TL;DR
Prescription vs. Over-the-Counter Options
There is a significant debate between using prescription medications and over-the-counter options. Prescription medications like Simparica Trio and Bravecto are often recommended by veterinarians due to their broad-spectrum protection and convenience of use [3:2]. However, these can be more expensive and may carry risks such as neurological side effects or, in the case of Bravecto, a rare seizure risk
[4:5]. Over-the-counter options like K9 Advantix II are popular for their accessibility and affordability, though they may not be as comprehensive in protection
[2:1].
Effectiveness and Safety Concerns
Effectiveness can vary based on location and specific tick/flea populations. Some users reported that products like Frontline were ineffective in certain areas [3:5]. Safety concerns are paramount, with reports of adverse reactions being a significant consideration for many pet owners
[1:2]. It's important to weigh the potential risks of adverse effects against the benefits of effective parasite control.
Veterinarian Recommendations
Consulting with a veterinarian is crucial when selecting a flea and tick prevention method. Vets can provide tailored advice based on your dog's health, lifestyle, and local parasite risks [5:11]. They can also address concerns about potential side effects and help monitor your dog for any adverse reactions
[4:4].
Natural Alternatives
For those concerned about chemical treatments, natural flea and tick prevention methods are available, although their effectiveness can be variable [3:1]. These alternatives may be worth considering in conjunction with veterinary advice, especially for dogs with sensitivities to conventional treatments.
Cost Considerations
Cost is a recurring theme, with many pet owners seeking affordable yet effective solutions. While prescription options tend to be pricier, they often offer rebates or discounts for bulk purchases [5:8]. Over-the-counter options can be more budget-friendly but might require more frequent application or additional treatments to cover all parasites
[2:6].
Ultimately, the best flea and tick prevention for your dog will depend on individual factors such as your dog's health, lifestyle, and the prevalence of parasites in your area. Consulting with a vet and considering both prescription and over-the-counter options will help you make an informed decision.
I’m really confused with all the back n forth on certain brands and side effects. Please give me the best one you can recommend thats over the counter n will do the job without having to worry about bad reactions?!
The issue with the newer medications is they can cause neurological symptoms in some animals. When you look at the study data of millions of animals, you are bound to see reactions, some severe, in any drug. That is what you see with the prescription flea and tick meds, a handful of animals that have adverse reactions. This is no different from any drug commercial you hear on TV, "and side effects can be headache, nausea, diarrhea, and death."
Wait, what? Death? Yes, because someone on the medication died and there was no clear evidence it was NOT related to the medication, the company has to list that as a possible side effect.
The bigger question you need to be looking at is the coverage and whether or not you need heartworm as well as flea and tick.
To that end, my girl gets Bravecto every three months, but only for nine months out of the year. I take my chances that the winter cold kills off the critters and her body gets a break from the medication.
This is what I mean yes. I wish I knew which one is the best option. We do live where theres a lot of ticks and fleas so its ideal that its stronger and kills them off easily. But at the same time, I dont want to lessen his lifespan, or cause neurological issues for him. So hard to figure this out
Talk to your vet about your concerns then, they would have a much better idea of the pros and cons of the choices.
I’ve used frontline. It works fine
I'd be curious if more people had opinions on this as well. I don't really have the $90 office visit fee, along with the probably couple hundred dollar prescription for the flea med the vet gives.
Exactly. Everyone gives me different answers, and then another person is warning me about the same product! I am losing it
Tick season is about to start and I need to get some for my fur baby but we have always went to the vet to get them. Each year the price increases due to him getting bigger and them raising their prices. I see different kinds in pet shops but idk if they really work or are they even safe?? I just want to know if there's an alternative or am I spending $400 this year.
I've always used K9 Advantix II for flea and tick
There was a big issue not that long ago with a lot of those over the counter brands causing horrible lesions and I think even some pets died because of it. I wouldn’t risk it if I were you.
Simparica Trio is the ticket. Costco $123 for 6-months. One chewy treat each month-simple!
No. It's not the same and some are outright dangerous
Unfortunately, so is what the vet uses
Advantix II is OTC, and seems to work perfectly.
Hello! My friend told me that Frontline doesn't work on the ticks in her area (she's in a different state), so I should ask people near me which flea and tick prevention they use. Don't know if that's true but...
I'd like to ask anyway! I just got a dog so I'd love to know what everyone else is using and what works for them.
Vet here. Obligatory, this is general advice, talk to your vet.
Currently, the best tick prevention (all of which also do fleas, and not labeled but functionally mites) is the isoxazoline class. This includes Nexgard, Bravecto, Simparica, and Credelio. All of them are functionally the same. The only big difference is Bravecto lasts for up to 3 months, whereas the others are one month.
To me, it makes the most sense to use the monthly that also does heartworm at the same time (eg Simparica Trio, Nexgard Spectrum) so it is one less thing to remember.
All of these require a prescription. All of these can potentially cause problems if your dog has a seizure disorder.
Your vet may only carry one of them. They can be acquired online. Some can be acquired locally (historically Simparica Trio could be purchased at Costco). Last I checked Simparica is the cheapest. Anecdotally, Nexgard tastes the best.
My dog has been on Bravecto for about a year and he is COVERED in fleas. The vet keeps giving him more doses, and it makes no difference. So I don’t recommend Bravecto.
I previously had great success with Comfortis, so I’m switching back.
>Nexgard, Bravecto, Simparica, and Credelio
How high are they when they come up with these names?
Says the guy called Space Manatee :P
I think at this point the entire pharmaceutical industry is just stringing together random syllables.
Higher than a cannonball. ...........where were you when were getting hi. Champagne super Nova in the sky. That hi. Audioslave. Like a stone and freeway 👋
How about kidney and liver damage caused by those oral pills? Is that something to worry about, has it been scientifically proven? I found some controversial information on the internet.
We’ve had good luck with K9asvantix. Much better than with frontline.
We’ve used bravecto in the past, but now we use Simparica Trio to cover heart worm, fleas, and ticks.
Also use Simparica Trio, been super impressed. Ends up being about the same cost as the separate medications but nice to only have one pill to sync orders on.
Oh wow, it’s a pill that performs all that? It would be very nice not to have an oily stain (Advantix II) on my dog’s back for a week every month.
bravecto
Selecting the right flea and tick prevention for your dog is a critical decision, and it can indeed vary based on specific factors such as your dog's size, age, breed and habitat. You might want to look into this Natural Flea and Tick Prevention for Dogs, which has generally received positive feedback from pet parents. It's easy to apply, effective in preventing fleas/ticks and is widely regarded as safe. However, keep in mind that every product may not work the same for all dogs due to individual health conditions or allergies they may have. Always consult with your vet first before starting any new prevention regimen!
What do you all recommend for flea and tick treatment. Preventative of course. I’m in Canada and just looking for the right options for my boy this year.
We use Bravecto (Fluralaner chewable tablets) when up in Canada. Protects for 12 weeks.
We use Bravecto too. So easy to give as a chew.
Our old vet told us back when we first started it that Bravecto has a rare seizure risk in some dogs, so I always throw that out there when recommending it.
But we’ve never had any issues, and it works great.
Yes, all the flea and tick preventatives carry risk, and the highest adverse events and death risk come from the newer combined formulas, like Simparico Trio and Bravecto Plus compared to original formulas.
I got young kids, and when I’m up north, it’s a tickbombed countryside (all the travelling geese are supposed carriers); it’s just a risk we cannot take. Funny enough, when our coonhound gets them, they just end up crawling on her slick guard hairs and transfer them to us while petting as they search for a suitable place to latch, compared to other ‘fluffier’ breeds like our livestock guardian dog.
Simparica Trio! We’ve been using it for awhile now. It’s amazing! no more telling my children “don’t touch the dog she’s got meds on her back” or “Lucy, don’t scratch your back against my couch!” First month she ate the tab no problem, now it’s not delicious enough so we just crush it and put it in her food and she eats it that way. It’s such a great idea too. 1 tablet for all of it!
Simperica Trio.
I shall check with my vet. We spend a lot of time in the woods and I do not want to take chances.
Another vote for Simparica Trio! I’m in Canada as well.
Credelio Quattro. It prevents six different types of parasites. I haven’t seen a tick on my dog this year (unlike the other members of my household!).
I’ve been using the drops for my Archie by K-9 Advantix, but have heard of other SAFER products and methods. Am I just being paranoid? I’m just curious as to what you all use! Please help!
Our vet gave us Bravecto from the start and we haven’t had an issues. It’s a chewable that we break up and wrap in a little cheese when we give it to her. It seems a little pricey but I honestly don’t know what’s average, but our vet usually has little rebates when you buy a certain amount of doses
Jumping in that Bravecto is 12-weeks of protection (8 weeks for a specific kind of tick, I forget exactly) and comes in both chewable and topical. It shakes out to be the same cost-wise of the 30-day dosages, but it’s less often that I a) have to remember and b) wrangle my dog for his treatment.
Use the 12 week bravecto also! My dogs actually love the taste on its own so it’s no problem to give to them without cheese! Lol
I use Simparica Trio for flea treatment monthly, and I use droncit for their worming treatment every 3 months. This is the only thing I have found what works with my two sausages, don’t bother with over the counter, my boy must have caught them from the grass out by mine and we have lot of foxes out there and they said the wild animals are almost immune to over counter meds (if your in the uk) I would only use prescription stuff from the vets.
This is what we use for all of our dogs (5) too. It’s easy to get them all to take it and we’ve never had problems with anything (fleas, ticks, or worms).
Same here never had a problem at all since using these products, I honestly swear by it, my boys are 2&1 would never use anything else now!
I use Simparica Trio for my 16yo guy
The VET, a VET can give you medical advice about your pets
i’m looking for first hand experience, what a vet recommends can work for someone but others can have a bad experience with it, just looking for some opinions!
A good vet should be able to do that, too. It's just crazy how often in this sub people are asking medical advice about their pets
Nothing wrong with asking others for opinions and first hand experiences. Don’t forget that most Vets receive monthly bonuses and incentives tied to products.
Just a vet popping in here to say this isn't true, and I don't know of any other vets receiving kickbacks. Please stop spreading this misinformation. My colleagues and I only recommend products because they actually work. I am paid a salary that does not change regardless of which medication I prescribe. Thanks!
Hi guys! I recently moved to a house with woods in the back. I take my golden retriever on daily walks back there and he LOVES it. But, I know I need to stay on top of flea/tick prevention as I found a deer tick on him a few days ago. What are your top recommendations?
Don’t know if it matters but he has a lot of fur, loves baths, and we live in northern USA.
Simparica TRIO covers fleas, ticks, and worms, so that's always been my preference.
Also use simparica trio. And spend lots of time in the summer in heavily wooded areas with my critter. We also do Lyme vaccine, since he has so much tick exposure.
We use simparica trio as well. We don't do too much hiking but a couple times I did find dead ticks on him - so, yay, it works for that.
We have a pack of aussies, so pretty hairy. I used Frontline for years, and it worked great. Then one year, it didn't...I guess the tick buggers built up a resistance from overuse? I also used Cutter yard spray for the perimeter of the yard every year, but that stopped working too.
When I moved to a wooded area, I went with Advantix, and switched to Frontline every other year, and that seems to work.
BTW, I recently got chickens, and wow, they really clear the area. I might not use anything on my dogs next year.
I definitely recommend continuing to use prevention just to be safe. Lots of nasty diseases can come from ticks, like Lyme disease, which can be fatal if not treated in time.
Simparica Trio is great because it includes heartworm protection as well, but it is pricey. Nexgard is also a great choice (but doesn’t include heartworm protection). I hesitate to recommend Bravecto to people with dogs who are in the woods/otherwise exposed to ticks a lot because it doesn’t have full tick coverage for the entire 12 week dosing period.
Sadly I just acquired a 4 yrs female golden retriever from a friend (65F) who became ill and had to be placed in a nursing home. A sad situation. I took possession of her golden retriever a week ago. I (59M) live off grid on 100 plus acres of all woods. I’ve been taking this golden for long walks. Probably a mile plus each day. This dog has been pretty much house bound for the last 6 months. She absolutely loves the walks in the woods.. She is 1000% all nose. Sniffs everything . I live in Northwestern Pennsylvania. However when the warm weather approaches I fear ticks and porcupines. Your post could not have come at a better time. Best wishes..
Simparica I TRIO or any of the isoxazolines (-laner drugs)
Hey guys! I used a liquid flea and tick preventative on my dog and I realized his back kept on twitching. His entire back muscle would twitch so badly that it was physically bothering him. I stopped the flea treatment for a month and a half and after about 2-3 washes his muscle spasms stopped completely. Now that it’s nearing summer I put the flea preventative to see if it really was that that was causing his back to twitch; it was! Even after washing him once it still continued. Any recommendations on flea preventatives that work without harming my dog?
I use Simparica Trio. Prescription flea, tick, and roundworm. 1 chewable tablet per month.
Yes this is the best option. I use this for both my pups no side effects
Agreed! It’s also one of the most cost effective in my experience as a vet technician working in the northeast.
I personally use Seresto and HG for my cats and dogs
I work for a pharmacy that sells single doses of pet meds, and we sell thousands of Simparica Trio doses a day. We also sell a lot of Nexgard and others, but the Simp Trio is definitely the most popular.
My vet never recommended these. It seems much more cost effective vs buying nexgard and heartgard at like $40ish for both a month! Just purchased them off of Chewy. I wish I knew about them earlier.
It also prevents heartworm
Nexgard spectra, bravecto, credelio, simparica
if you live somewhere with mosquitoes then adding a heartworm prevention would be recommended. Simparica Trio is a once a month chewable for fleas, ticks, heartworm prevention, and intestinal parasite prevention. it does require a prescription from your vet. another is Bravecto, which does fleas and ticks and works for 3 months. prescription strength preventions are the best working ones. ask your vet what they recommend for your pet
One of my guys has skin issues so I use NexGard with him. Others get topical since they have tummy issues.
Ask your vet what is working in your area and what they could recommend.
Edit: yeah simparico or bravado are great for my dog
Simparica Trio really is great stuff. And price wise, it’s very cost effective. Where flea/tick/heartworm medication can cost a fair bit separately, Trio is quite affordable for what it is. If you go that route, make sure to use the Zoetis rebates after you buy the Trio as well. You can use the credit you get from the rebate for any vet services, so it shaves off a bit on vaccines, more Trio, or that ear infection you hadn’t counted on.
Yes! Just use milbemycin monthly as well. Credelio plus protects against heartworm as well
I know they can have skin allergies, but what's better for them?
I bought a hypoallergenic shampoo with flea and tick repellent included. Was a game changer for sure!
Also spraying my yard for flea and tick every other week in spring/summer and once a month in winter/fall.
Haven't used preventative meds since.
Can you share the shampoo? Thank you 🩷
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00920YHOO?ref_=ppx_hzsearch_conn_dt_b_fed_asin_title_2&th=1
This is the shampoo I use. I have 3 pits all 50lbs+ so I buy the big bottle.
Seresto. It's a bit pricier but I've been putting it on my babys for a few years.
Agree. I've been using seresto for years with my pitty and I am using with my new bully puppy now too. It's easy, doesn't smell, and you don't have to avoid petting your dog.
I 2nd this!! We have been getting them as well and they work fantastic 👏 only ticks we found were dead
I do quarterly Bravecto for my two. It's a chewable.
Educational resources to help raise a friendly dog:
For training on puppy/dog biting click here
For training on early socialization click here
For training on becoming a good leader click here
For all newly adopted dogs, check out the 3-3-3 rule.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
Oral medicine would be ideal, but if you absolutely need something topical, I'd recommend revolution.
In very high tick/flea areas, I also recommend seresto WITH an oral preventative.
We have a mountain home and our 16 mo golden LOVES it here. Biggest problem is the massive amount of ticks he picks up whenever we go outside.
HE is protected. He gets his tick medication regularly. The family is at risk! What are the best tick repellants we can use on him to prevent us from having ticks running amok all over the house. We find them on him and the furniture for hours and even days after.
Pic for cute tax
Hi, don't know where you are living, but in ceratin countries you need a subscription.
Again, Nexguard has my strongest recommendation to fight ticks!
We are in New England and just about to start tick season. We are currently on simparica trio which has work great as well as seresto collar before switching to simparica. For more protection and not getting the In the house I found using Kin+Kind tick prevention Lemongrass spray before every adventure and also can be use on house after post adventure a tick comb over helps. Btw, ur pup is soo adorable!!!🥰
We also use Simparica Trio, I’m here in America. We just found a tick on our girl 5 month old Golden yesterday and it was already dead when we pulled it out.
Our dogs also have no trouble eating Simparica they think it’s treats.
When we’ve gotten free samples of Nexguard our dogs refuse to eat them.
I tried Nextgard for a while (simply because of size and dosing - it was closer to my pup's size as she was still growing). I had to cover the whole thing in peanut butter or my girl refused to eat it.
Switching back to Simparica next month because the girl will eat it as a treat, has grown enough to be right in the middle of their next weight range, and because I don't want to be monitoring to make sure she doesn't spit the Nextgard out.
Interestingly I got an ad for Simparica Trio on this page which is what I came to recommend. Fleas, ticks, heartworm in one monthly pill. It’s expensive though. In the past, I’ve used K9 Advantix II. It did the job but seemed to really bother my girl. It made her back itchy and uncomfortable, like she would twitch all over if I ran my fingers down her spine. So I don’t recommend that.
We used to use k9 advantix II with our first golden years ago and it work but right after applying he would run around the house for a hour and than settle down. His girlfriend also was on k9 and got a bad burn on her back so We stoped K9 and switch to seresto collar for years till about a few years ago when our vet suggested simparica.With the K9 we also noticed it caused some damage to our furniture when he would rub against it. I wouldn’t recommend K9 either.
Please use NEXGUARD tablets.
They are very effective, no side effects. Each month, one tablet.
The tablets are meatbased, therefor very essy to administer.
I had a big Golden boy, about 50 kg and Nexguard had great effect.
The ticks in one or orher way, sense that your dog has taken Nexguard, therefor they move to the nose of your dog, where they or drop of your dog, or your can squeeze the tick yourself.
When the tick chooses to bite your dogs skin, the will die instantly.
Good luck!
Just one thing to consider: Simparica is actually effective against one more species of tick that is common in some parts of the US. If ticks are the biggest concern, that is something to keep in mind. It is also a tiny bit cheaper than Nextgard (not enough for it to make a huge difference, but still)
This is a small Canadian Etsy shop that makes tick collars that absolutely work. Haven’t seen a single tick on our golden since getting it and they are quite bad around here. They also make smaller bracelet size ones that are safe for humans to wear. I believe they work by throwing off tick’s co2 or pheromone receptors, one of the two I forget which. But essentially they make the tick blind to the fact there’s a host nearby and they won’t jump on you:
Wow. This is looks promising. I'm in search for an all natural extra layer of protection for our boy againts ticks. Currently we are using the Kin + Kind lemongrass spray and so far so good, but an extra layer of protection would be great. Thanks for sharing 😃
We took our 11 month old puppy for a walk through some very well-groomed trails at my brother’s house last night. When we got back from the walk, we were SHOCKED to find a tick on her this early in the year. She has had her tick meds already, but thankfully we noticed it.
We are in Michigan.
We have been finding ticks since JANUARY in Upstate NY! It’s crazy!!!
My dog is a year old male German shepherd mix. Need to get him some tick prevention. Pic bcuz look at him! 🥹
What a cutie! We use SimparicaTrio monthly tablets and put a dab of geranium oil on her back before her tail when we go outside. We live in an area with lots of ticks so I check her body after walks just in case.
We also use SimparicaTrio tablets with good results (ie no ticks found). Hadn't heard of using geranium oil, but will look into that as well. Thx for mentioning it.
Nexgard monthly chews seemed to work just fine for fleas/ticks.
Bravecto works great. It's basically a treat you feed them every 3 months and when a flea/tick latches onto their skin it poisons them and they fall off & die within a couple hours. I assume it's the same thing as Trio.
There's too many bad reviews with collars to risk it and if you have cats I think the oil tube's can get them sick if they lick your dog or whatever but I'm not 100% sure.
I've used bravecto for years, but we still find lots of ticks on our dogs. My vet claims that there is 1 type of tick that it stops working for at 2 months instead of 3. So I'm not sure but recently switched to nexguard and still finding ticks anyway 🤦♀️
do you back bravecto? cause i used it once and my pup is just 6 months and i want to stick to only one or like deworming tablets, tick prevention tablets also need to be changed ?
I’ve always used Bravecto - live in a high tick area and it’s been great.
Yeah I trust Bravecto but I'm just some random dude, you should just ask your vet & see what they reccomend, they might sell something different aswell.
My 5 year old beagle has been on it since a pup and I've never had any issues, we're in the woods daily and live on old farm land with tall grass and he hasn't caught lyme yet. (Also get lyme vaccine for extra protection). Just one tablet every 3 months + yearly vaccines and he's good to go.
Trio! Covers fleas ticks and heart worms
This. I live in a very wooded area and my poodle's coat is like velcro.
6 years now, I pull ticks off him all the time but no issues with lime disease due to the meds.
Saving because ive tried the monthly pills & my dogs had bad reactions Ive since tried the collar, the topical oil, shampoos, i even have chickens :(
I would assume it depends on where you live and the weight class of your dog but ranges for me (IL) 20-39$ a pill
Best flea and tick prevention for dogs
Key Considerations for Flea and Tick Prevention:
Type of Treatment:
Effectiveness: Look for products that are proven effective against both fleas and ticks. Check for active ingredients like fipronil, imidacloprid, or afoxolaner.
Safety: Ensure the product is safe for your dog's age, weight, and health condition. Consult your veterinarian, especially for puppies or dogs with health issues.
Lifestyle Considerations: Consider your dog's lifestyle. If they spend a lot of time outdoors or in wooded areas, a more robust prevention method may be necessary.
Additional Protection: Some products also repel mosquitoes and other pests, providing broader protection.
Recommendations:
Tip: Always consult with your veterinarian to choose the best option tailored to your dog's specific needs and lifestyle. Regularly check your dog for fleas and ticks, especially after outdoor activities.
Get more comprehensive results summarized by our most cutting edge AI model. Plus deep Youtube search.