Eren Jaeger
Eren Jaeger is a complex character whose psychological profile is deeply explored throughout the series. His traumatic experience witnessing his mother's death instills in him a profound hatred for Titans, which can be seen as a manifestation of PTSD [1]. Eren's inferiority complex is evident when he fails to save Mikasa from the Smiling Titan, reflecting his struggle with self-worth despite possessing immense power
[1:2]. Some analyses suggest that Eren's pursuit of freedom is not entirely his own dream but rather influenced by Armin, indicating an internal conflict between his desires and external influences
[2:1].
Annie Leonhart
Annie Leonhart is another intriguing character whose depth often captivates viewers. Her apparent indifference to the world contrasts with her underlying care and strength, creating a sense of tragic complexity that resonates with fans [3:1]. Annie's interactions with other characters, such as Armin, hint at deeper relationships and emotional connections that enrich her narrative
[4:1]. Despite being underrated compared to other main characters, Annie's role and development are appreciated by those who delve into her character
[5:1].
Character Relationships
The dynamics between characters in Attack on Titan are pivotal to the storyline. The relationship diagram highlights various interactions, such as fear and discipline, which add layers to the characters' personalities and motivations [4:6],
[4:7]. These relationships contribute to the tension and drama within the series, influencing the characters' decisions and growth.
Overall Cast Writing
Attack on Titan's cast is praised for its depth and complexity, especially when compared to other series. While some argue that the main cast is overrated, others believe that side characters like Zeke, Reiner, and Erwin are well-written and deserve more recognition [5:2],
[5:4]. The series' writing quality varies depending on the standard used for comparison, holding up well against battle shounen and even more serious narratives like Monster
[5:7].
In summary, the characters in Attack on Titan are multifaceted, with intricate psychological profiles and relationships that drive the plot forward. Each character brings unique elements to the story, contributing to the series' acclaim and popularity among fans.
Hey y’all. So I’ve been a big fan of attack on titan for awhile. Recently in my psychology class, we have been asked to do a final paper of some sort, must be 8 pages. For my paper, I chose to do a character analysis on Eren Jaeger. In the planning stage right now, I’ve noted that he has PTSD from his moms death which has brought about his hatred for Titans. I’ve also mentioned that he displayed an inferiority complex when he is unable to save Mikasa from the smiling titan. He screams “Damn it, you haven’t changed one bit. Your still as useless as ever” . Now, I’m struggling with that to write for my psychological analysis. Erens character is sooo complex, but for some reason I can’t think of what to write. It can be anything psychologically related, I was just hoping you guys could give me some ideas for my paper.
Edit: I’m all caught up with the manga, OVAs, anything aot related. Don’t be afraid to mention some manga topics
You don't need PTSD to hate titans.
​
He enlisted thinking that he would defeat the titans, he failed in Trost.
He trained the power of Titan to defeat all the titans, he failed in the forest.
​
This power is a great responsibility. And even having this great power, he feels that he has not been able to make a difference, he is in front of the titan who ate his mother and after so many years, training, titan power and experience, but he is unable to save a great friend. He feels that he don't derserve this power because he can't defeat all the enemies.
​
It is not PTSD, it is just frustration.
In addition, Mikasa is always saving him since he is continuously being abducted. He thought he was going to kill all the titans, and after all... he sees how many other people are better than him. Would not you feel inferior?
Soul did a character analysis for Eren on his channel, I think that might help you. It has manga spoilers so you might want to consider that
If you want to do a character analysis of Eren then I think you should pick up the manga. Isayama really brings out best of his character in the later arcs.
I feel like Reiner would be better. A lot more to talk about
Do a search online for metas about Eren. Some folks have written amazing analyses of him.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Great analysis! I agree with everything you said. I was thinking the urge to destruct lies in the unconscious of him. His ego rationalized it into socially acceptable desire such as fighting for justice at first and protecting his friends later. As you said, freedom isn't a dream that comes from himself, it is from Armin. Probably he just interpret or justify this urge to move forward into pursuing freedom. And because his ultimate goal is never freedom itself, he cannot gain it. Since he cannot accept his unconscious, he cannot face it and therefore is controlled by it. He admitted to Armin that he did not know why he did all this, he just wanted to. He cannot recognize his hidden urge so he is helpless when facing his own heart. He can manipulate and change the outside world but he is clueless when it comes to himself. He rejects both himself and this world and is always angry at everything while Armin accept this world, in a sense, he is a child or a teenager who never grow up while Armin is the adult.
You put it beautifully in words, I would even like to add it to my analysis and tag you.
omg thanks! I appreciate that.
I haven’t watched past season 2 so plz no spoilers.
I wanted to talk about Annie as a character. I’ve been reading some threads and it seems like I’m not the only one obsessed with her. Hell I started watching the show based on a clip of her kicking Eren’s ass. And I was like dam she seems p cool.
Idk y I’m in love with her. I can’t stop thinking about her and was wondering if anyone else felt the same way. Why tf do we care so much lmao
If the post is flaired "Season 1" or "Season 2" or doesn't have a flair, do not discuss Season 3 or manga in the comments or in the post.
If the post is flaired "Season 3 Part 1" or "Season 3 Part 2", do not discuss anything manga related.
If you spoil someone, you'll be banned. Depending on the spoiler, the ban could be either temporary or permanent.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
I was thinking maybe it’s the way she seemingly doesn’t care about the world but actually cares a lot. She’s really strong but also kinda delicate in a way. And I guess she’s kind of a tragic character from the looks of it so we want to sympathize and help her... ugh my heartstrings ��
I wonder why cant Armin and Annie be together? They were so close when they were on the ship together.
This is pre final episode. All the information takes place before the rumbling is stopped and during attack fes it was hinted they are in a relationship.
It's talking about how Armin had to go stop the rumbling and Annie was left behind.
"Thinks the other is foolish"
There's something I find weirdly funny about that one of Reiner with the gun. Like it makes him seem cool and give the energy he'll use it for something badass when he only ever uses it to do the thing that created the brain graveyard that is r/okbuddyreiner
The “Fears him” is getting me 😭
I mean I'd be afraid of the guy who forcibly sawed his leg off and gouged his eye out just to blend in better too
But you also gotta put into consideration that he did it knowing he would get them back.
But also I would fear Eren to just not for that reason
"disciplines him strictly" it sounds great.
The main cast (Eren, Mikasa, and Armin) are overrated as hell while the side casts is underrated
>The main cast (Eren, Mikasa, and Armin) are overrated
I don't think I've ever seen even a single praise for Mikasa as a character, how the hell is she overrated?
Just check tiktok, it’s not that hard to see ppl glazing her
Eren i agree (but he’s tbh all in one, underrated, fairly rated and overrated) but how the hell are Mikasa and Armin overrated, Mikasa is constantly getting downplayed and hated to an oblivion and armin ain’t even talked about.
This sub greatly underestimates characters other than Eren. Zeke, Reiner, Erwin, Grisha are all well written characters.
Not really, more of they are underused, but I agree, someone like Floch and Historia are really well written too.
I think that Annie is seriously underrated. Surely, she isn’t best written AoT character, but she is still pretty good character. I hope to write the post about her soon.
Really depends which show/manga etc. Compared to something like battle shounen, it‘s top tier. Compared to Monster it holds up well. Compared to ASOIAF it‘s mid. Really depends on the standard.
Wtf is the image though
He begged me on discord to allow him to post it ;-;
Do we have to get an approval to shitpost now😭😭😭 (this is probably healthy for the sub lmao)
At the very top
With the release of the most recent chapter, which also came with the release of my worries that our favourite heichou might die, it actually had me pondering for the first time about who Zeke, as a person, really was.
Now this was a strange thing I found myself thinking about. I didn't care much about Zeke up until this point of the story, specifically the latest and current arc. And now the latest chapter has shown a moment, which would ultimately lead me to writing this, which humanised Zeke; the glasses.
This man is at death's door, head to toe covered in the nastiest of wounds, and he thinks of Xaver. He thinks of the glasses that were given by him and asks Levi where they are.
Now dont get me wrong, the glasses isn't where I felt bad for Zeke. Remember, he helped turn the entire village of Ragako into a bunch of mindless beasts stuck in some walking purgatory. Instead of killing Zacharias right there and then he let him have a slow and painful death.
Where I did feel bad for Zeke is when after heavy thought I came to this conclusion: He believes that human lives, and quite possibly his as well, are merely weapons; tools, a means to an end.
Zeke was never treated human. His mother and father were never his mother and father. At worst they were emotionally manipulative bastards who used him for their own selfish gain and at best they were generals ordering a soldier around which is still such a highly toxic parent-child relationship it might just end you up on Dr. Phil.
He was told, trained and conditioned that he would rule over the liberated Eldians not because of who he was, Zeke Jaeger the man, but what he was, Zeke Jaeger the tool who so happens to have royal blood.
His own parents materialised his soul to such degree that he could not see the humanity in humans. It helped him develop a mindset that all the means justify the ends, even if those means ended up outweighing the ends in human costs. After all, what even is human to Zeke when he himself isn't one?
And despite how inhumane Zeke is, it is only humane that he is.
In this chapter when Zeke realizes that Levi survived his trap, he rages in a pathetic manner. He screams as he bites into his hand and after transforming he kills a mindless titan out of a blind fit. So here we have screaming, violent outbursts, irrational and spontaneous decision-making, and the typical reaction of someone who doesn't get something his way. And all of this reminded me of how a child would rage in such similiar fashion as well, and it reminded me that Zeke never was a child.
>He screams as he bites into his hand and after transforming he kills a mindless titan out of a blind fit
i thought he killed the titan to throw its organs and brain matter at levi?
It was an impulsive move, not a strategic tactic.
I disagree. Zeke had nothing around to throw at Levi. And Beast's ability is to throw things, so he used what he had available to do that.
Excellent analysis. It just goes to show how Isayama managed to turn what could have been a generic keikaku mastermind villain to a compelling character with flaws.
It's clear that Zeke suffers from "excessive abstractionism." He supports and promotes the abstract, symbolic idea of humanity, the Eldian Empire, etc. He wants to be helpful to nurturing this idea of a peaceful, prosperous society of Eldians. That is genuine.
However, when it comes down to the individual human lives, the ethics and mechanisms of realizing his goals, he is utterly clueless and apathetic. He only sees importance in the whole of humanity, not one human life. To him, there is no sovereignty to be found in individual lives - all lives are nothing more than cogs in the machine, expendable tools for the idea of humanity. After all, what's a couple of cells dying to keep your entire body functioning?
While this logic holds merit if you think about it from a strictly utilitarian point of view, this devotion to the idea and not the human causes Zeke to become callous and ruthless.
His glasses also hid his emotions. Now that they're gone I think we can finally learn what hes thinking
This would make so so much sense. Zeke would transform from one of the most mysterious characters to one of the most human and morally complex ones, like an enhanced version of Severus Snape in Harry Potter.
i absolutely agreed! i think that the people who are upset about him not being some aizen-level mastermind underestimate the fact that his childhood and upbringing were incredibly traumatic. that amount of pressure on a child fucks people up for life. you see those child prodigies online doing all this crazy shit, and those are the kids that end up needing tons of therapy as adults.
it was shocking to see him so angry, because we have rarely seen his emotions. well, in my view i think he has seemed stressed, as if someone (pieck) is always watching him, so he seemed very cautious about his every move and every word. but im not sure if that truly counts as a big obvious emotion. but his anger and frustration in this chapter were so palpable.
and your explanation to how he was always treated as a tool as a kid completely explains why he's such a jarring character -- he speaks of saving humanity yet he doesn't give a fuck about transforming eldians into titans, nor of ripping the head off of a titan that was just seconds ago carrying him to safety.
I finally finished Attack on Titan today — properly, this time.😌
My feelings are different now. Since it’s been a while, I was able to keep some distance from it and view the story more objectively as a whole. I have to say, Isayama truly is a genius when it comes to worldbuilding. If you focus closely on just one character — for me, it was Jean — you’ll notice how meticulously he handles their development. Based on each character’s background and experiences, the things they say and do feel incredibly real. And so many parts of the story hold deep philosophical value. The narrative isn't just confined to the island — it expands into a grander portrayal of war. I really believe Isayama must be a very intelligent person. Yet, he’s also ruthlessly honest with his own characters.
I used to think the Rumbling arc was unbearable, mainly because I was too deeply immersed in the story from Eren’s companions’ perspective. I genuinely felt like he deserved better — there were clearly other ways things could’ve gone. (Maybe that's why Yuki Kaji, his voice actor, also had a hard time letting go.)
But when you stop standing too close to Eren, you realize: this was his choice. He’s such an emotional person that trying to analyze him with logic alone just doesn't work. He’s extremely driven by emotion, which sometimes makes him seem foolish — but he’s not actually that dumb. It’s just that his choices weren’t made from a rational place. To put it simply, he’s like a wild beast, surging forward with raw instinct — born craving blood, needing to feed its young, and therefore destined to consume other lives to survive. That’s his shocking, almost incomprehensible way of living. And in that light, the ending isn’t actually bad at all. None of the characters were ever out of character. I think Isayama had the ending planned from the very beginning — and remembering that, I realized he did say as much.
This series gave me a lot to reflect on, and I really enjoyed watching it.
Of course, that's because we’re the outsiders.
Obviously their situations and circumstances are vastly different, but he was a similar villain protagonist to Light Yagami from Death Note.
Both had an idealised view of what they wanted the world to be like, but were perpetually disappointed when it didn't live up to their expectations.
Though where Light was a pampered boy-genius who was purely driven by his giant ego, and apparently, sheer boredom, Eren had no ego, and seemed to be made to suffer, and his pent up rage from all his hardships led to him killing far more people than Light could ever dream of killing.
Light wanted to be a God who ruled over a perfect world free of corrupt people. Eren just wanted a world like the one he always pictured from childhood, where the few surviving people left were truly free.
Both were opposite extremes: Light an extreme fascist, Eren an extreme anarchist. Both led to their going off the deep end and becoming genocidal, though. Different, but ultimately the same.
Would u believe me if i told you I just watched Death Note for the first time a week or so ago, then decided to come back and finish off AOT.
About a year and a half ago I watched the first 3 seasons, then somehow watched S4 EP29, didn’t understand it and dropped the show. Came back and rewatched S3 and finished S4 just today.
While I agree to your analysis to an extent, Eren was reluctant while carrying out his actions made evident numerous times. Light on the other hand had barely any moments of hesitance, only really having any in S1. His conflict related to him not being caught compared to … I’ll be honest I don’t even know how to define Eren’s. I’m not smart enough nor was I analysing it enough lol, was simply enjoying the masterpiece before me.
It was pretty clear Light was a villain protagonist from the start. Only a couple episodes in and hes calling himself a god and killing innocent people.
Eren on the other hand is an anti-hero protagonist for the first 3/4ths of the series and then straight up switches to antagonist once we get to Marley. I dont think you can justify calling him a protagonist any longer from that point, its just not his role in the story anymore.
Yeah, that's another difference. One more, Light gleefully slaughtered millions while laughing maniacally about it. Eren did all he did reluctantly, and with a heavy heart.
I'd still say he's the protagonist though, as he's still the focal point of the story, just a villainous one who you kinda stop rooting for. Floch would be his Teru Mikumi.
I've been trying to say this for a long time, but every time I bring it up, I get nothing but backlash. There’s such a strong attachment to Eren among fans that they refuse to view the story from any perspective other than his. Yes, I agree — Eren is the main character. But that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t take a step back and look at the bigger picture.
Eren was an extremely emotional character from the very beginning. Almost all of his decisions were driven by his feelings — often impulsive, extreme, and unbalanced. Mikasa and Armin were written as grounding forces in his life, the ones who could offer logic and stability. But Eren was never able to be as calm or rational as they were. He always acted with the highest emotions and the most drastic responses.
I also believe the ending could have gone differently. If Eren hadn’t been so emotional... if he had just listened to Armin and Mikasa a bit more, or even opened up to them honestly about what he was going through... If he had shared the burden instead of carrying it all on his own... maybe things would have played out very differently.
Take that table scene, for example — >!the one with Gabi, Mikasa, and Armin. Eren deliberately said hurtful things just so they would grow distant from him. All because he thought it would make it easier for them to stop him later without guilt. But honestly, that logic just feels so forced and empty to me. LIKE COME ON, EREN. Mikasa literally followed you for years, did everything for you — and now you think a few cruel words will make her feel nothing when it comes time to stop the Rumbling? Really? Same goes for Armin. That entire strategy felt like yet another emotional, last-minute decision disguised as a master plan.!<
But maybe that’s exactly why we’re still talking about him. Because Eren was someone who could never be anything but Eren.
Your analysis of that convo between the three of them literally made me LOL 🤣 Eren’s so clueless about feelings it’s honestly kinda annoying —yet somehow, it also feels kinda kawaii.
Just finished the series. Do to the time travel it seems like Eren tried many different ways to find the best possible outcome for his friends.
Best he could find was 80% of humanity gone and only a couple friends dying before Mikasa would take him out.
He knew he couldn’t live another 4 years so the best thing was to save his friends and provide at least some peace before wars started again.
I don't know why people gloss over this fact. Eren literally said he tried every thing possible and nothing worked. There was no better alternative. The guy literally gives up his life for the sake of his people and he is still the villain, how ?
I do believe eren is a much more compelling character/mc to try to understand/analyze than most other shounen mcs.
And I guess he feels much more interesting to me because the stuff eren does spontaneously, out of emotion, is so far incomprehensible for the normal person to understand, that it will be borderline impossible for readers to self insert. ( People really like to self insert in characters such as Naruto).
In most adventure stories, and specially longer ones, the protagonists tend to be blander so they are a good vehicle to experience the story with. If they were too intense, they wouldn't let the secondaries neither the world shine, and could easily became kinda unbearable after some time.
Also, many of those protagonists are reactive, because the stories they are in want to let other characters shine by taking action first.
One character can reasonably experience not too many character arcs, so when an story arc happens and is no time for the protagonist to jave one, they step a bit aside to let a secondary have it.
Most shonnens follow this, which makes that under a more critic view, other characters shine more than the MC, because is easier to wrap up a tiny and compelling instory in an arc than maintaining the same level during all the series
I dunno Askeladd stole the show for me in season 1. S2 MC is carrying
Your perspective is really interesting! I guess the reason you’re drawn to these kinds of characters might be because you appreciate “realness” — after all, in real life, no one is destined to win, and everyone has some darker, unspeakable parts…
I think choosing not to get too immersed is just one way of watching — a kind of lens that gives you a wider view. It works especially well with plot-heavy or intellectually demanding stories, which can be super fun for those who love to think deeply.
On the other hand, immersive watching is also just another perspective. Its strength lies in emotional resonance — sometimes it helps us reflect on our own lives through the characters, like: “Would I want a life like this?” And in anime, these questions feel a bit safer to explore.
Hahaha, honestly, even when you try to understand someone who's completely different from you — even if they’re just an ordinary person — their worldview can still surprise you in the best way!
-Core Values: Armin values freedom, peace, and understanding between people. He dreams of a world beyond conflict and cherishes his bonds with friends.
-Intentions: His primary goal is to protect his friends and achieve peace, initially for Eldians and later for humanity as a whole. He seeks diplomatic solutions over violence.
-Use of Powers: Armin uses the Colossal Titan’s power sparingly and strategically, such as during the Liberio raid or to stop the Rumbling. He avoids unnecessary destruction and grapples with the moral weight of his actions.
-Favorable Development: Armin evolves from an insecure, self-doubting boy to a confident leader who embraces his role as a peacemaker. His growth is profoundly positive, as he remains committed to hope and diplomacy, even after inheriting Bertolt’s memories and facing existential dilemmas.
-Core Values: Falco is driven by kindness, loyalty, and a desire to protect those he loves, especially Gabi and his comrades.
-Intentions: He aims to end the cycle of hatred between Eldians and Marleyans, hoping to use his power to save others rather than perpetuate war.
-Use of Powers: Falco uses the Jaw Titan to protect allies (e.g., saving Reiner and Porco) and assist in stopping the Rumbling. His actions are defensive and selfless.
-Favorable Development: Falco matures from a naive cadet to a brave, self-sacrificing warrior who embraces his role without losing his compassion. His inherited memories of the flying Titan inspire hope for a better future.
-Core Values: Uri values peace and atonement for Eldia’s sins, believing in self-sacrifice to prevent further oppression.
-Intentions: He seeks to maintain Karl Fritz’s vow of non-aggression, accepting Eldia’s punishment to avoid global conflict, though this perpetuates a flawed status quo.
-Use of Powers: Uri uses the Founding Titan’s power minimally, primarily to maintain the walls and enforce the Reiss family’s pacifist ideology. He avoids abusing his control over memories.
-Favorable Development: Uri’s development is limited, but his friendship with Kenny shows growth in empathy, recognizing the humanity in someone from a vastly different background.
-Core Values: Pieck values loyalty to her comrades and, later, the greater good of humanity. She is pragmatic but compassionate.
-Intentions: Initially loyal to Marley, she shifts to stopping the Rumbling to save the world, prioritizing survival over national allegiance.
-Use of Powers: Pieck uses the Cart Titan’s endurance for reconnaissance, support, and combat, notably aiding the alliance against Eren. Her actions are tactical and non-destructive.
-Favorable Development: Pieck evolves from a loyal Marleyan soldier to a key member of the global alliance, showing openness to working with former enemies for a greater cause.
-Core Values: Ymir’s core value is selflessness, shaped by her traumatic life of slavery and abuse. She seeks freedom and love, even at great personal cost.
-Intentions: Her initial actions as the Founding Titan were coerced by King Fritz, but her later choice to help Eren (and ultimately abandon him) reflects a desire to break free from eternal servitude.
-Use of Powers: Ymir’s powers built the Eldian Empire under duress, causing immense harm. However, her final act—dissolving the Titan powers—frees the world from the curse.
-Favorable Development: Ymir’s arc culminates in profound growth, as she overcomes centuries of enslavement to reclaim her agency and end the Titan cycle.
-Core Values: Kruger values Eldian liberation and justice, driven by vengeance against Marley for his family’s suffering.
-Use of Powers: Kruger uses the Attack Titan decisively, such as destroying Marleyan forces to free Eldian prisoners, but his actions are violent and calculated.
-Favorable Development: Kruger’s development is minimal, as his life is defined by his mission. His empathy for Grisha and willingness to sacrifice himself show some moral depth.
-Core Values: Marcel values loyalty to his comrades and, to an extent, Marley, but shows compassion toward enemies.
-Use of Powers: Marcel’s time as the Jaw Titan is brief, with minimal shown actions before his death. His powers were likely used in Marley’s service.
-Favorable Development: Marcel’s development is limited due to his early death, but his selfless act to protect Reiner suggests potential for positive growth.
-Intentions: She seeks to live for herself after years of suffering, later prioritizing Historia’s safety. Her alliance with Reiner and Bertolt is pragmatic, not ideological.
-Use of Powers: Ymir uses the Jaw Titan to protect herself and Historia, but also aids Reiner and Bertolt, indirectly supporting Marley’s goals.
-Favorable Development: Ymir grows from a cynical survivor to someone willing to sacrifice herself for Historia’s happiness, showing significant positive change.
-Intentions: He begins as a Marleyan loyalist aiming to destroy the “devils” of Paradis, but later seeks to stop the Rumbling and atone for his sins.
-Use of Powers: Reiner’s Armored Titan is used to break Wall Maria, causing mass death, but he later uses it to fight for humanity against Eren.
-Favorable Development: Reiner’s growth is profound, moving from a brainwashed soldier to a guilt-ridden, self-sacrificing hero who seeks redemption.
-Intentions: She aims to maintain the walls and protect Paradis, but her adherence to the vow prevents her from resisting Marley or Grisha.
-Use of Powers: Frieda uses the Founding Titan to manipulate memories and maintain the Reiss status quo, avoiding broader conflict.
-Favorable Development: Frieda’s development is limited, as she remains bound by the vow. Her kindness to Historia shows potential for growth, cut short by her death.
-Intentions: He seeks to end the Eldian cycle of suffering by supporting Zeke’s euthanasia plan, believing it will prevent further pain.
-Use of Powers: Xaver’s Beast Titan actions are minimal, likely used in Marley’s service. His influence on Zeke is more significant than his direct actions.
-Favorable Development: Xaver’s growth is mixed; his bond with Zeke shows empathy, but his support for euthanasia reflects a nihilistic outlook.
-Core Values: Annie values survival and loyalty to her father, with a cynical view of the world’s conflicts.
-Intentions: She aims to complete her mission for Marley to return to her father, later joining the alliance to stop the Rumbling for personal and moral reasons.
-Use of Powers: Annie uses the Female Titan to kill many Scouts during her mission, but later fights to save humanity, showing restraint.
-Favorable Development: Annie grows from a detached, self-serving soldier to someone who confronts her guilt and fights for a greater cause.
-Core Values: Porco values pride and loyalty to Marley, driven by rivalry with Reiner and a sense of duty.
-Intentions: He aims to serve Marley and prove his worth, later sacrificing himself to save Falco and aid the alliance.
-Use of Powers: Porco uses the Jaw Titan in Marley’s wars and the Liberio raid, but his final act is a selfless sacrifice.
-Favorable Development:Porco’s growth is limited but positive, as he overcomes his bitterness to save Falco, showing selflessness.
-Core Values: Lara values her family’s legacy and Marley’s dominance, shaped by the Tybur family’s role as Marley’s shadow rulers.
-Intentions: She aims to protect Marley’s interests and eliminate Eren as a threat during the Liberio raid.
-Use of Powers: Lara uses the War Hammer Titan aggressively against Eren, showcasing its versatility, but her actions serve Marley’s oppressive regime.
-Favorable Development: Lara has no significant development, remaining loyal to her family’s cause until her death.
-Core Values: Bertolt values loyalty to Marley and his comrades, but is emotionally detached due to guilt and trauma.
-Intentions: He seeks to complete his mission to destroy Paradis’ walls, hoping to return home, but lacks strong personal conviction.
-Use of Powers: Bertolt’s Colossal Titan causes massive destruction (e.g., Wall Maria’s fall, Shiganshina’s devastation), with little regard for civilian lives.
-Favorable Development: Bertolt’s development is minimal; he becomes colder over time, with no clear redemption before his death.
-Core Values: Grisha values Eldian freedom and vengeance against Marley, driven by personal loss and nationalist zeal.
-Use of Powers: Grisha uses the Attack Titan to fight Marley and later kills the Reiss family to steal the Founding Titan, causing significant harm.
-Favorable Development: Grisha’s growth is mixed; he regrets his harsh parenting of Zeke but passes a destructive legacy to Eren, showing limited positive change.
-Core Values: Zeke values ending Eldian suffering, shaped by a nihilistic worldview and childhood trauma.
-Intentions: His euthanasia plan aims to sterilize Eldians to prevent future generations, believing it’s a merciful solution to their oppression.
-Use of Powers: Zeke uses the Beast Titan to devastating effect (e.g., Ragako’s transformation, Shiganshina’s massacre), prioritizing his plan over lives.
-Favorable Development: Zeke’s late realization of life’s value through Armin’s influence is redemptive, but too brief to outweigh his earlier actions.
-Core Values: The Reiss patriarch values maintaining the status quo and upholding Karl Fritz’s vow, prioritizing control over change.
-Intentions: He aims to preserve the Reiss family’s rule and the vow of non-aggression, avoiding conflict with Marley at all costs.
-Use of Powers: His use of the Founding Titan is limited to memory manipulation and maintaining the walls, reinforcing a stagnant, oppressive system.
-Favorable Development: He shows no significant growth, remaining rigid in his adherence to the vow.
-Intentions: He seeks to end Eldian dominance by creating the walled Paradis, enforcing a vow of non-aggression, and accepting Marley’s retaliation.
-Use of Powers: Karl uses the Founding Titan to build the walls, manipulate memories, and bind his successors, creating a century of stagnation and suffering.
-Favorable Development: Karl shows no growth, as his ideology is fixed and leads to long-term harm for both Eldians and the world.
-Core Values: Eren values freedom above all, initially for himself and his friends, later for Eldia, but his vision becomes distorted by vengeance and despair.
-Intentions: Eren’s goal evolves from protecting Paradis to initiating the Rumbling to destroy the world outside, believing it’s the only way to secure Eldian freedom.
-Use of Powers: Eren uses his Titan powers to catastrophic effect, unleashing the Rumbling to kill millions, making him responsible for unparalleled destruction.
-Favorable Development: Eren’s arc is tragic; he gains self-awareness of his flaws but chooses a path of destruction, believing it’s inevitable. His development is not favorable, as it leads to genocide.
Final Ranking:
Is this ascending order instead of descending order?
Also shouldn’t the effectiveness and prowess with the Titan powers be more of an important factor in the ranks?
Should the morality of their actions be relevant at all?
I guess it just seems strange to me that it’s a ranking of Titan-Shifters but the actual unique qualities that distinguish Titan-Shifters from everyone else seem to not be central to your choice of criteria.
Finally, it is obviously not an “objective” list.
It’s an interesting list regardless. Not sure which characters I agree with the placement of most and which ones I agree the least with. Having Armin at one end and Eren at the other will surely ruffle some feathers.
I don't understand where some people get the crazy notion that it's possible to moralize "objectively".
🤢
This is absolutely insane. Armin literally committed war crimes when he detonated the equivalent of a vacuum bomb in a civilian port. There was absolutely nothing strategic about it. It was indiscriminate slaughter of soldier and civilian.
An entire series of books could be written on confirmation bias based on nothing more than the interpretations of the AOT fan base.
Armin had to explode the port in order for Paradis to win
And Eren had to activate the Rumbling in order for Paradis to win.
They both hated themselves for what they "had" to do.
Why is Armin getting special treatment? Because he slaughtered "fewer" children?!?
You're free to like whoever you want. But there's absolutely no objectivity in the composition of this list whatsoever.
Armin getting special treatment cuz he killed thousands while his best friend killed millions. Understandable
And Zeke isn't nihilistic. Nihilists don't believe in solutions.
Zeke is an amalgamation of Hitler and all of the Nazi technocrats that orchestrated his sadistic "solutions".
Why is Zeke so much lower than his mentor Xaver? They had pretty much the same goal, and Zeke was unquestionably better at using his Titan powers.
Only after looking Eren as wholistically as possible; one can actually appreciate complexities of character like Gabi and Floch and role they play in the larger interpretable and implied narrative.
only when someone stays with eren even after his "easy-to-latch-onto" motive i.e. revenge gets taken away from him as well from the audience by making him play a part in carla's death and only when someone stay with him after his display of absolute human pathetic-ness amidst in sea of blood one can actually look into more loud and shallow seeming characters like Gabi and Floch
→ Looking Gabi past her annoying qualities; as disregarding someone's issues because of their aesthetic unappealing-ness is ethically wrong and unjust. Gabi has lot of on your face parallels to characters like Eren and Reiner but one thing is different from them and that is that she is good at it, “it” being the killing or the act of killing i.e. combat. Her socioeconomic environment has made her connection to combat similar to a artist’s connection to their artistry. So the hollowness that she experiences while the foundation of her worldview and the whole self gets shaken-ed, especially as a kid is as tragic as almost any other character/element in the show.
→ Looking Floch past his loud qualities; especially in S4 where his opinions start sounding hateful and less thoughtful compared to other characters and more importantly very annoying as he is misbehaving with more beloved members of the cast i.e. Hange. We forget that he too is just a teenager like most of our cast who has seen some very horrible sights just like rest of them. After going through such experiences not only his views about world and evaluation of threat they have at hand got changed drastically but also his perspective of himself. He got to come in face to face to his weakness and his self-diagnosed cowardness .All of this gave him an immense baggage of self-loathing which is quite similar to some other character in our cast i.e. erwin, armin, eren etc. This self loathing plays a key role in floch's behavior and action, even after hearing the story of the other side, he just isn't capable of empathizing with them or he is actively making the choice of not empathizing with them, if even there is a slight chance of him seeing that sight again then he wants make sure that it does happen because he knows his weakness that he won't be able handle it, our world i like this bcz not all people are capable of making such choice, empathy might a an innate quality of human but for it to properly bloom and take shape of compassion such that it doesn't become an excuse for inaction. To cope with all of this as well as the taste of authority over ppl also making his sadistic quality come in light. All of this is him, just like of whom he is a part of SNK (the story), the founder (paths, source of life) and Eren. Create a world where all ppl have the quality of life which includes such compassion Both in there environment, education and parents/peers. The anger of the yeagerist is very valid just focused on wrong ppl and institutions. To fight these institutions you need. The anger is also what just yams was feeling as he also grew up with nationalist and some fascist works. The anger of yeagerist is the one the loudest as well as an ugly manifestation of the ever present "Action/Advancement/Attack" within the context of the story.
Just some scattered thoughts; pardon the typos and Thank you for reading!
Gabi is essentially Eren if he was raised on Marley. Which is why I always liked her and seen the parallels on first watch.
Floch’s character development from szn3 to 4 is drastic but I like it. He finally seen the fighting Jean alluded to that he wasn’t experienced with. He also learned the truth about outside the walls, he went from a wimp that wanted to call it a day to a Yeagerist.
Gabi is closer to being Eren if he actually had character development from learning about the world rather than clinging to his child-like desire to kill everyone outside the walls. Eren would be the same person in Marley, Gabi is significantly better than Eren. She drank the kool-aid of Marley propaganda as a soldier but grew beyond it.
They have a lot in common but if Eren was to grow up in Marley I doubt he would turn out like Gabi. I believe he would be a restorationist like his father. Eren knew that there were people outside of the walls that were good but it wasn’t enough in his eyes to not try and protect the people of Paradis. We saw this during his interaction with the young refugee. Also, I don’t believe the rumbling boiled down to his original desire to kill all titans or anyone that opposed Paradis.
Yeah, although in this post i mean trying to propose that while Eren and Reiner struggle to meet the demands of their environment: Gabi is actually pretty good at meeting those demand. The system make her grow a very sick interconnection to these demands and her 'self', quite to similar to the connection today's youth have with act of 'incentivization' of almost everything in our hyper-capitalistic societies.
Agree. I don't like Floch but I think Gabi and Floch are two best written characters in season 4.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Just letting you know since you did it twice, it's "holistically"
Used that variant in all my write ups to this date... (I am cooked)
Attack on Titan character analysis
Key Considerations for Character Analysis in "Attack on Titan"
Character Development: Examine how characters evolve throughout the series. For instance, Eren Yeager transitions from a passionate youth seeking freedom to a complex figure grappling with moral ambiguity.
Motivations and Goals: Understand what drives each character. For example, Mikasa Ackerman's fierce loyalty to Eren shapes her actions, while Armin Arlert's desire for peace influences his decisions.
Relationships: Analyze the dynamics between characters. The bond between Eren, Mikasa, and Armin is central to the narrative and highlights themes of friendship, sacrifice, and conflict.
Themes and Symbolism: Consider how characters embody larger themes, such as freedom, oppression, and the cycle of violence. Characters like Reiner Braun illustrate the struggle between duty and personal identity.
Moral Complexity: Many characters in "Attack on Titan" face ethical dilemmas. For instance, characters like Zeke Yeager challenge traditional notions of heroism and villainy, prompting viewers to question their own beliefs.
Takeaways:
Recommendation: When analyzing characters, consider their backstories, motivations, and how they reflect the series' overarching themes. This will provide a deeper understanding of the narrative and its moral complexities.
Get more comprehensive results summarized by our most cutting edge AI model. Plus deep Youtube search.