Alternatives to Herschel Bags

For those looking for sturdy yet stylish bags, The Cambridge Satchel Company is highly recommended. These bags are known for their durability and can often be found secondhand at a more affordable price [2:1]. They offer a classic look that could serve well as an alternative to the Herschel Heritage style.

Coach

Coach offers a variety of leather bags that can serve as alternatives to Herschel. Their outlet store frequently has sales, making it possible to find quality bags under $100 [2:3][5:4]. Coach bags are noted for their craftsmanship and timeless design, making them suitable for both casual and professional settings.

Tusting

If you're seeking a brand with character and high-quality craftsmanship, Tusting is worth considering. Known for their excellent quality, Tusting bags provide a unique style that stands out from mainstream brands like Mark & Graham [4:1]. They offer a range of styles that could appeal to someone looking for something different from Herschel.

Status Anxiety

Status Anxiety offers minimalist designs with options like the Plunder Black crossbody bag. These bags are praised for their quality and affordability, fitting well within a budget while offering a stylish and functional alternative [1:2].

Other Recommendations

For those interested in exploring more options, consider brands like Lotuff, Mont Blanc, Hugo Boss, and Kovered. These brands offer a range of leather goods, from briefcases to crossbody bags, catering to different tastes and budgets [5:1][5:3][5:5]. Additionally, checking stores like TJ Maxx, Marshalls, or Ross could yield great finds at reasonable prices [2:4].

See less

Helpful

Not helpful

Turn chaos into clarity with Ultra.

Your insights at a glance—try Gigabrain Ultra to filter through the vastness of Reddit content and easily monitor your audience and market trends.

Products

Weighted Hoodie for Anxiety, Comfort Hoodie for Anxiety, Weighted Hoodie for Anxiety Women, Anxiety Hoodie for men

$47.99

Source Threads

POST SUMMARY • [1]

Summarize

Looking for silver hardware & small or no logo

Posted by seybeee · in r/handbags · 24 days ago

3 upvotes on reddit

6 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

View Source

ORIGINAL POST

Hi!

I’ve been a Kate Spade bag lover since I was a teenager. I am now older and I haven’t bought a new bag in years. I realized that I hate gold on bags and only want silver hardware. I also don’t like large logos but prefer no logo. I want a small bag (crossbody for wallet, purse, lip gloss, maybe sunglasses but not a must). I don’t carry much.

Any recommendations? Preferably brown or black pebbled leather. I tried an AllSaints bag from Nordstrom rack and I wasn’t sure of the quality so I returned it.

Hoping to stay under $200!

6 replies

srirachaho · 24 days ago

https://thehorse.co/products/clementine-bag-black a little over but they have a new customer discount

https://www.radleylondon.com/products/ivydale-road-small-ziptop-crossbody-black?variant=52306874990958

I’ll be back with more in a bit

3 upvotes on reddit

seybeee · OP · 24 days ago

Amazing thanks!! How is the quality of the horse bags, any input?

1 upvotes on reddit

srirachaho · 24 days ago

Great for the price. My friend has one and I think it’s nice leather. Hardware is fine, nothing special. I recommend searching the sub because they are popular around here

Other ideas as promised

https://www.statusanxiety.com/products/plunder-black?variant=4133565693993

https://www.farfetch.com/shopping/women/pinko-love-one-classic-crossbody-bag-item-29611453.aspx?storeid=17286

https://www.coccinelle.com/us_en/e1rbf180201-g28.html wildcard color

https://en.smaakamsterdam.com/collections/crossbody-tassen/products/figu-black

2 upvotes on reddit

Awkward_Cellist6541 · 23 days ago

The Horse bags are great for the price. I have four and I want another.

1 upvotes on reddit

AutoModerator · 24 days ago

Hi fellow handbag lover! Thank you for being a part of the r/handbags community.

This is a subreddit which relies on kindness. Your opinion is very much welcomed, however, we do not tolerate rude, mean or hurtful comments. Read the rules before posting. Comments or posts that do not fit our rule book will be removed and the OP can be banned by the mods' discretion.

If you see a comment or post which does not abide by the rules, please report it to our moderation team.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1 upvotes on reddit

Sufficient-Yard-2038 · 24 days ago

I was also going to suggest the horse clementine as soon as I read this. Pedro demi is a similar bag

2 upvotes on reddit

See 6 replies

r/handbags • [2]

Summarize

Anyone with suggestions for a sturdy yet still cheap-ish bag brand?

Posted by glitcharson · in r/handbags · 16 days ago

I’m looking for a stylish-yet-useful kind of bag for school, my current bag [a well-loved commuter backpack from target I’ve lugged around like a purse for a year] and it’s finally tearing on me. I’ve sewn up the tears but I’m unsure how much longer she can last and want to look for a replacement.

I’m specifically looking for something crossbody like a messenger bag [I can reinforce the stitching on the straps if needed] because my current bag has been hell and a half on only one of my shoulders so I’m looking to balance that weight a little better.

Around 200 bucks is going to be my limit here, but that’s still stretching it for me. I’m tempted to try and craft my own bag but I’ve never done something like that before and it’d be completely unpredictable for life-time and durability.

4 upvotes on reddit

6 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

View Source

6 replies

glitcharson · OP · 16 days ago

Forgot to add into the post, but backpacks are simply a no-go for me since they’re horribly impractical for the way I travel and work

3 upvotes on reddit

Gertiebeth · 16 days ago

Here are a few places to look for a leather handbag under $100. They all have sales too:

https://www.coachoutlet.com/shop/bags/view-all

https://www.katespadeoutlet.com

https://www.madewell.com/womens/accessories/bags/

https://www.quince.com/women/bags-&-leather-goods

https://www.portlandleathergoods.com

2 upvotes on reddit

Key-Boat-7519 · 8 days ago

Validate with real merchants before touching a line of code; everything else is noise. Book 10 short calls with Shopify store owners this week and ask about the pain your idea tackles-no demo, no pitch, just stories of how they handle it today and what it costs them in time or money. If at least 7 say “I need this, can I pay when it’s ready?” you’re onto something; if not, tweak. Use Typeform to collect structured follow-ups, Loom to share a two-minute click-dummy you hack together in Figma, and Stripe payment links to see if anyone will swipe a card for early access. Skip a public waitlist until you’ve got five paid beta users; they’ll give sharper feedback than a thousand anonymous emails. I’ve run this play twice and it shaved months off development. I mix in Pulse for Reddit alongside Intercom and Hotjar to watch how merchants talk about the problem in niche threads. Talk to real merchants first, then build.

1 upvotes on reddit

Conscious_Life_8032 · 16 days ago

check out TJmaxx, Marshalls, Ross sometimes they have great bags for decent price

the other option is coach outlet, hopefully they have some labor day sales going on.

2 upvotes on reddit

newfashionistagal · 16 days ago

Furla

4 upvotes on reddit

jessofthecreek · 16 days ago

If you’re willing to buy secondhand, I highly recommend bags from The Cambridge Satchel Company. They are workhorses. If you buy brand new, you may be able to buy one from the website if it’s on sale.I know they have stockists globally and can maybe catch a deal elsewhere; full price they are definitely over $200. But there’s lots on reselling sites! It may just take a while depending on your desired style, size, and color.

3 upvotes on reddit

See 6 replies

r/backpacks • [3]

Summarize

BIFL Recommendation: Want Herschel Heritage-like Bag Suitable for Office

Posted by pratyushmanocha · in r/backpacks · 4 months ago

Hey guys,

I have a navy/tan Herschel Heritage bag I bought in 2019. Its pleather has torn now, and I do not think it would be repaired by the limited lifetime warranty Herschel offers. Additionally, I will start a new job soon, so I want something a bit more formal than the navy/tan design. Therefore, I am in the market looking for a new bag similar to Herschel's Heritage that would last me more than a few years.

Requirements:

15" Laptop sleeve
Waterproof
Minimalistic design
Heritage look (I like the rugged look of leather- if I can get it in a material that wouldn't wear away, that is a huge plus!)
More than one zipped compartment (optional- more space is a plus)
Water bottle pocket (optional- having it is a plus)
Budget: 100-150 USD

I have looked at the Vaschy Classic Pack (cheap knockoff of Herschel, but I do not know how long it will last), Jansport Suede Campus, Topodesigns Daypack Classic, and L.L.Bean Mountain Classic Cordura Pack. So far, I liked Jansport the most since it meets almost all my requirements and looks very similar. However, I am worried the suede leather used would crack as it ages. So, I want to ask you all, do you have any recommendations (out of these or others) that are better than Jansport Suede Campus?

Thanks for your recommendations!

4 upvotes on reddit

2 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

View Source

2 replies

Breiting_131 · 4 months ago

an Eastpak Out of Office would be a good choice

1 upvotes on reddit

pratyushmanocha · OP · 4 months ago

I looked it up on Amazon US. It has a 13" laptop sleeve, but unfortunately, that doesn't fit my purpose; I have a 15.4" laptop, which I need to carry. Would you happen to have any other recommendations?

1 upvotes on reddit

See 2 replies

r/handbags • [4]

Summarize

I love bags of this style but I’d like to buy from a brand with a little more character than Mark & Graham

Posted by 2002forsport · in r/handbags · 7 months ago

I need a new every day bag/work bag. I currently use a YSL Sac De Jour or an LL Bean camo tote depending on the day. I love Mark and Grahams style but I hate their quality and I feel like the brand is a little lame (makes me lame too I guess). I will probably pull the trigger on a Barbour tote unless I can find a more unique brand. I love finding small brands, off the beaten path items, etc. Please drop recs! Willing to spend $$$$ a bag I love but happy to drop $150. Doesn’t need to be fancy.

reddit.com

3 upvotes on reddit

3 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

View Source

3 replies

AutoModerator · 7 months ago

Hi fellow handbag lover! Thank you for being a part of the r/handbags community.

If you see a comment or post which does not abide by the rules, please report it to our moderation team.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1 upvotes on reddit

Individual-Rice-4915 · 7 months ago

Tusting has a really cute bag like this, and the brand is SUCH wonderful quality.

1 upvotes on reddit

2002forsport · OP · 7 months ago

Oh wow, just checked it out, thanks for this rec! This sub is awesome.

1 upvotes on reddit

See 3 replies

r/mensfashionadvice • [5]

Summarize

Are there any companies that do similar bags to this?

Posted by FatPeopleDotCom · in r/mensfashionadvice · 2 months ago

Can be in the same price range or can be less. I want something like this to take to university as I don’t like backpacks

i.redd.it

2 upvotes on reddit

5 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

View Source

5 replies

DobryVojakSvejk · 2 months ago

Literally every company that produces leather goods makes an identical bag. You won't find a decent one for much less than the sale price in the screenshot.

22 upvotes on reddit

Cjsn · 2 months ago

If you just type laptop leather briefcase into Google you will get lots of options.

If you care about branding then Mont Blanc has a slick, classy look (might be out of your price range though - potentially check eBay) or Hugo Boss which would be cheaper. I do actually have a RL leather laptop bag myself though because I couldn't afford a Mont Blanc briefcase at the time. The branding on mine is black, so on black leather it is subtle compared to the one you posted though

3 upvotes on reddit

Appropriate-Pear-33 · 2 months ago

Coach makes a nice one for men.

2 upvotes on reddit

Acceptably_Attired73 · 2 months ago

For that price, I think kovered might be your option. Would be a bit more practical too. Maybe something from chapman or tusting but on eBay.

2 upvotes on reddit

rangkilrog · 2 months ago

Do you mean similar or cheaper?

This is a really common style. The RL bag you linked is a good price.

Mine are from Coach and Lotuff.

3 upvotes on reddit

See 5 replies

r/handbags • [6]

Summarize

Looking for this but better

Posted by Rare-Ad2766 · in r/handbags · 2 months ago

I am in love with this bag but have heard bad things about noirvere…anything similar anyone can find? Preferably vegan!

Thanks

i.redd.it

3 upvotes on reddit

4 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

View Source

4 replies

latestnightowl · 2 months ago

I feel like this is a Coach Brooklyn dupe

https://www.coach.com/products/brooklyn-shoulder-bag-28/CU068.html

1 upvotes on reddit

AutoModerator · 2 months ago

Hi fellow handbag lover! Thank you for being a part of the r/handbags community.

If you see a comment or post which does not abide by the rules, please report it to our moderation team.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1 upvotes on reddit

Playful-Exam8935 · 2 months ago

I’m cracking up and Do We Know them in the corner because it’s so relatable online shopping and watching lol

2 upvotes on reddit

srirachaho · 2 months ago

https://global.musinsa.com/ph/goods/4655521?gQT=1

but honestly if you’re debating between 2 PU bags, go cheaper since neither will last

Alternative https://www.solandselene.com/collections/handbags/products/revive-hobo?variant=43594028056767

5 upvotes on reddit

See 4 replies

r/handbags • [7]

Summarize

Alternative bags?

Posted by Nerdy-athlete64 · in r/handbags · 3 months ago

I love this bag but I don’t want to spend $300….. anybody know of any alternatives that are more affordable?

i.redd.it

10 upvotes on reddit

10 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

View Source

10 replies

roberbear · 3 months ago

I was looking at this bag yesterday because I really want the mini leather Baggu shoulder bag, but I’m not enamored with the materials, i.e., “recycled leather”. Anyway, that one is $140.

3 upvotes on reddit

Ramisugar · 3 months ago

Looks like there's a pretty crazy promo code working for the Baggu as well that brings the price down to $84!

1 upvotes on reddit

PotentPotables_ · 3 months ago

I saw those in person yesterday. They feel better than a lot of vegan leather I've felt but if you know and love leather then it doesn't feel great. For that price I'd rather sink it into genuine leather. It's not eco-friendly if it's going to peel and need replacing.

4 upvotes on reddit

roberbear · 3 months ago

Yeah. I’m not going to do it, but I really love the shape!! I have a nylon one and the size is perfect for me. The Brooklyn 28 is looking like the best alternative I’ve seen so far for a nice leather version.

3 upvotes on reddit

Awkward_Cellist6541 · 3 months ago

Portland Leather Goods Naomi

PLG Flora

3 upvotes on reddit

spoons431 · 3 months ago

I really like this bag and I wish I could get for $300! That's about £225 - it's currently £350 (approx $475)

So at the current price it's almost half the UK retail price!

3 upvotes on reddit

whataquokka · 3 months ago

I stumbled upon one on Woot! in black for $180. They're an Amazon company and it's claimed to be legit so I guess I'll see when it arrives this week.

2 upvotes on reddit

Suziannie · 3 months ago

Honestly, I was opposed to it because of the price for a long time. I broke down and got it and it’s truly wonderful! The size is fantastic as it holds a lot but remains slim and easy to carry.

Just go for it!

6 upvotes on reddit

Nerdy-athlete64 · OP · 3 months ago

You’re a bad influence!! 😂🙌🏽

6 upvotes on reddit

Suziannie · 3 months ago

I mean it’s just such a pretty bag!

https://preview.redd.it/tuz72etawc3f1.jpeg?width=4284&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=2cb2e034b9c1c6f2d6d246e473924a9e5d5001f0

7 upvotes on reddit

See 10 replies

r/EDC • [8]

Summarize

“Is that an off brand Herschel bag?”

Posted by A_Prophets_Vision · in r/EDC · 5 years ago

34 upvotes on reddit

7 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

View Source

7 replies

c05eden · 5 years ago

I love Tom! Sitting here staring at my synapse 19 and luminary 15 and obligatory pouches... so many pouches. Whoever said that to you a out hershel deserves an open hand slap!

3 upvotes on reddit

ImACoolDouche · 5 years ago

Before I got into EDC i would've probably thought the same thing. .^.

2 upvotes on reddit

KroniicaL · 5 years ago

Upvoted for being a fellow Ibanez owner

2 upvotes on reddit

adaytoocala · 5 years ago

It bothers me that you didn’t even try to place the bottle caps anywhere near their corresponding location.

12 upvotes on reddit

A_Prophets_Vision · OP · 5 years ago

Haha at first I attempted to, but it got complicated once I got to beers from overseas

3 upvotes on reddit

adaytoocala · 5 years ago

And you have repeats on there too. I need to just stop looking at that thing and go to a happy place.

2 upvotes on reddit

irkthejerk · 5 years ago

My Herschel is falling to pieces after only light use over a few years. Looking for an upgrade

3 upvotes on reddit

See 7 replies

r/handbags • [9]

Summarize

Looking for an affordable shoulder bag similar to these

Posted by hahdif · in r/handbags · 1 year ago

Hopefully I’m not breaking any rules, but I’m looking for something in this vein in black/dark brown/dark green/red. I’m trying to keep it below $100, which I totally recognize is a tough ask. I’m hoping for something subtle/not too heavy on branding. Thank you so much for all your help!!

reddit.com

10 upvotes on reddit

12 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

View Source

12 replies

starsamaria · 1 year ago

If you're going to spend $100, I'd recommend going for a genuine leather bag since that'll be better quality. You can find some bags that are these styles and are genuine leather for around the $100 price point, although it may be tough to find one in black for that price:

https://www.nordstromrack.com/s/kate-spade-new-york-penny-pebbled-leather-shoulder-bag/6581875

https://www.radleylondon.com/handbags/satchels/hanley-close-medium-flapover-shoulder-h7881-aw23

https://www.radleylondon.com/handbags/anniversary-camden-collection-summerstown-small-ziptop-multiway-h8248-aw23

I know this is over your budget, but Kate Spade recently had 40-50% off sale items, which would bring it under $100: https://www.katespade.com/products/hudson-medium-convertible-crossbody/K6576-1.html

4 upvotes on reddit

Manic-Star · 1 year ago

I was thinking Kate Spade Hudson Convertible as well (fits the shape OP requested and is a fantastic and versatile bag) but that bag is pebbled leather so has a different finish than the bags posted. I agree with the recc but just wanted to point out the different leather finish!!

3 upvotes on reddit

Specialist_Income_31 · 1 year ago

https://m.wconcept.com/product/rone-daily-bag-3-color-/710221621.html

3 upvotes on reddit

Specialist_Income_31 · 1 year ago

https://www.charleskeith.com/us/bags/CK2-50782198_BLACK.html

https://www.charleskeith.com/us/bags/CK2-41220016-1_TAN.html

2 upvotes on reddit

Specialist_Income_31 · 1 year ago

https://www.jwpei.com/products/jw-pei-womens-joy-shoulder-bag-deep-claret? I know it’s not exactly what you have pictured but the deep red is there

https://shop.mango.com/us/women/bags-shoulder-bags/short-handle-shoulder-bag_57001039.html

1 upvotes on reddit

hahdif · OP · 1 year ago

these are amazing thank you so much! the charles and keith crescent bag is gorgeous - do you know if it’s particularly hard to get into? i know bags with that shape often can be

4 upvotes on reddit

Specialist_Income_31 · 1 year ago

It’s just a flap with a zipper. You should be okay. The plain zipper ones are easy to get into too.

1 upvotes on reddit

Manic-Star · 1 year ago

There is a shoulder bag from Lauren Ralph Lauren called the Danni Medium Shoulder Bag, I think it’s 225 USD, but I’ve seen it go on sale (in Europe, I don’t live in US) for as low as €95. I have seen it in black, dark green, and burgundy, so I would assume you can find it in those colours at least, it seems to exist in many colours. It’s not shiny like the ones you posted, but the shape is really sleek and lovely. It looks very similar to the first one you posted but the leather is more matte. Best of luck!!

2 upvotes on reddit

Mochalover- · 6 months ago

Hey do you remember what time of the year you saw it at 95€? Im debating if i buy it or not because its currently 206€ in spartoo (original price is 249€) but i still think its a high price for a basic bag 95€ is much more reasonable

1 upvotes on reddit

hahdif · OP · 1 year ago

thank you so much!!

2 upvotes on reddit

tinysapling · 1 year ago

I'd look at Staud, Aesther Ekme

3 upvotes on reddit

bastillions · 1 year ago

Check out Charles and Keith, they are in that price range and have a bunch of styles

3 upvotes on reddit

See 12 replies

r/ManyBaggers • [10]

Summarize

Alternatives for Porter CRAG bag

Posted by uwqo · in r/ManyBaggers · 6 months ago

So i’ve fallen in love with a Porter bag today but it costs SO MUCH and i, as a guy with a low budget, can’t afford these steep prices. Does anyone know a similar bag to this?

reddit.com

11 upvotes on reddit

10 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

View Source

10 replies

mega5700 · 6 months ago

Uniqlo came out with some Porter knock offs this season that are cheap and nice.

1 upvotes on reddit

Perry4761 · 6 months ago

What currency is this? This bag retails for 43 000 yen, which is 290 USD at the current exchange rate.

6 upvotes on reddit

ColdYeosSoyMilk · 6 months ago

290 usd for THAT? LOL

-8 upvotes on reddit

Perry4761 · 6 months ago

Porter is a pretty expensive brand yes. The bags are good quality, but the aesthetic isn’t for everyone: https://www.yoshidakaban.com/en/product/search.html?bid=0001

6 upvotes on reddit

uwqo · OP · 6 months ago

the currency is czech krouna, and the additional money is probably the vat i can reclaim at the airport

1 upvotes on reddit

Perry4761 · 6 months ago

Yikes 10 500 czk is 456 USD that’s definitely too much for this bag!

2 upvotes on reddit

AmandaBanks · 6 months ago

To be honest, the bag fits so perfect and its beautiful

1 upvotes on reddit

uwqo · OP · 6 months ago

i know right?! ☹️

1 upvotes on reddit

trd2970 · 6 months ago

Love the porter vibes. MIJ quality is 👍👍👍

2 upvotes on reddit

Ok_Fortune_9149 · 6 months ago

Timbuk2 has a few

1 upvotes on reddit

See 10 replies

Top People to Talk to

These are some of the top contributors related to

handbags

backpacks

mensfashionadvice

1+ others

srirachaho

No bio available

7073

Karma

Posts

3865

Comments

View Profile

Chat w/ Profile AI

AutoModerator

No bio available

2000

Karma

10000

Posts

10000

Comments

View Profile

Chat w/ Profile AI

🤖

What are some alternatives to Herschel bags

Here are some alternatives to Herschel bags to consider:

Fjällräven: Known for their durable and functional designs, Fjällräven offers a range of backpacks and bags that are stylish and practical, like the Kånken series.
Patagonia: Offers eco-friendly bags with a focus on sustainability. Their Arbor Grande and Black Hole collections are popular for both everyday use and outdoor adventures.
North Face: Renowned for their outdoor gear, North Face backpacks are durable and functional, suitable for both urban and outdoor settings.
JanSport: A classic brand known for its reliable and affordable backpacks. They offer a variety of styles and colors, making them a great everyday option.
Adidas: Their lifestyle bags, like the Adidas Originals line, combine sporty aesthetics with functionality, suitable for casual use.
Timbuk2: Offers customizable messenger bags and backpacks that are durable and designed for urban commuting.
Osprey: Known for their high-quality outdoor backpacks, Osprey offers options that are great for hiking, travel, and everyday use.

Recommendation: When choosing an alternative, consider your specific needs—whether it's style, functionality, or sustainability. Fjällräven and Patagonia are excellent for outdoor enthusiasts, while North Face and JanSport are great for everyday use. If you prefer a sporty look, Adidas is a solid choice.

Still looking for a better answer?

Get more comprehensive results summarized by our most cutting edge AI model. Plus deep Youtube search.

Try Gigabrain Pro for Free

Add to Chrome