TL;DR
Versatile Grills and Smokers
For those seeking versatility, Kamado grills are highly recommended as they can function both as grills and smokers. They offer more control over temperature compared to a standard Weber kettle [1:1]. The 22” Weber Smokey Mountain (WSM) is another popular choice due to its ease of use and reliability
[1:6].
Offset Smokers
If you prefer traditional stick burners, Oklahoma Joe offsets are praised for their ability to maintain a constant temperature and provide authentic smokehouse flavor [1:8]. These smokers require more attention but are rewarding for those who enjoy the process of managing fire and smoke
[4:3].
Pellet Smokers
Pellet smokers like those from Yoder and Recteq are recommended for their ease of use and advanced features like WiFi temperature monitoring [3:1]
[3:2]. Yoder smokers are noted for their durable construction and heat retention, making them a long-term investment
[3:6]. Recteq models allow for set-and-forget cooking, which can be ideal for busy individuals
[3:5].
Budget Considerations
For those on a budget, Traeger pellet smokers are accessible options under $1000, providing convenience with less manual oversight [4:4]. However, true wood-burning smokers tend to be more expensive, often exceeding $1000 for quality models
[4:2].
Beginner-Friendly Options
For beginners, electric pellet grills like Pitboss vertical models offer simplicity and precision in temperature control [4:1]. These models are user-friendly and allow novices to focus on learning flavors without the complexity of managing a fire.
In summary, the best smoker for you depends on your preferences for involvement in the smoking process, desired flavor profiles, and budget constraints. Whether opting for a versatile Kamado grill, a traditional offset smoker, or a modern pellet smoker, each offers unique benefits tailored to different cooking styles and needs.
Looking to buy a smoker. I wanted to know what you all reccomend.
Edit: max budget is about $1000. But I wanted to see what’s out there too.
So I am not a complete novice, but by no means an expert.
Wouldn’t cook for more than 12 people generally.
Looking to cook all the different cuts.
Prefer stick burner
Definitely get the 22” too. It’s the best and easiest smoker to use unless you want to spend $1,000+ on a decent offset.
Second this, easy to use, it’s really the best starter smoker that you can keep using your whole life without needing an upgrade.
Another recommendation would be getting a kamado type grill that is more versatile since it doubles as grill and smoker. Many people will mention a simple Weber kettle but it’s harder to smoke in a Weber kettle than a kamado type grill (in my opinion).
I use my smoker as a grill.
Loaded question..... Every smoker type has its pro/cons
Do you want to push a button and walk away? Do you like to play with fire and think that will be fun? How much food do you plan to cook at once? How much of a budget do you have?
Thanks buddy. Family likes what I smoke and that's all that matters!
Given that, I’d definitely choose a 22” Weber Smokey Mountain (WSM).
How easy is this to use compared to just using the kettle to smoke?
I bought my Oklahoma Joe offset for around $500, I really like it. It's a nice big size, it's easy to maintain a constant temp and it sounds like you have the hang of things. I think you're ready for a real offset smoker. Don't buy a kettle, they're too small imo and its hard to direct the heat away from whatever you're smoking.
Depends on what you like, I have a pit boss pellet smoker . Most are against a pellet smoker but I don't have to tend to the fire which allows me to do other things. It's just more convenient for me
What do you want it to do?
Best do it all at a reasonable price is probably a 22" Webber kettle grill
I second this question. Do you already have a regular grill? I have a Kamado it’s good for searing, grilling, and smoking.
I have the pro series 5 so I don't have the sear option but I did add a Blackstone griddle so I have that to sear on
Over seven years ago, I bought this Trailblazer at it's release. Since then, it's been rock solid cooking brisket to hot dogs and everything in-between. I know she looks old and busted, but I've never had a more reliable machine.
I guess I'll be sad to see her go. (My wife said she wants to give it to someone she knows who can't afford one themselves) Who knew I could get so attached to a smoker, though?
Are we talking the smoker or the wife here?
I'm confused, you're supposed to slowly increase the number of smokers you have over time.
My dad rocking 2 offset smokers under an ez up in the rain every holiday lmao
I literally just did this with my rec teq and Traeger for my daughter's 3rd birthday party 🤣🤣🤣 full blown thunderstorm the day before but I had to get it cooking!
That’s me when I do bigger cooks for the high school marching band. I’ve got a 250 gallon reverse flow, a 100 gallon traditional offset, and 2 masterbuilt electric smokers to act as warming cabinets. If push really comes to shove I have a kettle and an 85 gallon drum smoker I built but I prefer the flavor from the offsets for sure
Yep I was just going to say that you use the opportunity to upgrade to a bigger/better smoker as prime smoker and this becomes secondary backyard smoker
Are you referring to the wife or the smoker?
I'm just confused as to why you seem to have no say in the matter?
And she gave it away already? Who's the other lucky guy getting a free smoker?
Sand and high-temp paint. I'd say Cerakote it personally but doing that whole thing would be more than a new smoker.
Sounds like your wife is giving you the go ahead to buy a new one, which makes you very fortunate . Maybe you should do that, have a friend hold into this one for a few months, then bring it back and say "you'll never believe what I just found for free along the road!" Boom, two smokers.
Exactly. I think the smoker will be excited about cooking for a new wife.
Cause they don’t think it’s possible for an old smoker to look like a new one. In their mind, the moneys been made, smokers ran its course, OP uses it enough to upgrade/replace. I’d take this as an absolute win 🏆
If you can afford a smoker, you can afford a hooker.
Son is deployed and will be back next month. He is great at smoking meats and think he has a decent cooker...
But what would people recommend for a high quality smoker that can monitor temp.
Thanks... for a gift.
For a high quality pellet smoker look at Recteq. I've got an offset smoker, a Recteq, and a Weber. On the Recteq you set your temp and forget it, your phone keeps you posted.
Camp Chef Woodwind Pro is amazing.
Id ask him what his dream smoker would be.
I love my Recteq as well! Built like a tank.
Yoder
Another Yoder vote, they aren't the cheapest but they sure are nice.
Yoder for sure.
American made, hand welded pits and they are the thickest metal in the pellet smoker market. This means they are durable and they hold heat very well. Plus you get the WiFi / phone app that monitors everything. You can ‘design’ your smoke and the pit will follow your recipe by itself. Cool stuff.
I’ve had a ys640 with competition cart for 6 years. I still smile when I get to use it. 😁
I am a beginner here, I want to get a wood smoker, I would love to hear your recommendations! What is the best smoker for a beginner?
Depends on how committed you are.
The "good" smokers will be more than $1k. Anything below that is not going to be a great smoker.
The "best" smokers will be $2k+
If you're lucky you could find a decent used one relatively cheap.
Hint: anything they sell at big box stores is not a "good" smoker. They're cheap materials and cheaply made.
THIS IS AWESOME ADVICE!!! THANK YOU SO MUCH!!! what is the brand to check out?? Is traeger good?
I guess let's define "wood smoker".
There are wood smokers and pellet smokers.
Wood smokers use split logs for fire/heat and smoke.
Pellet smokers use wood pellets.
Traeger makes pellet smokers. They can be had for less than $1k. The prices I was quoting you were for true wood burning smokers.
Your best bet is to set a budget of what you're willing to spend and how much babysitting you're willing to put into the cook.
Offset smokers- Some decent ones in the $800s but they really don't get good until around 1200-1500. They tend to require more baby sitting. Steeper learning curve for them.
Pellet Grills are extremely easy to use. Won't produce the smokehouse flavor, but if it's a hobby you really love, there will always be a place for them for you to use.
I got started on Masterbuilt electrics. My dad used the propane. Very low maintenance, very easy to use, don't require much babysitting. Very low cost. A default recommendation to anyone for me who is considering them. Got pretty good producing decent BBQ on them.
Weber Smokey Mountain is a fairly easy to use, lower cost option. Weber Kettle is another one, also doubles as a grill. Both are still quite popular.
There are Drum Smokers- I know they can be had for a lower cost, but I have never used them.
A good place to look is CL or FB marketplace. Tons of smokers show up on there.
But if you're buying new. I would probably expect to invest somewhere between $300-800 depending on what you get. Get a decent meat thermometer. I would also suggest getting a wireless/blue tooth ones are worth it when learning IMHO. Figure out what you like before you get something nice.
Some tips-
What looks like a small jump in size on paper usually manifests in a big jump in actual size.
Figure out your storage situation before buying something. I'd love to get a offset, but I have no space in my garage for it. I also live in an area where a crackhead might wheel it off for scrap if it isn't stored away.
Check out workhorse pits
If you have an academy near you the old country pesos would probably work well for you
what is an academy?
Ok, so I'm going to say the terrible thing. For a beginner, you want easy. More precision temps and less effort. Set and forget. That sounds like an electric pellet grill to me. Yes, it has a slightly different flavour than actually cooking on burning wood, but not badly or too much, just different. For that reason I'd like to suggest a Pitboss 3 or 4 vertical grill as a beginner option. You can just turn it on and watch it do what you tell it to do. The biggest plus of a vertical that no other smoker will give you is that it has a huge window to watch what's going on. Standing there with beer watching the meat and smoke is better than standing there with a beer watching the smoke alone.
I'm curious to know what one product or item has had the biggest impact to improving your smoking experience.
First it was Actitube filters for my joints but then I got a dry herb vape and man it’s the best thing ever.
I went to a smoking lounge in Vegas and they offered a little glass mouth tip with joints. It was elite!
They unfortunately don’t sell them where i live and Amazon only offers packs of like 1,000 which… i don’t want to admit my habit to THAT extent 😅
definitely glass daisy screens or smojo screens.
yes it's totally possible to smoke with no screen, but debris and ash can easily get pulled through accidentally.
and they are universal so they work with almost every type of bowl or pipe.
people act like the nug plug is a genius move, it's not it literally blocks the airflow.
also I'm a dry pipe guy now, but I did love my recycler bongs and recycler rigs, way more effective than regular bongs.
A ball vape and a 12" beaker bong?
When i used to smoke, raw pre shaped ready to use filter tips. Then I discovered vaping. So dry herb vaporizers been a game changer for me .
This 1000% - better in every way
Hey everyone I’ve been wanting to get into smoking meat. I was wondering what everyone would recommend for a beginner or if there is much of a difference between brands or kinds?
Weber kettle or Weber Smokey Mountain.
Weber kettle.
Start small and cheap. You will learn a ton, still have great flavor.
If you don't like to work fire, wood or charcoal, you might go for a pellet smoker.
If you don't mind the work, you can go home made UDS or fabricated by a friend.
Ceramic egg is more expensive but your are still working charcoal.
Offset is another level, working with wood burning.
Went from a Kettle to a Smokey Mountain and I'm very happy with it. I was never able to get the kettle to maintain temperature easily without constantly messing with the vents. The smokey mountain is much more set it and forget it once charcoal is going.
I got an Akorn kamado for my first smoker. Still very happy with it 4ish years later. One day I’ll upgrade to a fancy ceramic kamado but for $300-400 it’s easy to learn with some YouTube and can crank out some delicious meat.
Same. It was a whole deal to get it properly sealed and to get over that learning curve but I have it dialed in pretty good now and make just amazing bbq. Someday Ill probably grab an auto smoker just for when I dont have time to baby sit things but I think the Akorn is the best value smoker out there
I own this as well. I added the Pitmaster IQ device and have basically a set it and forget it piece of equipment. The new Akorn has the computer built in so there's no need to add a separate temp control. I am totally happy as a backyard pitmaster using this equipment and it's extremely reasonable and versatile.
Offsets are a serious labor of love so that's entering hard mode, but is my personal favorite regardless and what I started on. If you can snag something like an Oklahoma Joe it's a decent starter. If you go too cheap it will be near impossible to maintain temps which is a chore on it's own while learning.
Pure easy mode would be a pellet grill, but you don't get near the flavor of an offset in my opinion. However, it's borderline set it and forget it. My father has a Traeger and my brother has a Pit Boss and I can't really tell much of a difference in taste. No idea on how one holds up vs the other though.
People love Weber stuff, but I don't have any experience with them. Might be a good middle ground?
*I'll also add that I used an upright propane smoker with wood chips and that is hands down the worst thing I've ever used in my life.
*I'll also add that I used an upright propane smoker with wood chips and that is hands down the worst thing I've ever used in my life.
Haha I have an upright propane smoker with a wood burn box. I've been able to use chunk wood in it rather than chips. I've been popping into a couple of recent posts like this one to see what people say as I've been considering an upgrade to something else.
I feel like I've gotten some good results and I don't want to force an unnecessary expense on myself. I do kinda like the convenience of the propane, and I get good smoke from the burn box. I also think I want to be able to continue to use chunk wood instead of pellets.
This is the only smoker I've ever used so maybe my opinion on the results has been skewed a little? idk
I've had great results with my cusinart propane vertical smoker. And I like that it's pretty portable.
At some point I might try and WSM or some kind of kamado. I've grilled with charcoal before. But what I have is working for me for now.
If you want to learn to manage the fire, then get a Weber Smokey Mountain. A kettle is more versatile but can be more difficult to maintain temps and has lower capacity.
If you just want to focus on recipes, then go for something automated like a pellet smoker.
I came to say this. I learned on a wsm. Still think it prob makes the best food I’ve ever made. It’s good to learn with fire. That being said I now have a Traeger and a recteq because it’s easier. So wsm for experience and taste or WiFi pellet grill for easy and can still make some dang good bbq.
The Pit Barrel Cooker is awesome for beginners. It regulates temperature really well so there’s practically no fiddling with fuel to maintain temperatures. Been using it for a few years and have made all sorts of great BBQ with it.
Also it’s only 55lb so it’s very portable, I have taken it on several vacations.
So my dad's birthday is coming up and I wanted to get him a smoker as he's wanted one for a long time but has never had the time/money but I've saved up about 500 dollars and I was wondering what would be the best option in that price range?
At that price point you can probably get a Weber. My dad has the Smokey Mountain and loves it. Should be available at Lowe's/Home Depot.
I super love the one I got from ZGrills. Def in the price range and a great starter. Easy to use wood pellets, and I've done many a fine tri tip and pork shoulder on it. Even done some veggie smoking, too
What one specifically?
https://www.zgrills.com/pages/pellet-grill-blind-box
I did their blind box, because I was OK with whatever model in that line I got (and it respected the budget)
Isn't that just a wood fire oven, then?
It’s many things, smoker, grill, stove. Super versatile and I’m still adding to it and changing the design. It’s a prototype
Oh, home made? Nice work!
Celebrating 30 years of life..decided to get a padron black. Great smoke. Wish I had money to smoke these more often.
What a way to mark 30. Padron black is a beast. Well deserved.
Happy 30th fella
HBD!! ENJOY! ✌️
Happy Birthday!
How does it compare to a Padron 1964 maduro
When I'm washing my hair at the end of the day....
I think it's in my eyebrow or nose hair. I can shampoo after a good smoke and still lingers.
I'm not really complaining, TBH.
You have never smelled my farts.
I bet your fart bubbles are something else
Like smoked pouperie.
The ribs coming off the smoker is better
I love running an errand and then driving back and getting close to my house and then you pick up a gentle whiff. And as you get closer, stronger. And then I park, and it's just roasted meat. My goodness...
*when there is meat cooking in the smoker.
best smokers
Key Considerations for Choosing the Best Smokers:
Type of Smoker:
Size and Cooking Capacity: Consider how much food you typically smoke. Larger models can accommodate more meat, which is ideal for gatherings.
Material Quality: Look for smokers made from heavy-duty steel for better heat retention and durability. Stainless steel is also a good option for longevity.
Temperature Control: Features like built-in thermometers and adjustable vents help maintain consistent temperatures, which is crucial for smoking.
Portability: If you plan to move your smoker frequently, consider its weight and whether it has wheels for easy transport.
Recommendations:
Weber Smokey Mountain Cooker: A highly regarded vertical smoker known for its excellent heat retention and ease of use. It comes in various sizes (14", 18", and 22") to fit different needs.
Traeger Pro Series 575: A top-rated pellet smoker that offers great flavor, ease of use, and Wi-Fi connectivity for remote monitoring. It’s versatile for both smoking and grilling.
Char-Griller Akorn Kamado: A budget-friendly option that provides excellent heat retention and versatility for grilling, smoking, and baking.
Choosing the right smoker depends on your experience level, the type of food you want to smoke, and your budget. Each of these options has its strengths, so consider what features are most important to you!
Get more comprehensive results summarized by our most cutting edge AI model. Plus deep Youtube search.