/u/SaintGeneste

Ghost Hound ( Shinreigari)

Majin Tantei Nougami Neuro 

Mayoiga 

Shiki

Shinrei Tantei Yakumo 

Bakemonogatari 

Blue exorcist 

Yu yu hakusho 

Kore wa Zombie desu ka?

Natsume Yuujinchou

Gabriel dropout 

Tasogare Otome x Amnesia 

Blood +

Sewayaki Kitsune no Senko-san

Mononoke

Mushishi 

Nyan Koi 

Hoozuki no Reitetsu 

Gugure! Kokkuri-san

Uchouten Kazoku

Inari, Konkon, Koi Iroha.

Udon no Kuni no Kiniro 

Fukigen na Mononokean

Petshop of Horrors 

Youkai Apartment no Yuuga na Nichijou 

Gingitsune

Kyuuketsuhime Miyu (TV)

Yuu Yuu Hakusho

Kyoukai no Rinne

xxxHolic

Shaman King

Dark gathering is peak. Really hope it gets a second season

There's always ghost stories. As you prob heard, the dub is ridiculously funny. The story isn't bad either and there's a bunch of ghosts in it

3days ago some one also asked for supernatural anime suggestion, here's my recommendation

Supernatural the animation.

Devil May Cry (2007)

xxxHolic

Kekaishi

Kokuri-san

Bimbougami ga! (ecchi)

Noragami

Blood the Last Vampire (OVA) Blood+ (TV series) Blood-C (spin-off)

Chrono Crusade

Well there is a supernatural anime

Xxxholic?

Mob Psycho 100

Norogami

Jujutsu Kaisen

Bleach

The Monogatari series

In/Spectre fits. It has silly moments but cases they work on are usually very serious.

Dandadan just aired last year and i loved it. season 2 is almost here as well.

{Houseki no Kuni}

I mean all the characters are ridiculously well-animated Gemstones. What more could you want? I watched the opening and I was in awe istg

Noragami.

Dororo

Try Parasyte

This vid might help then. I’m trying to promote the channel, so I might as well try to help someone out in the process. 😄

https://youtu.be/wePrxJlx5PU

Mushishi

Xxxholic

Ancient magus bride

Natsume yuujinchou

Noragami

Kamisama kiss

Kakuriyo no yadomeshi

You might like Noragami.

Read kemono jihen. The art is good and the story is well developed, now it has around 100+ chapters so it is perfect to binge. Anime is good too for the first season, love the op tho. It tells a story about a boy that got adopted to a private detective agency and that boy is a frickin ghoul.

{somali and the forest spirit} {b: the beginning} {to your eternity} {vatican miracle examiner} {devilman crybaby}

if a manga is fine then <forbidden scrollery>

Jojo

Shiki

Drifters

Darker than Black

Seraph of the End

Mushishi

Bakemonagatari

Death Parade

surprised no one has said baccano

xxxHolic

you should "Another", trust me

ANOTHER is a 100 % gothic horror : no Dragon Ball style Battle against Monsters, no ecchi Angels. Just plot and atmosphere.

I don't want to give you spoilers But I can tell you that “Another” can boast one of the best written plots i have ever seen. The first two episodes seem mundane and taste like something you've already seen BUT IT'S A WILLING EFFECT because starting from the third episode a twist begins that reshuffles all the cards on the table and turns upside down all the certainties about the plot you thought you had up to that point.

Again without spoilers: I found absolutely brilliant the idea in ANOTHER that the villain does not know who is the villain. Not in the sense that he thinks he is in the right: in this case the big bad doesn't know that he is the big bad. Obviously without giving you spoilers I can't tell you more but I really recommend that you see this series

Blue exorcist is a good one for supernatural stuff.

Supernatural: The Animation

Tasogare Otome x Amnesia

Persona 4: the Animation (2011 version) (English dub recommended)

Corpse Princess: Aka

Shadows House

Summer time rendering is so good

In/spectre, Mushishi, fate/Stay night and fate/zero to name a few

You might like In/Spectre. I did, as a Supernatural fan, but I don't think they're exactly the same vibe, honestly. I do like how the two leads bounce off each other, though.

Hellsing

Blood +

Blood c 

Ghost hunt

Majin Tantei Nougami Neuro 

Shinrei Tantei Yakumo 

Dandadan

Dark Gathering

This is not a direct response to your question, but you should read Don't Underestimate Bread!. Trust me.

Blue exorcist

Inuyasha

Ascendance of a bookworm

Noragami

Fullmetal alchemist brotherhood Xxxholic Soul eater Sailor moon Dandadan

I mean technically the magic in Saga of Tanya The Evil is kinda religious as uh Tanya did need to call god when using advanced? Magic

Jojo’s Bizarre Adventure blends a bit of spiritual themes, with supernatural themes.

Ghost Hunt

Natsume's Book of Friends and Death Note

Unironically, I think you might like Dandadan!

Natsume’s Book of Friends

The Monogatari series