Romantic Restaurants in New York

Refine result by

Most Relevant

Most Recent

Most Upvotes

Filter by subreddit

r/FoodNYC

r/NYCbitcheswithtaste

r/Brooklyn

r/manhattan

r/AskNYC

Romantic Restaurants in New York

GigaBrain scanned 399 comments to find you 107 relevant comments from 10 relevant discussions.

Sort

Filter

Sources

Looking for recs for date night with my boyfriend?

r/FoodNYC • 1

Oddly Specific Restaurant Request

r/NYCbitcheswithtaste • 2

Romantic restaurant

r/Brooklyn • 3

View All

7 more

TLDR

Summary

New

Chat with GigaBrain

What Redditors are Saying

Romantic Restaurants in New York

TL;DR

iL Buco for cozy Italian vibes [5:1]
Rolo’s for romantic ambiance near JFK [2:1]
Vinegar Hill House for a perfect Valentine’s Day experience [3:1]

Brooklyn Recommendations

For those looking to dine in Brooklyn, Vinegar Hill House is highly recommended for its fantastic food and service. It's noted as a perfect spot for Valentine's Day [3:1]. Other notable mentions include Colonie on Atlantic Ave, which is praised for its ambiance and proximity to Barclays Center [3:4], and Cecconi in Dumbo for its good atmosphere [5:8].

Manhattan Recommendations

In Manhattan, iL Buco stands out as a quintessential romantic spot with a cozy, warm atmosphere and excellent food [5:1][5:7]. Le Coucou offers a high-end dining experience but may be close to the top of your budget [5:4]. For a unique Italian grotta feel, Bacaro provides a candlelit basement setting that is surprisingly romantic [5:4].

Queens and Surrounding Areas

For those willing to venture into Queens, Park Side offers an old-school NYC vibe with great food [5:2]. Keen's Steakhouse in Manhattan also provides a classic, classy steakhouse experience [5:2], [5:11].

Budget-Friendly Options

If you're looking for options under $100 for two, Ten Bells in Brooklyn offers romantic vibes during their happy hour [1:1]. Rana Fifteen in Park Slope has an awesome tasting menu for $45 each, ideal for grad students on a budget [1:5]. Chinatown is also recommended for its quality-price balance, with Dim Sum Palace being a standout choice [1:7].

Unique Experiences

For a memorable dining experience, consider Rolo’s in Ridgewood, known for its romantic ambiance and proximity to JFK [2:1][2:10]. The Paris Cafe at the TWA Hotel at JFK offers a convenient option if you’re flying out [2:4], though it may not meet cleanliness expectations [2:5].

See less

Helpful

Not helpful

Listen in on a custom audience.

Unlock the full power of Gigabrain to stay updated on topics that matter to you, or gauge community sentiment around your brand and competitors.

Source Threads

POST SUMMARY • [1]

Summarize

Looking for recs for date night with my boyfriend?

Posted by Electrical_Try8941 · in r/FoodNYC · 6 months ago

8 upvotes on reddit

11 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

View Source

ORIGINAL POST

I live in NYC, but my boyfriend is visiting for a few days next week. We do long distance so I'm wondering what some good restaurant recs are? We're both grad students, so something under $100 (splurging because this happens so rarely) would be wonderful, and I'd love if it felt intimate and cozy.

Any cuisine is okay, except I'm currently exhausted with eating Italian/American food. What are some places I should take him to make sure he's had a good experience?

11 replies

mikebassman · 6 months ago

$100 per or for two?

5 upvotes on reddit

Electrical_Try8941 · OP · 6 months ago

Sorry, for two!

3 upvotes on reddit

mikebassman · 6 months ago

Unfortunately you just missed restaurant week.

There are places still doing prix fixe menus, that could be a good bet. cafe alsace is good, and has menus for $40. cafe un deux trois is solid $49 prix fixe but that will run you more like $130 without wine. Sometimes the lunch menu is a better deal.

In the city, an interesting choice would be le relais de venise. $38 salad, steak, and fries, very pleasant atmosphere and service but not cozy. That said, add wine and dessert and you are going to go over $100. El Parador is an old ‘50s era place on east 34th that has the right vibe and could fit the budget.

You could go in the other direction, some atmospheric wine bars, get a few glasses and not much food and keep it under $100. Try Vin Sur Vingt on 7th ave south, or gottino enoteca a block away, or amelie on 8th st.

Otherwise, you can go in the boroughs for a full meal and there are some nicer places - dawa in sunnsyside is a good bet. I hesitate to recommend the great places in flushing as service can be brusque and the atmosphere is not what you are looking for. Same for all the great central and south american.

9 upvotes on reddit

justflipping · 6 months ago

Lots of options out there. Any preferred neighborhoods?

For example, the vibes of Moono are cozy and fit within your price range depending on what you order.

3 upvotes on reddit

Electrical_Try8941 · OP · 6 months ago

Thank you- I just checked Moono out and it looks wonderful. Anything below 50th St would be great, since ideally I would want to spend less time travelling and I live near Clinton Hill, Brooklyn.

Any other Asian recommendations you have? We're both big on Sushi/Ramen/Sichuan style places!

2 upvotes on reddit

justflipping · 6 months ago

Shuya can be a good fit for ramen and sushi. Also cozy vibes. Has one of the best ramens in NYC.

Ariari is cute and fun. You can try multiple dishes.

Mountain House for Sichuan

1 upvotes on reddit

Lazy-Specialist4561 · 6 months ago

Won’t gatekeep this: Rana Fifteen in Park Slope has an awesome tasting menu for $45 each. My girlfriend and I are also grad students so I feel you haha

14 upvotes on reddit

Lazy-Specialist4561 · 6 months ago

Oh also an early-ish dinner at Ten Bells while their happy hour is on! Def romantic vibes there, especially at the Brooklyn location

3 upvotes on reddit

QuesoDelDiablos · 6 months ago

Chinatown. Hard to beat it from a quality/price balance. I’d recommend dim sum palace.

21 upvotes on reddit

Electrical_Try8941 · OP · 6 months ago

Thank you!

3 upvotes on reddit

just_corrayze · 6 months ago

Popeyes. Get those chicken sandwiches. Bring it back to the crib, you set.

9 upvotes on reddit

See 11 replies

r/NYCbitcheswithtaste • [2]

Summarize

Oddly Specific Restaurant Request

Posted by mozzerella-ella-eh · in r/NYCbitcheswithtaste · 5 months ago

Hello fellow BWT! I have a restaurant request that's feeling a bit like an SAT question. My fiance (BWT supporter) and I are looking for a restaurant to have a special dinner on the night we leave for our honeymoon. Here are our requirements / preferences:

We live on the UWS and are flying out of JFK at 11:30PM on a Monday. Would love somewhere remotely on the way (although I'm willing to be flexible on this). We have considered just eating close to home and then leaving for the airport, but we want to try somewhere new and start our celebration on the way to the airport!
As a nervous traveler, I would prefer somewhere in Brooklyn / Queens (I always have a fear that there will be an accident on one of the bridges and we won't be able to cross the river - I know it's irrational).
We will need to have our luggage with us, so no where too small (although we'll be packing light).
We'll also need to be wearing semi-casual clothing. We'll change for our flight at the airport, but not really interested in going somewhere that would require a jacket / cocktail dress.
Would love somewhere vibe-y / romantic. It doesn't need to be super popular, but definitely looking for good food and drinks. We aren't suuuper adventurous eaters, especially not before a long flight.

I've been wanting to go to Four Horsemen and I also saw Misi recommended here, but looking for additional thoughts / recommendations! Thanks in advance!

Edit: thanks for all the recommendations!!!

4 upvotes on reddit

11 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

View Source

11 replies

gingerkiki · 5 months ago

Don’t go anywhere in Brooklyn, that’s a traffic nightmare. Think Harlem/astoria/queens directions. I don’t have a restaurant rec but I know traffic (I often go from UWS to JFK). If it’s international flight you’re gonna wanna arrive at the airport at 8:30-9 ish, which means leaving your restaurant at 8ish. Anything after that and you’re cutting it close in a way that’s not worth it for your honeymoon. I would pick something ideally 30-45 minutes away by car, so you can have a 6:30 booking and feel relaxed.

11 upvotes on reddit

meyers-room-spray · 5 months ago

Williamsburg is no where near on the way to JFK lol for those suggesting.

Rec 1 Sushi - Mikado on Metropolitan Rec 2 Steak - Aged Stakehouse on Austin St Rec 3 Latin - Casa Enrique in LIC Rec 4 Italian - Parkside in Corona

13 upvotes on reddit

FlightAttendantFan · 5 months ago

The Paris Cafe at the TWA Hotel at JFK. If you are able to, consider overnighting at TWA the night before you fly.

19 upvotes on reddit

Apart_Emu8916 · 5 months ago

That place (hotel and restaurant both) are insaneeeeely dirty

5 upvotes on reddit

FlightAttendantFan · 5 months ago

Oh nooooo, are you serious. It was so lovely when it first opened. Such a bummer.

2 upvotes on reddit

chococatcunt · 5 months ago

Eyval

8 upvotes on reddit

Known_Ad4789 · 5 months ago

Four horsemen could work but you’re still in Williamsburg so lots of traffic potential, misi is on the water so same issue, both are really hard to book.

Assuming you want a 8:30 pm seating I’d go for Rolo’s—it’s in ridgewood and super romantic, great cocktails and service. You’ll be super close to JFK!

26 upvotes on reddit

mozzerella-ella-eh · OP · 5 months ago

Thank you!! We’ll add Rolo’s to the list!

2 upvotes on reddit

loratliff · 5 months ago

No way they could do an 8:30 seating and make an 11:30 flight...

10 upvotes on reddit

JudgeNo5087 · 5 months ago

Came here to say Rolo’s!

2 upvotes on reddit

New_Moment_7926 · 5 months ago

Adding another vote for Rolo’s!

2 upvotes on reddit

See 11 replies

r/Brooklyn • [3]

Summarize

Romantic restaurant

Posted by nibul83 · in r/Brooklyn · 3 months ago

Have a concert/ date night scheduled with the wife in September at the Barclays Center. Staying at the Marriot Brooklyn Bridge and going to walk to/from.

Any recommendations for a romantic or nice dinner in the area would be greatly appreciated.

19 upvotes on reddit

10 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

View Source

10 replies

GeneValgene · 3 months ago

Rucola, Colonie, River Deli, La Vara, French Louie

9 upvotes on reddit

RegisterOk2927 · 3 months ago

Gage tollner is walkable and historic, tiki bar upstairs

11 upvotes on reddit

jhb42 · 3 months ago

Good rec. Tiki bar is underselling it though. Very fun if a bit silly fun date experience

6 upvotes on reddit

hova414 · 3 months ago

Beautiful place but not in a very scenic area

1 upvotes on reddit

seeda4708 · 3 months ago

Check out Colonie on Atlantic Ave. maybe a ten minute walk from the hotel

14 upvotes on reddit

Sandlocked · 3 months ago

Came here to say Colonie!

0 upvotes on reddit

nibul83 · OP · 3 months ago

Thank you!

1 upvotes on reddit

United-Dragonfly323 · 3 months ago

Sofreh

14 upvotes on reddit

brownhippie · 3 months ago

I love the food but the ambiance can use some work in the romantic/vibe section. Good for groups/fun diners but not low light romantic vibes

1 upvotes on reddit

mintymeerkat · 3 months ago

Vinegar Hill House! Plus fantastic food and service. Our most recent Valentine’s Day was there and it was just perfect

14 upvotes on reddit

See 10 replies

r/manhattan • [4]

Summarize

Good romantic restaurants to go to in Manhattan?

Posted by seeyouspace__cowboy · in r/manhattan · 4 years ago

My partner and I are visiting Manhattan next week for my birthday and we’re staying in lower Manhattan . What are some good, not too expensive , romantic or just cool restaurants around that area or Manhattan in general? Personally I’m in the mood for either Italian, Korean , pizza or Mexican food but really open to anything .

14 upvotes on reddit

9 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

View Source

9 replies

TinyTornado7 · 4 years ago

The Eataly rooftop is cool. Also City vineyard by the water is great. If you can afford it gramercy tavern is fire

3 upvotes on reddit

seeyouspace__cowboy · OP · 4 years ago

Thank you . I’ll look into them

1 upvotes on reddit

historymaking101 · 4 years ago

What part of lower manhattan? honestly I've compiled lists of dozens of romantic restaurants to take my fiancee to, separate lists for separate parts of the city

4 upvotes on reddit

seeyouspace__cowboy · OP · 4 years ago

Lower east side

2 upvotes on reddit

kort677 · 4 years ago

lower east side is not lower manhattan.

try dirty french in that area

-7 upvotes on reddit

Ok_Goose_771 · 4 years ago

La lanterna di Vittorio...specifically the back patio!

6 upvotes on reddit

seeyouspace__cowboy · OP · 4 years ago

Ooo I like the look of it . It looks beautiful

1 upvotes on reddit

riceonwhite · 4 years ago

Frenchette, Pasquale Jones, Atoboy for Korean,

2 upvotes on reddit

19374729 · 4 years ago

Lupa tasting

2 upvotes on reddit

See 9 replies

r/FoodNYC • [5]

Summarize

Looking for romantic restaurant in Manhattan/Brooklyn

Posted by SaintSexburga · in r/FoodNYC · 7 months ago

Hello! My partner (31M) and I (28F) are visiting NYC from Boston next month (the weekend of Valentine's Day). After a search through this subreddit, we decided that the best option for us on Valentine's Day would be to hit up a pizza joint and go to a Broadway show. From what I've read, it seems like there's a lot of fixed menus/rushed service on actual Valentine's Day and I'm not about that.

That being said, we would like to go on a romantic dinner date on the 15th. I am asking now mainly so I can make a reservation well in advance. We are open to many styles of cuisine except for sushi restaurants. We typically go to Italian places, Mediterranean style restaurants, or steak houses (I don't do seafood but my partner does, and a lot of Italian restaurants often have excellent seafood options for him).

As for setting, we are looking for something intimate but still lively. Ideally, the restaurant is a place we could have a conversation with each other without yelling over the music. I also really enjoy when a restaurant has a nice atmosphere. We are both willing to dress up a bit!

We would like to stay under $200 per person (so under $400 total, tip included). This assumes a drink (maybe 2) for each of us, a split appetizer, and an entree each. I appreciate any and all of your suggestions greatly!

3 upvotes on reddit

12 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

View Source

12 replies

dummonger · 7 months ago

I am going to my favorite restaurant in NYC on Valentine’s Day: Park Side. It’s in Queens though and extremely old school, like walking into a Time Machine of old NYC.

However, if you’re looking for something a little nicer, may I recommend Keen’s? It’s very classy, centrally located and has been great forever.

6 upvotes on reddit

SaintSexburga · OP · 7 months ago

Keen's looks super classy! Park Side looks INCREDIBLE! Both have an old school vibe to them - which I absolutely love. I've noticed some newer restaurants tend to have a very sterile feel and your recs seem very real and lived in. Thank you for the recommendations!!!

2 upvotes on reddit

Tink1024 · 7 months ago

Fellow Bostonian here, we go to NYC a lot and we’ve been to Keen’s it very good & old school steakhouse. Another fave steakhouse is Club A on E 58th. I think it’s a total gem in an old brownstone… :-)

4 upvotes on reddit

Touslesceline · 7 months ago

You'd like Osteria 57, Scarpetta, Le Coucou (might be close to your top budget), La Mercerie, or if you don't mind a bit of a trek Bacaro might beat them all by having an Italian grotta feel by being candlelit in a basement (it's way more romantic than it may sound and the food is exceptional!).

5 upvotes on reddit

SaintSexburga · OP · 7 months ago

My partner and I have been to Scarpetta in Las Vegas! We went there for our first anniversary maybe ~4ish years ago and we loved it. We had a window view overlooking the Bellagio fountain and I felt so chic at the time. It would be really cute to clock in our 5th year together by going to the one in NYC. Osteria 57 looks great as well. Le Coucou looks great, but you are right - close to top of the budget. Bacaro would actually not be too far of a trek for us as we are staying nearby.

3 upvotes on reddit

MustachioBashio · 7 months ago

Le Coucou is not worth its price… food is not bad but my wife and I ate there a few months ago and were surprised it had a star. Cramped seating and a $450 bill for just ok food.

1 upvotes on reddit

Born_Stable5668 · 7 months ago

For romantic Italian I have a soft spot for the original iL Buco. It’s cozy, warm, very small without feeling crowded and the food/service is great. They have specials that aren’t on the menu, every time I’ve gone it’s included a steak if you’re in the mood to split a big piece of beef instead of going to a proper steakhouse.

That being said I haven’t been in a year, and our friend group defaults to alimentari around the corner for a more casual vibe but curious if people come out of the Reddit woodwork to give an opinion on this one.

Editing to add Brooklyn if you are considering exploring:

Bar Bete, La Vara, Vinegar Hill House, Chez Ma Tante

3 upvotes on reddit

samuride · 7 months ago

Il Buco is quintessential oh so chill but cool place and great food! Haven’t been in a while, thanks for reminding me:)

3 upvotes on reddit

SaintSexburga · OP · 7 months ago

Thank you for your suggestions!!! Right now iL Buco is winning for me out of all the suggestions. Between the location, the vibe, and the menu, I am really hoping I can snag a reservation!

1 upvotes on reddit

SaintSexburga · OP · 7 months ago

Wanted to let you know I snagged a reservation for iL Buco! Thanks for the rec!

1 upvotes on reddit

Marianabanana9678 · 7 months ago

Cecconi in Dumbo has a good atmosphere.

3 upvotes on reddit

bobbystills5 · 7 months ago

Go to the Ritz Carlton Nomad, get a drink in the lobby bar, get a snack in the Nubeluz....

3 upvotes on reddit

See 12 replies

r/AskNYC • [6]

Summarize

Romantic Restaurants Recommendations

Posted by Lumpy_Effort_3755 · in r/AskNYC · 3 years ago

Hi everyone, I am travelling to NYC in a couple weeks, it is my girlfriend's birthday and I would like to take her to a restaurant that is romantic, with good food and that does not cost more than $60 per person. I know that it is quite hard to fit those requirements, but if can someone help me, I would be grateful.

Thanks in advance.

2 upvotes on reddit

7 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

View Source

7 replies

CuteWolves · 3 years ago

Check out:

Celestine (DUMBO, Brooklyn)

St. Anselm (sit at the bar) in Williamsburg

The Binc or Henry's End in Brooklyn Heights (rarely packed and you can walk to the Promenade for amazing views after dinner. Also close to FiDi)

1 upvotes on reddit

queenmollykat · 3 years ago

Shalel Lounge on the UWS is one my favorites and fits what you're looking for.

2 upvotes on reddit

Lumpy_Effort_3755 · OP · 3 years ago

Wow looks awesome, a hidden gem from what I have seen! Definitely going to have dinner there on one of the days I am staying in NYC! Thank you!

1 upvotes on reddit

Tilly828282 · 3 years ago

Lil Frankies in the east village, it’s pretty cozy and dimly lit. Cash only, reasonable prices.

2 upvotes on reddit

halfadash6 · 3 years ago

Assuming you drink, look for restaurants that do BYOB—that will be the major roadblock to spending less than $60/person. Eg, Tartine or piccola strada would come in way under budget.

3 upvotes on reddit

IsItABedroom · 3 years ago

The 💖💖💖 Valentine's Megathread 💖💖💖 has a list of places that should be of interest to you and links to similar questions.

5 upvotes on reddit

Lumpy_Effort_3755 · OP · 3 years ago

Thank you! I will take a look at that thread!

1 upvotes on reddit

See 7 replies

r/Brooklyn • [7]

Summarize

Romantic restaurant

Posted by Young_padawan · in r/Brooklyn · 1 year ago

Hi everyone,

I am visiting New York from the Netherlands. I somehow got the luck of meeting this amazing woman and we had an awesome first date on Saturday. Our second date will be having dinner date tonight. I’ve been looking at Google/Maps but I am getting really overwhelmed with all the options available. So I am actually just looking for some personal experience/suggestions.

Sidenote: not a big fish fan and doesn’t have to be haute cuisine

Thanks!!!

62 upvotes on reddit

12 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

View Source

12 replies

hornsly · 1 year ago

Evelina in Fort Greene if either of you like Italian food!

44 upvotes on reddit

boimilk · 1 year ago

I second Evelina - great food and consistent. Also check out Rucola

12 upvotes on reddit

ParlezPerfect · 1 year ago

Try Chez Ma Tante, Glassiere, El Born, or Maman in Greenpoint, easy to get to from W'Burg or Queens.

21 upvotes on reddit

mintjulep3 · 1 year ago

Maman is a casual sandwich/coffee shop - did you mean Madre? Chez ma tante and glasserie are great recs for romantic spots. I’d add Achilles heel and naked dog to that list too if you’re sticking to Greenpoint (which is a great location choice)

14 upvotes on reddit

BrettTheShitmanShart · 1 year ago

In Greenpoint, Achilles Heel and Glasserie are the spots for sure. Oh, and Cafe Mogador in Wmsburg!

4 upvotes on reddit

allisong965 · 1 year ago

Achilles heel and glasserie are perfect for this!

1 upvotes on reddit

kmv787 · 1 year ago

Bamontes if you want some old school Italian American charm vs modern/trendy

Rule of Thirds - really cute space and good food

Achilles Heel - cozy. They have a fire place inside

19 upvotes on reddit

Thecryptsaresafe · 1 year ago

Rule of Thirds is an awesome idea. Maybe it’s not everybody’s idea of a good date but I love a restaurant that has sharing options. I find it really ties you together in a shared sort of activity

9 upvotes on reddit

crzyyy · 1 year ago

I’m here for this NYC love story OP, please keep us posted

54 upvotes on reddit

throwawayzies1234567 · 1 year ago

Celestine

34 upvotes on reddit

Stephreads · 1 year ago

How’d it go?

1 upvotes on reddit

throwawayzies1234567 · 1 year ago

The ferry goes there from Williamsburg, nothing mor e romantic than that

3 upvotes on reddit

See 12 replies

r/FoodNYC • [8]

Summarize

Most romantic Michelin starred restaurant?

Posted by KarlCullinaneLives · in r/FoodNYC · 3 years ago

21 upvotes on reddit

11 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

View Source

11 replies

Ice_Like_Winnipeg · 3 years ago

River Cafe

18 upvotes on reddit

KarlCullinaneLives · OP · 3 years ago

Haven't been there in years. Decades actually. Really incredible view, is the food still good?

2 upvotes on reddit

ChefSuffolk · 3 years ago

Clicked to post this.

The food… I mean, it’s fine these days. But the setting, daaamn.

3 upvotes on reddit

theRealDoctorG · 3 years ago

Agreed. Must have the record for proposals

3 upvotes on reddit

ChefSuffolk · 3 years ago

Saga will probably get a star (it’s still new) given that their sister restaurant (Crown Shy) has one. the ambience and view are something else.

Other places suggested so far are ones I’d be inclined to agree with as well - Kreuther, Coucou, River Cafe (the food is fine, The ambience is magic)

Per Se not so high on but YMMV.

6 upvotes on reddit

KarlCullinaneLives · OP · 3 years ago

Saga looks great! They're pretty booked for the date I want to go but it will be top of my list next time. Edit: thanks for the opinion on the other places as well, it's always a good sign when the same suggestion comes up more than once.

1 upvotes on reddit

CuteWolves · 3 years ago

L'appart. About 5 tables total in this quiet restaurant.

13 upvotes on reddit

KarlCullinaneLives · OP · 3 years ago

They were my first choice! But sadly they are closed for a private event the day I'm looking to book. If you know anything else like it I'm all ears.

3 upvotes on reddit

fluffanuttatech · 3 years ago

So far my favorite romantic one was gabriel kreuther. Went for a dating anniversary, they let us sit in the kitchen table for dessert. Gave us an extra dessert. And food is delicious

8 upvotes on reddit

PostPostMinimalist · 3 years ago

Second this. Could hardly eat the extra dessert because we were so full but everything was great. And it’s relatively ‘cheap’ as far as 2 stars go.

4 upvotes on reddit

watchsnob · 3 years ago

Le Coucou

4 upvotes on reddit

See 11 replies

r/FoodNYC • [9]

Summarize

Recommendations for romantic dinner date in NYC? (up to $100 per person)

Posted by TheHazor · in r/FoodNYC · 5 months ago

Will be visiting NYC soon and I'm looking for a romantic dinner date restaurant. Budget is up to 100 USD per person including tax and tip but the cheaper the better :D We just want to have a romantic date where we can enjoy good food and talk. Do you guys have any recommendations?

Open to trying any cuisine! Thank you!

7 upvotes on reddit

12 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

View Source

12 replies

MadoogsL · 5 months ago

Will you be consuming alcohol? That changes things

Also how romantic do you want it to be or is the good food/atmosphere more of the focus?

I think Maison Pickle is a great date spot!

15 upvotes on reddit

pandemichope · 5 months ago

I’m curious by your question. How do you define a romantic place when you asked how romantic do you want to be or is good food and atmosphere more of the focus? I’m trying to understand the line between atmosphere and romantic (atmosphere?)

when I think of a romantic restaurant New York, I’m picturing a place where the tables are not literally 2 inches next to each other where I can take bread off the next table. Where it’s not super loud and I could hear the person across from me very easily without hearing the conversation of the people at the next table or the next booth. Maybe a booth versus a table. Maybe the lighting would be a little dimmer and not bright neon etc. Maybe candles on the table. How do you define?

1 upvotes on reddit

MadoogsL · 5 months ago

I guess I meant how much do you value the ambiance and the fact that you would feel like you're on a special private date along together versus somewhere that you can have a romantic/memorable time together but the place doesn't feel inherently romantic? Like balancing the vibe of the place, the quality of the food, the ambiance, the experience you'll have. Maybe I just meant atmosphere? I'd describe it similarly to you - more romantic-scaled would be a bit quieter, spaced our tables or personal booths, not too bright maybe even a little dim, candles, probably no kids/families/big friend groups and instead mostly couples.... I guess how romantic do you want the place means to me does the romance happen in the chemistry between sharing an experience together or is a specific ambiance/atmosphere setting the stage an important detail. I do think a lot of it is subjective and dependent on the couple.

-1 upvotes on reddit

newb_1996 · 5 months ago

Bottino. My bf and I had a great date night a couple years ago!

4 upvotes on reddit

Efficient_Hyena_563 · 5 months ago

I ate there last weekend! The wine list and drink list is great. It’s usually crowded enough to be interesting but they can space you so it’s not cafeteria style.

2 upvotes on reddit

GoliathGrouper_0417 · 5 months ago

Mercato on W. 39th St. I learned about it on this sub, and it’s a classic, old school, brick wall Italian trattoria with fantastic food, lovely service, great prices, and the atmosphere you’re seeking. Truly a throwback to an NYC without influencers.

3 upvotes on reddit

MadoogsL · 5 months ago

Maison Pickle should fit your budget then! :) and I think they have decent drinks there. And desserts are good!

6 upvotes on reddit

JuZNyC · 5 months ago

If you're willing to go outside of Manhattan a little bit, my girlfriend and I love Rolo's for a cozy date spot especially if you can get one of the booths.

4 upvotes on reddit

mistadoctorprofessor · 5 months ago

This.

If you can there for a 6pm res you can get the burgers. If not they usually sell out.

For 100 per you’ll have to skip on the ribeye(incredible) but the skirt steak is great also. Don’t skip the polenta bread to start - Calabrian chili one is my fave. Try out the “war potatoes” and the pea greens are a phenomenal veggie side for the steaks

1 upvotes on reddit

Especiallymoist · 5 months ago

La Lanterna is quite cute especially if you reserve that back “garden” area. Lasagna is great, pizza is alright, great wine.

14 upvotes on reddit

664178082 · 5 months ago

Desserts are good too!

1 upvotes on reddit

baldgjsj · 5 months ago

Food was great but I thought it was too loud

1 upvotes on reddit

See 12 replies

r/AskNYC • [10]

Summarize

What’s a nice, upscale but not extravagant, romantic restaurant in NYC?

Posted by Fawkes_tears · in r/AskNYC · 6 years ago

Not picky about the sort of cuisine (I like good meat but I’m also looking for ideas), I’d like for it to cost about or under 200 for a dinner for two, ideally it’d be located in Manhattan or Brooklyn.

119 upvotes on reddit

12 replies

Helpful

Not helpful

View Source

12 replies

Lyin-Don · 6 years ago

If you don’t drink that really opens things up. I’m late to the party so this is gonna be as much for me as you! Love playing this game. Will try not to offer repeats.

WV - LArtusi and Voula. Someone mentioned LArtusi but I’m gonna add it anyway cause it’s that damn good and sounds like just what you’re lookin for

GV - Loring Place and North Square

NoHo - Bohemian and Bond St

NoLita - Peasant and Musket Room

SoHo - Cocotte and La Sirene

Hell’s Kitchen - Gloria and Print

Gramercy - Casa Mono - it’s a Batali restaurant tho :/ and Maialino

East Village - Hearth and Prune

Flatiron - Cosme and Nur

LES - Le Turtle and Contra

Marea on Central Park South is outstanding and can be kept under $200 if you aren’t drinking. Two Michelin stars. Some of the best food in the city. Maybe the best restaurant in New York that doesn’t require a fixed menu

11 upvotes on reddit

pancyman · 6 years ago

Hangawi on 32nd.

Korean food, very lovely atmosphere. Take off your shoes when you enter and sit on pillows. Pre-fixe for 80 a plate but they have individual entrees for 20 dollars.

Does a fantastic job of feeling upscale without totally breaking the bank and the food is some of the best I've ever had despite not being crazy about korean food in general.

40 upvotes on reddit

clementinejuice987 · 6 years ago

ABC Cocina

Mercer Kitchen

Barbounia

41 upvotes on reddit

burningtoad · 6 years ago

Also here to "meh" Mercer Kitchen and Baroubnia. Strongly second Buvette and I Sodi from that other comment, and also want to add Via Carota, which is Tuscan by the same people as Buvette. When I went I cried a little, it was so good.

EDIT: Barbounia is really good, but the vibe doesn't do it for me romantic-wise. I like cozier places.

6 upvotes on reddit

Chrisbradshaw3 · 6 years ago

Great recommendation - love Mercer Kitchen!

3 upvotes on reddit

futurebro · 6 years ago

Not Mercer! It's a beautiful space, but the food is meh for the price. You're paying for hype.

1 upvotes on reddit

foreseeablebananas · 6 years ago

If you're really down for anywhere, I'd recommend the following for romantic atmospheres:

Lucali (Carroll Gardens), gotta get here early to put your name down for a reservation in-person and then hang out at a nearby bar for a bit
Vinegar Hill House (DUMBO), out of the way but A+ atmosphere
Buvette (West Village)
I Sodi (West Village)
Prune (East Village), I don't care for Gabrielle Hamilton as a person but solid food
Compagnie des Vins Surnaturels (Nolita), more of a wine bar but great mood

43 upvotes on reddit

mcfoobar · 6 years ago

+1 Vinegar Hill

Also out in Brooklyn Olmstead and Gristmill.

7 upvotes on reddit

114631 · 6 years ago

Looooove Vinegar Hill House. I went there the night I got engaged.

14 upvotes on reddit

ronindog · 6 years ago

I Sodi is my wives favorite restaurant, and we have celebrated her birthday there for the last 4 years, and will be 5 in a few weeks. Gotta make a reservation! Thanks for reminding me.

2 upvotes on reddit

callmeDNA · 6 years ago

St. Anselm in Williamsburg

13 upvotes on reddit

pancyman · 6 years ago

I have never encountered a problem with this. While they have pillows to set on, the area under the tables dips down so you can sit as if it were a chair rather than kneeling. I'm assuming people with stinky feet just put their feet under the table which mostly masks it?

4 upvotes on reddit

See 12 replies

Top People to Talk to

These are some of the top contributors related to

FoodNYC

NYCbitcheswithtaste

Brooklyn

1+ others

QuesoDelDiablos

No bio available

68874

Karma

Posts

4761

Comments

View Profile

Chat w/ Profile AI

No bio available

457

Karma

Posts

Comments

View Profile

Chat w/ Profile AI

AI Answer

🤖

romantic restaurants in New York

Here are some key considerations for choosing a romantic restaurant in New York:

Ambiance: Look for places with dim lighting, cozy seating, and a warm atmosphere. Soft music can also enhance the romantic vibe.
Cuisine: Consider what type of food you and your partner enjoy. Whether it's Italian, French, or a unique fusion, the cuisine can set the mood.
View: Restaurants with scenic views (like rooftop dining or waterfront locations) can add a special touch to your experience.
Privacy: Opt for restaurants that offer intimate seating arrangements or private booths for a more personal dining experience.
Reservations: Popular romantic spots can get busy, so it's wise to make reservations in advance.

Recommendations:

Le Bernardin: A Michelin-starred French seafood restaurant known for its elegant atmosphere and exquisite dishes.
The River Café: Located under the Brooklyn Bridge, it offers stunning views of the Manhattan skyline and a romantic setting.
One if by Land, Two if by Sea: This historic restaurant in Greenwich Village is famous for its romantic ambiance, complete with candlelit tables and a fireplace.
L'Artusi: An Italian restaurant in the West Village with a modern vibe, known for its delicious pasta and great wine selection.
The Rainbow Room: A classic choice with breathtaking views of the city, perfect for a special occasion.

Choosing any of these spots will likely create a memorable and romantic dining experience!

Still looking for a better answer?

Get more comprehensive results summarized by our most cutting edge AI model. Plus deep Youtube search.

Try Gigabrain Pro for Free

Add to Chrome

Romantic Restaurants in New York

Sources

TLDR

Summary

Chat with GigaBrain

Romantic Restaurants in New York

Listen in on a custom audience.

Source Threads

Summarize

Looking for recs for date night with my boyfriend?

Summarize

Oddly Specific Restaurant Request

Summarize

Romantic restaurant

Summarize

Good romantic restaurants to go to in Manhattan?

Summarize

Looking for romantic restaurant in Manhattan/Brooklyn

Summarize

Romantic Restaurants Recommendations

Summarize

Romantic restaurant

Summarize

Most romantic Michelin starred restaurant?

Summarize

Recommendations for romantic dinner date in NYC? (up to $100 per person)

Summarize

What’s a nice, upscale but not extravagant, romantic restaurant in NYC?

Top People to Talk to

QuesoDelDiablos

Known_Ad4789

Lazy-Specialist4561

mintymeerkat

seeda4708

United-Dragonfly323

FlightAttendantFan

Ok_Goose_771

Related

Places for date night in New York

best theaters in New York for a date

unique date ideas in New York

AI Answer

Still looking for a better answer?

Who are we?

Get API access

Leave us feedback

Contact us

Terms of Use

Privacy Policy

Product Comparisons