I’m a huge Mindhunter fan and I also loved the Shield. I’d say the first season or two is much lighter than the rest. I will always say it’s a damn good show that I would watch a third time from beginning to end.

True Detective, Season 1

Not sure if they're exactly similar but they're really good shows.

Home Before Dark

Clickbait

Tell Me A Story

Severance

From

The woman in the house

True Story

You Don't Know Me

Rules Of The Game

The Booth at the End

Innocent

Panic

Candy

The Thing About Pam

Bates Motel

Are subtitles ok? I just came across a show from Iceland called TRAPPED. Seasons 1&2 are on Prime and season 3 (ENTRAPPED) is on Netflix. It was good and twisty.

Similar to Mindhunter and The Sinner, but not convinced i would consider them all “psychological thrillers”. Everyone has different definitions. Regardless, they all make for good viewing.

-The Missing/Baptise

-Capitani

-Delhi Crime

-Valhalla Murders

———————————————————.

-The Tunnel

-Safe

-Stay Close

-The Stranger

-Tell Me Your Secrets

-Hit & Run

True Detective, Broadchurch, Mare of Eastown, The Alienist (it’s a time period piece but it is dark). Baptieste, Bosch, Deadwater Fell, Hinterland, Line of Duty, Luther, Mindhunter, Prime Suspect, Shetland, Ripper Street, The Fall, The Killing, The Missing, Top of the Lake, Wire in the Blood.

Broadchurch 💯

True Detective S1

Okay so it's not a cop show, but Midnight Mass reminded me of s4 of The Sinner a lot. Set on a small island community, a dark secret, an outsider coming to the island, all very similar. But it has supernatural horror elements so if you're not into that you probably won't like it.

Sharp objects

True Detective

The Fall used to be on netflix but isn’t anymore :( it’s available to stream for free elsewhere though it seems

Mare of Eastown, ur welcome

Mare of east town

This one is sometimes on Netflix so I'm sorry if it's not, but The Killing! It's a remake of a Swedish show, it's got similar vibes for me.

Quicksand has similar concepts with “violent crime, main character has memory loss, fucked up shit” and I actually preferred it over The Sinner, but it is in Swedish. It’s on Netflix with subtitles though.

Top of the Lake is one kind of similar and not mentioned yet.

Unbelievable.
Mindhunter.
Safe.
The Act.
Dirty John.
Sharp Objects.
A Very English Scandal.
London Spy.

The killing. Nice and Dark. Or True Detective season 1.

American Crime is on Netflix and, like The Sinner, is an anthology style show.

Succession, Industry, The Americans, Damages, Weeds, Six Feet Under, Bosch, The Diplomat

The Shield

Bad Sisters

Line of Duty

Boardwalk Empire

The Shield

True Detective Season 1

Servant 

A Shop for Killers 

Bloodhounds 

Watchmen

The Sinner Season 1

Mayor of Kingstown 

Stranger Things

Snowfall 

Game of Thrones

Weak Hero Class

Mindhunter 

• Marcella (Netflix)
• Orphan Black (Amazon Prime)
• Thirteen (the mini series, not the movie) (Amazon Prime)
• The Missing (Amazon Prime)
• The Killing (Hulu)
• Top of the Lake: China Girl (Hulu)
• Retribution (Netflix)
• The Five (Netflix)
• The Forest (mini series, French language) (Netflix)
• Broadchurch (Netflix)
• Black Spot (French language) (Netflix)
• The End of the F**king World (Netflix)

The Night Of - an HBO miniseries.

Seven Seconds - Netflix

The killing! Is so much like the sinner. Great suggestion from the person above ����

The Missing on Amazon Prime, but only season 2 (it's an anthology so you can start anywhere). Incredible story, very complex with multiple timelines. The main detective has a lot of similarities to Bill Pullman's character. Super satisfying.

Season 1 has some good aspects but a terrible ending.

Broadchurch is a great murder mystery/ police investigation show from a few years back with Olivia Coleman and David Tennant. Set in a small town so everyone’s stories are super intertwined. Great acting. The first season is the best but all three are good.

Marcella - netflix Luther - netflix Tell me your secrets - prime Orphan black - prime (this one is less crime and more scifi as the seasons go on)

Mind Hunter. The FBI investigators try to learn more about serial killers and at the same time the audience learn more about the investigators.

The undoing on HBO. Fantastic!

Edit: sorry, just saw you specifically said Netflix.

“You” on Netflix

true detective

Unforgotten, if you haven't seen it yet. Seasons 1-3 are amazing.

I think you would love The Killing, and I also agree with Department Q. Also, have you watched Happy Valley? I watched that right after Broadchurch and loved it. If you don't mind subtitles, there is a great Icelandic show called Trapped (Netflix). It definitely fits the broken detective genre. I loved the male lead so much in that show and was so excited when I also saw him in Severance!

The Fall w/ Jamie Dornan and Gillian Anderson

Chestnut man and Deadwind

No shows come to mind but a few film suggestions if you don’t mind… The film American Beauty (1999). It’s a little dated but brilliantly written. Three Billboards Outside Ebbing Missouri (2017) The Banshees of Inisherin (2022)

Twin Peaks, Seasons 1 and 2.

The OA

Angel Heart (movie)

Pi (movie)

Dead Man (movie)

Lots of literature and philosophy. Ancient Greek Dramas; Dostoevsky; Camus, the existentialists... something more accessible? Herman Hesse (Damien and Steppenwolf in particular)

I really enjoyed season 3, I loved how they worked in real philosophy. It’s strange how most people hate this season, it’s always regarded as the worst.

The only show I can think of that’s actually similar is True Detective season 1, which is one of the best seasons of television ever made.

I found The Sinner a few days ago so I'm just barely seeing this. I'm very surprised no one recommend the Hannibal tv series to you. S3 of The Sinner feels like a shitty knock off of it almost.