TL;DR
Drinkmate
The Drinkmate soda maker is highly recommended by several users for its versatility. Unlike some other brands, it allows you to carbonate a variety of liquids beyond just water, such as cocktails and flat beverages [1:4],
[1:8]. However, one user reported issues with the product's durability, mentioning problems with bottle lids and fizz infusers
[3:2].
SodaStream
SodaStream remains a popular choice for many due to its availability and ease of use. Basic models are affordable and can be found on clearance [2:1]. However, some users express concerns about being locked into proprietary CO2 tank refills, which can be more expensive compared to DIY solutions
[1:2].
Aarke
For those looking for a stylish option, Aarke soda makers are praised for their high-end design and ease of use. They are described as looking like a statement piece in the kitchen, with minimal plastic components [1:6].
DIY CO2 Setup
For heavy users or those who want to avoid proprietary CO2 systems, a DIY CO2 setup can be a cost-effective solution. Users have shared guides on how to build your own carbonation system, which can significantly reduce costs over time [1:2],
[5:1]. This approach allows for more control over the level of carbonation and can be used to carbonate a wide range of beverages.
Considerations Beyond the Discussions
When choosing a soda maker, consider factors such as the types of beverages you wish to carbonate, the frequency of use, and whether you prefer a countertop model or a more permanent setup. Additionally, think about the long-term costs associated with CO2 refills and the convenience of the machine's operation and maintenance.
Does anyone have recommendations for a good soda maker? I know of Sodastream but that's about it. I remember Greg from How To Drink commented on one of his videos that he liked another brand (Drink Mate maybe?) better than Sodastream.
Any recommendations are appreciated. I'm looking to mostly just carbonate water for high-balls.
Make your own home co2 setup! I'm still in the research phase myself buy plan on this being one of my winter projects. I want to make high balls, campari sodas, mojitos, and cut out the $5-10/week La Croix bill.
Was initially going to buy a sodastream but I don't like the idea of being locked into proprietary and expensive co2 tank refills. Also many people observe that you can get more highly concentrated and tasty bubbly with your own tank as compared to a retail countertop product.
I plan on following this guideline.
For the same cost as a Soda Stream Bundle, $150ish will get you a much more robust solution. Jeff Morgenthaler lays it out in this post. A tank of CO₂ should last you years.
Drinkmate has the added benefit of being able to carbonate liquids other than water.
I have the Drinkmate and I love it. I'm able to fully carbonate a Tom Collins or a mojito, revive flat Spritzes and beer too. I can also make sparkling negronis, which you should not do because they are too much fun and easy to drink.
Im currently borrowing a friend's sodastream, but I've tried the Drinkmate and it is much nicer to handle and has those advantages you both point out -- I plan to buy it when I get a chance. I understand the suggestion of Morgenthaler's system others are making, but its much easier to handle a countertop model if you have to move. The Drinkmate gets my vote.
Lol mate all soda makers can carbonate ANY liquid
have fun cleaning up your Sodastream afterward
not true… reviews say carbonating juices or other drinks clogs the nozzle and sodastream explicitly lists anything other than water will void the warranty
At the moment I have a Sodastream but this point is getting me to buy a Drinkmate or an Sage the Infizz Fusion. Wondering wich is better.
iSi has a pretty good old fashioned soda bottle that's very convenient to use, but you need to keep those tiny little CO2 whippets stocked ($11.25 for a ten pack), and the bottle will lose a fair amount of its effervescence after a week. best to charge it for a lot of soda drinks in one big batch, like when hosting company or drinking a lot at home.
I have one of those - it's good for the occasional use. Soda stream always seemed so junky in comparison.
All I can say is that this Aarke brand is the BEST. First off, it looks like a statement piece, like a high end appliance, with a finish like a kitchen aid mixer. I got the white color since it goes with everything. There really aren’t any plastic pieces everywhere like the other one’s entire body. To put the gas cylinder in, you just insert it in the hole in the bottom of the unit and screw it in. Super easy. You don’t have to angle it in or something else stupid. The only drawback at all I would say is that the unit isn’t well weighted, not even with the cylinder in. It stands just fine and functions perfectly without having to hold the machine but I just wish there was more of a weighted bottom to be extra sturdy. Finally, the bottle it very chique, not like the other ones at ALL, BUT the other brand of bottles DO FIT PERFECTLY! Pay attention to the expiration dates on the bottle since it could be dangerous otherwise. I would never buy the other one again, ever. The carbonation is even better. Get a few new gas cylinders from the store so you will never run out and you can just exchange the cylinders.
I am looking for a reliable machine that would allow me to make simple highly carbonated water that I can put into ideally glass or steel bottles and take with me.
Any suggestions? I have taken a look at soda stream but been reading issues about reliability of the machine.
Soda stream plus it promotes peace in the Middle East
I have a drink mate and love it
We have the most basic soda stream that was on clearance at wal mart for about $50. It downs do any flavors, just carbonates water and it came with 2 nice glass bottles. For the price I have no complaints!
I changed from sodastream to drinkmate and am extremely unhappy. Since February I’ve had 8 bottle lids need replacing because the silicone seal has come loose, and of the 3 fizz infusers I ordered, 1 is dead, 1 is dying and 1 is playing up. I’m not willing to waste more money on a sub par product. I wish I’d bought the Breville, but for now I’m going to switch back to my sodastream once this canister is empty.
Have you reached out to them for free replacements? That sounds like lemons galore.
And the rubber comes out of the lids so you can wash them and so they do not inhibit and hold onto mold, you wash them and put them back in the cap.
Long time lurker, first time posting.
Saw this article in one of my feeds and thought I'd share.
That Breville sure looks cool.
>Breville sure looks cool.
Yes, it would appear to be a better quality material version of the Omnifizz
Carbonation caps
Or kegs. https://imgur.com/a/tcSpPuP#DTkIeur
I just use soda bottles and carbonation caps. I can put anything in them. No risk of exploding
Universal healthcare? Nah. Omnifizz for all? Yeah!
I changed form Sodastream to DrinkMate and I’m very happy. In general I avoid Breville.
I am a sparkling water heavy user and I love making sparkling water at home. I have tried Sodastream, Sparkel, Dinkmate,Phillips, Aarke, almost every product on the market,however none is perfect.
I think a perfect machine should have the following characteristics:
I have quit my current job and start building a prototype. I plan to launch a product on kickstarter in June. Any soda maker user's opinion we would like to know, which is crucial to the success of our product.
Today update: After hundreds of attempts, I used a venturi tube to increase the solubility of carbon dioxide, and so far I have got sparkling water that is more carbonated than SodaStream!!!
Venturi tube helps creat microbubbles, which increase the solubility dramaticly. Venturi seems to be an alternative path, I will continue to test other methods.
​
I think you have some great ideas but I will say I LOVE that my SodaStream is cordless. I live in a very small house that is very old, the kitchen just doesn't have the electricity outlet to spare. I'm happy to stick my bottle in the fridge to chill. I wouldn't buy your machine with cooling and electric hookup but if you kept it simple I would be a bigger fan.
I used to use the frige to cool the water,but this has two disadvantages:
1st,If I invite friends to my house for a party, I have to put a lot of water in the fridge.
2nd,the frigerator drops water temperature to 32°F,45°F sparkling water tastes the best for me. really hope to build a machine that can adjust the drink temperature.
one more question, if we designed a cool machine, would you put it in the living room or somewhere other than the kitchen?
>I used to use the frige to cool the water,but this has two disadvantages: > >1st,If I invite friends to my house for a party, I have to put a lot of water in the fridge.
This isn't a problem that everyone has, though. For example, Americans are known for big refrigerators. Another thing to consider is a lot of Americans have a second refrigerator and often times this refrigerator is just for beverages: water, soda, beer, and even, extra milk. I'm American so I see this myself but I know other countries don't necessarily have this option.
A few more things to consider, SodaStream is not the least expensive way to have soda or sparkling water and while I would share my soda stream with 1-4 people I am honestly not using it during a larger party. Plus, I don't want to make drinks for people during a party or teach everyone how to use a machine they are unfamiliar with. If I'm having a party I want to relax and enjoy it. Self-serve beverages from a refrigerator or cooler is the way to go in my opinion.
>2nd, the frigerator drops water temperature to 32°F,45°F sparkling water tastes the best for me. really hope to build a machine that can adjust the drink temperature.
The temperature of my refrigerator is variable to specific degrees via a digital display. It's already very easy for me to get the precise temperature I want.
>one more question, if we designed a cool machine, would you put it in the living room or somewhere other than the kitchen?
No. Again, my house is small. The living area is not where I would want to mix beverages. Plus, what if I wanted to put cut citrus fruits or berries in my beverage? Do I make my water in the living area and then take it to the kitchen to finish it? That seems unnecessary.
I really do wish you good luck with your project. I hope you do well. I am sure someone would love it, it simply isn't for me as it is planned.
Yes, exactly. I like the fact that my Sodastream is fully self-contained. I refill my own CO2 tanks with dry ice so it's cheap enough ($20 for a 10+ month supply of CO2). I have an older analog unit with no batteries or power cord. I use a water cooler to dispense cold water and carbonate a 0.5L bottle with only enough for each glass I drink
I'd want something that can highly carbonate on demand, like a soda fountain, but without the ice/bulky equipment/cost. Might be a bit hard to do on the cost side though (Sodastream and others are the low end, and you're talking a thousand plus for the fountains). The cost is probably the part that'll get you.
You are right. In the low-end market, no one can beat sodastream. What I hope is to make better products for heavy users. The price may be a little higher, but the product has more features
Sparkel does it that way
uses a "secret" mixture of citric acid, sodium bicarbonate and maybe an extra acid in the powder.
its slower to use but you can do a high pressure extraction with it, ie put in fresh mint leaves or fruit slices and it squeezes out flavor from those into the water.
Citric acid and Sodium bicarbonate can produce CO2 in a short time and they are cheap and easy to get..
But will that produce enough pressure to achieve that level of carbonation youre after?
I guess the question I would have on that is if it can generate enough to highly carbonate water.
Hey if you are doing a system that relies on base and acid combination can I maybe recommend simplifying the combination chamber system.
The Sparkel system seems to have an issue with powder getting loose up by the inlet and causing a less than perfect seal and sometimes particulates can make it through the pump into the drink.
Not sure, maybe they mean a proprietary one? I’m sure one with a standard connector would be fine to most people.. even soda machines at restaurants have them.
I have a condition called achalasia that soda water makes slightly better. Does anyone have any recommendations? Thanks.
SodaStream with a Sodamod adapter. You just hook up a big CO2 canister that you can refill at any paintball supply store or gas store and you can make sparkling water for like $0.02 per liter.
This is great! Thanks!
I did this (there might be other links out there as well - so do your research):
https://www.popsci.com/diy/article/2012-06/how-make-your-own-home-carbonation-system/
and got what feels like 100s of 3liter bottles of soda out of it over the past 8 or so years... and the CO2 canister is still 80% full ...
so if you are somewhat handy - go for it
bonustrack: I had an emergency situation where I needed an air compressor for a few seconds... that setup did the trick!!!! bonustrack 2: I also started making home-made ginger-ale ... surprisingly easy and tasty ... google that as well ;-)
cheers and best of luck
https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/best-soda-maker/
The one I have, the SodaStream Terra, got a fairly bad review.
They picked the one with exploding bottles. Nice choice. DrinkFizz I heard was like a Hummer, Sodastream like a prius - DrinkFizz wastes CO2 - tons.
I hate to tell you this but Sodastream has had multiple recalls for the same bottle issue over the years.
The Drinkmate is also a lot more efficient on CO2 than Sodastreams. The base way it works inherently uses less CO2 for a given level of carbonation than Sodastream style mechanisms. It's part of the point. And having worked with commercial carbonation, that's a known known. Leaving your pressure vessel sealed, is more CO2 efficient than venting gas through a liquid.
They make better seltzer, and they use less gas to do it. Flat out. I've used both, and other brands too.
It might also be useful to mention and link to the actual product recall on the bottles. That's got useful information.
Rather than just going all tEAm SoDaSTraM
My Terra makes my cold water fizzy and I like it. Everyone has an opinion.
As with many other things in life, there is a difference between one person's opinion and the opinion of experts (or, in this case, people who have actually run head-to-head tests of products in the same category). So, not every opinion has equal weight.
I'm not saying that you should ditch you Terra because it got a bad review; I'm certainly not getting rid of mine. I'm just putting the information out there so that people can make informed decisions.
I'm too invested with SSverse to give up now. Just picked up a SS Revolution and it is dynomite!!! Prices are so low used right now, $20-30 and massive discounted bundle at Costco right now.
I have the Omnifizz and LOVE IT. I had carbonated mulligatawny soup for lunch with a cup of hot steaming carbonated java!
As is the case for many of us, the home theater is never quite done. In the last year or so I’ve added a row of chairs, upgraded my screen and speakers, added a popcorn machine and a candy station.
The next thing that now comes to mind is beverages. Are there “home” style fountain systems available? Anyone here have any experience?
Just a bit of warning— if you don’t clean a soda fountain daily, you’re going to have all kinds of gunk and slime and shit in the nozzles. It’s pretty disgusting.
I used to manage a restaurant, and you wouldn’t believe how much maintenance those things require. You can’t just half-ass clean it.
Thanks for the heads up!
Just buy a mini fridge and stock it with canned and bottled stuff. You can even recycle the empty containers when you’re done.
Other than Sam’s or Costco, I don’t even know where you could buy the syrup in the boxes. I ordered directly from the distributors. Our fountains were hooked up to a huge industrial compressor and it had to be serviced regularly, too.
I rather take a shot out of a bar mat at the end of a shift than get a soda from a gun that gets used a couple of times a month.
I’d look into the pepsi spire. Not 100% if you have to be a business to get it but I think they have a small one which would be good for home use.
I’ll look into it, thanks!
We need more of these questions, lol.
Gotta love the dedication, some people go all in.
I know it's a poor man's version, but I have a sodastream, and it does it for me :)
On a budget and manual carbonation: Fizzi.
You can make it rain, electric, carbonation with an user-friendly button press: Fizzi One Touch.
I am very happy with the Fizzi One Touch.
Genesis for the most fizz. Play for decent fizz & bottle locking mechanism. Fizzi has the bottle locking but also seems to hold back on the fizz because people don't like the loud buzzing. Fountain is cheap, screw in bottle, decent fizz, dirt cheap. Fizz can handle bigger CO2 bottles, as can the Play. There are many pros & cons with the various models.
The cheapest one. They all do the same thing.
Gotta take bottle size into account tho.
I love my sodastream power. Discontinued, bought used on Craigslist. I also make like 4 liters a day lol. Its nice to have the power version
We drink a lot of Diet Coke in my house so we though it would be fun to get a tap just for Diet Coke kinda like this. I’d like it to hook up to the water line and use the bags of syrup restaurants use.
Problem is I can only seem to find multi flavor machines with all the bells and whistles that cost upwards of 4 grand.
Does anyone know of a good system that’s around $1000 or less? I don’t need refrigeration.
You can pick up a two flavor fountain off bevco for less than $400.
Are you talking about this?
I saw that but there’s absolutely no info on how it works, what it comes with what hookups it uses or anything. My guess is this doesn’t come with anything that actually makes the fountain work.
It does. You'll just have to get a hard line run to wherever you place it. But that goes with all fountains. They work like any other system.
I don’t like flavours in my soda water just crisp super bubbly water.
Any recommendations on which machine to go with would be great.
Thanks in advance!!
I just got my first Sodastream, I ordered the terra model bundle that came with 3 quick connect co2 canisters and 1 1L bottle for $116. I’ve made 19 bottles in 5 days lol and I do 4-5 pumps for fizz. I have a 20oz tumblr and the bottle fills it perfectly lol. I like the sharpness of plain fizzy water but have added some lemonade mio flavoring in as well.
I love the Jet. Good seal and doesn't need electricity, which is incredibly useful since I don't have to deal with plugging it in all the time or keeping it out on the counter.
The plastic bottle thing concerned me initially, but it's only me using the device and replacement bottles are cheap on Amazon.
I really like my Fizzi with 20# external tank. I use the half size bottles, which I keep 6 of in the fridge full of cold water. Grab one, pop it in the Fizzi, (occasionally add a packet of True Lime or True Grapefruit), and I'm good. Easy peasy. I like the Fizzi because I use the machine so often the single button push operation is really nice.
I love the true citrus packets! I was able to get a box of 100 each of the orange, lemon, lime and grapefruit for about $6.50 per box from Walmart shipping. Mixing 1 lemon and 1 lime tastes like a super crisp Sprite or 7 up
The 500 packs are like $24 on Amazon if you want to decrease your per pack price even more :)
While there is the plastic expiration thing, I really love my Terra. Got a 5 lb tank for it and drink 3-4 bottles of fizzy water per day. Mostly just water, occasionally I’ll throw some lemon or lime juice in for good measure.
It is the bottle that expires, not the device. You should see a date printed on it.
Yes I’m aware… the point I was making is that the Terra uses plastic bottles.
Old school jet model
best home soda maker
Key Considerations for Choosing a Home Soda Maker:
Carbonation Level Control: Look for models that allow you to adjust the carbonation level to suit your taste preferences.
Ease of Use: Choose a soda maker that is user-friendly, with simple operation and easy-to-fill CO2 canisters.
Syrup Variety: Consider whether the machine is compatible with a wide range of syrups or if it offers a selection of flavors. Some brands allow you to use your own ingredients.
Design and Size: Ensure the soda maker fits well in your kitchen space and matches your aesthetic preferences.
Cost of CO2 Refills: Check the cost and availability of CO2 canisters, as this can affect the long-term cost of using the soda maker.
Cleaning and Maintenance: Look for models that are easy to clean and maintain, with dishwasher-safe parts if possible.
Recommendations:
SodaStream Fizzi: This is one of the most popular options, known for its ease of use, compact design, and ability to customize carbonation levels. It also has a variety of flavored syrups available.
AARKE Carbonator III: If you're looking for a more stylish option, the AARKE Carbonator III has a sleek stainless steel design and is highly durable. It also allows for adjustable carbonation levels.
Drinkmate: This model stands out because it can carbonate not just water, but also juices, tea, and other beverages, giving you more versatility.
Takeaway: The best home soda maker for you will depend on your preferences for design, functionality, and the types of beverages you want to create. If you prioritize versatility, the Drinkmate might be the best choice, while the SodaStream Fizzi is great for straightforward soda-making.
Get more comprehensive results summarized by our most cutting edge AI model. Plus deep Youtube search.