TL;DR
Popular Cycling Options
For cyclists, the Specialized Purist water bottle is a common choice due to its widespread availability and BPA-free status. It's noted that most modern cycling bottles are made from polyethylene or polypropylene, which are generally safe plastics [1:1]
[1:4]. The Bivo stainless steel bottle is another option praised for consistent flow rate and minimal plastic contact
[1:3].
General Use Recommendations
Klean Kanteen stainless steel bottles are highly recommended for their durability and improved taste compared to plastic bottles [5:2]. Hydro Flask bottles are also favored for being dishwasher-safe and having good insulation properties
[4:3]. Both brands offer options that minimize plastic contact, making them suitable for those concerned about leaching chemicals.
Material Considerations
Stainless steel is frequently cited as the healthiest material for water bottles due to its durability and lack of harmful chemical leaching [5:4]
[5:10]. Glass bottles are another excellent choice for minimizing health risks, although they may not be as practical for all situations due to their fragility
[5:9]. While BPA-free plastics are available, concerns remain about other potentially harmful compounds like BPS and phthalates
[5:1]
[5:8].
Additional Options
For those looking for alternatives to plastic, ceramic-coated bottles and copper bottles were mentioned as viable options [3:2]
[3:4]. Titanium bottles are noted for their biocompatibility and lack of interaction with contents, though they are typically heavier and less common in larger sizes
[2:10]
[2:12].
Trying to get healthier and need recommendations for bottles without bpa.
Haven't tried them yet, but I plan to switch to all Bivo soon, especially as the weather gets warmer.
I've been a loyal Specialized Purist user for the past 3+ years, but even when there's no scrubbing of the bottle (which would wear off the silicon dioxide coating), I still get the plasticky taste which I can't imagine is good (it's admittedly unscientific but I have a hard time understanding how that happens without some organic / aromatic compounds ending up in my water).
I've been using Tritan bottles that happen to fit in my bottle cages as a 2nd bottle for sports drinks / hydration mixes (+ versatility to refill with literally any beverage at longer stops), since they're easier to clean + don't have the plastic taste. However, as I've done more research on microplastics, it seems like the science out there is pretty murky -- there seems to be way too much involvement by manufacturers' PR firms for me to be comfortable about the possibility that it's as bad or worse than BPA in its estrogenic effects.
It's kind of sad how hard it is to get certainty on all of this but I'm glad there's at least one company out there trying to make a product that addresses these concerns.
Bivo.
My LBS has sold these for years because I think the company is local. They are getting around everywhere now though. Takes a minute to get used to but I like it a lot. The flow rate is consistent no matter how full/empty the bottle is. No more blasting skratch directly into my lungs.
Don't get the raw metal one (if they still even sell it). It looks cool but rattles in bottle cages.
Don't get the raw metal one (if they still even sell it). It looks cool but rattles in bottle cages.
Do you know if they'd rattle in plastic/carbon cages, or is it more of an issue with metal cages?
Grabbed a few of these about a year ago and love them! Very easy to clean and no problems with fitting then into cages.
Anything that is polyethylene or polypropylene and marketed for food/beverage contact will probably be pretty safe. These plastics typically don't contain plasticizers and are quite chemically inert. This is what most cycling water bottles are made out of these days. Look for recycling codes 4 and 5 (LDPE and PP, respectively).
I have a camelback podium that's insulated. It works pretty well and I've used it for 6 years. Can lock the spout closed and it does a good job keeping water cold. The lid does comes apart so it can be thoroughly cleaned. Fits very well in every cage I've used.
These are great bottles.
Specialized purist for me. I've used carious CamelBak podiums but they're an absolute nightmare to clean.
Really ?
Never had a problem and I've had mine for years. Rinse when you finish your ride and wash them then or rinse and leave in the dish washer.
They are over designed though - lots of bumph in the lid that means you can never drink the full bottle.
Yep.
I use an electrolyte mix that ends up building up mould in the bits that you can't really get to. Also - when I put mine through the dishwasher on a gentle cycle (not crazy heat) one of the lids then started to leak.
Maybe I just had a bad batch!
What’s so specialized about the specialized purist and are they purist insulated ?
Probably 80% of the water bottles you come across, with whatever logo or design they've got splashed on it, is a Specialized Purist. They're definitely BPA free. I'd be shocked if you found a bike bottle made in the last ten years that wasn't. The entire industry of outdoor water bottles moved on a long while back.
If you're concerned about plastics in general, I know Bivo makes a stainless steel bottle with just a little bit of plastic for the lid and straw that fits in normal cages and is supposed to be pretty great, but I haven't bought one yet.
I'm seeing a lot of smartwater bottles out on the trail these days, but I'd rather not be drinking from a bottle that contains BPA. Do you guys have any favorite BPA-free alternatives?
They may be BPA free but that doesn't mean they don't leach other hormone disrupting chemicals. https://www.abc.net.au/science/articles/2009/04/29/2555698.htm If you are looking for a truly inert vessel for water glass is probably your only choice. Other than that it's choose the lesser of many evils.
I have a metal bottle that weighs 5oz and BPA free. Heavier than a smartwater, but more durable and water stays clean and tasty.
klean kanteen?
No, those are actually too heavy. I don't remember the brand, but it has more of a bottle shape with a slender neck than the cylinder shape of the Kleen Kanteen. It has a metal cap too, but the inner seal is better and not stainless steel as on the KK.
They're supposedly BPA free.
Oh, awesome! Wasn’t seeing them on lists of BPA-free bottles, but this is good to hear. Thanks!
My understanding is only polycarbonate bottles used BPA, these were the original nalgenes, the new ones use a different plastic. The "disposible" water bottles are made of PET (a type of polyester) and never contained BPA. They may have other leachables or catalysts that could be problematic but I haven't read anything conclusive like BPA.
ps. I have a PhD in materials science but don't work on polymers
See NOsquids answer above. They are regular PET(Polyethylene Terephthalate) bottles that contain no BPA.
I thought most water bottles were BPA free now days (since that all blew up in the media), and the only worry was BPB and other compounds that are leeching?
Titanium water bottles are great. Not many lightweight options available in 1 liter+ sizes though.
If it doesn't have some coating/lining-epoxy or plastic and is made from a pure titanium I would say yes.
It is, yes. Non-alloyed titanium is the most biocompatible metal available. Nothing leaches or interacts with what it contains. I haven't seen any coated titanium so you should be okay with any you find. They all come from one of three factories/companies anyway.
Hey all, I’m looking to get away from drinking so much water from plastic bottles. I recently purchased an Aquatru Reverse Osmosis system and was looking for a good reusable stainless steel water bottle. If found a few on Amazon (Stanley, Yeti, Coolflask) but the lids and or straw the water will come in contact are made out of plastic. The Stanley specifically says it is BPA/BPS free and “made from Polypropylene and is a type 7 plastic” …. Is that safe ? I keep seeing conflicting information on this. Any clarification or recommendations are appreciated!
I use a copper water bottle.
If it makes you feel better awesome for you. There is no evidence any of the EDCs found in plastics are bioactive in humans, they are certainly a problem for fish and birds (good enough reason to avoid them) but like phytoestrogens looking similar to doesn't mean they actually do anything to receptors in the human body. We have been living with them for so long now (about 150 years) negative health effects are certainly small or they would be detectable.
It's probable a small number are bioactive. It's unlikely we will know in the foreseeable future which ones; modeling of proteins is simply not advanced enough to even point in the direction of the more likely candidates.
All plastics leech EDCs. More thermally stable plastics do so less when heated. Reducing your plastic (particularly single use) usage is awesome ecologically and should absolutely be encouraged, the amount you can actually manage your exposure to EDCs and microplastics is nearly zero so it shouldn't be something that gives you anxiety. They are in all food, air and water. We are talking about potential health effects that are lower from nearly anything you will see suggested from any nutrition & health body. There are real meaningful changes that can optimize your nutrition & health, focus your brain on those things.
Reverse Osmosis system
You do you, anyone reading tap water is fine. If you don't like the taste, get a fridge or under sink cartridge filter (Brita etc).
Stainless steel, ceramic coated, glass
Discussion in this subreddit should be rooted in science rather than "cuz I sed" or entertainment pieces. Always be wary of unsupported and poorly supported claims and especially those which are wrapped in any manner of hostility. You should provide peer reviewed sources to support your claims when debating and confine that debate to the science, not opinions of other people.
Good - it is grounded in science and includes citation of peer reviewed sources. Debate is a civil and respectful exchange focusing on actual science and avoids commentary about others
Bad - it utilizes generalizations, assumptions, infotainment sources, no sources, or complaints without specifics about agenda, bias, or funding. At best, these rise to an extremely weak basis for science based discussion. Also, off topic discussion
Ugly - (removal or ban territory) it involves attacks / antagonism / hostility towards individuals or groups, downvote complaining, trolling, crusading, shaming, refutation of all science, or claims that all research / science is a conspiracy
Please vote accordingly and report any uglies
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
I got a under sink 5-year water filter off Amazon and a couple stainless steel bottles from Costco, simple and effective.
I want to know a water bottle that is mold proof, no plastic (BPA free) and dish washable. Thanks!
if you want spill proof, it’s gonna have a gasket and even tho most of it is ok for the dishwasher, you have to thoroughly hand clean those pieces and mouth pieces…. things won’t mold so long as they’re washed properly. Kleen lantern and hydro flask or lowest maintenance but I do prefer owala.
The new hydroflasks are dishwasher safe.
You still need to pull the gasket from the lid occasionally, but if you only use the bottle for water and let everything air dry after a run through the dishwasher, not very often.
I like my owala! It has a straw and keeps ice for over 24 hours even when sitting in the sun
you can get a metal straw too.
I love my yeti, but I also love my water to be cold and it keeps ice well.
I got borosilicate glass straws for mine, so no plastic touches my water!
Nalgene.
Hi! Can you please tell me which is safer for health, if a Plastic (BPA-Free), Aluminium or Stainless Steel water bottle or if are all ok?
I heard that Stainless Steel are the best if it has to stay under the sun, but I need a water bottle to keep in my backpack, plastic ones are obv lighter, but I don't know if are ok for the health
Can you help me?
Thanks!
Stainless steel is the healthiest of the three. They're not very heavy either.
BPA isn't the only harmful thing leeching from plastics.
I've recently replaced my old plastic bottle with a Klean Kanteen stainless steel single wall bottle, and I will never look back. It's surprisingly light, fits a little more water than my old one with pretty much the same height and the taste of the water is just so much better!
Plus they don’t just take out the BPA, it serves a purpose and the plastic wouldn’t function the same without it (I think it makes it more flexible). Instead, they just use a similar compound that is chemically different enough that they can SAY it is not BPA, but still will have the same effect. In the US, companies don’t have to prove that a chemical is safe before they use it, it is on consumers and consumer advocates to prove something is harmful after the fact. So theoretically, the new chemical might be just as bad or worse than whatever is being replaced.
Pthalates are another harmful substance coming from plastic. They never get as much attention as BPA, but were identified a long time ago.
BPA has been replaced by almost the exact same chemical, BPS and is causing the exact same health problems.
BPA-free is pretty much a meaningless description.
Any recommendations for a glass water bottle?
Stainless.
Yeah I love my stainless but I also love my plastic naglene. I think when one eventually breaks, likely the naglene that I won't get another plastic bottle. I think I'd get a stainless naglene as the stainless bottle I have doesn't have the best lid and has a rubber washer that is almost impossible to remove and clean. Not to mention it will decay.
Good lord... You misspelled Nalgene thrice!
Glass is the best option in terms of potential health toxicity.
What about silicone?
Stainless steel. I use Stanley but it’s up to you! Plus durability, stainless steel will handle drops and dings. I have a old one and it’s so beat up but it tells a story
So I'm wanting to purchase a new water bottle. I always would buy cheap ones say like Hydrapeak ones from like TJ Maxx or Ross.
However I'm needing a very good water bottle that will keep water cold (40oz or higher) and that it won't have these little plastic thingies that most water bottles have on the inside. The reason being it's so annoying to clean/hand wash them and they mold at times (though I do my best to wash my bottle everyday). But the other issue is I just struggle to remove the plastic/silicone and then put it back on.
My other thing is I hate straws. So a Stanley is an absolute no. (Also not a fan of the handle).
So any suggestions for a good 40 oz (or higher) bottle that's easy to clean and keeps water cold?
I personally love my Owala. It has a straw on the inside, but it’s not like a Stanley straw. You can sip using the mouth piece and the straw or just drink out of it like a water bottle with no straw. The silicone pieces on the top are easily removable for cleaning.
I keep seeing that, thank you for the recommendation! I wasn't sure if it could be without the straw or not and if the silicone was hard to remove! Do you have the freesip or freeswip sway? (Trying to learn which one is which since I noticed they have different ones)
I also do not like straws but love my owalla. I've had mine for 3 years. I've replaced the lid a couple times (kids under 10) but its my favorite water bottle
We have a couple FreeSips - Note there are two pieces of silicone in the lid. There's the molded insert that seals the mouthpiece, which is very easy to pop out, can just pinch and pull the tab on one end. There's also the circular o-ring type gasket that seals the screw top, which is trickier to get out just because it's down in a groove. I use a blunt (so it doesn't damage the silicone) dental pick to hook around under it, but you can get it with a toothpick or similar. That o-ring doesn't get gross as fast since your mouth isn't on it, though, so I only have to pull it out every few months. Less often if you're just putting water in thebottle, more often if you're putting things like coffee or soda.
The Spin looks like the o-ring is more external so might be easier to pull off, can't tell about the mouthpiece deal.
Obsessed with my Owala. It's the best water bottle I've ever owned.
Klean kanteen is great
+1 for Kleen Kanteen. Had mine since 2011 and it's still chugging along (pun intended).
Honestly, I hate my klean kanteen. The bottom is kinda rounded, so if you bump it - it tips over easily. The “normal” lid on it has an air relief hole. The lid of this water bottle is always dripping all over the dang place. I’d probably like it more with the screw-off cap, but I hate unscrewing a cap then holding it while I drink water. Just bugs me
It is one of very few non-insulated steel water bottles out there, so I wish i liked it. But I just don’t. So I got a 25 oz camelback chute recently and like it much more. I anticipate having this water bottle forever, and using the klean kanteen as a backup / extra bottle when needed
Yes, I know I’m picky - but I work in design and hate when simple things are wrong, like having a rounded bottom on something that needs to stand up
Agreed! Mine is 1.9 L or 64 oz and she's been trucking along for over a decade. There are multiple options for the cap, and they fit any size of the bottles. I toss a few ice cubes in mine, and it stays nice and icy cold for most of my 8 hour shift. My boss calls it my Scuba Tank.
never heard klean kanteen mentioned anywhere before. but I happened to receive one as a gift aboot 10 years ago??? The one I have is 16 oz. and since it is smaller, I don't use it much. It's def good long lasting quality. Very thick plastic handle
What I have been going with for the past few years as daily drivers for the summer months is a couple of generic insulated bottles. Pretty sure I got them from walmart on clearance. They are quite sturdy oddly enough. I'm not quite sure what may end them. I just checked the one, too. I filled it up with ice and water 14 hours ago. Had most of it, and there's a 1/3 left. And there's still a large chunk of ice in water. And it spent 8 hours in a 100 F factory. It looks very similar to the klean kanteen bottles.
Yeti makes some great bottles in that size and larger
I’ve had a stainless steel Yeti water bottle for 10+ years. Goes with me everywhere. No dents, no paint to scratch or flake over time. It’s a beast.
I hear Stanley’s are not a good choice. Any recommendations, and would be helpful if you can link the Amazon for the item as well.
I am currently taking water bottles everyday to work and want to make a change.
I love the stainless steel water bottles from clean canteen. Get the ones with the stainless steel top as well (some of their models have plastic tops).
I am seeing stainless steel options for Clean Canteen but can you link me to the ones specifically with the stainless steel top.
You can get this one:
But now it looks like you have to order the classic bamboo cap as a separate accessory these days.
Here to recommend clean canteen also. I got the large thermos for me and my brother and soon to get for his girlfriend. Customized engraving recommend. Picture and initials.
https://www.kleankanteen.com/collections/all/products/32oz-tkpro-insulated-thermos This is the one I got. Seems like out of stock they only have tofu color currently. I recommend this one for sure. Kinda heavy, obviously. They had a green I got and black for my brother
Why are Stanley’s bad? I use a silicone straw.
Stanley uses lead solder, so some people think it's bad.
In locations that aren’t accessible as long as the product is intact
I like mine with the sippy top. Not sure what OP meant exactly.
hydroflask or larq?
2nd Hydroflask and I think hands down they are the easiest reusables to clean with like a standard dish brush.
Old Absolut vodka bottle
Really getting tired of getting "BPA-free" plastic bottles/bladders that end up tasting super chemical-y after a big trip. Same goes for stainless, which I'm not confident isn't leaching chemicals as well. I'd really like to find a good glass bottle but I'm struggling to find something big enough for a 20 mile dayhike - like 2L. Anyone have any good recs?
I doubt there are many, if any, glass bottles designed for this sort of activity. Glass is fragile. There's a reason they're all plastic and stainless.
I havent ever had any chemical taste from my nalgenes, neither my few year old ones, or my new ones.
Stainless steel does not leach into clean water. There is a good reason food/beverage processing equipment is made of stainless.
fair. but it tastes very bad
Stainless steel should not impart a taste into water. It does not react with water. If you can taste it you might want to make sure it is actually stainless and not some cheap nonsense.
You could try emptying out a big bottle of sangria and using that. I think those are 2 or 3 liters
You think nalgenes have taste?
I was going to suggest a fucking coconut, but if you think nalgenes have a taste to them, you definitely will notice the coconut.
yeah
Then you would definitely notice drinking out of a coconut, so that is out.
If you can’t find a water bottle that doesn’t leave a funny taste, maybe your mouth is the problem. I’m not a mouth doctor or anything, but I know all the water I drink from my Platypus bladders and Nalgenes taste fine.
Good luck finding a 2L glass bottle. I couldn’t imagine carrying something like that!
I’ve been through so many water bottles that claim to be leakproof and then end up drenching my note books! Does anyone know any water bottles that won’t leak?? Preferably under 10 dollars and bpa free
Can’t beat a Nalgene!
Crank on a Nalgene lid a bit and you're good.
Owala
My Nalgene doesn’t leak.
Best BPA free water bottles
Key Considerations for BPA-Free Water Bottles
Material: Look for bottles made from materials like Tritan, stainless steel, or glass, which are all BPA-free and durable.
Insulation: If you prefer keeping your drinks hot or cold, consider insulated bottles. Stainless steel options often provide excellent thermal insulation.
Capacity: Choose a size that fits your hydration needs. Common sizes range from 16 oz to 32 oz or more.
Design and Portability: Consider features like a wide mouth for easy filling and cleaning, a carry handle for portability, and a leak-proof lid.
Ease of Cleaning: Ensure the bottle is dishwasher safe or easy to clean by hand, especially if you plan to use it for smoothies or flavored beverages.
Brand Reputation: Look for reputable brands known for quality and safety, as well as customer reviews for real-world performance.
Recommendations:
Hydro Flask: Known for its durable stainless steel construction and excellent insulation, Hydro Flask bottles keep drinks cold for up to 24 hours and hot for up to 12 hours.
Nalgene: Made from Tritan, Nalgene bottles are lightweight, durable, and come in various sizes. They are also dishwasher safe and have a wide mouth for easy filling.
CamelBak: Their Chute Mag series features a BPA-free plastic design, a magnetic cap for easy access, and a comfortable carry handle, making it great for on-the-go hydration.
S'well: These stylish stainless steel bottles are insulated and come in various sizes and designs, perfect for keeping drinks at the desired temperature while looking good.
Choosing a BPA-free water bottle that fits your lifestyle will help you stay hydrated while ensuring safety and convenience.
Get more comprehensive results summarized by our most cutting edge AI model. Plus deep Youtube search.