TL;DR
Brioche Buns
Brioche buns are a favorite among many burger enthusiasts due to their rich, buttery flavor. They are often toasted on the inside to add texture and prevent sogginess [1:1],
[2:3]. However, some find brioche too greasy when paired with high-fat burger patties
[2:8],
[3:6].
Potato Buns
Potato buns are another popular choice, praised for their ability to remain chewy and soft while standing up to toppings [2:1],
[3:4]. Martin's potato rolls are frequently mentioned as a top brand, though some users have ethical concerns about purchasing them
[3:4]. Arnold/Orowheat is suggested as a good alternative
[3:5].
Pretzel Buns
Pretzel buns are favored for their toughness and ability to handle sloppy burger fillings [1:2],
[1:3]. They offer a unique texture that can complement gourmet-style burgers
[2:4].
King's Hawaiian Rolls
For those interested in making sliders, King's Hawaiian Rolls are recommended for their sweetness and soft texture [1:5]. They provide a different flavor profile that can be appealing for smaller, sweeter burger creations.
Homemade Options
If you're inclined to bake your own buns, King Arthur's website offers recipes that are highly regarded by home bakers [5:1],
[5:2]. Their potato bun recipe is particularly noted for its quality and taste
[5:1].
In conclusion, the best burger bun for grilling largely depends on personal preference and the style of burger you plan to make. Consider trying different types to see which complements your grilling style and taste preferences.
I bought brioche buns tonight so I can make burgers tomorrow. Also, what brands are the buns from if they're not from a bakery?
Pretzel bun. You can put a lot on it and it's tough enough to take some mauling from your hands. If I was going to make a gigantic burger I'd make a large pretzel bun myself, because they'd be hard to find in stores.
Agreed. I find brioche etc to be too greasy for what's going to be a high fat filling. A nice chewy pretzel bun is ideal to handle sloppy burger fillings.
I like to make sliders with King's Hawaiian Rolls.
They also make burger and hotdog buns from the same recipe.
Whatever you do, just make sure there's a layer of fat under your patty. Either cheese or a thin layer of mayo or whatever. It will act as a barrier to keep the juices from the patty from sogging your bottom bun.
I personally love potato buns, no particular brand tho
Brioche is my go to (buttered/toasted). Also a fan of potato buns and onion rolls.
Let me know what everyone thinks! I’m looking to start cooking more gourmet end burgers as a side gig, and I know what buns I prefer, but what does everyone else think? Brioche, sesame seed, toasted, untoasted? Dense or light and fluffy? Let me know your thoughts and opinions!
Pretzel bun.
I second this. It can stand up to toppings, remain chewy and soft. Just, yum.
Brioche. Buttered and toasted on the inside only.
Brioche! Brioche! Brioche!
The bun I love to nosh!
Nope probably the worst. Brioche is a grease trap and you're making it greasier with butter.
100% team butter bread and more butter
Potato bun
First thing I thought of, too.
Two grilled cheese sandwiches
Martin’s potato rolls are the best burger bun
The buns I get at the supermarket don’t ever seem to be as good as the ones I get at in-n-out or Shake Shack. I realize that they are probably more fresh, but does anyone have a favorite go-to bun that can be found at the store?
Edit: thanks for all the great suggestions everyone! Brioche seems to be a clear favorite with potato buns in a close second. I’ll try out some next time I make burgers!
Hawaiian Rolls has a pretzel bun that's good and different, but we usually use brioche buns. Nature's Own or Sara Lee.
People talk shit about brioche, but I can’t find anything else around me that can hold up to the juices from a 70/30 or 80/20 patty even when toasted to almost burnt. Politics aside I can’t get Martin’s rolls shipped and not stale or smashed.
I’ve had good luck at grocery store bakery departments with brioche buns. Or find a local bakery and see what they have.
Shake Shack uses Martin's, which is readily available in the Northeast. A percentage of every sale goes to support insurrection, if you are into that.
Arnold/Orowheat potato buns are a decent alternative.
Just tried Arnold brand earlier this week since I refuse to give any more of my money to Martin's, and they're really good. They toasted very well in some beef tallow. Nice to know I have another option.
I've tinkered with baking my own potato buns because of it, and they're good, it's just a lot of work.
I might be misreading but Orowheat is the same as Arnold, just different parts of the country. Like Hellman’s vs Best Food.
Too much of a hassle for me, but these are my personal favorite store bought buns of all time: https://nordicexpatshop.com/ENG/kohberg-yoghurtboller
What do you mean when you say they contribute to "Insurrection"?
Potato bun is my go to!
Yep. With Martin's as my go to brand
This is the way.
I’m a big fan of thin buns, especially the ones from Aldi. Otherwise, it’s too much bread for my liking.
My burger got some love yesterday so wanted to share the bun I’ve been using. Looks like they are available at many stores. If you can get them i definitely recommend.
I think brioche is too sweet for a burger
Absolutely zero sweetness in these. It reminds me of the hamburger buns you get at most good restaurants. Just a good well-made soft hamburger bun
Honestly, these are not particularly sweet. It’s more the texture. They’re even rather low-calorie for a burger bun of this size. Highly recommend (can’t say the same for their hotdog buns, though they are good for a lobster roll).
I agree. Amazing hamburger buns but their hot dog buns are sliced that weird lengthwise way that's more common on a lobster roll.
Costco also has a 12 pack for the same price you’d pay for 6 at the grocery store. And they last for over a month so you don’t need to worry about eating burgers every night for a week. Not that I’d complain.
I had to quit Costco unfortunately. They're just too damn busy. Going to my local Costco (there are two in my metro area) was getting to be worse than going to the DMV. I slum it at Sam's now. It's a shameful existence, but at least I can go to the store and get home with my sanity still intact and most of the hours of the day remaining.
I use these every time, love them!
Aldi did an everything bagel seasoning bun last year that was amazing! Unfortunately it seems they haven’t brought it back this year
Au contraire, mon ami de Reddit.
Just had one yesterday. Apparently photo comments aren’t allowed on this sub (but gifs are, weirdly). But I have a pack in my fridge right now.
I like the sesame seed ones. The ones from Aldi are great too.
50% of the burger grade comes from the bun alone.
Thank you. They are just as good as well. Plus they have sesame ones in addition to plain ones.
Love love love their bun recipe my family goes crazy for them!!
They look great! I love King Arthur’s recipes - they always come out for me. Is this the regular patties? I’ve made the potato buns and they are so good I could eat them by themselves
I ate one by itself LOL. Always have one or a bite to make sure they are good
Baker’s treat! :)
I'm looking to experiment more and am looking for suggestions. About as fancy as I've gone lately is a potato bun.
Try a Portuguese muffin.
Chicken
Marbled Rye, Brioche, Onion roll or Ciabatta
Nice buns for your burgers.
Just made brioche burger buns yesterday for a burger grilling... they are amazing. Enjoy your cook out!
Thanks, yeah today was like the fifth time that I made the buns in the last 4 weeks I can’t get enough of it
…
Dang, homemade buns? Thats next level. Did u use a specific recipe or wing it?
I used a recipe I saw on TikTok
Mix
2 tbsp active yeast
1 cup warm water
3 tbsp sugar
Let sit for ~5-10 mins until foamy
Add
3 tbsp oil
1 tsp salt
1 room temp egg
Mix
Add
3 cups of flour
Knead until smooth. Add more flour if it stays too sticky
Cut into ~8 pieces and form into rolls
Cover with a towel and let raise for 30 mins
Bake @ 425° for 10-15 mins until it looks done
I did these with melted butter brushed on and sesame seeds sprinkled on
Own buns take time, but it is so worth it
Agreed! Took just over an hour maybe? Will definitely be doing that again
You have me craving a burger now! That looks delicious
I'm admiring your buns, OP.
Was prepping for grilled burger night, but these lend themselves for just about anything! Next time I think I would add some honey or more sugar for a deeper flavor, as these are a little one note, and more salt to bring out the flavor. Still though they are rich and buttery and fluffy.
The condiments will help. Those look great. What recipe did you use?
I figure between mayo, ketchup, relish or other sauces it should be okay. I used this: https://momsdish.com/homemade-brioche-buns
Side note, I grew up using the fanny farmer cookbook brioche recipe and I find it really tender and flavorful. Might go back to using that
Is that the coffee cake (brioche) recipe. I only really know her Parker house rolls.
Hey, even my brioche buns looked damn good but they tasted very bland. Do you mind sharing the recipe of fanny farmer. TIA
Noice
As the title says, what's the best bun for burger in your opinion, and why? Novice here
Potato or brioche, depending on type of burger.
What is it about the burger that helps determine your bun choice? I always use either potato or brioche, but don't really discriminate based on toppings or anything, just whatever I feel like in the moment.
Brioche are just too sweet imo. But I'm an Aussie.... I get it, but no thanks. Potato or milk for my smash burgers and buttermilk chicken, don't mind either
Not OP but I would say potato for smash burgers and brioche for thicc burgers
I would also add Hawaiian Sweet Rolls as well. They are perfect for sliders if used individually. If you group 4 together, it can be used for a regular burger.
People who use four Hawaiian rolls on a single burger are the same kind of people who bite into all the Kit Kats at once.
Hunker down everyone, here come the Brioche Bros.
Martin’s potato roll (used by Shake Shack).
This and only this!
Best burger buns for grilling
Key Considerations for Choosing Burger Buns:
Texture: Look for buns that are soft yet sturdy enough to hold up against juicy patties and toppings without falling apart. A slightly toasted surface can enhance texture.
Flavor: Choose buns that complement the flavor of the burger. Brioche buns offer a slightly sweet taste, while pretzel buns provide a savory, salty flavor.
Size: Ensure the buns are the right size for your patties. Standard burger buns are typically around 4-5 inches in diameter, but you may want larger or smaller options depending on your burger size.
Grilling Capability: Opt for buns that can withstand grilling without becoming too charred or soggy. Look for buns that are specifically labeled as grill-friendly.
Ingredients: Check for quality ingredients. Whole grain or artisan buns can add nutritional value and flavor.
Recommendations:
Brioche Buns: These are a favorite for their rich, buttery flavor and soft texture. They grill well and add a touch of elegance to your burgers.
Pretzel Buns: Great for a unique twist, pretzel buns are sturdy and have a delightful salty crust that pairs well with savory burgers.
Potato Buns: Known for their softness and slight sweetness, potato buns are excellent for holding up against juicy patties and toppings.
Whole Wheat Buns: For a healthier option, whole wheat buns provide a nutty flavor and added fiber, making them a good choice for health-conscious eaters.
Tip: Always consider toasting your buns lightly on the grill before adding the burger. This adds flavor and helps prevent sogginess from the juices.
Get more comprehensive results summarized by our most cutting edge AI model. Plus deep Youtube search.