TL;DR
Ultimaker Dual Extruders
The Ultimaker S3 and S5 dual extruder printers are noted for their reliability and problem-free operation, particularly when printing with multi-materials rather than just multi-color [1:1]. These models are often recommended for users who prioritize consistent performance.
Sovol SV04
The Sovol SV04 is a dual-extruder printer that has garnered attention. Some users appreciate its functionality [2:3], while others have returned it due to issues such as an out-of-square frame and poor-quality extruders
[2:4]. It's advisable to explore other options and read detailed comparisons before purchasing.
QiDi X-Pro
For those seeking a budget-friendly option, the QiDi X-Pro is praised for being easy to use, maintain, and having good customer support [3:1]. It comes pre-assembled and calibrated, making it suitable for beginners. However, it does have limitations like a smaller build area and manual bed leveling.
Prusa MMU2S
While not a traditional dual-extruder setup, the Prusa MMU2S allows for printing with up to five different materials simultaneously [4:3]. This upgrade kit is compatible with the Prusa i3 MK3S+ and provides a unique multi-material printing experience, though it requires careful handling and tuning.
DIY and Advanced Options
For those interested in DIY or advanced setups, the Voron Tridex offers independent extruders for dual extrusion [5:2]. The Phaetus TaiChi hotend is suggested for creating separate flow paths, although this involves significant engineering and customization
[5:3]. Users should be prepared for potential frustrations and challenges if pursuing custom builds.
I had a very early FlashForge dual extruder printer. (so early, it was made of wood). It was pretty well built and lasted a long time.
But I never actually used the dual extruder capability. Printing in two colors was never worth the extra effort of perfectly leveling two nozzles. Ultimately I removed one extruder (to reduce the weight of the hotend) and used it for spare parts
Maybe it would be more useful now that soluble support material is a thing.
Yeah I have a specific purpose for dual extrude. I’m just wondering how the quality is on the newer ones.
I did not like the creator pro2. loud, slow, their slicer sucks, their pla stuck ok but lots of stringing, other pla wouldn't stick well.
Thank you for the insight!
I have a TenLog Hands 2, it is nice now but I had a bad stepper driver board and that took me a while to figure out. I am still learning a lot in the 3D printing world and my IDEX is making sure of that.
I have experience only with the Ultimaker dual extruder printers (S3/S5), so I cannot really say if they are the “best dual extruder printers” out there. What I can say is that they’ve been reliable and problem-free for my usage (multi-materials, more than multi-color).
I seem to remember that the “3D printing nerd” on YouTube has reviewed a bunch of dual-extruder printers over the years, including FlashForge (https://youtu.be/nKY61V9soVM).
Awesome thank you, I’ll check him out!
Hello everyone. I'm in the market for a new 3D printer, mostly for personal projects, and I'm kind of interested in dual extruder printers for dissolvable supports. Specifically I'm interested in the Sovol SV04, but I wanted to get you guy's opinion on it and the technology in general before actually buying it.
Any input is appreciated. Thank you in advance!!
I have used for dissolvable and multi material. It takes some different understanding when slicing . I'm not familiar with the unit you are considering but would recommend a dual extruder that runs independent. Just easier and less messy.
SV04 is a good machine – I have one and I like it a lot. Check out your other options though – this article compares a lot of these printers.
You can do a lot of the same stuff with the AMS now with Bambu, or there’s the Palettes or MMU for Prusas. You get a lot better quality if you have $5K+ though – for a more prosumer machine like a Raise3D, or even a Voron DIY kit.
I bought an SV04 last year and returned it. The frame was out of square and the extruders were junk. I don’t think there are any inexpensive, dual extruder machines that work very well.
https://www.creality.com/products/cr-x-pro-3d-printer
Anyone tried this?
I don't think you would want to use this with two drastically different types of material, as would be the case with dissolvable supports. Nozzles tend to clog when transitioning between certain materials.
One issue I've had with the Elegoo Neptune 2D(which is basically the same concept), is it kept constantly clogging to the point where I got rid of it, but idk this could be a better version of it.
I have an older Flashforge Creator Pro and my experience with dual extrusion is the idle hot head will ooze while the active hot head is making its layer. I imagine a small amount of ooze is happening at all times but you won't know it on a single extruder because the hot head is always busy. In any case, if you go in thinking "I'm gonna make some cool two-tone prints" you might be disappointed. I've tried printing in black & white PLA and both materials end up catching in the print where they're not supposed to due to said ooze problem. I decided its better to print colors separately and just assemble the final product. Some people might use the 2nd extruder for dissolvable supports, I have not tried that. My experience is basically that in trying to print in two colors at once I end up with degraded quality and a messy print. I wouldn't bother buying another dual extruder in the future.
Did you try adjusting retraction settings?
Also, are you sure you're not overextruding either/both extruders? Easy test:
I'm fairly new to 3d printing, I've been using an ender 3 pro for just around a month now and most of the stuff I make gets destroyed from removing supports, I'm now looking for a dual extruder printer so I can use dissolvable filament to avoid hours and hours of printing going to waste, any good ideally cheaper recommendations for a dual extruder printer?
I'm in the market for the same thing/same reason and so far the best lower-cost options I've found are the FlashForge Creator Max 2, Weedo x40, and JGMaker Artist-D. I'm leaning towards the Creator Max so far, but I'd be interested if you find any better options too.
What stuff do you make, if you dont mind me asking? Maybe there can be somethibg done, to improve the quality of your supports?
It sounds as if the parts are filigrane komplex structures, so maybe a dlp printer might be the better choice for you
A lot of stuff I make is like smaller figures for display, I've tried different support methods and still have small pieces destroyed in the support removal process
So what do you think then about the resin printer idea?
I have and like the QiDi X-Pro. It comes all ready assembled and calibrated for the dual heads.
Pros:
Cons:
I have had mine for over a year and it just works. I have run multiple multi-day prints and it just works. Their support is just about the best I have ever used. They have sliced and test printed files for me when I have had issues getting them to work. They have purchased filament to test print stuff for me and sent me photo proof with the sliced files. I have printed as small as .02 layer height with .4 nozzle, as large as .2 layers with 1.0 nozzle, and at .1 layers with .2 nozzles. Used PLA and PLA+ with PVA and LOTS of two color. It just works.
In full disclosure I am planning to sell the X-Pro soon as I am getting a Prusa w/MMU. Not due to anything with the X-Pro but cause I now know I very much like multi-filament and want to go to more than two. I also have a QiDi X-one2 that I plan to keep (wife thinks 2 printers are more than enough - at one time I had three) as it is quite precise and why not.
There may be cheaper dual-head printers, there may be some with larger print beds but for the money and the support, I think the X-Pro is hard to beat.
I have been researching dual filament 3d printers and they all seem to have problems. Can anyone recommend one that worked right out of the box or are they inherently problematic and in need of upgrades?
I've had an Ender 3 Pro for about two and a half years now, before that I briefly owned an Anycubic Delta printer. While the Delta is faster and (arguably) can do a little better with fine detail, it was a pill when it came to leveling and other mechanical quirks that made me spend more time working on it than printing.
For dual extruder printer i use these printer. From my research I found that printing with support material was crucial and a problem to remove from the part without causing damage. The solution is PVA, or water-soluble 3D printing material. Unfortunately, this requires dule print heads, one that prints the part material, in this case PLA, and one that prints the support material PVA.
The prusia series seems the best for just out of the box printing .
I agree, but dual extruder?
https://shop.prusa3d.com/en/upgrades/183-original-prusa-i3-mmu2s-upgrade-kit-for-mk25-mk3s
>Original Prusa i3 MK3S+ Multi Material 2S is a completely unique consumer option allowing to print with up to 5 different materials simultaneously. The enhanced version 2S (available for MK3S+) is much simpler than original MMU, which makes it easier to use and less sensitive to the quality of filament.>
Its not dual extruder exactly but I think using different filament is the most popular use for dual extruder set up.
If your trying to print two of the same thing at the samentime it might be easier to get two printers
I recently bought a Creatbox Dx triple extruder printer. It has been pretty painless after a few minor hiccups. User support is excellent.
I have a "tenlog tl-d3 pro", although that printer seems to come in about 75 flavors, which are hard to tell apart. 300mm square build plate, true independent dual extruder, with direct extrusion on both toolheads, and TMC2209's on all 7 motors (it has dual motors for Z). Has an edge over the 'filament switcher' systems if you want multiple temperatures, and I've also heard that if you're using different materials (rather than just different colors) you can get adhesion problems if you're sharing a nozzle. It works well if carefully handled and tuned. It's a low temperature deal, can't go above 250 degrees I don't think, although that's enough for my needs. The toolheads are pretty cramped, I'm not sure how much luck you'd have trying to replace the hotends. Usual low price Chinese printer problems, loose bolts, not-very-flat glass bed, requires frequent mechanical tweaking to maintain first layer adhesion. It's a fussy machine, more or less like a Creality. I've been using it for soluble supports, and have been getting results I'm pretty happy with. It can get down to about 0.15mm layers fairly easily. Below that, you'll start getting fine artifacts due to the lack of a geared extruder, but I've taken it down to 0.1mm and it still basically works.
Biggest negative: not much of a user community, and almost no customer support. I can't even get manufacturer firmware for this thing from the web site. But it works, and it's IDEX for less than $600, or at least it was when I bought it. There were two other ones I looked at which seemed very similar. I can't remember the names now.
Thanks.
If you've done much research, I guess you already know that what they can do depends on the type, and they can be expensive if you're looking for a "works out of the box" experience. There are several types, and you need to decide what you want dual extrusion for, determine a budget, and then look around for solutions.
If you already know what you want dual extrusion to do, you can probably ignore the rest of this (lengthy!) comment.
For example idex types have two independant hotends so they can print two things at the same time, usually identical though possibly as mirror images, and certainly can print things in two colours or with different filament types, like soluble supports, but like all other 2-nozzle solutions won't allow colour blending. Idex usually implies a purpose-built printer.
There are 2-in-2-out types with two hotends on a single carriage, good for two colours or soluble supports, where the support filament needs a different hotend temperature from the main filament. You can usually upgrade an existing printer to use a 2-in-2-out hotend, though it will need a board with dual-extruder capability. There isn't usually much in the way of retraction problems with these, but you need to be careful of oozing from the idle nozzle. The Chimera from E3D, and clones, are like this.
There are some non-mixing 2-in-1-out types, even DIY versions on Thingiverse, good for 2 colours or filaments, providing the required temperatures are reasonably close, but they can suffer from clogging because the filament sometimes has to be pulled back a long way out of the nozzle, or you need lot of purge block, for each filament change. But you don't lose any X-axis space, the way you do with other dual extruder solutions.
There are also 2-in-1-out and 3-in-1out mixing hotends, which allow you to mix colours into a single nozzle from multiple extruders. The Cyclops is like this, but it's only useful for filaments that all need the same temperature, doesn't really work for abrupt colour changes or soluble supports, and needs a special nozzle.
An alternate method is to use the MMU2 (or MMU2S) from Prusa, or one of several clones (including a DIY version) which allows the use of several colours, but can be tricky to set up. It doesn't need to be on a Prusa printer, and only uses a single nozzle, but no colour mixing and not so useful for filaments that need significantly different hotend temperatures.
Another reasonably reliable but expensive solution, as an addon to an existing single-extruder printer, is the Palette 2S or Palette 3 from Mosaic Engineering. It's multi-colour but not really multi-material.
Thanks for your input.
Thank you for this summary. Useful and deserves upvotes.
Im working on a huge 3d printer and want to keep the quality at it's highest but with low cost. I was looking a bit around to find the best dual and high speed hotend. I don't want no problems it has to run perfectly but be in a range of 100 and have 2 nozzles so there is no contamination from changing to support material to normal. Any suggestions?
You're looking for.. a single extruder.. with 2 entire hotend flow paths.. that works perfectly..?
Asking that question, in an end-user forum like 3Dprinting, indicates that you shouldn't be trying to attempt this.
You're so far into serious engineering territory that you're not going to have a good outcome.
The closest you're going to get would be something like an Independent Extruder (idex) 3d printer. They have 2 entirely separate extruders.
Since you're looking to do a DIY build, have a look at a Voron variant called Tridex
Designed by an engineer on the Voron Design Team and with a youtube assembly playlist by another Voron team member.
Both of them have said that it's very much "beta" and difficult to design, assemble and tune properly.
If you are not already experienced in building 3d printers (such as Vorons) then look at a commercial Idex printer like the Snapmaker J1S instead.
Thanks. I was also thinking about simply building two dependent triangel lab std hotend but that's kind of blowing the cost. Found some cheap depend ones but they seem pretty low.
What is a good first diy 3d printer design? The Voron guy put in his description that it's not a good first printer, so i'm just wondering what is a good first one cause that would be fun
You want a Phaetus TaiChi hotend and a second extruder stepper. Make sure the board you get has enough stepper drivers for all your stepper, and make sure you set up your firmware to do a little poop off to the side after filament change. You'll also need to retract stepper 1 before loading stepper 2's filament. also something to note, no 3d printer works perfectly everytime. CNC machines crash, have errors, will try to use bad files, ect.
Ignore these guys saying you cant do it, you can if you have experience with diy electronics. It might be frustrating but with enough commitment you could definitely make this happen.
Thanks mate. Im half way done building my machine.
Lmao
I think you might have quite optimistic expectations of what’s possible here, OP. But, I’ll still try to help as best I can.
As someone else in this thread mentioned, the Voron is an option for DIY dual extrusion… but whether this works for what you need is only something you know.
Depending on what printer you have, you might be able to use the AMS, or Palette splicers, or the Prusa MMU. These let you switch colors / filaments, but not in the same way as the ongoing IDEX dual extruders.
This article compares a lot of the dual extruder printers, and multi-filament accessories for multi-color printing – hope this helps!
All, I found a printer evaluation web site that claims that the K2+ combo comes with a dual extruder ! From the Creality web site it is not an obvious ! Can somebody confirms whether the k2+ comes with a dual extruder? If not which printer has it , at good price volume and quality! Thank you
It’s probably just AI picking up something about dual gears in the extruder and deciding that means dual extruders.
Yep, the internet is now thoroughly polluted with AI rubbish
Reminder: Any short links will be auto-removed initially by Reddit, use the original link on your post & comment; For any Creality Product Feedback and Suggestions, fill out the form to help us improve.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
If it had a dual extruder it would be very obvious on the Creality website as a huge selling point, it is a single extruder. Anything around that size is going to cost a good amount more H2D and the pursa would be the closest in size with more than one extruder I believe, both over 2k
Thx indeed this was the reason of this post! Thx for the reference as well - these are the one coming most often out of the search engine. Good day
Sorry if this gets spammed.
I am looking for a multifilament 3d printer. As for price. Let’s say max £2000 but I am not looking to overspent for no reason.
Looking for a nice size let’s say 30cm cube.
But my main focus is ease of use and print quality. I am interested in making 3d not messing with the printer.
I have a massive laser cuter so I’m used to cad and fusion and can make my own files already. I just used the printers in college and want my own now.
Bambu Lab H2D checks all those boxes.
Sovol SV04 is an option.
Its an IDEX, so you have two independantly moving hotends.
You cant mix colors, but you can use two different colors or even materials without having to waste a ton of material while purging.
You can also print two items at once, mirrored or copied, build volume is 30/*30/*40cm, comes with a leveling probe and works fine and reliable if you set it up correctly.
That beeing said, getting both toolheads to perfectly align and everything to be tuned takes some time but its rewarding as hell.
I think also an advantage is that you can switch between different material types more easily, like using both TPU and PLA in a single print.
Costs like 300-400 bucks, the firmware is also a bit tricky.
If you have an engineer mindset think about trying it, if not id definetly stay away from it and go for a bambu printer(though theire more expensive and have other pros/cons)
Having actually read your post properly again, yeah id go for a bambulab. Even though i hate this company because theire closing up their systems, i think for a user like you they might just work best.
Maybe Kobra 3 max?
Though in the EU prices will be pretty damn ass because of the new regulations regarding the US rn... might be a significant factor
Creality's K2 has a 300mm bed size and I've heard good reviews.
If you go 250mm Anycubic Kobra S1 was less than $1000 with their AMS.
Is this the one your on about?
https://www.crealityofficial.co.uk/products/creality-k2-plus-3d-printer
https://uk.anycubic.com/products/kobra-s1-combo?variant=49515364614429
If so is the any "technically optional but not really" add ons for either system I would need to get? Again 0 interest in printers just what the printers can make for me i view these things like a screwdriver.
Not that I'm aware of, they seem to do fairly well out of the box.
I guess if you really want plug and play, the Bambu P1S will do everything very reliably. There are some deeper questions about their software and repairability but most hobbyists won't care.
If you are looking to not overspend, going from a 25cm cube to a 30cm cube basically doubles the price.
Im looking to buy a new printer after I sold my old one that can this time to duel colour on its own and dones't waste much fillament. Do you guys have any type of printers are good? I was looking at the Bambu Lab P1S 3D Printer because I heard alot of good things about it. Though something more like the UltiMaker S5 where it doesn't use much fillament just MUCH cheaper could be nice. Any thoughts on it?
You can have the XL2T that is the XL with only 2 print heads at 2600 - 3150 semi assmbled / assembled.
That is color changing in 5 seconds without purge and minimal prime, often into the infill. Also 360x360x360 build volumne.
I was very lucky to pick up a secondhand flashforge creator 3, I baught it unseen but figured I would fix it if as needed. When it arrived it was practically brand new and has only done 39 hours of printing. But sides for being slow it wastes exceptionally little filament, since all you need are tiny purge towers, and that is basically just to get rid of filament that was cooking in the nozzle while the other nozzle is printing.
But not every person is willing to go for a second hand
I absolutely love my P1S. It does purge filament on color changes, but I haven’t found it to be a huge amount unless I’m changing colors a LOT during a print. It does offer a mode to purge as infill which helps a lot on the waste factor by using the old color as infill where it isn’t visible.
That sounds good with the factoring! I think I might get it or another type, I started now looking into dual heads to not waste much that sounds great hope you have a good time printing!
If you're really looking to get the best consumer grade multi head machine you need to look at the Prusa XL. I have a 5 head and it's an amazing machine. But.... You'll Pay.
Holy thats quite a big price, ill look into something close to it thank you Ill deffinitly check in the future when MAYBE i have money!
Yeah, it's a bit much. I'm lucky to be at a point in life where I can splurge on things like that.
I also have a Bambu X1C and it is quite impressive in it's own right. It's the same kinematic system as the cheaper P1S though so I can say that you would likely not be disappointed at anything a P1S does, except for the filament waste.
I'm waiting on a wondermaker
I'll check it out have fun with it!
I have successfully printed good TPU parts on my Artillery Genius which is not dual extruder tho. What do you need the dual extruder for ?
I’d prefer to be able to use multi colors in my prints, I’m buying a new printer specifically for tpu, dual extruder isn’t going to be a deal breaker it’s just preferred ��
I don’t know if TPU works well with dual extrusion, it tends to string quite a bit. Preferably direct drive extruders are used for flexibles, but if you’re printing slow it should work with nearly any printer. I did some research the last weeks and just ordered my first spool of TPU (95A), I’ll let you know how it works on my bowden-printer :). There’s also some stuff that’s called Varioshore TPU that can foam up while printing to give you softer objects although the material is relatively ridged so it should print nicer.
Ahh ok thank you! I was looking at the Qudi Tech x- pro, from what I gathered it’s direct drive with dual extruders. I’m only hesitant because I don’t want to pour money into something that is becoming outdated
What I can tell for now it’s not as much of a deal printing TPU as I thought. It’s a 95A shore and I’m printing it with the default profile at 25mm/s and 0.15mm layers. Also strings much less than expected.
Sorry for the click-baity title, I'm looking for opinions and accounts of people's experiences around dual vs single drive extruders.
Personally, with standard-issue, cheap Mk8 style extruders, I had problems with PETG getting crushed during repeated retractions, resulting in filament slipping. So I upgraded to a TL cloned Titan and ended up running that for years in both bowden and direct configurations. Never had any filament slipping issues again, even when the clear faceplate cracked due to TL's use of the wrong bearing lubricant. In fact when the Hermera was announced, my first thought was that shortening the filament path made a ton of sense, so I went and bought an Aero heatsink instead of joining the pre-order.
I never ended up installing that heatsink though, because I was given an Hermera as a gift. As expected, the Hermera also works great, with zero slipping and a short filament path for consistent retractions across materials and nozzle diameters. But then again, slipping was never a problem with my Titan, the Aero's filament path is equally as short, and the Aero would have been lighter due to the use of the pancake NEMA 17 instead of the long-body motor.
Nevertheless, ever since Bondtech started to popularize the approach, dual drive has been the focus of the community's interest. So I'm curious to hear accounts of applications where dual-drive is important. If you have stories where dual-drive succeeded where single-drive failed, please post 'em up!
Personally I'm a big fan of dual drive extruders with filament driving gears shaped like a half moon for more gripping surface, makes extrusions very consistant.For me it helped with old, harder filament which I had almost trown away and now prints excellent.
best dual-extruder 3d printer
Key Considerations for Dual-Extruder 3D Printers:
Print Quality: Look for printers that offer high resolution (at least 50 microns) and consistent layer adhesion for better results.
Extruder Design: Consider printers with independent dual extruders (IDEX) for better print quality and reduced risk of oozing, as they can move independently.
Build Volume: Ensure the printer has a sufficient build volume for your projects. Common sizes range from 200x200x200 mm to larger options like 300x300x400 mm.
Material Compatibility: Check if the printer can handle a variety of filament types, including PLA, ABS, PETG, and specialty filaments like flexible or composite materials.
Ease of Use: Look for features like automatic bed leveling, touchscreen interfaces, and good software support to simplify the printing process.
Community and Support: A strong user community and manufacturer support can be invaluable for troubleshooting and finding resources.
Recommendations:
Prusa i3 MK3S+ with Multi-Material Upgrade (MMU): This printer is known for its reliability, excellent print quality, and strong community support. The MMU allows for multi-material printing, making it a great choice for dual-extrusion projects.
Raise3D E2: This printer features an IDEX system, which minimizes oozing and allows for high-quality prints. It also has a decent build volume and is compatible with various materials.
Artillery Sidewinder X1 with Dual Extruder Upgrade: A budget-friendly option that offers good print quality and a large build volume. The dual extruder upgrade can be added for multi-material printing.
Choosing the right dual-extruder 3D printer depends on your specific needs, budget, and the types of projects you plan to undertake.
Get more comprehensive results summarized by our most cutting edge AI model. Plus deep Youtube search.