TL;DR
Series Recommendations
Several series were recommended across discussions for fans of The Sinner. The Killing is frequently mentioned as having a similar vibe, with its dark and intricate plot [1:2],
[2:1],
[5:4]. True Detective, especially season 1, is noted for its compelling storytelling and complex characters
[2:2],
[3:5]. Mare of Easttown is another popular recommendation, praised for its gritty realism and strong performances
[2:4],
[3:7].
Other series that capture the psychological and mystery elements of The Sinner include Broadchurch, known for its intense drama and emotional depth [3:4],
[5:2], and Mindhunter, which delves into the minds of serial killers
[5:2],
[3:3].
Unique Series Suggestions
Some lesser-known series that might appeal to fans of The Sinner include Marcella, Orphan Black, Thirteen, Top of the Lake: China Girl, Retribution, The Five, The Forest, Black Spot, and The End of the F**king World [1:3]. These shows offer unique plots and intriguing characters, often exploring psychological themes and mysteries.
Movie Recommendations
For those who enjoyed The Sinner, the movie I Don't Feel At Home in the World Anymore on Netflix is suggested as having a similar vibe to The End of the F**king World [1:6]. This film combines dark humor with a sense of mystery and is likely to resonate with fans of unconventional narratives.
Additional Recommendations
In addition to series and movies, other suggestions include Sharp Objects and Haunting on Hill House for their psychological depth and suspenseful storytelling [5:2]. These recommendations aim to provide viewers with engaging content that mirrors the psychological intrigue and complexity found in The Sinner.
I’ve never really seen anything quite like this, it’s unusual plot just really intrigued me. Can anyone recommend me series that are a bit out of the box?
The killing! Is so much like the sinner. Great suggestion from the person above ����
The Killing is 1000x better
All these great. End of the f ing world. Loved it
If you liked "End of the F**king World", then watch the movie "I Don't Feel At Home in the World Anymore" on Netflix. It has the same vibe to it.
Thanks so much !
The Night Of - an HBO miniseries.
Amazing!!
Seven Seconds - Netflix
The Missing on Amazon Prime, but only season 2 (it's an anthology so you can start anywhere). Incredible story, very complex with multiple timelines. The main detective has a lot of similarities to Bill Pullman's character. Super satisfying.
Season 1 has some good aspects but a terrible ending.
Already seen mindhunter, couldn’t really get into broadchurch for some reason...any recommendations?
We have Netflix Hulu and prime.
True Detective
The Fall used to be on netflix but isn’t anymore :( it’s available to stream for free elsewhere though it seems
Mare of Eastown, ur welcome
Mare of east town
This one is sometimes on Netflix so I'm sorry if it's not, but The Killing! It's a remake of a Swedish show, it's got similar vibes for me.
Wow thanks for all the responses, adding a ton to my lists!
Mare of easttown
Just finished this, pretty good show. (Most) of the acting is top notch, but feel like it’s held back by some poor writing decisions, plus didn’t really feel like the main case was as interesting as it could’ve been
Broadchurch
Yes I've seen it I love it
True detectives season 1
Are the others not good, I have been meaning to try it but keep hearing its hard to follow
Just finished my 4th rewatch and haven’t seen a single other season
Still not talking to you
for real. Seasons 2 and 3 are good but season 1 is another level.
The Fall. British show about a serial killer
Interesting you mention “Get Out.”
No only will “Sinners” have the “Get Out” effect where word of mouth will have it have a long time making bank in theaters (I think next weekend will make as much or more than this weekend’s $49 million); Sinners is kind of like Get Out in a way plot wise but mixed with “O’ Brother Where Art Thou.”
O’ Brother Where Art Thou?
You mean the Odyssey?
The Odyssey was the source material, but Homer didn’t know about bluegrass music!
The Mississippi setting and music focus definitely connects Sinners and O’ Brother.
Oh that’s a good comparison
Now yall hyped me up to see this movie😂. Im going to see it regardless and tell my parents to see it if they can. However i hope it does good too because this just further invests in Bryan cooglers career. This will also motivate him to create movies representing black voices outside of hype and more original in terms of plot.
>It's honestly more refreshing than most Marvel and DC movies
That ain't saying much lmao...
Hollywood's in a superhero, reboot, 20 year later sequel tails pin. It's refreshing to see something new and interesting get made.
It’s primarily been reboots and sequels and adaptations of pre-existing IP since the 80’s.
Black fantasy cinema makes money the powers that be just don't want us seen in a positive light on TV or the big screen unless a white person is centered. They're willing to lose money because of this.
(Some spoilers ahead)
​
I really enjoyed both seasons, but I liked season 1 better.
​
For me, it was brilliant that everything got answered by the last episode, no bs cliffhangers so they get renewed. It was refreshing that the mistery wasn't something supernatural but purely psychological. The fucked up childehood that the protagonist and her sister had, and in top of all, the hell released in a small town.
​
Any other shows that has some of this aspects currently been streamed on netflix?
Give Sharp Objects (HBO) a try. Or Broadchurch (its on netflix) is also an exceptionally well made show.
If your looking for more of a gritty show watch Mindhunter on netflix.
So many good shows that are kinda similar in different ways.
Hope this helps!
Totally forgot Haunting on Hill House!
True detective
##The Killing!!!
Wait, there's a season 2 of The Sinner?! I loved Season 1 and binged it all in 2 days!
Hi ya’ll, can anyone tell me without spoilers or revealing too many details if there is anything like the following in the movie:
Lynching, the Klan, police brutality, degradation, etc?
I really want to see it and support but I am highly sensitive to seeing black people in certain situations. I can only take so much 😅. Tried to find this in other posts/google but I feel like I was seeing too much about the plot. Thanks!
Its really really good. Wonderful acting. Yes many triggering themes of race and trauma. May caution about watching w mostly white audiences. Just bc of the material and times we r currently in. It is worth the hype. See it soon cause so many spoilers out there
Thank you for asking this. The “trauma porn” of a lot of black focused films is a lot for me and I was wondering this myself
I will say this movie does what other movies struggle to not do when it comes to this topic. It doesn't glorify or create trauma porn. So yes hard topics addressed but it wasn't as bad as u think. Coogler highlights hardships but mainly beauty of blackness in this film in my opinion
Thank you!
Yes (with least amount of spoilers I can give):
The klan is a medium sized part of the plot and several members show up and the robes are seen for a second, but no one wears them and they don’t attack anyone who can’t or doesn’t fight back and win. No lynching. There is someone dunking a black boy’s head under water but it’s brief, not racially charged and it doesn’t result in death or injury.
Two black men get shot in the leg by another black man for stealing. It’s implied they’ll be patched up.
There’s a short scene of in the middle of the film of men in prison wear digging holes overseen by white wardens on horseback, while a character talks about how and why they didn’t deserve to be there.
The main character is a share cropper and there’s brief scenes at the beginning of him and others picking cotton.
There’s a white (ish) lady and several scenes where there’s an underlying threat of people getting attacked by being around her (no one does). She does spit in a black man’s mouth tho, it was consensual but gross imo
Thank you so much for this well thought out response!
There’s also a scene talking about a lynching with some audio but no visuals. Very short and important to the plot
You're a lifesaver.
Spoiler: one yt person drops the n word after being righteously killed
Not very racial trauma porny... Only violent in the sense of vampires being... Vampires.
If you liked MM enough to join this sub, you're gonna love Sinners! I don't want to say too much more for risk of spoilers, but there were similar angles of social commentary, music that shakes your bones, slow burn ominous setup... Go see it, it's amazing.
Totally agree! I loved Sinners, kind of want to go see it again and it was giving major MM vibes at certain points. MBJ is great at horror… maybe someday he’ll be cast in a Flanagan project!
Yes!!!!!! I totally thought Sinners had both Midnight Mass and Buffy vibes!! And MBJ loves anime too and one scene in particular…
But I’ve seen Sinners twice and totally want to rewatch MM now
The shout-out to Irish vampirism? The doorway effect? YES YES YES YES YES
👏 👏 👏
I saw it for the second time with my friend who’s a huge Buffy fan and she commented on the >! Post credits 90s scene that Buffy would kill them and it made me laugh !<
I loved Sinners and think it’s the best vampire media I’ve seen alongside MM. I think there are tons of little similarities too!
YES!!!!
I love this show!! Each season is a different story and they have that.. what do you call it? That feeling where you think of the characters long after you've watched it, it kinda haunts you and you must watch it again.
Oh we're talking about something else, I meant the new Ryan Coogler movie currently in the cinema. What are YOU recommending?
Oh! Lol! It's a Netflix series? Maybe?
Just looked it up, it's THE Sinner, actually. Bill Pullman (Lonestar from Spaceballs!) is a detective, each season starts with a different crime, and you generally know who did it, but with each episode you get closer to understanding WHY.
Totally recommended, 100%!
I'll have to check out the movie though!
Agreed!! Loved it so much, makes me want to watch MM again!
Red Tape Edition. Genuinely like this movie, good acting, good actors, definitely worth watching if you've missed this one.
The new world video logo placement on the tape makes it look like he’s holding a waffle from a distance haha
Did you make this? So cool
Yeah I make loads of different one.
Beautiful. How do you make the colored tapes?
Omg I have to have one
🔥🔥
I appreciate the old style (and best style) BBFC rating
The old way is the best 👌
Do you also think that "Sinners" could easily be an introductory film for Blade in the MCU? Ryan (Director of the film who also wrote both Black Panther films) could have sold the script to Marvel.
I don’t think Sinners had anything to do with Blade other than Coogler might have wanted to direct the Blade movie and/or be involved with the vampires in the MCU.
But the script itself probably wasnt ever for a MCU Blade movie
The themes and symbolism in Sinners must have went clear over your head. This film is nothing like what a Blade project would be.
Maybe you're taking OP more literally than I am. I assumed OP did not literally mean that Sinners was intentionally created as a Blade prequel. Rather, I assumed they are just speculating about Coogler's inspirations for Sinners. That's what this sub is for, after all!
Coogler has been very clear about what inspired sinners and it has nothing to do with Blade. It’s a film about culture and community and how black culture is coveted by others and how insidious white supremacy is. He said it’s his most personal project. Associating it with Blade is an extremely surface level interpretation of the film and is obviously coming from someone who isn’t black and the film just went other their head.
it’s not like the themes were very subtle, like at all. not to mention at least coogler understands vampirism and how it’s portrayed in media very well. i don’t see why he couldn’t apply these same things to blade considering he’s a black vampire slayer? are you sure you understood the surface level themes or?
In the comics Blade is British which brings a different perspective on racism that isn’t the same as the deep south of the early 1900’s. Just because it’s black people dealing with Vampires doesn’t instantly translate to Blade. Coogler is directly connected to the black panther franchise and is ep on ironheart. He did not make sinners because he wasn’t working on Blade. As a black man raised by a woman born in Alabama in 1923 and whose grandfather was a creole man from Louisiana I find this reductive surface level interpretations and non black people need to attach sinners to Blade ridiculous. Just because it’s black people interacting with vampires doesn’t mean it was a Blade project that got turned to a different project op is saying it was coolers take on Blade which makes no sense because the only vampire hunters in the film where Native Americans with 10 minutes of screen time. I grew up in my great grandmother’s house hearing stories about this time period it’s extremely relevant to my experience
Considering there was sex, gun violence, blood, gore, cursing, racism, alcoholism/drinking, super raunchy sex, a lot of sex, themes of slavery/oppression/conformity/assimilation… no, not really. But more importantly, why would he even want to?
He had the creative freedom to do what he wanted, how he wanted, help write it, direct it, design the look of it, choose that it was filmed on actual stock not digital, and had minimal studio interference to make the highest rated movie in a decade so why would he want to give all that up on top of being unable to implement all the things that made Sinners so unique and great?
I think this desire to want him for it stems mostly from the idea that it was good and had vampires while completely ignoring why Sinners was great and how very few of those are replicable within the MCU.
Beyond that, what would make a good Blade is a ton of martial arts, much better prolonged gun battles, and a John Wick style action movie with minimal plot and action set pieces - most of which wasn’t in Sinners and isn’t what made Sinners good at all.
Yeah, people venture into bigger projects so that the money they make can be used for smaller more artistically inclined projects. The film did 4 times its budget. The religious symbolism alone would make Marvel dust their hands off of it.
I’ve been waiting for this. My Marvel Studios conspiracy theory…Coogler wanted to do Blade but the original production schedules clashed with Black Panther: Wakanda Forever (not to mention the heavy rewrites required for our fallen comrade Chadwick Boseman) so Marvel didn’t hand it to Coogler so he made his own vampire film. I can’t believe Coogler would make such an incredible vampire film and not have interest in doing Blade. But his desire to also write his films caused Marvel to outsource it. I hope Coogler does Blade when it does happen. Or give it to Chad Stahelski from John Wick.
i have fully heard rumors that sinners was originally meant to be a blade movie but they changed it into a separate project, and i do somewhat believe it. blade was rumored to take place in the 1930s with a bunch of period inspired sets and outfits, about a bunch of vampires, sinners is a movie thats set in like the 1920s with a bunch of period inspired sets and outfits about a bunch of black vampires.
Yeah I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s 100% true as you stated. I personally haven’t read anything but if it ever got confirmed I have my 🥲 ready because Coogler’s Blade would have been peak. Also side bar wasn’t Jonathan Majors supposed to play one of the twins before that whole thing happened or was that just a rumor?
Yeah that’s true. I would imagine that is a priority if he wants to use Denzel considering Denzel seems like he’s winding down his career.
My sister and I are looking for our next binge, and we narrowed the list down to these two shows. Both has fairly average scores though. I was told that "you" is a poor man's Dexter, yet I really liked Dexter, so I guess I am fine with it. Any other recommendations, preferably for thrillers (movies as well), are more than welcomed. Thanks in advance.
The Sinner I watched all seasons , I tried watching You and couldn’t get past 2 episodes.
The Sinner season 1 is good
Season 2 is average
Season 3 is some of the worst garbage pretentious TV I've ever watched. Wouldn't bother
No idea about season 4 as I've given up on this show
You in my opinion is a very solid show throughout
Lol. What the hell was happening in season 3?!? I struggled!
100% The last season was terrible.
Agree!
The Sinner
"You" season 1 is good thou. Some others shows I'd check out....
"Rectify"
"Mr Mercedes"
"Hannibal"
Hannibal is a must watch.
Top notch acting and superb story
God, I could not handle how much time we spent watching that guy pee in Mr. Mercedes.
Huge thanks !
I loved season 2 of You and absolutely adored Jessica Biel’s season of The Sinner
The fall, one of the most underrated series in my opinion.
similar movies to The Sinner
If you enjoyed "The Sinner," here are some similar movies and series to consider:
Mindhunter (2017-2019)
Top of the Lake (2013, 2017)
Broadchurch (2013-2017)
The Fall (2013-2016)
Sharp Objects (2018)
The Killing (2011-2014)
Recommendation: If you appreciate character-driven narratives and psychological depth, "Mindhunter" and "The Fall" are particularly strong recommendations. They both offer intense storytelling and complex characters, similar to what you find in "The Sinner."
Get more comprehensive results summarized by our most cutting edge AI model. Plus deep Youtube search.