Tide Detergents
Tide is frequently recommended across various discussions as a reliable and effective detergent choice. Tide + Ultra Oxi and Tide with Bleach powder are particularly noted for their effectiveness in HE machines, offering good stain removal and being cost-effective [1:1]. For those sensitive to scents, Tide Free & Gentle is suggested as it provides excellent cleaning power without strong fragrances
[1:3],
[4:4]. Tide Stain Release Plus is also highlighted by Consumer Reports as one of the best detergents currently available
[4:1].
Persil Detergents
Persil is another popular choice among users, known for its deep cleaning capabilities. It is often mentioned alongside Tide as a top contender for laundry detergents [5:1],
[5:6]. Persil Free & Sensitive is recommended for those with sensitive skin
[3:2].
Alternative Options
For those interested in eco-friendly or less conventional options, Charlie's Soap is praised for its ability to clean effectively without leaving residue, making it suitable for sensitive skin [4:3]. Additionally, Arm & Hammer with OxiClean is noted for odor control and can be combined with vinegar as a natural fabric softener
[2:4].
Additional Laundry Products
Some users recommend using additional products like Oxiclean for stain removal, though it's advised not to use too much in HE machines [4:1]. Vinegar is suggested as a natural alternative to fabric softeners, which can leave residue in washing machines
[2:4],
[2:5].
Considerations for Sensitive Skin
For those with sensitive skin, it's important to choose detergents that are free of dyes and fragrances. Tide Free & Gentle and Persil Free & Sensitive are both recommended options. Proper rinsing is crucial, and adding citric acid crystals during the rinse cycle can help ensure all detergent residues are removed [3:2].
I have an HE washing machine. We do a fair amount of laundry. What is the best soap option? Considering cost and effectiveness?
It’s really hard to beat Tide + Ultra Oxi or Tide with Bleach powder and a warm wash cycle in terms of bang for the buck in HE machines. Dose between lines 1 and 2 for a starting point. Covers the most common soils, works in most water conditions, is cheaper than liquids for comparable performance.
Agree on the detergents. Have you used both? I switched from Ultra Oxi to the Tide with Bleach thinking it’d be better and they feel the same to me. Can’t really tell the difference in stain or odor removal.
They’re so close in formula I can’t tell a difference so long as it’s a fresher box of ultra Oxi and has the lipase restored.
I’m not a big scent person. What’s better in your opinion: Tide’s Free & Gentle Powder or Whole Food’s 365 Unscented Powder?
Tide Free & Gentle powder if you’re not a big scent person. Regular or Tide + Oxi powder if you like scented things. The stain removal is crazy good. I don’t even have to pre treat things anymore and they come out clean…and I have an 8 month old who loves spaghetti.
I like dad mode and dirty labs. They both have clean ingredients (and full ingredient disclosure) and use a wide variety of laundry enzymes. For my busy family, they have both worked well on a wide range of materials, stains, and odors.
Box of Tide from Costco. Never been happier.
Persil for me.
I recently upgraded from a cheap 20 year old washing machine to a brand new fancy top loader with trays for all the different products. I've always just used detergent and occasionally the scent beads. What are your must-have or even luxurious laundry products that you use?
I've been seeing ads for the rinse agents and have never really used fabric softener. Are any of these worth it? I've actually been excited to do laundry for the first time in YEARS!
Detergent, fabric sanitizer, bleach, oxiclean and scent beads. I only use scent beads on my bedding. I love the smell when I get in.
Detergent and sanitizer. I don't use the sanitizer all the time, just when needed. I have a cat who has an infectious disease so I use the sanitizer for her laundry. Sometimes, I will get the oxiclean powder to brighten. I don't use fabric softener because I don't need it and it isn't good for anyone, let alone my pets.
Don't use fabric softener, it will leave residue inside your machine. You can use vinegar as a fabric softener. Personally I use arm and hammer oxiclean odor blast detergent, 1/4 cup vinegar and 1/4 cup oxiclean powder. I don't use dryer sheets. Never used scent beads but I have read they do the same as fabric softener.
Please don't use fabric softener. It just COATS your clothing.
Must haves
My luxurious product is bath and body works detergent and scent beads. I also use laundry sanitizer and the color catching cloths.
I'm looking for a detergent that's good for sensitive skin but works well with old washers. We have an old washer with agitator. i'm not sure if detergent sheets, powder, or liquid works best for it. help!!!
Tide Clean & Gentle powder, dosed carefully. Honorable mentions to Tide Free & Gentle Odor Refresh, Persil Free & Sensitive and Kirkland Signature Free liquids. Follow the dosing instructions carefully - you have a lot of water in there and your cycles are shorter so you tend to need a little more detergent.
The most important thing for sensitive skin is good rinsing. If you have a softener dispenser on top of the agitator, add a teaspoon or so of citric acid crystals and water to the fill line. Or get a Downy Ball and use the same mixture.
Avoid All Free & Clear in all forms. It’s a crap detergent for the price charged and there is zero magic in it.
Powder detergent is usually the best for old school washing machines
It does not matter what you use. Those washers are work horses!
thank you so much for the tips <3
Just avoid All detergent like Kismai mentioned. It has no enzymes (enzymes are really important for removing stains and smells) and the surfactant sodium cocoate has a tendency to cause build-up.
Edit: I am in the USA but open to anything I can order here :)
I'm ready to try something new again! Basically I just want something that has good cleaning power and bonus points for stain removal. I am quite messy lol. I use a scoop of oxiclean powder with almost every load and of course spot treat. I have arm and hammer oxi pods I use occasionally and I just finished a bottle of Gain spring meadow (or something similar).
But! I cannot stand strong scents, however I like something and not just no scent.
I haven't tried Tide in a while... any one of their products recommended in particular? There are so many. I remember disliking the original scent. Same with Persil, which is a bummer because we always have it stocked at my house.
Try a small box of powder Tide detergent. Just use 2 tablespoons per load and warm water always. It gets stains out and doesn’t leave that much of a heavy scent. Biz Stain remover is better than Oxi Clean in my experience. I’ll add 1 tablespoon to every load. I know you asked for liquid but powder detergent works extremely well.
Charlie's Soap!
It's not really a soap, but it is the finest laundry detergent that I've ever used. It's excellent at cleaning. It doesn't leave any residue behind, and it even removes buildups of residue in your clothes and washer (it's the buildup of residue that can lead to the smelly washer problem). It's safe for the most sensitive skin. Plus, it's scent free.
As you can tell, I love Charlie's! I've been using it for about two decades, and I wouldn't consider using anything else.
For me it's Tide Free & Gentle but you can check this post https://www.reddit.com/r/Reviews/comments/1cazv72/all_the_laundry_detergents_that_you_need/ for more options
Consumer Reports says Tide Stain Release Plus is the best laundry detergent out right now. They do make a free and clear version if you have sensitive skin. But I find if you use the correct amount there isn’t a scent at all after the wash. Also you shouldn’t use a full scoop of oxiclean in the washer. HE machines are only supposed to get up to the 2 line on the scoop.
I don't use a full scoop, I put it to the 1 line. It was just easier to type it out that way:) I'll check out that version of Tide!
tide costco kirkland and persil are some of the best choice imo
About to do some laundry tonight and had the fun thought to start a discussion on it, what’s everyone’s preferred brand??
I personally like Tide since it’s a classic and does it’s job pretty well, and I love the scent!
How about everyone else?
Tide is the best. It does smell amazing.
Many years ago when I was in college I started using Dynamo and used it for years until disappeared. I loved it.
Tide Pods, They're just the right balance between sweet and sour. The after taste is yet to be desired.....
Persil Deep Clean or Intense Fresh. I also add Lysol Sanitizer to some loads.
What are your favorite laundry soaps/powders/sheets? I need something that's effective against stains.
I'm especially looking for low to no scent due to smell sensitivity. Most I've tried that we're "perfume free" left the laundry smell unclean/musty. I can't "freshen it up" with dryer sheets, because those give me an even bigger headache.
I really like those sheet detergents, because they're light to carry and don't take up a lot of storage. However, the ones I tried are not very effective against the food/marker/paint/whatever stains my kids come home from school with.
I got good at removing blood, thanks to all the great advice I got here in a previous post, but that doesn't work on other stains.
Edit: Thanks everyone for all the detailed suggestions! It'll take me a while to work through them. This sub is awesome.
Detergent sheets are often actually ineffective “soap,” not detergent. I’ve not had great luck with them.
Start with a clean machine (run a cleaning cycle with a cleanser). Clean monthly to avoid buildup on the drum.
Pre-treat stains by thoroughly wetting the item, then applying a paste of Tide powder, or a bit of liquid detergent, or a stain stick of your choice.
A lot of folks use way too much detergent; experiment with scaling back. Clothes will be clean, but smell like virtually nothing coming out of the machine. If you’re still getting a lot of detergent smell, do an extra rinse.
NO SOFTENERS, NO DRYER SHEETS. These eventually cause buildup on items and the machine.
I’ve had the best luck with Tide + Oxy (I use powder for environmental and budget reasons).
Make sure not to machine-dry items that were stained, until you are 100% sure the stain is gone. Heat drying will bake them in for good.
Might have been way more than you asked for, but I hope this helps!
Thank you for the thorough instructions! I'll try to follow them.
Yeah I think we have some heat-baked stains that are beyond help. It's more complicated when sharing a laundry room with other people who will just throw your stuff in the dryer on high heat to free up the washer for their stuff. I usually try to do laundry after they're done, but they're not very predictable, lol.
It's not cheap, but I'm a big fan of Tide. It's better on stains and smells than pretty much anything else I've tried. The original formula has a "fresh" scent but to me, it's not that strong. Stay away from the other varieties if you're scent-averse as those scents are stronger. I believe they also make a "free and clear" option.
Also, Dawn (I like the plain blue kind the best) or liquid dish detergent is amazing on stubborn stains, especially stains/oils from food. I use more of it on my laundry than I do on my dishes 😆.
Oh, I've never thought of using dish soap to pretreat stains. I actually have that at home, so I can try it right away, thanks!
Just one little tip: you only want to use just enough to cover the stain. Too much can cause an excess of suds in your machine.
But I will put a little on the stain or stains, let it sit for at least an hour or so, then wash it like normal.
i use All free and clear with oxy and i spot treat any stains with a tide stain remover pre wash
I've tried some stain removers, but they only seem to work when I brush them in vigorously. Trying to find one that works without too much elbow grease.
Sadly I have not found anything that works without elbow grease. On stains that resist blue dawn (oil or the like) grime water can work.
I had the same issue with unscented detergent making the clothes not smell fresh enough. Two things I recommend: 1) run a clean cycle through your washer with an oxyclean washing machine packet. 2) whatever detergent you use, run an extra rinse cycle on every load. I use Tide pods but the extra rinse takes the edge off the scent.
How often do you run the clean cycle?
I'll try the extra rinse next time, thanks!
I run it once a month to keep the musty smell out, and use a splash of vinegar when I wash bath towels/washcloths as it helps prevent any musty smells from coming back.
I have a small container of that, but the instructions say to use it together with normal detergents. I'm trying to find a detergents that works on its own.
best recommendations for washing detergent?
thank you!
Purex Free and Clear
Arm and Hammer Free and Clear Sensitive skin.
I pretty much use anything "free and clear" or "free and gentle". I also make sure everything is unscented.
Molly suds
Free and clear Tide works well for me
So I recently moved to my first apartment and have discovered how freaking expensive laundry detergent is. I have a front loaded washing machine so powders don't really work for me.
I got 64 oz of gain for $6 or so but I think I can get something better. What is your favorite)best laundry detergent that actually works and smells good? Is persil a good brand? What about purex? Both of those looked pretty cheap but I looked online and there was mixed opinions about their efficacy
I've used powder with any kind of washing machine including front loader.
I do as well. Powdered Tide! Can also use a tsp of powdered Tide and hot water to mop floors.
Liquid detergents lose effectiveness after 9-12 months. Powdered detergents are cheaper and good for 3 years or even longer.
I can't advise you on the detergent, but I will tell you that you don't have to wash clothing after every single wear. Underwear, yes please wash those. But the shirt you put on to go to the store for 30 min can go right back on the rack. I have a certain space in my closet for items like this. After a few wears, I'll put them in the laundry and get a new shirt in the rotation.
We use Tide, like someone else said, don’t go by the markings on the cup. I use a max of a couple of tablespoons in my front loader for big loads, less for smaller loads. We found that using too much soap made clothes stiff because it didn’t rinse out well.
I think the detergent companies make the marks on the cups to get you to use more so they sell more!
I got a 64 oz bottle of Tide for about $9 the other day, had coupons and it was on sale. That will last spouse and me 6 months. We don’t wash everything after each wear. Pants, jeans and shorts get many days wear unless we get them dirty. Shirts don’t last as long in summer…most only get one wear, but some get more.
The lines on Tide are pretty accurate in my household, but that’s because clothes get filthy—food, dirt, sweat—and I don’t treat stains and everything washes out. But if you’re someone who just works in an office and your clothes don’t get very dirty, you don’t need much detergent to get out that small bit of soiling.
More like—they test the soap using hard water because it’s part of the testing standard. So if you don’t have hard water, you don’t need the amount stated. It definitely works in the company’s favor because they suggest you use about 2x what you actually need. I find that if I sprinkle in some borax, it helps the surfactants work even better and I need even less detergent.
This! OP check your water hardness. It matters so much. Really good laundry detergent IS formulated to soften most water however i live in north texas. I had to switch laundry detergent back to tide (i chose hygienic clean) because it performs better with our water. I also would check out jeevesny on youtube. He owns a very well known laundromat in new york and provides education & laundry tips. My favorite is that he keeps a long list of laundry detergents he tested rated in performance on a wall and is keeping it updated! Gain is high on the list. If you like gain, but your water is too hard for it to completely clean, you can also add a laundry booster either diy or purchased like oxiclean. I’ve learned so much from him and it got me excited about laundry lol
Powders last longer and clean better. Tire and Tide free and clear consistently win the awards for being the best in class. Like others have said, use less than they ask for.
This powder info is true for dishwashers too- cleans better, and you can use less.
This is also my answer, but I like both the free and clear and scented. Consumer Reports rates it just slightly below Tide. I’m very happy with it. When it goes on sale you can get the 146 load jug for about $14-$15.
I use powder Gain in my front loader, too. Was wondering why OP believes they can’t use powdered detergent in a front loader?
Edit: should also state I don’t use more than 2 tbsp per load. A big box of this stuff from Costco lasts me foreverrrrrr (when they sell the powder).
Tide, although Persil is also good. I prefer the free&clear varieties. Being frugal does not mean buying the cheapest option and detergent is one item where it pays to spend more for better quality.
I searched and haven't seen this topic come up for a few years. I'm wondering what preferences people have for most effective laundry detergent? (We have a front loader, so can't use pods)
Do you need to be using something specific with a front load machine? I use Kirkland powdered detergent and like it just fine.
Greetings from Europe where fronties are the usual - I recommend powder (any) and white vinegar instead of fabric softener. Your machine will live longer =)
I use tide
I use pods with my front loader.. just throw it in the drum. I use Dropps brand and I like them a lot.
I use Tide HE and have for over a decade.
Causes no problems, gets clothes clean, and you can have scented or unscented.
as far as cleaning, scent, intangibles etc.?
I know this thread is a bit dated, but I came across it while doing some research and thought I'd share what I went with.
As far as detergents go, I always buy scent free and I live alone, so don't have as much laundry to clean, so laundry sheets work really well for me. They are like dryer sheets but they fully dissolve in the wash.
Easier to find more of these that are better for the intangibles, like eco and animal friendly, don't take up as much space, etc. Just my preference!
I have seen these, do they clean as well as regular detergent?
Tide and Persil are the 2 top rated detergents. Those 2 are considered the best for stain removal and cleaning power. Gain is typically the next in line but it’s geared towards scent. Kirkland (Costco) rates up there too but I haven’t found it to be as effective as Tide. It works well though and especially if you don’t have heavily stained laundry it’s a good one to choose for a balance of efficacy and cost.
is Tide and Persil tied or is 1 better?
I'm gonna say Tide is a slight bit better, I've been using both Tide Oxi and Persil Oxi back to back for the last 6 months and will just be sticking with Tide now.
I saw another person recommending Mollys suds off of Amazon and I want to say they are great. Very good product.
I only use mollys suds, which are cheaper than tide pods and only have 4 non toxic ingredients. A bunch of papers from 2022 came out about normal detergent with SDS causing allergies, so I decided to move away from standard detergent.
nice, seventh generations and ecos seem to be pretty nice detergents too u shud check them out
best detergent for washing machines
Key Considerations for Choosing the Best Detergent:
Type of Detergent:
HE Compatibility: If you have a high-efficiency (HE) washing machine, ensure the detergent is labeled as HE to avoid excess suds and ensure optimal cleaning.
Stain Removal: Look for detergents with strong stain-fighting capabilities, especially if you frequently deal with tough stains.
Fragrance: Consider whether you prefer scented or unscented options, especially if you have sensitive skin or allergies.
Eco-Friendliness: If sustainability is important to you, look for biodegradable detergents or those with eco-friendly certifications.
Recommendations:
Takeaway: Choose a detergent that fits your washing machine type, addresses your specific cleaning needs, and aligns with your preferences for scent and environmental impact.
Get more comprehensive results summarized by our most cutting edge AI model. Plus deep Youtube search.