Jojoba oil. Works wonder on my waterproof eyeliner too.

Take a Q-tip and soak it in olive oil. Then hold the Q-tip to your lashes and rub the olive oil in as good as you can. It should come off with warm water pretty easily 😊

Coconut oil works well

Oil based cleanser/cleansing balm. No need to scrub. Follow with a water based cleanser.

cleansing oil. it melts everything without damaging the skin/lashes

have you tried the kiss me mascara remover? it's a japanese brand and it's the best. can get rid of my judydoll mascara (literally the hardest product i've tried to remove)

I use eye makeup remover with an old mascara brush. It fully coats my lashes so I can gently wipe it or rinse and it all comes off.

Try applying a waterproof over a non water proof mascara. It comes right off when you use any cleanser, but stays waterproof otherwise. I learned it from Wayne goss years ago. Works like a charm!

Oil-based cleansers or oil.

You can do a double cleanse. First, oil to break down everything and then a cleansing gel that’s safe to use around your eyes. I like this method because it removes face from my whole face. If there’s some stubborn makeup around your eyes use micellar water.

When I use Clinique Take Off the Day balm on my whole face I rub a bit over my eyes and then take a shower after and that gets it off without stinging or aggressive rubbing. The product is so oily and thick that it does the work for you

Petroleum jelly (Vaseline). It’s completely sting-free, very gentle, just rub gently until the mascara is dissolved & wipe away. It will also condition your eyelashes and promote growth. Oh, and it’s as cheap as chips! Try it, you’ll love it. (Baby oil stings my eyes)

Cleansing oil on a cotton round—but don’t rub for a bit, just put it on your eye and let it rest there for a minute. It starts to dissolve the makeup and then it’ll come off with gentler motiob

Use baby oil to remove the mascara (GENTLY with your fingers) and then use the cloth to wipe the excess off. Your eye area will be moisturized and the baby oil will help your lashes grow!

Try cleansing oils or cleansing balms - they tend to be gentler on the skin and remove makeup from your face by bonding with and chemically breaking down the makeup. You'll irritate your skin much more by scrubbing at makeup with a cloth. There's a wide range of products at different price points, so try looking up the keywords for recommendations and usage experiences from others.

I love the Clinique Take the Day Off cleansing balm. I'm a stickler for waterproof mascara and I only use a small amount (pea size?) rub between my fingers and then massage gently over my eyes for a bit, rinse, and then use my usual cleanser for my whole face. It works wonders for all makeup (like a full face day) but I conserve and mostly use it on the mascara. Hope that helps! Bonus: comes in a travel size too!

The real question is, « how do I remove waterproof mascara without also removing all of my eyelashes? » 🙈

I use Garnier Micellar water with the blue cap. It’s for waterproof makeup. It works just fine

Coconut oil works on literally the toughest makeup

Any oil cleaner, also you should always doble cleanse specifically if you wear makeup / sunscreen.

Try oil cleansing

I have extremely sensitive skin and can’t use any makeup removers without them burning.

The cloth brand “Makeup Eraser” works well for me, even on waterproof eye makeup. You need hot water, hold the cloth over the eye for 10-15 seconds, then it will start to come off.

Makeup Eraser towels work well for me.

Have you tried tubing mascaras?

Use a type of plain oil you're not allergic to. (Like olive oil, coconut oil, vitamin E oil)

I know what you mean, I need intensely waterpoof mascara and a lot of it. Micellar water doesn't really work without scrubbing, liquid eye makeup remover is only marginally better.

Cleansing balm works best. And is not oily to me. I liked the Clinique one but it is expensive. At the cheapest pricing online, $8.22 USD per ounce.

I just recently tried the Garnier version instead, and not only does it work twice as well, it works out to $3.57 an ounce.

Any cleansing oil, or cooking oil for that matter, will take waterproof mascara off.

I swear by baby oil. I’ve been using is for 15+ years. Never irritates my eyes. I’ve tried makeup removers, wipes, other oils, lotion. Baby oil is the only thing that gets everything off, doesn’t irritate, and moisturizes my skin and lashes. Highly recommend!!!

Ponds cold cream, one swipe and off it comes!

Olive oil or coconut oil works really well.

Clinique Take the Day Off liquid remover

I have never been able to get mascara off with micellar water, even the non waterproof

Use an oil based makeup remover.

Micellar water won’t effectively remove waterproof makeup. I’d recommend the Neutrogena oil-free liquid makeup remover or a Makeup Eraser towel. Never use wipes!

Maybe soak a cotton round in the micellar and lay down with it over your eye? That may soak the product enough that it'll slide off the hair shafts

Coconut oil, it takes off all of my waterproof mascara without damage.

Biphasic micellar water. Pick a cotton disk, or a reusable one, doesn't matter, and pour some on it. Keep it on your eye for at least 15 seconds and then start to swipe delicately until all of it comes off 

Coconut oil

Biphasic micelara water. The one from the Sephora brand is the best

Coconut oil is the easiest and great to have around because it's versatile - body lotion, hair, cooking.

Kiss Me Heroine Make Speedy Mascara remover. Comes in a mascara tube. Stuff is magic. They have it on iHerb if you don’t want to shop Amazon

I use tubing mascaras, and I use either warm water or micellar water on a cotton pad. I hold it to my lashes and it melts off.

it has suspicious ingredients because it's an ancient product, but i use good ol' albolene to take everything off. drag queens generally use it, if that tells you anything.

I love the Clinique take the day off eye makeup remover. It’s oil based but don’t let that scare you, because In the end it will help moisturize your eyes. If you were contacts I suggest to take your contacts off first. Soak a cotton pad with it place the pad on your eye for like 5 seconds then you can gently take off. Easy peasy ❣️🥰

Micelles water

You can use coconut oil to remove mascara. It will work great for you.