Build Quality and Durability
When it comes to build quality, both the Dell XPS and Lenovo ThinkPad are highly regarded, but they cater to slightly different preferences. The ThinkPad is often praised for its ruggedness and durability, with features like a carbon fiber chassis and spill resistance [4]. This makes it particularly appealing for business users who need a reliable machine for travel or field use
[5:3]. On the other hand, while the XPS series is known for its sleek design and high-quality materials, some users have noted a decline in quality over time
[4:2].
Performance and Features
In terms of performance, the Dell XPS is often highlighted for its powerful specs at a competitive price point, making it suitable for demanding tasks like machine learning and simulations [4]. However, if you require a dedicated GPU for your work, it's important to consider the potential drawbacks such as overheating and increased bulk
[4:5]. The ThinkPad P-Series, on the other hand, offers models with dedicated GPUs and is recommended for those needing robust performance for professional applications
[2:4].
User Experience and Preferences
The user experience can vary significantly between the two brands. ThinkPads are renowned for their excellent keyboards, which many users find crucial for productivity [1:7]. Additionally, ThinkPads tend to have better Linux compatibility, which could be a deciding factor if you plan to dual boot or primarily use Linux
[5]. Conversely, the Dell XPS is favored by some for its superior display quality, which can enhance the overall user experience, especially when working with visual content
[4:4].
Price and Value
Price is another key consideration. ThinkPads are often seen as more expensive due to their enterprise-focused features, but buying used or previous-generation models can offer significant savings [4:1]. The XPS line, while generally priced lower than brand-new ThinkPads, may not offer the same level of enterprise support or durability, which could impact long-term value
[2:5].
Conclusion
Ultimately, the choice between a Dell XPS and a Lenovo ThinkPad for business purposes will depend on your specific needs and preferences. If you prioritize durability, keyboard quality, and Linux compatibility, a ThinkPad might be the better option. However, if you're looking for a powerful machine with a great display at a competitive price, the Dell XPS could be more suitable. Consider visiting a store to get a hands-on feel for each model, as personal comfort with the device can also play a crucial role in your decision [1:5].
Can anybody that used laptops from both brands describe the differences between them? Either Inspiron or XPS is okay but do compare one with Lenovo's Thinkpad lineup.
If anyone has only used an Inspiron or XPS, please just tell me what you like and do not like about them. Both hardware and software discussions are welcome.
Try limiting the comparisons within laptops between 13" and 15" though. And no, I'm not rich; I'll be getting a lower-end model from one of the three as I'd much prefer build quality over specs (and i5+8GB is sufficient for me).
I'm trying to decide which of the three to get, essentially. Please don't include laptops of other brands/series, namely HP (doesn't seem like people loved their service) and Apple (doesn't like OS).
If you're looking for a business notebook, it's the Latitudes for midrange/high end and Vostro for lower end vs ThinkPads.
If you compare consumer notebooks vs business notebooks, build quality of the business notebooks will win every time because they cost almost twice as much spec for spec.
Just moved on from an Inspiron 7472 back to ThinkPads. The 7472 was the highest-end (7000 series) of the Inspirons.
Performance was consistent, but that's true for most midrange and higher end computers these days. Screen was great for the time. Upgradability was still good (socketed RAM/WiFi/ M.2 and SATA), but much poorer nowadays; however, that applies to ThinkPads as well. Keyboard was mediocre at best. Thermals were okay, but I had to have the fan replaced twice under warranty FWIW.
For most people, durability shouldn't be a concern. Nevertheless, even entry-level ThinkPads use objectively better materials. I've tried (but have not owned) XPS 13/15s over the years and honestly have been very impressed.
What are your use cases? How important to you are bezels? Keyboard? Durability? Upgradability? Onsite support?
As an aside, even when on a budget, I would strongly avoid the lower end 3000-series Inspirons: low-end plastic construction and generally poor components (esp. screen).
You might actually be happy with a previous-generation ThinkPad if budget is a concern. A T480 or later will have quad core i5s, which IMO will suffice for Android development.
If you are still interested in Dells, their Latitude series of business laptops are more comparable to ThinkPads.
You may want to stop by a Best Buy or similar and get a feel for laptops first hand. I've never seen a Thinkpad at a retail store, but IMO it's helpful to feel first hand what those extra couple hundred dollars are buying you when you get higher SKUs. Less plastic, less flex, nicer chassis, better hinges, better feeling keyboards and trackpads, etc.
I can't comment personally because I haven't used a Thinkpad newer than an X230 but it does have amazing build quality. I have an HP Firefly from work and it's super nice too (just anecdata).
I have both the xps 13 2in1 & the x1 yoga gen 5. Both have 512gb ssd, 16gb ram, & 4k display. Xps has the i7-1065G7 processor, x1 yoga has the i5-10210U processor. Decided to keep the xps 13.
In terms of build quality, finish, & features, the x1 yoga wins hands down. Smooth edges & hinges, physical camera shutter, more ports, weighs about the same, has a stylus built in, amazing keyboard, quiet fans, & a brighter screen. I liked everything about the x1 yoga except the cpu performance, it stuttered playing 4k video, or even multi tasking. I got another replacement from Lenovo, same performance issues. The xps 13 didn't suffer from these stutters.
Xps 13 is a great laptop but it does suffer from loud fan & the build quality, while sturdy, feels a little unrefined. The 16:10 aspect ratio is fantastic, screen is awesome, keyboard is not bad, & performance is fast.
It came down to performance & price which dell won both categories
16:10 - this should be the defining factor
XPS and the Thinkpads of 2021 have both of those.
I think the build quality and quality control on Thinkpads are better. Nonetheless, the recent XPS 13 series is very highly regarded everywhere. I had XPS 13 and XPS 15 and they were all fine. But my Thinkpad X1 Nano plays in my opinion in another league. (You can compare it to the XPS 9310 or how they call it.
I would never buy a 16:9 Device anymore. I would rather opt for an XPS 13 than for a Thinkpad.
Help! I currently have an HP and its on its last life. I am using a lot of different software for my job (one of them being unity). I am doing a lot of simulation work, machine learning, and coding and I need something fast that can handle just about anything. I have been looking at the DELL XPS and the Lenovo Thinkpad. Any thoughts on these? Or any other recommendations
XPS for the win.
thinkpad, no contest.
I second u/chethedog10 recommendation for a ThinkPad. Look into something Like a Lenovo ThinkPad P-Series such as a ThinkPad P1.
AVOID DELL XPS's like the plague, unless you enjoy swapping out motherboards every couple of months.
I second this. I'm not a fan of Dell.
We usually recommend HP or Lenovo to our customers.
Important question you have to consider: Do you need a dedicated GPU?
The Thinkpad P1 Gen series do have them, but just make sure before you buy.
Exactly. But, XPS is designed for Prosumers not business and the people who use them need understand that. No business is buying a Thin laptop with a GPU that overheats. Also, none of them have Vpro.
Thinkpads are great, I personally have an older model but I’m pretty confident there are new models that can meet your needs
You should use macbook for professional work
ThinkPads no longer seem to be an attractive option. I’ve noticed that most of the posts in this community are about ThinkPads that are at least three years old. It's rare to see posts about the newer T, X, or P series. Perhaps it's because of the high prices and the lack of innovation that fewer people are buying ThinkPads? At the same price point, the MacBook Pro appears to be the more popular choice among users compared to ThinkPads or other laptops in the same range.
Very valid point. I still think the new ones are nice, but have overall lost their “thinkpad” identity in the grand scheme of things. Heck, many laptops have, as everyone now is trying to replicate the MacBooks build and design and I hate apple for it. Sadly it’s what majority of consumers/market demand so Lenovo has to to compete. Frustrating and sad, really
I’m switching back and forth between a work MBP 16 Pro and a T14 Gen 3 and sometimes I wish I could unite them in some ways. The T14 feels so light and plasticky in comparison, I’d like to call it Thinkpad Air. Battery-wise, the MBP is phenomenal. Just give me that full day on the Thinkpad please! Keyboard-wise, I’m always on the fence. Sometimes I like the Mac’s slightly firmer keys better. But in layout, Thinkpad is the clear winner. I hate Apple’s key layout. It’s just different for the sake of being different. (background: I never had a Macbook before this, but I did several Thinkpads, and I’m still a Thinkpad fan.)
That's to be expected, and it's always been like this if you look back a decade and more.
The majority of posters on here buys used, and used devices are only available in large quantities as three-plus year-old corporate lease returns. That (the enterprise and SMB markets) is Lenovo's core Thinkpad customer base, not individuals.
Agreed. This is an enthusiast forum. I've used ThinkPads in the Corporate world for the past 15 years and never once thought to join this subreddit ... until I started considering buying a laptop for personal use and at modest cost. I've bought an L14 and couldn't be happier with it, and it compares favourably to my P14s and T14s I use through work. And none of these seem of lesser quality than the T480s, etc I used a few years ago.
Exactly this! I remember back in the day when the T40- and T60-series was the popular choice, and everything that came after them was shit. Granted, the quality of those machines was on another level compared to the newer ones, but ThinkPads are still popular to this day and I'm sure will continue be.
I had a couple bad P series that needed main board swaps but the T14 series has been rock solid. I support a couple hundred Lenovos and MacBooks. Even the L series has been a solid value choice. ZOMG who here has changed out a P series keyboard? Like 73 screws JUST for the friggin keyboard. I didn’t know.
incorrect.
There is a fair bit of buzz on the new T series as it seems to mark a return to serviceability and upgrade ability.
The reason why people buy the older Thinkpads in part is the thinkpad community has a large Hobbyist and Linux component. We are tinkerers by nature and like an object which can be tweaked, customized and made unique. We don’t necessarily buy into the captive ecosystem approach of Apple.
Also we don’t like e waste. Built in obsolescence drives us crazy. upgrading a screen, maxing out memory and throwing in a SSD on a 15 year old laptop can give new life to old hardware and keep precious metal materials out of the landfill.
It also needs to be understood that the newest ThinkPad models have never really been popular among enthusiasts/consumers. ThinkPads are primarily marketed towards enterprises and let's be real, for most people they're just overpriced for what they offer as brand new devices since consumers don't have much use for onsite servicing and other enterprise support stuff. Whenever the enterprises replace their ThinkPads (usually after 3/5 years), that's when the consumers/enthusiasts start to get their hands on them.
This was (the x201) imho the last true thinkpad like design. Real led indicators, led shine down keyboard light, ports, thicckkk enough its comfortable to use all day, and great old fashion keyboard, not that crappy new mac like one with minimal key travel. Very much disliked the work t470, t480, t490s, and t14 ive recently had.
Really miss and prefer the old clunky modular design personally.
Hoping the retro community has some good tricks one day to make a really nice drop in mobo that doesnt involve hacking up the case, loss of ports, features etc.
Yeah, integrated everything is frustrating. Have you seen the Framework laptops?
I like an older T/P/W/X series but it was really windows that moved me away from ThinkPads.
Rocking a T440p since the beginning of 2015. Best laptop ever. But even after a few upgrades I might have to get a newer model in the near future. Would love to have a new model in the same spirit as the T440p.
Costs 1000$ to buy a modded thinkpad with 8th gen CPU. Put 200 more grab latest T14 maxed out.
Thanks to some of you lovely people, I learned that macbook is not necessary. Thank heavens, because i am personally a windows person. I was only worried that macbook would be more compatiable with unix/linix, but i guess that's not the case, esp with the new M1 chips.
Anyways, I narrowed down my options to two machines: Dell xps vs Lenovo Thinkpad. The Dell is more powerful for models at comparable same price point but the Lenovo is more durable with a carbon fiber chassis and spill resistance. Which should I get?
XPS quality has declined over the years. My GF has a Thinkpad with a 3rd gen Ryzen and uses it for her PhD work (lots of simulation, R, and Python) and it's been fantastic.
thanks for the info. whats her phd in, just about of curiosity?
No prob. Climate Science/Physics.
In the end, it doesn't matter.
A new Thickpad does cost a lot more than they are worth because they make little money on their direct to customer. So, they artificially increase the customer price to make it seem like their business customers are getting a deal. But a used Thickpad can be had pretty cheaply since their are so many business that count it as depreciated after 3 years and let it go. And depending on the model, it's compatibility with Linux is unbeatable (I want to say Red Hat employees use these), and it can be upgraded quite easily. But it's not like the XPS isn't compatible with Linux (they have a Linux option).
But if you couldn't tell by the way I'm writing about it, I find the form factor for the Thickpad to be atrocious.
But in the end of the day, you should be connecting it to an external keyboard and display at least 90% of the time (that is, unless you hate your 50 year old self), so it's not like form factor should be a key issue.
>And depending on the model, it's compatibility with Linux is unbeatable (I want to say Red Hat employees use these), and it can be upgraded quite easily. But it's not like the XPS isn't compatible with Linux (they have a Linux option).
what about the lenovo models make them more compatible to Linux than other windows machines?
They use standard off the shelf components. There's a subreddit dedicated to Thinkpads running linux /r/LinuxOnThinkpad/ that can probably answer all your questions.
The one with the best screen. At the end of the day you want the most area for your eyes and code. I used to be a thinkpad guy but the XPS is just too nice.
Personally, I think a laptop with a discrete GPU is more trouble than it's worth. They're power hungry, so you either wind up with a heavier and bulkier cooling system, or with a laptop that overheats all the time. The driver architecture is more fragile, so things tend to go wrong more often if you're plugging and unplugging from an external monitor or dock. And for all this, laptop GPUs don't perform particularly well compared to their desktop counterparts. Not to mention, they're considerably more expensive.
If you plan to run games on it, then none of this matters and you'll just get the GPU version. But for OMSCS, you don't need it.
Another personal preference of mine is to stick with business-class laptops, for the build quality and good warranty service. For that reason, I would choose either the Thinkpad or a Dell Latitude. I like the Latitude 5320/5420/5520 for its robustness, easy repairability/upgradeability and no-issues Linux compatibility. But the Thinkpad X1 Carbon is also really good.
Whichever one you like better.
A novel idea, this.
I’ve looked at: tuxedo, laptop with Linux, framework laptops. I’ve haven’t done 20 hours of research but im going to take it that thinkpads are among the best laptops you can buy commercially. So im edging towards that product line.
My use case: Linux of course as my daily drive, I prefer to have dual boot windows (only use in a military/DoD setting other wise it’s Linux) I mostly focus on light programming, networking.
The appeal of a think pad is their general construction, which I find particularly solid for general field use/travel etc. I’d you had a budget between $700-1500 what would you buy right now if it was your money?
Im looking at a gen 5 thinkpad 14s on Lenovo outlet. Thoughts?
If it was your money, what would you drop it on right now?
I personally would prefer framework because I prioritize repairability, the climate and control over hardware. Though if I were to choose something else, Lenovo Thinkpads would be my next option.
I would look at a Lenovo Thinkpad which has either Intel core ultra 5 (or 7) 200 series OR AMDs ryzen AI 5 (or 7) 300 series. Minimum 16GB ram, pref 32.
Intel has better battery life (not 100% sure if it has better performance) than AMD, check just josh reviews to check out laptop CPU reviews. It would be your choice of 14 or 16 inch and if the CPU needs to be power efficient or performance (Intel has 200V (power save) or 200H (performance)). I have seen decent options of 1500 or below in this category.
I checked a couple of AMD devices on Lenovos website, they come with Mediatek wifi cards. These specfic models are supported in Linux, but be aware that Intel WiFi cards have the best support on Linux. The Intel Lenovo laptops commonly uses AX211, which is fully supported (but WiFi 6E vs WiFI 7 if that matters to you).
> I personally would prefer framework because I prioritize repairability
Except every review on Framework systems state that their basic premise of being module and updateable is false. Most upgrades require buying SEVERAL modules to perform and at that point, it's not a update, it's called BUYING A NEW SYSTEM. So you spend more money up front for a mediocre system, and you're stuck with it just like ANY OTHER VENDOR.
OP should just buy a Lenovo and when they need something newer/better, sell the old one on Ebay and get something new.
You are missing my point, but yes; OP should choose Lenovo instead.
I'd buy a second hand thinkpad and save myself a lot of money. Personally I'd go for a T480, others may have different recommendations.
Just be sure to get the FHD resolution screen and not the last century 1366x768 or you'll spend all your time scrolling back and forth.
+1 and a bit more advice on buying used thinkpads:
https://forums.linuxmint.com/viewtopic.php?p=2484241#p2484241
Framework
Apologies if this falls foul of rule 2 as is discusses not ThinkPad, although only in relation to ThinkPads so I'm hoping it will be allowed. Please remove if not appropriate.
This is both a discussion about specific models but also brands more generally. I'm in need of a new laptop, no heavy workloads or anything, just something to chuck a lightweight Linux distro on and do mostly terminal work. I also like a small form factor (oh how I wish netbooks would have stuck around longer!).
I understand that thinkpads in general are praised for playing nice with Linux, and the two mentioned are appreciated for the build quality, ease of finding replacement parts and the ability to mix and match parts, aftermarket modding ect. All of this appeals to me.
The only downside seems to be they have become a victim of their own success, now commanding prices that I find hard to personally (and to my partner) justify for such old machines.
Are there any other companies (or even just specific models/series) that offer some or all of the qualities for which these specific ThinkPads are beloved? Any other manufacturer that comes close to the open nature or build quality? Any other company that has (or had at some point in time) a reputation for simple reliable machines?
x280/380 then?
I did look at those, but they seem a lot more locked down in terms of what you can do with them. Plus my last laptop was an x240 and the motherboard has failed from flexing too much so I'm worried the build quality isn't as good as they used to be. Please feel free to correct me if I'm wrong
mobo flex affect most on xx40-70 and some 80 series, probably you knew how to add shim or extra sponges to make it flex less when lifted at corner. 13" don't have ram slot anymore after x270, so maybe hard to find small lightweight that fit your requirements, but take a look at t14s for lightweight but less upgrade, or t14 amd gen1.
Or if you have money at right place, see if framework laptops fit you more without trackpoint ofc
Dell Latitude
Interesting. What about them is similar?
They're also pro business laptops. Just like HP elitebooks..
There are newer X-series laptops. The X240, for instance is not very popular, due to the touchpad, but the touchpad can be replaced with a X250 type pad.
These are, old machines, but not old enough to be modded with the classic 7-row keyboard of the X220. Therefore they are not as collectible and you may be able to find a deal on them. They will also come standard with better eDP displays.
Or, cut to the chase and look for a X250, which came with the "good" touchpad as standard. Again, it's old enough to be cheap, but it's not particularly collectible.
I’ve heard from many sources that Thinkpad is one of if not that best brands of work laptops. However, I’ve also heard that in recent years the durability they once had has been greatly diminished, but that some current models still display that same level of resilience.
Anyone know anything more about this? If it’s true that there’s still a good modern model, which one is it?
Both of those things are true. Durability and quality has gone down across the board in pursuit of thinner and lighter designs, and yet Thinkpads are still some of the best.
Lots of people use older models and throw Linux on them. If that’s feasible for you it’s a great option.
But if you need real durability check out the Panasonic Toughbook; those are made to withstand just about anything you could possibly throw at them.
We called them Stinkpads, but we still thought they were good, except for the red nub in the middle of the keyboard.
Does anyone know somebody who uses that? They’re sticking to it still so there has to be a reason lol What’s the use case.
I haven’t used that in years. I have a Dell Latitude with a nub but never use it.
They are still one of the best, the lower end models specifically the E are not as rugged as the past. But the T or P series will get you what you need.
Just make sure the model you get doesn't have soldered ram and such so you can upgrade it in the future.
Quality tanked since production moved to china. Not the premium price though.
The E14/E15 Gen 2 had a mainboard fault where the PD charge controller chip wouldn't turn two power transistors fully on, so they got so hot they literally melted their own solder and disconnected.
Every ThinkPad before and after has been rock solid, and even the ones with the fault are easy and cheap enough to fix.
small business serial: cax15wp1c1653p
consumer serial: rkxn7590dqmo
There's no difference between the specs other than the former comes with windows 10 pro vs home for the latter.
But are there any other differences I should be aware of between a small business product vs a consumer product? are the respective tech supports any better or worse? Warranty/replacement?
Also, just to confirm the consumer XPS comes with Dell Cinema 2.0. Can I assume the business version comes with it as well even though it isn't listed in the product page?
Looks like the same hardware to me. Sometimes they will have specialized hardware for one or the other, but generally that's only with workstations and servers.
Generally, warranties and support are better on the business side of products since businesses can't mess around with stuff while people can get jerked around all the time.
As far as the camera, I would NOT assumed that it does come included. And this would make sense why the consumer version costs more as well. However, I bet you could add it to the business one and the price end up the same as the consumer one.
And one thing to keep in mind is that both of these are consumer in terms of quality. Even though one machine is being sold as business, it is going to be no more robust than the consumer version. And in my experience I consider these type of business systems 'consumer crap' as they don't last like real business or enterprise products do.
I appreciate the help. I chatted with support before I bought it in regards to the Dell Cinema 2.0 and the guy confirmed that the business laptop has it as well but he wouldn't give me a guarantee for some reason...
Have them give you the expresscode of the one you're about to buy so you can check the specs in Dell's support section. It would suck to buy it and it then not have a camera.
From some quick searches to see if the business and consumer version are separate, they aren't, so as long as the camera is an option that you're purchasing that's all that should matter.
I’m starting a small business and am in the market for a reliable Windows laptop. I’m currently considering either the Lenovo ThinkPad T14s (AMD) or the X1 Carbon (Intel). Could you recommend a Dell laptop that would be comparable to these models and priced under $1200 USD? It doesn’t have to be the latest model, a 2024 laptop would work just fine. I’ll primarily be using it for the Microsoft Office suite, web browsing, and light productivity tasks. Thanks in advance for your help!
There are T14s on Ebay with factory warranty for around $400 which are Gen 3 and Gen 2 with I5 and I7 processors and other T16 Gen 2 ($739.99) and X1 Carbon Gen 11 ($919.99).
I am doing the same as you are and I am looking for 2.
Lenovo ThinkPad T16 Gen 2
X1 Carbon Gen 11 (Open Box) i7-1365U (13th Gen) 32GB 512GB Intel Iris $919.99 Warr 2/28
Look at the Dell Pro 14 Plus Laptop It's right at your $1200 price point.
I suggest the Pro 14 "Plus" since it has an aluminum chassis. The less expensive entry Pro 14 is plastic.
I would also suggest checking out the HP Elitebook at Microcenter. It's $849 for a previous model. But still great and very high quality.
I’ve worked with Dell Latitude laptops for years. They’re very reliable.
ETA I bought a Latitude 5420 and upgraded the RAM & SSD myself as it was cheaper to do it this way.
Dell Pro are the new name for the Latitude. They are reliable systems. Get the ProSupport Plus warranty. There is an ultra 5, 16 gb memory, 512 gb SSD. Nice system and is in your budget. https://www.dell.com/en-us/shop/deals-for-business/dell-pro-16-laptop/spd/dell-pro-pc16250-laptop/?_gl=1*1tlkenb*_up*MQ..*_gs*MQ..&gclid=Cj0KCQjw953DBhCyARIsANhIZobY2glO2sgLgv3L6SWDTLS1fgSNU0pFaA77-HpaHcbUOEKubMhwsPQaAtqMEALw_wcB&gclsrc=aw.ds&gbraid=0AAAAADllXQesnkmzkpPg6wNGvlK6mA5p-
OP is comparing it to 14" machines, so the two he'd probably want to look at are the AMD vs. Intel Dell Pro Plus 14 for the T14s, and the Dell Pro Premium 14 for the X1 Carbon.
The Pro Premium would be "definitely not for $1200 or less" but the Pro Plus with either processor hits just under $1200 (before tax and warranty expension.
The Dell Pro 14 (non-Plus) is well under, and probably good enough. Hopefully it's more like the T14 and less like Lenovo's cheaper series (L14 or E14) - I haven't seen one in person to assess the build or a detailed teardown (which Notebookcheck has done for the Premium)
I have a Dell Latitude 3520 with 16gb of DDR4 Ram and a 256gb SSD…that’s more than enough for those tasks and I got it for $100 on Facebook Marketplace.
You don’t really have to go all in unless you need the power.
dell xps vs thinkpad for business
Key Considerations for Dell XPS vs. ThinkPad for Business:
Build Quality:
Keyboard and Trackpad:
Performance:
Battery Life:
Port Selection:
Support and Warranty:
Recommendation:
Ultimately, your choice should depend on your specific needs, such as typing comfort, portability, and design preferences.
Get more comprehensive results summarized by our most cutting edge AI model. Plus deep Youtube search.