well it deserves it. My favorite game of all time. Does loose a few things from fes like the tone, and also making the characters a bit closer, but I really like it personally. They're both amazing different ways to experience the game now

I always said "If you ever find yourself in a position where you agree with IGN, it's time to reevaluate life".

Wow, guess it's time I reevaluate my life.

It really is a fantastic game!

Persona should be high but Heartgold and SoulSilver being so low is criminal Id even argue it is the best Pokemon game period

7.8/10 too much Tartarus.

Dammit don’t ask me these questions while doing homework

Persona 3

3-Yukari

2-Akihiko

1- Mitsuru

Persona 4

3-Naoki

2-Rise

1- my homie Yosuke

Persona 5

3- Sojiro

2- Sumire

1- Makoto

1 - Nanako

2 - Nanako

3 - Nanako

4 - Shinjiro

5 - Naoto

Kanji, Naoto, and Futaba

Kanji, Aigis, Maruki

FeMC

Da Man

Maya

Tanaka in C tier hurts my soul

The real tier list were the friends we made along the way!

Criminal! Fuuka and Maiko should be top S!

https://preview.redd.it/udaiu9g7hywe1.jpeg?width=720&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=b7ad8820f48b9d7fd14bfbfdd704a361f699ba07

Tanaka in C tier? Alright bro never cook again

3 actually, I don't think he's bad annoying sure but endearing.

If Morgana has supporters, I'm one of them.

If he has only one, it's me.

If he has none, I'm dead.

Design-wise, it's definitely Diego, he looks so damn clean.

In terms of function though, it's probably Lucy, Life Wall is absurdly broken even by third-tier standards.

By design-wise: Hereward

By gameplay: Agnes (edit)

I love love looove Raoul. He is so dapper and I'm a huge sucker for bat motifs.

Makoto's Persona being a god damn Motorcycle will never not be cool, so Agnes

Yuji is 100% within the top 10 by the end of the series, I personally have him in either 5th or 6th place.

For me he’s always gonna be #7 - #5 in the top ten above or below Yuki and Yorozu

I NEVER see a scenario where Maki/Toji > Yuji 😭✌️

Only way I could see it is if you scale MBA, Maki and Toji separately (and glaze them slightly above Yuji like I do), AND scale both Agito and Mahoraga then it can be valid.

It's pretty insane downplay, though I get it. He's a very handsome, kind young man, they hate him cause they ain't him.

Because rankning characters in jjk doesn't actually make sense since mahito violates someone like hakari only to get violated by maki, who are both relative to each other. It's basically character a beats character b and c is stronger than b but loses to a because of a bad matchup. Most people don't realise this though so the ranking is always meh

No his Domain isn't an insta win. IT can be resisted and even Mahito questions if he can oneshot multiple people in Shibuya and Spirit Bodies durability falls off in comparison to the real top tiers in durability and using it gives up his advantage of being able to change his shape on the fly.

Also all Incarnated Sorcerers should be able to damage him with no issue and without his protection of IT he's not nearly as formidable especially given his fighting style assuming he's untouchable, he'll get blindsided at the start

One, removing Gojo and Sukuna is a stupid way to go around things. And two, I'm going to do that anyways.

Takaba

Kenjaku

Yuta

Yuki

Yorozu

Yuji

Geto

Uraume

Toji

Maki

His technique could take any place in the Top 5, yes including number 1. Depending on how you account for conditions, it can be better than Copy (limited to 3 techniques with limited usage unless you include Rika), Limitless (requires Six Eyes), CSM (needs you to be strong enough to tame curses), Ten Shadows (doesn’t have Mahoraga unless you’re Sukuna). I’d probably put it at top 3, but it’s an insane technique

I mean, he was nerfed TBF and Shibuya Yuji ≈ Culling Game's Yuji

Narrator: Aside from Satoru Gojo of course

Why not including those two? Because Mahito would be down to 32nd instead of 30th?

His true form was so durable Yuji couldn’t even damage him with regular punches and needed a max output black flash just to knock him out of it because he was already incredibly weakened not to mention he took a black flash right before his transformation which fucked it up as well.

At 100% health and in his true form he’d be quite a lot stronger than Shibuya Yuji.

Mahito took more damage than Yuji in Shibuya from all the fights, while Yuji being healed 2 times. So it's hard to say about Mahito's stats.

It still amuses me how people often put Ohya in with completely horrible villains. I get it's just opinions. So, whatever. It's just funny how someone who rediscovers her will of exposing scum like Shido is on the same level of people who actively made the lives of others worse. 

Why is Shido not in the “NO” tier?

Mishima is the first confidant/social link I’ve seen where the player actively hates them.

Aside from Yoshizawa, it felt like there was a "push" in some way for most of the female Thieves other than Futaba. It seemed lighter in Ann's case, mostly Ryuji (and kind of Ann herself?) asking how Joker feels about her. Makoto's confidant starts in the red-light district and is based around dating, which was obviously very romance-coded, and Haru's confidant (which I didn't finish) seemed to have her be crushing on Joker from the start. At the very least, she talks about marriage, is curious whether Joker has been in love with someone, and even states that she reconsidered her engagement because of Joker.

Ah that makes sense. I did actually find that whole reveal interesting.

I tend to have really really hot takes. For example, the other characters in my bottom three are Akechi and haru 💀

I guess so yeah. Personally I LOVE makoto so maybe I just didn’t notice since I was picking every flirt line I could anyways lol. I’ve also heard that same sentiment but with Ann instead of makoto.

I do feel like it was pushed like REALLY hard with yoshizawa tho. Like, her metaverse outfit is just jokers but leotard version lmao.

Fair enough, honestly I’m just glad Kasumi, Haru and Futaba are in the “do anything for them” tier because like same

I understand yoshizawa is a fan favorite but I just don’t get why.

For me her personality is annoying but the biggest issue is how hard they push the joker x yoshizawa ship.

What makes you like her? I would love to understand why. (It won’t change my opinion but I’ll be a bit more understanding)

Mishima is the goat dude, having a negative character arc is totally realistic especially for him. He's genuinely in my top 10 of all these games.

Same here. Yuta or Gojo? Nope, Yuji would always be the best choice for the protagonist of jjk.

He is never strong enough to protect anyone around him, he's thrown into chaos time and time again and have to lose something everytime. All he's got are his ideals, using which he faces Sukuna who embodies the logic of jjk's world, and only he reached Sukuna or beat him in the battle of ideals and ended this cycle of cursing each other or took down Mahito (again, ideologically) who was the curse of humanity.

I really liked Yuji's entire thing with Mahito. Yuji and Todo vs Mahito is my favorite fight too.

I’m a member.

In general, Yuta fans I’d say don’t dislike Yuji so much as they dislike how Yuji fans refuse to stop going after Yuta.

I also do.

But like, this is the coldest take known to man. I legit don’t think I’ve met someone who actually dislikes Yuji.

He is built off a the happy and empathic MC trope, but has things that make him different:

-He feels like a real person for one. For example: he has hobbies outside of the main gimmick of the show and even bonds with an important side character over one of them.

-He is genuinely challenged in his beliefs constantly and must reconcile them with reality. The answers he finds are spoilers for an anime discussion thread so I will not go further.

-He has great and varied interactions with almost every important character he shares screen and panel time with. It is never the same style of interaction. Each character we see him with brings out a new side of his personality.

-Power of teamwork/friendship is actually utilized. He doesn’t simply power up because of friends. He actually works together with them.

I view it more as people just think there's so many good characters worthy of being the protag, Yuta and GoJo, that Yuji has to share the spotlight. Havent seen anyone seriously hate yuji tbh.

Yes the manga would’ve been so shitty if Yuta was actually mc😭

Man, 100% with ya. Yuji ain't your typical "damsel-in-distress" shonen MC. Dude's got grit, and ain't afraid to show it.

Nah. A generic shonen MC would be someone like Luffy or Natsu. Yuji is a fairly deep character for a shonen battle manga.

Imo it's Ichiban by a fairly wide margin. Ichiban's ideal life is taking time to help people who have been left behind or abandoned by society because he believes it's never too late in life to work toward your dreams.

Ichiban unironically made me a better person in real life.

to me, it's yagami. he's optimistic but also he understands that sometimes there is no easy answer for the problems at hand. I think both kiryu and ichiban are little too stubborn for my tastes, I enjoy a character who can occasionally just let things go, and yagami has grown through his games to know how to do that. he's vulnerable in a way that I admire as well, I never felt like I had to worry for ichiban or kiryu, but there are parts where yagami felt so realistic as a protagonist that I didn't know if he'd survive or not.

https://preview.redd.it/1vuuskkfq1mf1.jpeg?width=1304&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=245b9c58de6395a94c7d6f1b3ba17cc3af9ac242

Always my goat

Ichiban is my optimistic goat and I wish I had a friend like him in real life

it's not like any of them are particularly great at dating. the love of kiryu's life is his foster sister, ichiban proposed on the first date, akiyama apparently chases girls to other countries... the only ones I feel like would be decent partners are saejima and shinada.

Not even a contest, guy is just an instant classic.

https://preview.redd.it/9hgo21zjx1mf1.jpeg?width=400&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e59548591e297fd7190f0b102f166d461d901c12