Frigidaire professional french door is the one we chose based on how it felt when we checked them out in person.

I'm in the same boat (will be buying by this summer) and narrowing it down to one appears challenging. From what I have seen in person and researched, I came up with the below. I'm interested in a counter-depth French door, no dispensers on the outside of the door. Based on functions, usability, etc., -

Samsung Bespoke with Beverage center (model #RF23DB960012 or RF23DB9600QL or other similar)

1. Quad door flex model with adjustable freezer/refrigerator on one of the quad door is great
2. The beverage center with the water pitcher is a great idea; also the moving of ice dispenser to the freezer probably reducing the ice maker issues. Door in door is a great idea as well
3. The glass front on the doors is another great idea; it gives customers an option to change up. I believe this is a big hit; however, it appears Samsung is botching this up (among other things) by not having enough options available to meet the demand.
4. There is universal agreement that Samsung service sucks or non-existent
5. Priced at about $2500 (discounted at this point)

GE Profile quad door (model #PHD23BYWFS or similar) LED backlight /wall light looks awesome

1. Similar to the Samsung Bespoke, the Water pitcher is great. Not the same as the beverage center but feels similar with door-in-door.
2. Overall has a nice look.
3. Quad door with temperature adjustable to convert the bottom right to a fridge or a freezer or chiller.
4. Soft close drawer and adjustable shelfs are nice Std 1yr warranty but has 5y (parts and labor) on sealed systems
5. Dual evaporator (but single compressor)
6. GE (and Whirlpool) have their own service team (Bodewell); this could be advantageous
7. Priced at about $3000 Four model exists (with a temperature adjustable drawer instead of a quad door) - model #PJE23BYWFS at a price point of $2600

KitchenAid quad door (model #KRQC506MPS or similar)

1. Similar to Bespoke, quad door flex model with adjustable freezer/refrigerator.
2. There is a Whirlpool version with exact quad door but does not have the adjustable feature. Whirlpool model (WRQA59CNKZ) is priced at $1400
3. Nice look and feel overall with adjustable shelfs and soft-close drawers.
4. Priced at about $2400 (discounted at this point).

Bosch French door 3 door (model #B36CT80SNS or similar) there are other models with no handles, or four door with a additional beverage drawer

1. Bosch 800 series, obviously pricey
2. Generally rated well
3. Good looking flush model; no handle models look even better but pricey.
4. Dual compressor, dual evaporators; believe they are Panasonic compressors;
5. Crisper drawer doesn't appear to be designed well; had trouble opening them most times at the floor models. Guessing this will be the first one to fail or break
6. Bosch service may not be available if you are not in a metro area
7. Bosch models are 72in tall, it may not fit in some of the older homes Priced at about $3200

Other models look unimpressive or nothing special to speak about (not considering Thermadoor/Wolf/Sub-zero categories). LG is another that looks nice (Max Depth counter-depth has the largest capacity for a counter-depth) but considering their compressor issues, not sure I would go that route. Haven't seen a lot of Frigidaire models (other than base models). Dont think have seen any Frigidaire Pro models or gallery models in-store, so not sure.

Among the above, Bosch seems to be the best bet but it's pricey. If there is a good discount during the holidays, might go for it (HD spring Black Friday sale has them on sale in-store for $2799 now, so hoping it might come back during Memorial Day or July 4th). The next on my list is GE profile quad door but not sure if GE Profile is worth at the $3K price point.

Hope this is helpful.

Edits: formatting; couldnt post with rich text editor.

I can’t remember which brand, but something to look out for. French door models have a ‘flap’ on the left door that acts as a seal between the doors when closed. They are spring loaded so the flap flips 90 degrees when the door is opened. This is so the nub on the top of the flap will fit into a receiver on the frame when the door is closed. When that doesn’t happen correctly, there is potential damage to the flap and the doors won’t close completely. One manufacturer has solved this problem by spring loading the ‘nub’ so it will snap into the receiver. Difficult to describe.

I bought a GE Cafe French door 5 years ago that was a floor model, no problems so far. It's a little noisy at times but GE tech said that's how they are. I don't like the high cost of water filters but those chipped water filters are now sold by 3rd parties, so much cheaper now.

I was warned about Samsung as they're impossible to get serviced where I'm at. If you do buy a GE and get an extended warranty, buy the GE extended warranty, not 3rd party.

Measure, measure then measure again for which ever one you choose.

Look into BEKO refrigerators!

I typically recommend Whirlpool or GE. Whirlpool also owns Kitchenaid and Maytag, so that’s something to consider.

I’d stay away from Samsung and LG.

Source: work for an appliance repair company.

Hello as someone who sells appliances for a living LG/Samsung are a nightmare trying to get serviced. I know whirlpool also is getting stricter on what they deem is covered under warranty now. (Could just be my region). Just something to think about with the kitchenaid. If I’m not selling luxury, I’m usually recommending Bosch, Cafe, GE Profile.

These look like decent choices:

https://www.appliancesconnection.com/bosch-cafe-fisher-paykel-frigidaire-frigidaire-professional-ge-ge-profile-jenn-air-liebherr-maytag-whirlpool-36%22-french-door-refrigerators-b746-4905845,4909487,4909490,4909498,4909503,4909504,4909506,4909507,4909513,4909521,4909743-0-3477,708.html?attr=83%3AFrench+Door%2C333%3AIntRng24-27.99%2C333%3AIntRng28-31.99%2C383%3AInternal

Or these:

https://www.appliancesconnection.com/bosch-cafe-fisher-paykel-frigidaire-frigidaire-professional-ge-ge-profile-jenn-air-liebherr-maytag-whirlpool-36%22-french-door-refrigerators-b746-4905845,4909487,4909490,4909498,4909503,4909504,4909506,4909507,4909513,4909521,4909743-0-3477,708.html?attr=83%3AFrench+Door%2C333%3AIntRng24-27.99%2C333%3AIntRng28-31.99%2C383%3ANo

For a French door refrigerator, get an internal water dispenser or no water dispenser. Same goes for the ice maker.

Any GE and secondarily, Whirlpool. The french door design is less reliable from any maker [vs the cheapo top freezer], so expect trouble after 5 years, but if you buy a US make, its more easily fixed.

The Bosch 800 series B36CT80SNS is basically a mini sub zero with two compressors and has great air filtration to keep vegetables fresh longer.

Two compressors will make the unit not have to work as hard so it won't break down as easily. Currently the 800 series is the non built in unit doing this.

It is a bit pricier but it's definitely a quality unit.

Fisher paykel. Had one in my last house. Miss it everyday. Super quiet. Will never break.

I just bought 28 cu ft LG French door at Costco for $1700 after some extensive research. Most top rated fridges are LG on Consumer Reports. Yes I read bad customer reviews on LG but I gave much more weigh to objective professional reviews.

u/erikibarra14 What did you end up getting and how has it been? I was looking at getting an LG soon. My 14 year old Kenmore isn't keeping as cold anymore.

GE profile fridge ordered in Jan. Promised for May. Backed up to August. In stock is going to be your deciding factor most likely.

I have had LG for years and no issues. I have the counter depth model with two ice makers. One in the door and a separate one in the bottom freezer. I get filters on Amazon (not LG brand) for water and air. The dual ice makers means I never run out even when having a party.

I assume all modern large appliances are going to (at max) last 10 years if lucky. In saying that, if you live in the states, parts/service is likely goin to be easier with whirlpool brands imo.

Best thing to do is buy it from a local appliance dealer with their own service dept because they will be more likely to be able to fix it when it breaks and will be able to give a warranty. I paid $200 I think for my dryer 5 year service warranty and if I don't use it they give me store credit on my next purchase.

Stay away from Frigidaire. The newer ones are built cheap and are noisy as hell. We've learned this the hard way.

I bought an Amana side by side fridge in 2018. Its has an in door ice maker and water dispenser. I have had no issues with it. I buy the filters from Amazon every 6 months.

This is the biggest cubic feet I could find/bought recently…that was basic (no water dispenser-to break) GNE29GYNFS. We’ve only had it a week, so only time will tell, but the capacity has been nice compared to our old much smaller side by side. But what I basically learned through deep diving Reddit was, nothing is made to last anymore and thus go for the the basic/no bells and whistles models and stay away from Samsung/LG, and just cross your fingers that you get lucky.

Actually Consumer Reports rates LG and GE as being the most reliable brands for french doors, giving them scores of 75 and 74. Whirlpool and Bosch are close behind. Way back are Frigidaire and Samsung which are the worst two scoring at 58 and 52 on reliability. The rule of thumb is go as basic as possible, every advanced feature is just something new that can go wrong.

I like the kitchenaids. They seem like the high end of whirlpool. Just whatever brand you get, you have somebody in town who can fix it. We have no one in town to fix Samsung or Lg.

I've been in New home construction for 20 years this month. There is only one manufacture I will personally buy for myself and tenants and recommend to a person choosing Kitchen apiances for themselves. Buy any of the brands built by Whirlpool.

GE has had problems with ice makers freezing and leaking for years even with their Profile line.

Frigidaire is part of Electrolux and their kitchen appliances have been very unreliable for years and that's for all of their kitchen suites.

The longest lasting dishwashers and refrigerators of any brand sold in America are products made buy Whirlpool. I have found their stoves and microwave rangehoods to perform great as well.

For frontload laundry I have a Electrolux washer and dryers that perform flawlessly and I have a Frigidaire Gallery frontload washer and dryer, which is the first frontload laundry equipment reintroduced to America in many years and I bought the set in 1998 and it's still working for a family of 4 without any repairs to the Electric Dryer or washing machine.

If not a reliable Electrolux then buy a Speeed Queen frontload washer.

That's my recommendations, best of luck.

LGs are good. Not sure why some people don't like them. Whatever you pick just have in mind - top freezer are the most reliable and most energy efficient. Ice makers break a lot and need monthly maintenance. Also use a ton of electricity to run constantly. Pick a brand that has good service department in your area if problems arise.

Full depth or standard depth

We bought a GE Profile PVD28BYNFS, absolutely love it! Ended up finding one at a Best Buy outlet store, but no scratches or dents. Just a return due to the buyer not measuring his/her available space properly. Bought it for $1599, retailed around $3800,

The middle drawer is awesome, this gets used more than the top part of the fridge. Love the rear LED wall that illuminates every item in the upper fridge area. The only trade off is the ice maker does not make massive amounts of ice, if you have 6 family members who love ice either buy a bag of ice for the freezer or choose another fridge. We are 3 people and we make out fine.

Searched for weeks comparison shopping and read hundreds of reviews. We had first chosen a kitchenaid platinum interior, but after reading about many issues with that model having a cracked plastic housings we went with the GE Profile.

So happy with my Bosch fridge! It keeps everything perfectly chilled and the water dispenser is so convenient.

I finally got my Bosch fridge after weeks of waiting and extensive research (previous fridge, maybe a GE, wasn't great). It's definitely a premium appliance, and while I love it overall, it did require some early maintenance - the ice maker needed replacing almost right away, and then the display went out. The extended warranty saved me a ton on repairs, especially since the recent display issue would've been a pricey fix without it. So, while I wouldn't necessarily discourage a Bosch fridge, getting the warranty is a wise move.

The Bosch 800 series is a great choice for a reliable French door fridge with a water dispenser and ice maker, and it falls within your $3,000 budget. Here's a breakdown of why it's a good option and some alternatives to consider:

Why Bosch 800 is a good choice:

• Reputation for Reliability: Bosch is known for its well-built appliances with a good track record for longevity.
• Features: Within the 800 series, you'll find various models with different capacities and features, but most will offer what you're looking for: water dispenser, ice maker, and a spacious French door design.
• No Smart Features: You specifically mentioned avoiding smart features, and Bosch offers plenty of models without them.

Alternatives to Consider:

• Whirlpool French Door Refrigerator: Whirlpool offers reliable and feature-packed French door fridges at a good price point. They might not have the same level of prestige as Bosch, but they are known for durability.
• LG French Door Refrigerator with Craft Ice: LG offers innovative features like craft ice for specialty cocktails. While their reliability can vary slightly compared to Bosch, some LG models consistently rank well in consumer reports. Keep in mind that features like craft ice might push the price closer to your budget limit.

We were forced to replace our Kenmore French door fridge because the compressor failed. It was only 7 years old.

The repairman said it wasn't worth repairing. We knew that our Kenmore was a rebadged LG, but the repairman educated us that the older LGs had a known compressor problem. Not sure about the new ones, but our experience turned us off to any further LGs.

I asked the repairman which brands he saw more and less during his service calls. He said he serviced more LG and Samsung and less Maytag, Frigidaire, and GE. As you may know, there's a lot of consolidation. As of a couple years ago, this was my understanding:

Whirlpool owns Jenn-Air, Maytag, Amana, and KitchenAid.

Electrolux owns Frigidaire, Tappan, Kelvinator and Gibson.

Haier owns GE and Fisher/Paykel.

Here's an independent review site that may help: Best Fridge

When we went shopping in Sept. 2020, inventory shortages due to COVID were a huge problem. We went to two local appliance stores, Best Buy, and Home Depot. I wanted a Frigidaire or even Bosch.

But despite having hundreds of models on the floor, the four stores collectively had six models that fit our criteria and were in stock. Everything else was at least 2-4 weeks away.

The only good news was that our fridge failed right before Labor Day weekend, so we were able to get a decent sales price on this GE, which the store also said could be delivered in 48 hours: PVD28BYNFS. It has some nice features, but it has its annoyances too. Do not buy this model unless the price is at least $1K less than their "suggested retail price."

There's generally some wiggle room even with their sales price, so be sure to ask for a discount (5-10% would be a reasonable ask).

Good luck!

Don't buy a Samsung. We've got a Samsung french door fridge and have replaced the broken springs in the door about every 9 months. Then there's the internal water dispenser that has broken several times, and the ice maker in the lower freezer needs repairs also about every 9 months.

Consider the Bosch B36CT80SNS

I used to work for samsung specifically. Don’t get samsung.

In the market for a new French Door Fridge as well, so glad to see this post. I’ve been planning on LG based on Consumer Reports but curious to see what folks recommend.

The house we just moved into has a horrible Samsung, and the house we just sold had a pre-sell off GE that worked reasonably well.

We’ve long been fans of Bosch dishwashers, so I’m definitely interested in their Refrigerators as well.

Edited to add: I don’t view major appliances as true BIFL items, as I’m a big proponent of energy efficiency and so was to take advantage of tech upgrades. That said, I’d like to get 10 years out of a refrigerator ideally.