I tried the Mario setting spray and it’s decent. Probably won’t purchase it again but I do love his setting powder. I have like every single setting powder and always grab Mario. I have huda beauty setting spray (not a fan in general) and her setting spray literally looks like someone spit on your face the way it comes out. She needs to go back to the drawing board on that one. Tried and true is Patrick Starrr ONE/SIZE setting spray. It’s like hair spraying your face but your make up stays and I go back in with Mario powder to really seal it in and keep the shine away.

i use the milani setting spray, it's the only setting spray i use and i set with powder after, my makeup basically doesn't budge

Daily - CT setting spray

Special event/extended wear - O/S org. version

i loveee the danessa myricks blurring balm as a primer, and de-slick by urban decay for setting spray as a fellow oily girlie! these two tame my oil like its nobody’s business. also, skin prep is super important beforehand. if i know im gonna be out all day with a full face i also use the laroche-posay effaclar mask followed by a cerave oil control moisturizer😋 i make sure not to completely dry out my skin since this can have an opposite effect (if your skin is dry, it’ll compensate by releasing more oil to hydrate itself) but this routine has worked so good for me!

I feel like I have tried them all and I keep going back to UD All Nighter. Nothing else lasts as well.

I swear by the One Size. It legitimately feels like hairspray for my face. I am also oily, acne-prone, and sensitive.

This isn’t sold at Sephora but just trust me. MAC Fix Plus. Been using for 10 years and always repurchase. Don’t even waste your time trying other setting sprays.

Skindinavia oil control has been my HG for years! They make UD setting sprays but you can get an 8oz with a code for about the same as a 4oz UD. I specifically use the oil control and it works great. They usually have a deal where you get 2 travel sprays to try of their other formulas too

I like CT and O/S.

i also have acne prone oily skin and i’ve struggled with looking like a ball of grease for awhile😞 it was also the worst when i used foundations like the new huda one BUT ive found a way to fix it and make it look nice!

after my skincare i use a light layer of setting powder, followed by setting spray, and after that dries the porefessional primer from benefit! i do my regular makeup routine and then use whatever setting spray i have on me! i’ve never had a problem with longevity but this has really helped me maintain a more natural finish to my makeup!!

anyways, that’s just something that’s helped me. if you’re looking for a nice matte setting spray the one size is very long lasting, i wore a full face of makeup to disney world in florida and my makeup stayed on all day! the l’oréal infallible setting spray is nice too and is about twenty dollars cheaper i believe, so i prefer that for everyday wear. the milani setting spray is nice too!!

A little tip to get the most effective use from this would be to do a spray layer after everything on your face is done except your mascara. Do a setting spray before your mascara. AND THEN do a light layer once your mascara is on.

I found that it stops my mascara from accidentally running/smudgey from the spray, and then also acts as almost a primer on my "naked" lashes. ZEROOOO crumbly or flaking under my eyes with this method, which would sometimes become a problem with my oily skin plus heat.

I think you're going to love it!

I use Skindinavia (bridal) and in 2 layers. After base then as a final seal.

For base, either Danessa Myrics blurring balm or Neat 3B Face antiperspirant gel.

I’m in a tropical country so you can guess how hot and humid things are.

When I need things to be damn near waterproof: Mehron barrier spray under the foundation, PPI Blue Marble SELR on top. Locks things down, but can be irritating to sensitive skin and not ideal for daily use (very drying).

Day to day: start with a good moisturizer and let it dry down, then a primer and foundation with the same base (i.e., silicone with silicone, water with water), then NYX Matte Finish setting spray. I don't use powder if I can help it as I find it tends to over-dry my skin and cause even more oil later.

In the worst parts of summer, I'll use a face antiperspirant underneath everything too.

You may want to start with looking into your foundation as well. I have super oily skin and I have to be careful what I use. Nothing dewy for me. Everything has to be matte.

Charlotte tilsbury's Air Brush Flawless Setting Spray is 😙🤌

Seriously magic!

Agree with the suggestions so far, I think it’s also worthwhile for you to carry around oil blotting wipes to use throughout the day if you aren’t already!

I remember being told this before! Haven’t tried UD all nighter. I love the fine, even spray from Skindinavia so haven’t really thought to try others. Thank you, I’ll keep this in mind.

If you aren't using a setting powder, like the other commenter said, it's super helpful in controlling oil.

I haven't used the Morphe setting spray, but MAC Fix+ imo is more of a hydrating spray than a setting spray, especially if you're looking to control oil. I use it when I'm looking too dry/powdery and matte.

My favorite setting spray is the one from Charlotte Tilbury, but other sprays to consider:

Urban Decay All Nighter (I didn't like it so much but others swear by it)

One Size on til dawn setting spray (haven't tried it but I've heard others rave about it)

For something available only at Ulta, their Wannabe Free Setting Spray (the original one, not the matte or SPF one) isn't half bad. It's alcohol free, fragrance free, relatively budget friendly ($12), and it does a fairly good job. Not quite as good as Charlotte Tilbury, but it's close. You can also consider drugstore options like Milani Make it Last and Maybelline Lasting Fix; I've heard others say they're good.

I would take a look at your skincare..if not dehydrated, then your base. I have oily skin and i stopped using setting spray because i found out it's skincare and primer or pre setting with powder. My favorite is the fenty invisimatte powder. Buut if you still want that spray, i suggest Nyx or Skindinavia.

My take is that controlling shine is just not what setting spray is meant to do. Its job is to keep your makeup from breaking apart when your skin gets oily.

Some way to keep your makeup from getting too shiny without making it totally matte at the start include:

• Powder underneath foundation and setting spray over
• Mix a little bit of liquid highlighter into a very matte foundation, topped by setting spray

It’s not a setting spray but I highly recommend laura mercier translucent powder!

Benefit the porefessional super setter spray leaves a nice matte / pore blurring finish and has a super light feeling on the skin. It’s a true mist, not a heavy spray like some setting sprays so good for sensitive skin imo. It’s my favorite setting spray I’ve tried. I’ve used NYX matte finish spray too and liked that one as well for a less pricey option.

Thank you for contributing to MUA! If this is your first post, please be sure to check out our rules in the subreddit sidebar. If you are on mobile, they can be viewed by tapping the ⓘ symbol.

A few quick highlights:

• Rule 1 has been updated to include self-deprecation. Please review the rule in the sidebar and our wiki page here.

• Looks, hauls, and flatlays require a product list in the comments, complete with shade names within 20 minutes of posting.

• Photos must not be edited or filtered. This includes automatic beauty and portrait modes found on many phones and newer cameras.

• Lastly, our Helpful Guides for Navigating MUA in the sidebar explains some of the basics of the community as well as commonly misinterpreted rules.

Is your post just a search away?

Before you make a post, search with Reddit's search feature or use this handy customised Google search.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

UD De-Slick is my spray of choice.

I would recommend trying the NYX Professional Makeup Matte Finish Setting Spray. This setting spray is formulated with a shine-stopping matte finish that helps to control oil, while also keeping your makeup in place for up to 8 hours.

Another option to consider is the Skindinavia The Makeup Finishing Spray Oil Control. This setting spray is specifically designed for oily skin and helps to reduce shine and keep your makeup in place for up to 16 hours. It also contains a unique oil-control complex that helps to reduce the appearance of pores.

If you have sensitive skin and are prone to rashes, try the Milani Make It Last Setting Spray Prime + Correct + Set. This spray has a lightweight formula that is gentle on the skin, and it also helps to control oil and keep your makeup in place for up to 16 hours. Additionally, it's infused with vitamins B, E, and arctium majus root to help soothe skin and minimize irritation.

Rimmel Stay Matte Setting Spray.

NYX stay matte setting spray!!!

I have the same problem as you. I bought the UD de slick mini spray and haven't found it to help me. It's been 15 days of uses and I haven't noticed a difference.But I haven't broken out and I'm suppose to get my period in a day or so. Also my makeup uses might affect it's performance? I also wear light makeup- concealer, eyes stuff, contour, blush, etc. But no foundation. (Love my freckles to much to cover them up)

Anyways,I'll by trying some of the suggestions in the comments. Thanks for asking the question for me ��

I am oily and found Milani's spray to be better than UD's De-Slick, believe it or not. De Slick certainly works, but Milani's provided the same effect of "melting" my powder and giving my makeup some more lasting power but for 1/3 the price.

Another drug-store option I really like it JOAH Beauty's setting spray. It's sold only at CVS. I think it's about the same price (maybe $1-2 cheaper) than the Milani spray though I do believe it's a larger size (I'm not at home otherwise I'd confirm since I have both in my makeup bag).

Also, I know it sounds counter-intuitive but you might want to give the original Milani spray (the one in the see-through bottle) a try instead of the matte one. I have tried quite a few setting sprays, high end and drug-store, and the "normal skin" or "dewy" setting sprays actually work better for me, despite the fact that my face produces enough oil to power a car that runs on alternative fuel. When I try to fight my face and suck moisture from it using a ton of matte products and blotting sheets, my foundation seems to wear off much faster and look patchier at the end of the day.

I really like Wet n Wild’s matte finish!

I have pretty oily skin and I've had good results with the Rimmel Stay Matte setting spray

If you have a CVS nearby, look for KimChi Chic Stage Proof Matte setting spray. It's pricier for a drugstore option ($16 according to the website) but bulletproof and it doesn't have any annoying fragrance.

Milani Make It Last Setting Spray

Makeup Revolution Sport Fix Extra Hold Makeup Fixing Spray

Maybelline Lasting Fix Setting Spray

I have very oily skin and I wear masks. When I use this stuff, my makeup barely transfers onto the mask and it keeps me from looking like an oil slick.

I love the L’Oreal Paris Infallible and ELF Mist & Set.

Morphe Continuous Setting Mist! It is only $23 for 6.5 oz!

Not from Ulta, but I'll share anyway just in case!

I use KimChi Chic Stage Proof Matte setting spray, and I love it! Nice sprayer, not stinky, SETS, and keeps the oil down. It's $16 on their website.

Ulta is doing their 21 days of beauty and the MAC setting spray will be half off. Check the ad for the specific date it will be on sale. Sorry I don’t know the date off the top of my head!

Other than the MAC setting spray, I’ve had good luck with the PIXI makeup setting spray. You can find it at target and Ulta. And if you get it from Ulta you can use their usual $3.50 off coupon.

Hope that helps!

Milani or Nyx have really nice matte sprays. Elf is okay but it stinks 🤢. I will say though definitely check for price per oz. A lot of drugstore sprays are much smaller.

make up revolution sport fix !!!!

Hiya! Makeup artist here, my favs to use are the Urban Decay All Nighter, and MAC fix+. I've heard good things about the Morpe one but I haven't used it myself. But it seems like the issues you're describing with your makeup aren't something that can be solved by just a setting spray. :)

If you think about it, spraying a setting spray over the top of your makeup will definitely help to melt any products together ON TOP of your skin, but it's not going to do anything to help it actually stick to your skin underneath.

Usually makeup breaks up through the day due to oils coming through from your skin, underneath your makeup. This is why using a good primer is so much more effective than just a setting spray when it comes to the longevity of your makeup. (some of my favs are the maybelline fit me primers, milk hydro grip, and ELF putty primers.

I love using setting spray after I've done liquid foundation and concealer, and then I let it dry for a few minutes before powdering lightly over the top. I find I use less setting powder when I do this, and the makeup looks smooth and lasts all day.

Hope this helps!

Nothing beats the morphe mist imo!! It takes away the powderiness yet helps my face stay set all night!

I like the Urban Decay sprays, they're a little pricey but good. The NYX matte setting spray is good too, at a lower price point. I've also heard great things about the Morphe one, but personally the scent gives me a headache so I don't use it.

"Designer" brand - Urban Decay All Nighter Setting Spray

• Went into a hot tub in the rain with a full face of makeup & it didn't move!

• Spilt coffee on my face while trying to drink it and my makeup still looked flawless.

"Drugstore" brand - NYX matte finishing spray.

• I haven't had the same situations to test it but it seems to be just as good!

NYX matte spray, in a black bottle :)