on reddit
O
Ovalman · 4 years ago

Isn't that the point of home brewing with purified water? To add those minerals back in?

The water is boiled so any nasties are destroyed and RO usually has a DI rinse for under sink solutions so I don't think it matters.

I honestly don't know the science behind both but have dealt with both for purifying water. Anything I say is purely for information and not recomendations (says the lawyer in me lol)

I asked the question to a water expert in a AMA thread on Reddit. I'll try and find the thread but they never answered but I'll take that as a doesn't know or didn't see my question.

1 upvotes on reddit
V
videoismylife · 4 years ago

> The only reason DI might be dangerous is that it could lower your levels of ions and minnerals since it itself has none.

This is a myth. The amount of minerals in normal tap water are trivial for your nutritional needs and are orders of magnitude below what's normally in your cells, tissue fluids and blood. Neither DI nor RO will "strip" minerals from your body, your body is a far more sophisticated piece of equipment than that.

3 upvotes on reddit
A
acaellum · 4 years ago

Another option is setting up a still and evaporating your water, collecting the vapors and condensing them back down.

The water won't be DI anymore once you start adding things to it. The DI is just giving you a fresh slate. It's not great for you if you drink it as straight DI.

1 upvotes on reddit
Beer-dude · OP · 4 years ago

Thanks for the thoughts and info gang!

1 upvotes on reddit
Y
Yaggaboola · 4 years ago

Not sure if it's portable enough for you, but I've really enjoyed my APEC Countertop RO System. It's slow but reliable and gets my ~300 ppm TDS water down to <10 ppm.

2 upvotes on reddit
See 12 replies
r/hikinggear • [9]

Summarize

are portable water filters worth it?

Posted by mpt28003 · in r/hikinggear · 3 years ago

thinking of buying one for my trip to north cascades & mt rainier. one of my friends is comfortable with drinking the water unfiltered but i am not so sure.

i found the sawyer one for $30 which seems reasonable. what do y'all use and what's an appropriate price range?

19 upvotes on reddit
12 replies
Helpful
Not helpful
View Source
12 replies
OptOutside5 · 3 years ago

I use the sawyer squeeze and it works great. If it gets slow you just use the syringe to back flush it a few times and it gets going again. The bags they give you that act as bladders work but could be better. Just get a 1L smart water bottle. The filter will screw right on the top of that. Much easier to fill and drink from.

14 upvotes on reddit
Y
YakovAttackov · 3 years ago

I use the Sawyer squeeze (not the mini). Small lightweight and works well. Also threads onto a Smart Water Bottle directly if you want to omit the bags.

Water born illnesses are no joke.

9 upvotes on reddit
M
mpt28003 · OP · 3 years ago

can the mini also screw onto a water bottle or is that only a perk of the full size one?

1 upvotes on reddit
ElenaDragon · 3 years ago

I use a sawyer mini. To collect the water, I use a Platypus soft water bottle (which collapses), and the mini screws right onto it. I filter the clean water into Smart water bottles, which are lightweight and the drinking cap can be used in place of the syringe to backflush the filter.

3 upvotes on reddit
A
allaspiaggia · 3 years ago

Sawyer squeeze all the way. Your friend is an idiot. You can tell them I said that.

I have a friend who was comfortable drinking unfiltered water and now he has chronic giardiasis.

Yup, that means he has chronic explosive diarrhea, among other symptoms. He has had many rounds of treatment, but it still flares up. Not super easy to hike/work/exist when your ass is constantly pissing poop-water. Also if you think you have giardia, get treatment ASAP.

Anyways. Always filter or treat your water! Better safe than sorry. I like the Sawyer squeeze because it’s easy to use and doesn’t change the taste of the water at all. I carry backup chlorine tablets, just in case my only water source looks gross, but I’ve never had to use them. They’re in a tiny packet and weigh like 0.1gram or something.

Also I’m very frugal, but clean drinking water is my #1 priority on hikes. So $30 for a Sawyer squeeze is very reasonable, considering that (in the US) you’d probably spend thousands on medical treatment for GI issues from drinking dirty water!

Ditch the plastic bag that comes with the Sawyer, it sucks. I use 2 smart water bottles, removed the label from my “dirty” bottle. You need to “burp” the bottle every so often when filtering, but it’s easy to do. Yeah it takes a couple minutes to filter water, but again, would you rather risk CHRONIC DIARRHEA!?!?!?!!!

6 upvotes on reddit
M
mpt28003 · OP · 3 years ago

haha i will tell him! when you use the smart water bottles, do you filter it into another clean reservoir/bottle or drink directly from them?

1 upvotes on reddit
A
allaspiaggia · 3 years ago

Nah I just drink directly from the clean bottle, no need to pour it elsewhere. Make sure to differentiate between clean and dirty bottle! Never ever drink from the dirty bottle. You can also re-use smart water bottle basically indefinitely. I used one for 4 months on my AT hike.

2 upvotes on reddit
[deleted] · 3 years ago

Yes, they are absolutely worth it. Any water coming directly from a spring is fine to drink straight, since the chances of that water source being contaminated by an animal is basically zero. However, the chances that a spring will be readily available and accessible when you need water are also low. Rivers, ponds or puddles are usually in abundance in woodland environments, and any water from those sources should be treated.

For filtration, the Sawyer is the gold standard among backpackers. It's small, light, effective, and will last indefinitely (I don't believe you will go on enough backpacking trips in your lifetime to filter 100,000 gallons of water before it needs replacement).

If you watch any thru-hiking videos on Youtube, especially on the PCT, these hikers are safely drinking water out of some absolutely vile, nasty water sources (like rainwater cisterns that livestock drinks from, or with dead animals in them) after filtering with the Sawyer. They're also just a good thing to have around the house. I've used mine during boil water advisories in my town.

4 upvotes on reddit
IspeakNpings · 3 years ago

Sawyer is good but I don't consider it the "gold standard".

They also used to claim 1million gallons until their lawsuit threat, then they changed to 500k gallons and now they are down to 100k gallons and people are still questioning that.

along with no real test that you can verify that it is still working and their lifetime warranty that rarely gets backed up. I just don't deal with them much anymore based on business practices alone (I have had 3 different sets of filters from them).

Of course if you watch YouTube you will see many on there because it looks the best on paper so many will gravitate to that and stick with it. YMMV HYOH :)

1 upvotes on reddit
[deleted] · 3 years ago

By "gold standard" I mean it's the backpacking filter system by which everything else on the market today is compared. This is based on its size, weight, filter effectiveness, and price -- all of which are difficult for a competitor to beat, which is why nothing has yet replaced it as the go-to for backpacking.

100K gallons, even 50k gallons -- you will lose it or break it before you reach that threshold. Few people will claim their lifetime warranty on something that can be replaced at Walmart for $40. That's probably what Sawyer is banking on with those marketing claims.

Still, even if you buy one for a thru-hike and are able to filter potable water from livestock cisterns, you definitely got your $40's worth and will very likely be able to use it for many more thru hikes.

3 upvotes on reddit
T
timechuck · 3 years ago

The squeeze, not the mini!!!! Also, get a cnoc bag for it. It makes it so much easier to use!

6 upvotes on reddit
IspeakNpings · 3 years ago

I was one of those people. 300 miles into my first AT thru hike attempt my filter messed up and I decided that I could "visually tell" if the water was good or not... Man I was a jackass back then... At 698 miles I was very sick for two weeks and ended up going home.

Please, please, use a filter. I have one and another as a backup on me at all times now

8 upvotes on reddit
See 12 replies
r/preppers • [10]

Summarize

What kind of Portable Water Filter did you recommend?

Posted by paw07 · in r/preppers · 6 years ago

I saw this video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fx8PH5jdHyg did you guys recommend one of them?

15 upvotes on reddit
10 replies
Helpful
Not helpful
View Source
10 replies
jeremiahcastelo · 6 years ago

I'm a fan of the Sawyer MINI due to its compact size, its 0.1 micron filter, and the 100,000 gallon filter capacity. Sawyer also offers a lifetime warranty for their MINI. I've done a lot of research on the MINI as well as other portable water filters and I've compiled all of the information here: https://worldwaterreserve.com/potable-water/purification/best-portable-water-filters/

&#x200B;

5 upvotes on reddit
GunsRfuns · 6 years ago

The Sawyer Squeeze is the best for the money. It can filter the most water and has the best flow from the research I did. You can then mix that with a flexible bag like this

6 upvotes on reddit
[deleted] · 6 years ago

I love my sawyer mini. 10/10. Would recommend.

7 upvotes on reddit
GunsRfuns · 6 years ago

The Sawyer Squeeze gets better flow. IMO its worth the extra size and money.

4 upvotes on reddit
[deleted] · 6 years ago

I've been meaning to try one. Maybe I'll take one hiking next spring.

1 upvotes on reddit
paw07 · OP · 6 years ago

sawyer is not available here. LifeStraw is very big for me to carry everyday.

2 upvotes on reddit
B
BenCelotil · 6 years ago

Where are you?

If you're in Australia, I know it's difficult to find the Sawyer Mini but there's a few shops who have it, and deliver. I bought one from Aussie Storm Shop and they deliver overseas if you're in New Zealand.

1 upvotes on reddit
GunsRfuns · 6 years ago

You can't get Sawyer on amazon?

1 upvotes on reddit
waltwalt · 6 years ago

I keep a life straw in my car and a katadyne pump in my primary bag and a sawyer gravity filter in my auxiliary bag.

5 upvotes on reddit
MetroPrepper · 6 years ago

I recently purchased a Katadyn BeFree and am really happy with it. Compared to the Sawyer the flow rate is greater and it’s lighter. Pairing it with a Seeker for gravity filtration. Sawyer is a solid choice as well.

3 upvotes on reddit
See 10 replies

Top People to Talk to

These are some of the top contributors related to
Survival
specializedtools
preppers
2+ others
G

greggorievich

No bio available
35258
Karma
28
Posts
1793
Comments
View Profile
Chat w/ Profile AI
K

KREDDOG79

No bio available
6684
Karma
8
Posts
833
Comments
View Profile
Chat w/ Profile AI
I

idk_lets_try_this

No bio available
73656
Karma
73
Posts
9722
Comments
View Profile
Chat w/ Profile AI
B

Braindead_cranberry

No bio available
27616
Karma
60
Posts
5420
Comments
View Profile
Chat w/ Profile AI
D

drunkbackpacker

No bio available
658679
Karma
633
Posts
10000
Comments
View Profile
Chat w/ Profile AI
C

carlbernsen

No bio available
59049
Karma
42
Posts
10000
Comments
View Profile
Chat w/ Profile AI
S

StaffSergeantBarnes

No bio available
8252
Karma
33
Posts
1302
Comments
View Profile
Chat w/ Profile AI
P

Philosopherski

No bio available
33536
Karma
31
Posts
1705
Comments
View Profile
Chat w/ Profile AI

Related

best brand of water filter

best water filter for home use

best water filter for removing lead

AI Answer

🤖

best portable water filters

Key Considerations for Portable Water Filters

  1. Filtration Type:

    • Activated Carbon: Good for improving taste and removing chemicals.
    • Ceramic Filters: Effective against bacteria and protozoa.
    • UV Filters: Use UV light to kill pathogens but require batteries or a power source.
    • Reverse Osmosis: Highly effective but often bulkier and slower.
  2. Flow Rate: Look for a filter that provides a good flow rate (measured in liters per minute) to ensure you can get clean water quickly, especially in emergencies.

  3. Portability: Consider the size and weight of the filter. Compact and lightweight options are ideal for hiking or travel.

  4. Capacity: Check how much water the filter can process before needing replacement. Some filters can handle thousands of liters, while others may need more frequent changes.

  5. Ease of Use: Look for filters that are easy to set up and operate, especially in outdoor or emergency situations.

Recommendations:

  • Sawyer Squeeze Water Filter System: Highly regarded for its lightweight design, high flow rate, and ability to filter up to 100,000 gallons. It’s versatile for both drinking directly and filling containers.

  • Katadyn BeFree Water Filter: Known for its compact size and fast flow rate, this filter is great for hiking and travel. It can filter up to 1,000 liters and is easy to clean.

  • LifeStraw Personal Water Filter: A popular choice for emergency preparedness and outdoor activities. It’s lightweight, filters up to 1,000 liters, and is effective against bacteria and protozoa.

Choosing the right portable water filter depends on your specific needs, such as the type of activities you’ll be doing and the water sources you expect to encounter.

Still looking for a better answer?

Get more comprehensive results summarized by our most cutting edge AI model. Plus deep Youtube search.

Try Gigabrain Pro for Free
gigaGigaBrain Logo
Support

Who are we?

Get API access

Leave us feedback

Contact us

Legal

Terms of Use

Privacy Policy

Shopping Tools

Product Comparisons

2023 GigaBrain Corporation
As an Amazon Associate, GigaBrain may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.